Gene profiling of cattle blastocysts derived from nuclear transfer, in vitro fertilization and in vivo development based on cDNA library

Oct-4 activating compound 1 (OAC1) could improve the quality of somatic cell nuclear transfer embryos in the bovine

Previous studies described aberrant nuclear reprogramming in somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) embryos that is distinctly different from fertilized embryos. This abnormal nuclear reprogramming hampers the proper pre- and/or post-implantation development. It has been demonstrated that SCNT blastocysts aberrantly expressed POU5F1 and POU5F1-related genes. With regard to this, it has been postulated that promoting the expression of POU5F1 in SCNT embryos may enhance reprogramming in SCNT embryos. In this study, we treated either fibroblast donor cells or SCNT embryos with OAC1 as a novel small molecule that has been reported to induce POU5F1 expression. Quantitative results from the MTS assay revealed that lower concentrations of OAC1 (1, 1.5, and 3 μM) are non-toxic after 2, 4, and 6 days, but higher concentrations (6, 8, 10, and 12 μM) are toxic and reduced the proliferation of cells after 6 days. No enhancement in the expression of endogenous POU5F1 was observed when both mouse and bovine fibroblast cells were treated with 1.5 and 3 μM OAC1 for up to 6 consecutive days. Subsequently, we treated either fibroblast as donor cells in the SCNT procedure (BFF-OAC1 group) or SCNT embryos [for 4 days (IVC-OAC1: D4-D7 group) or 7 days (IVC-OAC1: D0-D7 group)] with 1.5 μM OAC1. We observed that neither treatment of fibroblast donor cells nor SCNT embryos improved the cleavage and blastocyst rates. Interestingly, we observed that treatment of SCNT embryos all throughout the in vitro culture (IVC) (IVC-OAC1: D0-D7) with 1.5 μM OAC1 improves the quality of derived blastocyst which was indexed by morphological grading, blastomere allocation, epigenetic marks and mRNA expression of target genes. In conclusion, our results showed that supplementation of IVC medium with 1.5 μM OAC1 (D0-D7) accelerates SCNT reprogramming in bovine species.

Pluripotent Core in Bovine Embryos: A Review

Early development in mammals is characterized by the ability of each cell to produce a complete organism plus the extraembryonic, or placental, cells, defined as pluripotency. During subsequent development, pluripotency is lost, and cells begin to differentiate to a particular cell fate. This review summarizes the current knowledge of pluripotency features of bovine embryos cultured in vitro, focusing on the core of pluripotency genes (OCT4, NANOG, SOX2, and CDX2), and main chemical strategies for controlling pluripotent networks during early development. Finally, we discuss the applicability of manipulating pluripotency during the morula to blastocyst transition in cattle species.

Epigenetic modification with trichostatin A does not correct specific errors of somatic cell nuclear transfer at the transcriptomic level; highlighting the non-random nature of oocyte-mediated reprogramming errors

Background

The limited duration and compromised efficiency of oocyte-mediated reprogramming, which occurs during the early hours following somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), may significantly interfere with epigenetic reprogramming, contributing to the high incidence of ill/fatal transcriptional phenotypes and physiological anomalies occurring later during pre- and post-implantation events. A potent histone deacetylase inhibitor, trichostatin A (TSA), was used to understand the effects of assisted epigenetic modifications on transcriptional profiles of SCNT blastocysts and to identify specific or categories of genes affected.

Results

TSA improved the yield and quality of in vitro embryo development compared to control (CTR-NT). Significance analysis of microarray results revealed that of 37,238 targeted gene transcripts represented on the microarray slide, a relatively small number of genes were differentially expressed in CTR-NT (1592 = 4.3 %) and TSA-NT (1907 = 5.1 %) compared to IVF embryos. For both SCNT groups, the majority of downregulated and more than half of upregulated genes were common and as much as 15 % of all deregulated transcripts were located on chromosome X. Correspondence analysis clustered CTR-NT and IVF transcriptomes close together regardless of the embryo production method, whereas TSA changed SCNT transcriptome to a very clearly separated cluster. Ontological classification of deregulated genes using IPA uncovered a variety of functional categories similarly affected in both SCNT groups with a preponderance of genes required for biological processes. Examination of genes involved in different canonical pathways revealed that the WNT and FGF pathways were similarly affected in both SCNT groups. Although TSA markedly changed epigenetic reprogramming of donor cells (DNA-methylation, H3K9 acetylation), reconstituted oocytes (5mC, 5hmC), and blastocysts (DNA-methylation, H3K9 acetylation), these changes did not recapitulate parallel marked changes in chromatin remodeling, and nascent mRNA and OCT4-EGFP expression of TSA-NT vs. CRT-NT embryos.

