Non-myeloablative bone marrow transplantation

Cost structure and clinical outcome of a stem cell transplantation program in a developing country: the experience in northeast Mexico

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) in developing countries is cost-limited. Our primary goal was to determine the cost structure for the HSCT program model developed over the last decade at our public university hospital and to assess its clinical outcomes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Adults and children receiving an allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant from January 2010 to February 2011 at our hematology regional reference center were included. Laboratory tests, medical procedures, chemotherapy drugs, other drugs, and hospitalization costs were scrutinized to calculate the total cost for each patient and the median cost for the procedure. Data regarding clinical evolution were incorporated into the analysis. Physician fees are not charged at the institution and therefore were not included.

RESULTS

Fifty patients were evaluated over a 1-year period. The total estimated cost for an allogeneic HSCT was $12,504. The two most expensive diseases to allograft were non-Hodgkin lymphoma ($11,760 ± $2,236) for the malignant group and thalassemia ($12,915 ± $5,170) for the nonmalignant group. Acute lymphoblastic leukemia ($11,053 ± 2,817) and acute myeloblastic leukemia ($10,251 ± $1,538) were the most frequent indications for HSCT, with 11 cases each. Median out-of-pocket expenses were $1,605, and 1-year follow-up costs amounted to $1,640, adding up to a total cost of $15,749 for the first year. The most expensive components were drugs and laboratory tests.

CONCLUSION

Applying the cost structure described, HSCT is an affordable option for hematological patients living in a developing country.

Breaking dogmata to help patients: non-myeloablative haematopoietic stem cell transplantation

Various dogmata have been broken as a consequence of the evolution of knowledge in the area of allogeneic haematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation. The following is now clear: for the successful engraftment of allogeneic HSC, bone marrow ablation of the recipient is not required; HSCs create their own space through graft-versus-host reactions; several malignancies can be eradicated by the graft-versus-tumour effect; HSC allografting can be conducted on an out-patient basis; HSC allografting can be done in aged or debilitated individuals; HSC allografting can be achieved without transfusion of blood products; and the costs of the allografting procedures can be substantially diminished. Despite the fact that HSC allografting with reduced intensity conditioning may be related to several disadvantages, such as mixed chimaerism and relapse of the malignancy, breaking these dogmata has resulted in availability of HSC allografting to a larger number of individuals worldwide, thus offering true curative therapeutic options to patients who otherwise would not qualify to be given these opportunities.

Significance of one human leukocyte antigen mismatch on outcome of nonmyeloablative allogeneic stem cell transplantation from related donors using the Mexican schedule

Using the Mexican approach to conduct nonablative stem cell transplantation (NST), we have prospectively performed 58 allografts in individuals with various malignant and nonmalignant hematological diseases using sibling donors, either HLA identical (6/6) or compatible, with one mismatch (5/6). When comparing allografts obtained from HLA identical (n=40) or compatible (n=18) siblings, respectively, the overall median survival was found to be 33 vs 8 months (P<0.01), the 52-month survival was 47 vs 38% (P>0.2), the prevalence of acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) 57 vs 38%, that of chronic GVHD 25 vs 11% and the relapse rate 45 vs 55%. The two patients who failed to engraft were both 5/6 matches. Probably stemming from the low number of patients, and despite a trend toward worse results in patients allografted from HLA compatible (5/6) siblings, most differences in outcome were not significant. It seems that NST can be offered to individuals with either an HLA identical or a compatible sibling donor.