Applying criteria for hepatocellular neoplasm of uncertain malignant potential reclassifies more than half of hepatocellular adenomas

Borderline Hepatocellular Adenomas: A Practical Diagnostic Approach Based on Pathologic and Molecular Features

Borderline hepatocellular adenomas (BL-HCA) are characterized by focal architectural/cytologic atypia and reticulin loss, features that are insufficient for a definitive diagnosis of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). The diagnosis and management of BL-HCA are challenging as their biological behavior, especially in terms of malignant potential, is still debated. We aimed to compare the clinicopathologic and molecular features of BL-HCA with those of typical HCA (T-HCA), HCA with malignant transformation (HCC on HCA), and HCC to assess the risk of malignancy. One hundred six liver resection specimens were retrospectively selected from 2 reference centers, including 39 BL-HCA, 42 T-HCA, 12 HCC on HCA, and 13 HCC specimens. Somatic mutations, including TERT promoter mutations associated with HCA malignant transformation and the gene expression levels of 96 genes, were investigated in 93 frozen samples. Additionally, TERT promoter mutations were investigated in 44 formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded samples. The clinical features of patients with BL-HCA were similar to those of patients with T-HCA, patients being mainly women (69%) with a median age of 37 years. The median tumor size was 7.5 cm, 64% of patients had a single nodule, and no recurrence was observed. Compared with T-HCA, BL-HCA was significantly enriched in β-catenin-mutated HCA in exon 3 (41% vs 6%; P < .001). Unsupervised statistical analysis based on gene expression showed that BL-HCA overlapped with T-HCA and HCC on HCA, favoring a molecular continuum of the tumors. TERT promoter mutations were observed only in HCC on HCA (42%) and in HCC (38%). In conclusion, these results suggest that despite their worrisome morphologic features, the clinicopathologic and molecular features of BL-HCA are much closer to those of T-HCA than those of HCC on HCA or HCC. This strongly supports the usefulness of combining morphologic and molecular analyses in a practical diagnostic approach for guiding the management of BL-HCA.

Genetic and epigenetic analysis of hepatocellular adenomas with atypical morphological features

BACKGROUND

Hepatocellular adenoma (HCA) is a rare liver tumour, which can have atypical morphological features such as cytological atypia, pseudoglandular architecture, and altered reticulin framework. Little is known about the genetic and epigenetic alterations of such HCAs and whether they show the alterations classically found in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) or in HCA without atypical morphology.

METHODS

We analysed five HCAs with atypical morphological features and one HCA with transition to HCC. Every tumour was subtyped by immunohistochemistry, sequenced by a targeted NGS panel, and analysed on a DNA methylation microarray.

RESULTS

Subtyping of the five HCAs with atypical features revealed two β-catenin mutated HCA (b-HCA), two β-catenin mutated inflammatory HCA (b-IHCA), and one sonic hedgehog activated HCA (shHCA). None of them showed mutations typically found in HCC, such as, e.g. TERT or TP53 mutations. The epigenomic pattern of HCAs with atypical morphological features clustered with reference data for HCAs without atypical morphological features but not with HCC. Similarly, phyloepigenetic trees using the DNA methylation data reproducibly showed that HCAs with morphological atypia are much more similar to nonmalignant samples than to malignant samples. Finally, atypical HCAs showed no relevant copy number variations (CNV).

CONCLUSION

In our series, mutational, DNA methylation, as well as CNV analyses, supported a relationship of atypical HCAs with nonatypical HCAs rather than with HCC. Therefore, in cases with difficult differential diagnosis between HCC and HCA, it might be advisable to perform targeted sequencing and/or combined methylation/copy number profiling.