Conclusions

The results obtained suggest that despite the extensive reprogramming of donor cells that occurred by the blastocyst stage, SCNT-specific errors are of a non-random nature in bovine and are not responsive to epigenetic modifications by TSA.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12864-015-2264-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Differential developmental competence and gene expression patterns in buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) nuclear transfer embryos reconstructed with fetal fibroblasts and amnion mesenchymal stem cells

The developmental ability and gene expression pattern at 8- to 16-cell and blastocyst stages of buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) nuclear transfer (NT) embryos from fetal fibroblasts (FFs), amnion mesenchymal stem cells (AMSCs) and in vitro fertilized (IVF) embryos were compared in the present studies. The in vitro expanded buffalo FFs showed a typical "S" shape growth curve with a doubling time of 41.4 h and stained positive for vimentin. The in vitro cultured undifferentiated AMSCs showed a doubling time of 39.5 h and stained positive for alkaline phosphatase, and these cells also showed expression of pluripotency markers (OCT 4, SOX 2, NANOG), and mesenchymal stem cell markers (CD29, CD44) and were negative for haematopoietic marker (CD34) genes at different passages. Further, when AMSCs were exposed to corresponding induction conditions, these cells differentiated into adipogenic, chondrogenic and osteogenic lineages which were confirmed through oil red O, alcian blue and alizarin staining, respectively. Donor cells at 3-4 passage were employed for NT. The cleavage rate was significantly (P < 0.05) higher in IVF than in FF-NT and AMSC-NT embryos (82.6 ± 8.2 vs. 64.6 ± 1.3 and 72.3 ± 2.2 %, respectively). However, blastocyst rates in IVF and AMSC-NT embryos (30.6 ± 2.7 and 28.9 ± 3.1 %) did not differ and were significantly (P < 0.05) higher than FF-NT (19.5 ± 1.8 %). Total cell number did not show significant (P > 0.05) differences between IVF and AMSC-NT embryos (186.7 ± 4.2, 171.2 ± 3.8, respectively) but were significantly (P < 0.05) higher than that from FF-NT (151.3 ± 4.1). Alterations in the expression pattern of genes implicated in transcription and pluripotency (OCT4, STAT3, NANOG), DNA methylation (DNMT1, DNMT3A), histone deacetylation (HDAC2), growth factor signaling and imprinting (IGF2, IGF2R), apoptosis (BAX, BCL2), metabolism (GLUT1) and oxidative stress (MnSOD) regulation were observed in cloned embryos. The transcripts or expression patterns in AMSC-NT embryos more closely followed that of the in vitro derived embryos compared with FF-NT embryos. The results demonstrate that multipotent amnion MSCs have a greater potential as donor cells than FFs in achieving enhanced production of cloned buffalo embryos.

Follicular progesterone concentrations and messenger RNA expression of MATER and OCT-4 in immature bovine oocytes as predictors of developmental competence

