Performance des glottiscopes : une étude comparative randomisée menée sur simulateur d’intubation difficile

The novel video-assisted intubating laryngeal mask Totaltrack compared to the intubating laryngeal mask Fastrach - a controlled randomized manikin study

BACKGROUND

The novel Totaltrack combines a supraglottic airway device with video laryngoscopic tracheal intubation. The intubation laryngeal mask Fastrach is an established device without visual control of intubation. We hypothesized that supraglottic ventilation success with Totaltrack would be similar to Fastrach, but intubation would be performed faster due to visual control of the procedure.

METHODS

Fifty-five anaesthesiologists were randomized into one of two study arms: Fastrach Totaltrack. After a standardized introduction, six consecutive attempts of supraglottic ventilation and intubation attempts with each of one of the devices were performed on an airway manikin. The combined primary outcome was: time to supraglottic ventilation and time to ventilation after intubation. Additionally, success rate and learning curves were evaluated.

RESULTS

Supraglottic time to ventilation was shorter when using the Fastrach compared to the Totaltrack (median: 7.8 s [confidence interval [CI]: 7.0-8.6 s] vs. 11 s [CI: 7.8-14.2 s], P < 0.001). Intubation was faster using the Fastrach compared to Totaltrack (median: 12.5 s, [CI: 10.1-14.9 s] vs. 23.3 s [CI: 21.5-25.1 s], P < 0.001). Success rate for supraglottic ventilation was comparable between Fastrach and Totaltrack (86-96%). Successful intubation via the device was 100% in Fastrach and ranged from 61% to 93% in Totaltrack, with a higher probability of successful intubation after four applications.

CONCLUSION

In this manikin-based study the novel Totaltrack did not prove superior to Fastrach despite a similar design. Video laryngoscopic control of supraglottic ventilation and endotracheal intubation was prolonged using the Totaltrack. Clinical trials are mandatory to evaluate the role of the Totaltrack in airway management.

[Difficult intubation: should follow the recommendations]

Intubation and ventilation impossible mask is a dramatic situation with potentially serious consequences. We report the case of a patient of 43 years, followed for a goiter, which was scheduled for a total thyroidectomy under general anesthesia. Preoperative evaluation is not noted signs of compression or tracheal deviation, and there were no criteria predictive of intubation or difficult mask ventilation. The induction of anesthesia was standard. Mask ventilation was effective allowing paralysis. The standard laryngoscopy showed a score of Cormack and Lehane grade IV. Several attempts at intubation were made leading to a situation of intubation and ventilation impossible mask with deep desaturation. A tracheostomy was done urgently. The patient was operated on, six months later, with a fiber optic intubation. Through this case, the authors draw attention to the difficulty of achieving an emergency tracheotomy in the presence of goiter and emphasize the need for integration of different modes of learning and retention of management skills of the upper airway.

[Video laryngoscopic tracheal intubation under sedation]

We report a video laryngoscopic tracheal intubation under sedation in a patient with a hip fracture. Preoperative assessment revealed signs of difficult airway management linked to a cervical spine immobilization. Here we describe an alternative method to awake fiber optic flexible intubation.

[Awake intubation using Pentax Airway Scope as an alternative to awake fiberoptic intubation in management of anticipated difficult tracheal intubation in major burn patients]

Intubating patients with facial burn is difficult to most anesthesiologists. Awake flexible fiberoptic intubation is the gold standard for management of anticipated difficult tracheal intubation. However, serious facial burn and dysmorphic syndrome can make fiberoptic intubation more difficult or impossible. We report the use of awake oral intubation using the Pentax-Airway Scope (AWS) in two major burn patients with facial injury, in whom awake fiberoptic intubation was impossible. As shown in morbidly obese patient and in patients with unstable necks, AWS could be useful to facilitate tracheal intubation in awake, facial burn patients presenting with a potentially difficult airway. Awake AWS intubation seems as a potential alternative to awake fiberoptic intubation.

[Comparison between the Airtraq, X-Lite, and direct laryngoscopes for thyroid surgery: a randomized clinical trial]

PURPOSE

To compare the performance of the Airtraq, X-Lite, and direct laryngoscopes for tracheal intubation for elective thyroid surgery.

METHODS

In this randomized prospective study, Patients who were ASA (American Society of Anesthesiologists) I or II physical status I or II and patients undergoing thyroid surgery were included in this randomized prospective study. Patients with attributes for difficult intubation criteria were excluded. After induction of anesthesia with fentanyl, propofol, and cisatracurium, patients were randomized into three groups according to the intubating device used: Airtraq laryngoscope (Airtraq), X-Lite video laryngoscope (X-lLite), and direct laryngoscope with a Macintosh blade (Direct). The primary outcome measurement was the time needed for tracheal intubation. Secondary outcomes included intubation difficulty score (IDS), Cormack-Lehane classification, as well as hemodynamic and respiratory effects.

RESULTS

One hundred and five patients were included. Mean (standard deviation) time for intubation was 28.2 (2.1) sec in the Airtraq group vs 36.6 (3.7) sec in the X-Lite group (P < 0.001), and 41.1 (4.4) sec in the Direct group (P < 0.001). Compared with to the direct laryngoscope, the Airtraq provided better visualization of the glottis (P = 0.003) with fewer attempts (P < 0.001) and lower IDS (P < 0.001). The intubation difficulty score was lower with the Airtraq than with the X-Lite (P = 0.003). Patients in the X-Lite and Direct groups showed more hemodynamic variations than those in the Airtraq group. There was only one failed intubation, in the direct group.

CONCLUSION

In thyroid surgery, the Airtraq and X-Lite laryngoscopes decrease time to intubation when compared with direct laryngoscopy.

Validation of a model of graded difficulty in Laerdal SimMan: functional comparisons between Macintosh, Truview EVO2, Glidescope Video Laryngoscope and Airtraq

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

A randomised, cross-over study was designed to validate a new model of graded difficulty (based on mandibular space reduction) in the Laerdal 'SimMan' mannnequin and to suggest functional comparisons between Macintosh. Glidescope Video Laryngoscope, Truview EVO2 and Airtraq.

METHODS

Twenty anaesthetists attempted intubation with all four laryngoscopes in three settings: easy, intermediate (based on a custom-made removable prosthetic insert) and difficult ('tongue oedema', a mannnequin feature). Laryngoscopic view and time to intubate were the primary outcome measures. Other measures were successful intubation, ease of laryngoscopy [visual analogue scale (VAS)] and intubation (VAS), tongue compression score and number of attempts.

RESULTS

Between settings comparisons demonstrated that Macintosh, Glidescope and Airtraq had worsening scores from easy to intermediate with lesser changes for Truview. However, with the intermediate to difficult comparison, Airtraq was the only blade with no worsening of scores. Within-blade comparisons showed that Macintosh was superior over all in both the easy and intermediate settings, whereas Airtraq was the most successful blade in the difficult setting.

CONCLUSION

Our study suggests that Glidescope and, to some extent Truview, are functionally similar to Macintosh and suffer from similar limitations in the difficult setting. On the contrary, Airtraq was functionally unique in providing good laryngeal exposure in the difficult setting and without excessive tongue compression.