Hepatocellular Neoplasm of Uncertain Potential of Malignancy or Well-Differentiated Hepatocellular Carcinoma Arising within Hepatocellular Adenoma

Background. Hepatocellular adenoma (HCA) is an uncommon solid, solitary, benign liver lesion that develops in an otherwise normal-appearing liver. Hemorrhage and malignant transformation are the most important complications. Risk factors for malignant transformation include advanced age, male gender, use of anabolic steroids, metabolic syndrome, larger lesions, and beta-catenin activation subtype. The identification of higher risk adenomas enables the selection of patients most suitable for aggressive treatment and those who benefit with surveillance, minimizing the risks for these predominantly young patients. Case Presentation. We present the case of a 29-year-old woman with a history of oral contraceptive intake for 13 years, which was sent to evaluation in our Hepato-Bilio-Pancreatic and Splenic Unit because of a large nodular lesion in segment 5 of the liver, compatible with HCA, and was proposed to surgical resection. Histological and immunohistochemical investigation revealed an area with atypical characteristics, suggesting malignant transformation. Conclusions. HCAs share similar imaging characteristics and histopathological features with hepatocellular carcinomas; therefore, immunohistochemical and genetic studies assumes great importance to discriminate adenomas with malignant transformation. Beta-catenin, glutamine synthetase, glypican-3, and heat-shock protein 70 are promising markers to identify higher risk adenomas.

A Case of a Beta-Catenin-Activated Hepatic Adenoma in a Male Patient With Familial Adenomatous Polyposis

Hepatocellular adenoma is a benign liver tumor often diagnosed incidentally in women of reproductive age who are taking oral contraceptives. In this study, we present a unique case of an 18-year-old man with known familial adenomatous polyposis who presented with sepsis in the setting of a recent total proctocolectomy and was incidentally found to have multiple large hepatic lesions. A biopsy of a liver lesion confirmed the diagnosis of a beta-catenin-activated hepatic adenoma. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first known case of beta-catenin-activated hepatic adenoma in a patient with a known familial adenomatous polyposis mutation. Beta-catenin is one of the many subtypes of hepatocellular adenomas, which carries a high risk of malignant transformation.

Hepatocellular adenoma: Where are we now?

Hepatocellular adenoma (HCA) is a benign hepatocellular neoplasm, commonly occurs in young women with a history of oral contraceptive use. Complications including hemorrhage and malignant transformation necessitate the need for a thorough understanding of the underlying molecular signatures in this entity. Recent molecular studies have significantly expanded our knowledge of HCAs. The well-developed phenotype-genotype classification system improves clinical management through identifying "high risk" subtype of HCAs. In this article, we attempt to provide updated information on clinical, pathologic and molecular features of each subtype of HCAs.

Hepatocellular Adenoma: What We Know, What We Do Not Know, and Why It Matters

In the last 2 decades there has been significant progress in research and diagnosis of hepatocellular adenoma (HCA), resulting in the establishment of a molecular and immunohistological HCA classification. This review aims to fine-tune the current expertise in order to enhance the histopathological diagnostic possibilities, by refining issues that are already known, addressing diagnostic difficulties and identifying still unknown aspects of HCA. We will discuss novel methods to identify HCA subtypes, in particular the sonic hedgehog HCAs and the interpretation of glutamine synthetase patterns for the recognition of beta-catenin mutated HCAs. The major complications of HCAs, bleeding and malignant transformation, will be considered, including the dilemmas of atypical and borderline lesions. Paragraphs on HCAs in different clinical and geographical settings, e.g. pregnancy, cirrhosis and non-western countries are included. The natural history of the different HCA subtypes in relation with age, sex and risk factors is a feature still insufficiently investigated. This is also true for the risks of clinical bleeding and malignant transformation in association with HCA subtypes. As HCA is a relatively rare tumor, a multicenter and multidisciplinary approach across geographical boundaries will be the appropriate method to establish prospective programs to identify, classify and manage HCAs, focusing on several aspects, e.g. etiology, underlying liver disease, complications, regression and growth. Updating what we know, identifying and addressing features that we do not know matters to warrant optimal patient management.