The ability of bovine embryos to develop to the blastocyst stage and to implant and generate healthy offspring depends greatly on the competence of the oocyte. Oocyte competence is attributed to its close communication with the follicular environment and to its capacity to synthesize and store substantial amounts of messenger RNA. Higher developmental competence of bovine oocytes has been associated with both the expression of a cohort of developmental genes and the concentration of sex steroids in the follicular fluid. The aim of this study was to identify differences in the expression of FST in cumulus cells and OCT-4 and MATER in oocytes and the influence of the follicular progesterone and follicular estrogen concentration on the competence of bovine oocytes retrieved 30 minutes or 4 hours after slaughter. Cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) were left in postmortem ovaries for 30 minutes (group I) or 4 hours (group II) at 30 °C. Aspirated oocytes were then subjected to IVM, IVF, and IVC or were evaluated for MATER and OCT-4 messenger RNA abundance by quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction. Total RNA was isolated from pools of 100 oocytes for each experimental replicate. Progesterone and estradiol concentration in follicular fluid was evaluated by immunoassay using an IMMULITE 2000 analyzer. Three repeats of in vitro embryo production were performed with a total of 455 (group I) and 470 (group II) COCs. There were no significant differences between the cleavage rates (72 hours postinsemination [hpi]) between both groups (63.5% vs. 69.1%). However, blastocyst (168 hpi) and hatching (216 hpi) rates were higher (P < 0.05) in group II compared with those of group I (21.3% vs. 30.7% and 27.6% vs. 51.5%, respectively). Group II oocytes exhibited the highest MATER and OCT-4 abundance (P < 0.05). Follicular estradiol concentration was not different between both the groups, whereas the progesterone concentration was lower (P ≤ 0.05) in group II follicles. These results indicate that retrieving COCs 4 hours after slaughter could increase bovine in vitro developmental competence, which is linked to higher levels of oocyte MATER and OCT-4 transcripts and lower follicular progesterone concentration. Moreover, the results of the present study contribute to the identification of factors involved in the developmental competence of immature oocytes.

Epigenetic disorders and altered gene expression after use of Assisted Reproductive Technologies in domestic cattle

The use of Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ARTs) in modern cattle breeding is an important tool for improving the production of dairy and beef cattle. A frequently employed ART in the cattle industry is in vitro production of embryos. However, bovine in vitro produced embryos differ greatly from their in vivo produced counterparts in many facets, including developmental competence. The lower developmental capacity of these embryos could be due to the stress to which the gametes and/or embryos are exposed during in vitro embryo production, specifically ovarian hormonal stimulation, follicular aspiration, oocyte in vitro maturation in hormone supplemented medium, sperm handling, gamete cryopreservation, and culture of embryos. The negative effects of some ARTs on embryo development could, at least partially, be explained by disruption of the physiological epigenetic profile of the gametes and/or embryos. Here, we review the current literature with regard to the putative link between ARTs used in bovine reproduction and epigenetic disorders and changes in the expression profile of embryonic genes. Information on the relationship between reproductive biotechnologies and epigenetic disorders and aberrant gene expression in bovine embryos is limited and novel approaches are needed to explore ways in which ARTs can be improved to avoid epigenetic disorders.

Changes in the expression of pluripotency-associated genes during preimplantation and peri-implantation stages in bovine cloned and in vitro produced embryos

In cattle, embryos elongate before implantation and after hatching. Changes in gene expression during this transition are not well studied. Especially important are variations in the expression of pluripotency-associated genes as a result of assisted reproductive biotechnologies, such as cloning and in vitro fertilization (IVF). We hypothesize that there will be a decline in the expression of key pluripotency-associated genes and an increase in the expression of IFN-tau in elongated embryos when compared with day-7 blastocysts. To test this we generated cloned and IVF bovine day-7 blastocyst and day-17 elongated embryos (day 0 = day of nucleus transfer or IVF). Gene expression in all embryos was assessed via RT-qPCR. OCT4 was overexpressed (p < 0.05) in the cloned blastocysts when compared with IVF. No differences in gene expression at this stage between cloned and IVF embryos were found for EOMES, NANOG and FGF4. At elongation EOMES, NANOG and FGF4 were upregulated in IVF embryos (p < 0.05). IFN-tau and OCT4 were expressed at similar levels. There were changes in the expression levels for all transcripts between blastogenesis and elongation. NANOG, IFN-tau and EOMES were overexpressed in all the elongated embryos (p < 0.05), FGF4 was underexpressed in both treatments. OCT4 dropped drastically in the cloned elongated embryos, but not in the IVF. Interestingly only adult donor cells (but not fetal) from which the cloned embryos originated also expressed high levels of OCT4. Our findings might help to understand the shift of gene expression during elongation and to identify key markers of embryonic development useful for embryo screening purposes.

Comparison of early development in utero of cloned fetuses derived from bovine fetal fibroblasts at the G1 and G0/G1 phases

In bovine somatic cell nuclear transfer (NT), embryos are more likely to develop to full term when they are derived from fibroblasts at the G1 phase instead of cells at the G0/G1 phase. To better understand the reason for this difference, we examined morphological development in the early pregnancy of NT embryos using G1 phase cells (G1-NT embryos) and G0/G1 phase cells (G0/G1-NT embryos). Blastocysts derived from G1 and G0/G1-NT embryos were transferred to recipient heifers, and the conceptuses at day 50 of gestation were retrieved non-surgically using prostaglandin F(2alpha) and oxytocin. In vitro-fertilized (IVF), parthenogenetic and artificially inseminated (AI) embryos were used as controls. The percentages of embryos that developed to the blastocyst stage did not differ between G1 and G0/G1-NT embryos. Pregnancy rates at day 30 of recipient heifers carrying G1-NT, G0/G1-NT, IVF, parthenogenetic and AI embryos were similar (57-100%). Two recipient heifers carrying parthenogenetic embryos returned to estrus between days 30 and 50 of gestation, whereas all other pregnancies remained viable. Most fetuses at day 50 of gestation of all experimental groups (83%) were recovered non-surgically by several PGF(2alpha) and oxytocin treatments. Recovery rates of normal fetuses derived from G1-NT embryos (83%), IVF embryos (80%) and AI embryos (88%) were greater than those of G0/G1-NT embryos (33%) and parthenogenetic embryos (0%). Our results suggest that NT embryos reconstructed with cells at the G1 phase have a high developmental competence from the time of embryo transfer to day 50 of gestation.

Gene expression in early expanded parthenogenetic and in vitro fertilized bovine blastocysts

Mammalian oocytes can undergo artificial parthenogenesis in vitro and develop to the blastocyst stage. In this study, using real-time PCR, we analyzed the expression of genes representative of essential events in development. In vitro matured oocytes were either fertilized or activated with ionomycin + 6-DMAP and cultured in simple medium. The pluripotency-related gene Oct3/4 was downregulated in parthenotes, while the de novo methylation DNMT3A gene was unchanged. Among the pregnancy recognition genes, IFN-t was upregulated, PGRMC1 was downregulated and PLAC8 was unchanged in parthenotes. Among the metabolism genes, SLC2A1 was downregulated, while AKR1B1, COX2, H6PD and TXN were upregulated in parthenotes; there was no difference in SLC2A5. Among the genes involved in compaction/blastulation, GJA1 expression increased in parthenotes, but no differences were detected within ATP1A1 and CDH1. Expression of p66(shc) and the Bax/Bcl2 ratio were higher in parthenotes, and there was no difference in p53. Parthenotes and embryos may differ in the way they stimulate apoptosis, with a preponderant role for p66(shc) within parthenotes. Differentially affected functions may also include pluripotency, de novo methylation and early embryonic signalling.

Cloning from stem cells: different lineages, different species, same story

Following nuclear transfer (NT), the most stringent measure of extensive donor cell reprogramming is development into viable offspring. This is referred to as cloning efficiency and quantified as the proportion of cloned embryos transferred into surrogate mothers that survive into adulthood. Cloning efficiency depends on the ability of the enucleated recipient cell to carry out the reprogramming reactions (‘reprogramming ability’) and the ability of the nuclear donor cell to be reprogrammed (‘reprogrammability’). It has been postulated that reprogrammability of the somatic donor cell epigenome is inversely proportional to its differentiation status. In order to test this hypothesis, reprogrammability was compared between undifferentiated stem cells and their differentiated isogenic progeny. In the mouse, cells of divergent differentiation status from the neuronal, haematopoietic and skin epithelial lineage were tested. In cattle and deer, skeletal muscle and antler cells, respectively, were used as donors. No conclusive correlation between differentiation status and cloning efficiency was found, indicating that somatic donor cell type may not be the limiting factor for cloning success. This may reflect technical limitations of the NT-induced reprogramming assay. Alternatively, differentiation status and reprogrammability may be unrelated, making all cells equally difficult to reprogramme once they have left the ground state of pluripotency.

Climbing Mount Efficiency--small steps, not giant leaps towards higher cloning success in farm animals

Despite more than a decade of research efforts, farm animal cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) is still frustratingly inefficient. Inefficiency manifests itself at different levels, which are currently not well integrated. At the molecular level, it leads to widespread genetic, epigenetic and transcriptional aberrations in cloned embryos. At the organismal level, these genome-wide abnormalities compromise development of cloned foetuses and offspring. Specific molecular defects need to be causally linked to specific cloned phenotypes, in order to design specific treatments to correct them. Cloning efficiency depends on the ability of the nuclear donor cell to be fully reprogrammed into an embryonic state and the ability of the enucleated recipient cell to carry out the reprogramming reactions. It has been postulated that reprogrammability of the somatic donor cell epigenome is influenced by its differentiation status. However, direct comparisons between cells of divergent differentiation status within several somatic lineages have found no conclusive evidence for this. Choosing somatic stem cells as donors has not improved cloning efficiency, indicating that donor cell type may be less critical for cloning success. Different recipient cells, on the other hand, vary in their reprogramming ability. In bovine, using zygotes instead of oocytes has increased cloning success. Other improvements in livestock cloning efficiency include better coordinating donor cell type with cell cycle stage and aggregating cloned embryos. In the future, it will be important to demonstrate if these small increases at every step are cumulative, adding up to an integrated cloning protocol with greatly improved efficiency.

Biological differences between in vitro produced bovine embryos and parthenotes

Parthenotes may represent an alternate ethical source of stem cells, once biological differences between parthenotes and embryos can be understood. In this study, we analyzed development, trophectoderm (TE) differentiation, apoptosis/necrosis, and ploidy in parthenotes and in vitro produced bovine embryos. Subsequently, using real-time PCR, we analyzed the expression of genes expected to underlie the observed differences at the blastocyst stage. In vitro matured oocytes were either fertilized or activated with ionomycin +6-DMAP and cultured in simple medium. Parthenotes showed enhanced blastocyst development and diploidy and reduced TE cell counts. Apoptotic and necrotic indexes did not vary, but parthenotes evidenced a higher relative proportion of apoptotic cells between inner cell mass and TE. The pluripotence-related POU5F1 and the methylation DNMT3A genes were downregulated in parthenotes. Among pregnancy recognition genes, TP-1 was upregulated in parthenotes, while PGRMC1 and PLAC8 did not change. Expression of p66(shc) and BAX/BCL2 ratio were higher, and p53 lower, in parthenotes. Among metabolism genes, SLC2A1 was downregulated, while AKR1B1, PTGS2, H6PD, and TXN were upregulated in parthenotes, and SLC2A5 did not differ. Among genes involved in compaction/blastulation, GJA1 was downregulated in parthenotes, but no differences were detected within ATP1A1 and CDH1. Within parthenotes, the expression levels of SLC2A1, TP-1, and H6PD, and possibly AKR1B1, resemble patterns described in female embryos. The pro-apoptotic profile is more pronounced in parthenotes than in embryos, which may differ in their way to channel apoptotic stimuli, through p66(shc) and p53 respectively, and in their mechanisms to control pluripotency and de novo methylation.

Global gene expression analysis of bovine blastocysts produced by multiple methods

Reproductive efficiency using somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) technology remains suboptimal. Of the various efforts to improve the efficiency, chromatin transfer (CT) and clone-clone aggregation (NTagg) have been reported to produce live cloned animals. To better understand the molecular mechanisms of somatic cell reprogramming during SCNT and assess the various SCNT methods on the molecular level, we performed gene expression analysis on bovine blastocysts produced via standard nuclear transfer (NT), CT, NTagg, in vitro fertilization (IVF), and artificial insemination (AI), as well as on somatic donor cells, using bovine genome arrays. The expression profiles of SCNT (NT, CT, NTagg) embryos were compared with IVF and AI embryos as well as donor cells. NT and CT embryos have indistinguishable gene expression patterns. In comparison to IVF or AI embryos, the number of differentially expressed genes in NTagg embryos is significantly higher than in NT and CT embryos. Genes that were differentially expressed between all the SCNT embryos and IVF or AI embryos are identified. Compared to AI embryos, more than half of the genes found deregulated between SCNT and AI embryos appear to be the result of in vitro culture alone. The results indicate that although SCNT methods have altered differentiated somatic nuclei gene expression to more closely resemble that of embryonic nuclei, combination of insufficient reprogramming and in vitro culture condition compromise the developmental potential of SCNT embryos. This is the first set of comprehensive data for analyzing the molecular impact of various nuclear transfer methods on bovine pre-implantation embryos.

Pregnancy and fetal characteristics after transfer of vitrified in vivo and cloned bovine embryos

This study was conducted to examine pregnancy progression and fetal characteristics following transfer of vitrified bovine nuclear transfer versus in vivo-derived embryos. Nuclear transfer (NT) was conducted using cumulus cells collected from an elite Holstein-Friesian dairy cow. Expanding and hatching blastocysts on Day 7 were vitrified using liquid nitrogen surface vitrification. Day 7 in vivo embryos, produced using standard superovulation procedures applied to Holstein-Friesian heifers (n=6), were vitrified in the same way. Following warming, embryos were transferred to synchronized recipients (NT: n=65 recipients; Vivo: n=20 recipients). Pregnancies were monitored by ultrasound scanning on Days 25, 45 and 75 and a sample of animals were slaughtered at each time point to recover the fetus/placenta for further analyses. Significantly more animals remained pregnant after transfer of in vivo-derived embryos than NT embryos at all time points: Day 25 (95.0 versus 67.7%, P<0.05), Day 45 (92.8 versus 49.1%, P<0.01) and Day 75 (70.0 versus 20.8%, P<0.0). There was no significant difference (P=0.10) in the weight of the conceptus on Day 25 from NT transfers (1.14+/-0.23 g, n=8) versus in vivo transfers (0.75+/-0.19 g, n=8). On Day 45, there was no significant difference in the weight of either fetus (P=0.393) or membranes (P=0.167) between NT embryos (fetus: 2.76+/-0.40, n=12; membranes: 59.0+/-10.0, n=11) or in vivo-derived embryos (fetus: 2.60+/-0.15, n=6; membranes: 41.8+/-5.2, n=4). However, on Day 75 the weight of the fetus and several of the major organs were heavier from NT embryos. These data suggest that morphological abnormalities involving the fetus and the placenta of cloned pregnancies are manifested after Day 45.

Application of DNA array technology to mammalian embryos

Early embryogenesis depends on a tightly choreographed succession of gene expression patterns which define normal development. Fertilization and the first zygotic cleavage involve major changes to paternal and maternal chromatin and translation of maternal RNAs which have been sequestered in the oocyte during oogenesis. At a critical species-specific point known as the major onset of embryonic expression, there is a dramatic increase in expression from the new diploid genome. The advent of array technology has, for the first time, made possible to determine the transcriptional profile of all approximately 20,000 mammalian genes during embryogenesis, although the small amount of mRNA in a single embryo necessitates either pooling large numbers of embryos or a global amplification procedure to give sufficient labeled RNA for analysis. Following array hybridization, various bioinformatic tools must be employed to determine the expression level for each gene, often based on multiple oligonucleotide probes and complex background estimation protocols. The grouped analysis of clusters of genes which represent specific biological pathways provides the key to understanding embryonic development, embryonic stem cell proliferation and the reprogramming of gene expression after somatic cloning. Arrays are being developed to address specific biological questions related to embryonic development including DNA methylation and microRNA expression. Array technology in its various facets is an important diagnostic tool for the early detection of developmental aberrations; for improving the safety of assisted reproduction technologies for man; and for improving the efficiency of producing cloned and/or transgenic farm animals. This review discusses current approaches and limitations of DNA microarray technology with emphasis on bovine embryos.