What Factors Affect Whether Patients Return to the Same Surgeon to Replace the Contralateral Joint? A Study of Over 200,000 Patients

Matching the other side at staged bilateral total hip arthroplasty : investigating radiological variations in staged bilateral total hip arthroplasty

Aims

The aim of this study was to assess the variations in the positioning of components between sides in patients who underwent staged bilateral total hip arthroplasty (THA), and whether these variations affected patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs).

Methods

A retrospective review included 207 patients who underwent staged bilateral THA between June 2017 and November 2022. Leg length, the height and anteversion of the acetabular component, and the coronal and sagittal angles of the femoral component were assessed radiologically and compared with the contralateral THA. The effect of the surgical approach and the technology used on this variation was also assessed. Linear regression was used to investigate the variations between the two THAs and the PROMs.

Results

Between the two sides, the mean leg length varied by 4.6 mm (0.0 to 21.2), the mean height of the acetabular component varied by 3.3 mm (0.0 to 13.7), the mean anteversion varied by 8.2° (0.0° to 28.7°), the mean coronal alignment of the femoral component varied by 1.1° (0.0° to 6.9°), and the mean sagittal alignment varied by 2.3° (0.0° to 10.5°). The use of the direct anterior approach resulted in significantly more variation in the alignment of the femoral component in both the coronal (1.3° vs 1.0°; p = 0.036) and sagittal planes (2.8° vs 2.0°; p = 0.012) compared with the use of the posterior approach. The posterior approach generally led to more anteversion of the acetabular component than the anterior approach. The use of robotics or navigation for positioning the acetabular compoment did not increase side-to-side variations in acetabular component-related positioning or leg length. Despite considerable side-to-side variations, the mean Hip disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome, Joint Replacement (HOOS JR) score was not affected by variations in the postioning of the components.

Conclusion

Staged bilateral THA resulted in considerable variation in the positioning of the components between the two sides. The direct anterior approach led to more variations in anteversion of the acetabular component and sagittal alignment of the femoral component than the posterior approach. The use of computer navigation and robotics did not improve the consistency of the positioning of the components in bilateral THA. Variations in the positioning of the components was not associated with differences in PROMs, indicating that patients can tolerate these differences.

After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Surgery, Variables Associated With Returning to the Same Surgeon If a Subsequent Antrior Cruciate Ligament Surgery Is Needed?

INTRODUCTION

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions (ACLrs) unfortunately can require revision ACLr, or contralateral ACLr may be indicated (together subsequent ACLr). This study aimed to examine the rate of and factors associated with returning to the same surgeon.

METHODS

Patients who underwent ACLr and subsequent ACLr within 3 years were abstracted from the PearlDiver database. Patient factors and surgical factors were examined. Factors independently associated with changing the surgeon were examined.

RESULTS

Overall, 63,582 ACLr patients were identified with 2,823 (4.4%) having a subsequent ACLr. These subsequent ACLrs were performed by the same surgeon for 1,329 (47.1%) and by a different surgeon for 1,494 (52.9%). Factors independently associated with changing surgeons were 90-day adverse events after index surgery (odds ratio [OR] 1.95), longer time to second surgery (OR 1.61), and second surgery on the ipsilateral knee (OR 1.28). Notably, sex, comorbidity, depression, psychoses, and insurance plan were not correlated with choosing changing surgeons.

CONCLUSION

Over half of the patients who required a subsequent ACLr changed surgeons. Changing surgeons was associated with adverse events after index surgery, ipsilateral revisions, longer time to surgery, and patient age. However, there should be confidence that the other assessed factors were not associated with the decision to change surgeons.

Variables Affecting 90-Day Overall Reimbursement After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Analysis of Nearly 250,000 Patients in the United States

Background

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) is a commonly performed orthopaedic procedure. As the number of ACLRs continues to increase in incidence, understanding the variability and drivers of cost to the health care system may help target cost-saving measures.

Purposes

To examine the variability in overall 90-day reimbursements (amount paid for health care services) for ACLR using a national, multi-insurance, administrative database and to assess factors associated with variability.

Study Design

Cross-sectional study.

Methods

Using the M151 PearlDiver data set (data from 2010 to April 30, 2021), the authors identified the 90-day total reimbursements in patients who underwent ACLR. Patient age, sex, and comorbidity burden; insurance type; inpatient versus outpatient surgery status; and 90-day postoperative adverse events were determined and were correlated with overall reimbursements using multivariable logistic regression.

Results

A total of 249,484 patients who underwent ACLR during the study period were identified. The mean patient age was 31.6 ± 13.58 years, 50.3% were female, the mean Elixhauser Comorbidity Index (ECI) was 1.4 ± 1.8, and procedures were performed on an outpatient basis for 245,507 patients (98.4%). Insurance type was commercial for 220,284 patients (88.3%), Medicaid for 17,660 (7.1%), and Medicare for 3500 (1.4%). The mean overall 90-day reimbursement was $4281.91 ± $4982.61 (median [interquartile range], $3032 [$1681-5142]), and the total reimbursement for the patient cohort was $1,049,250,747. On multivariable linear regression, the variables independently associated with the greatest changes in overall reimbursement were (in decreasing order) hospital readmission (+$17,675.23), adverse events (+$1554.14), inpatient procedure (+$1246.51), and emergency department visits (+$784.06). Lesser but significant associations were found with greater ECI (+$252.30) and female sex (+$101.01). Decreased overall reimbursement was associated with older age (-$12.19) and Medicare (-$883.48)/Medicaid (-$493.18) relative to commercial insurance.

Conclusion

In the current study, large variability was found in overall ACLR reimbursement/cost within the health care system. Hospital admissions (inpatient surgery and readmission) and adverse events were associated with the greatest increase in costs and emphasize the need to optimize these metrics above and beyond patient experience.

Individualized Surgeon Reports in a Statewide Registry: A Pathway to Improved Outcomes

ABSTRACT

Despite progress with the development of joint replacement registries in the United States, surgeons may have limited opportunities to determine the cumulative outcome of their own patients or understand how those outcomes compare with their peers; this information is important for quality improvement. In order to provide surgeons with accurate data, it is first necessary to have a registry with complete coverage and patient matching. Some international registries have accomplished this. Building on a comprehensive statewide registry in the United States, a surgeon-specific report has been developed to provide surgeons with survivorship and complication data, which allows comparisons with other surgeons in the state. This article describes funnel plots, cumulative sum reports, complication-specific data, and patient-reported outcome measure data, which are provided to hip and knee arthroplasty surgeons with the goal of improving quality, decreasing variability in the delivery of care, and leading to improved value and outcomes for hip and knee arthroplasty in the state of Michigan.

Following carpel tunnel release, what factors affect whether patients return to the same or different hand surgeon for a subsequent procedure?

BACKGROUND

Following carpal tunnel release (CTR), patients may be indicated for subsequent hand surgery (contralateral CTR and/or trigger finger release [TFR]). While surgeons typically take pride in patient loyalty, the rate of returning to the same hand surgeons has not been previously characterized.

METHODS

Patients undergoing CTR were isolated from 2010-2021 PearlDiver M151 dataset. Subsequent CTR or TFR were identified and characterized as being performed by the same or different surgeon, with patient factors associated with changing to a different surgeon determined by multivariable analyses.

RESULTS

In total, 1,121,922 CTR patients were identified. Of these, subsequent surgery was identified for 307,385 (27.4%: CTR 289,455 [94.2%] and TFR 17,930 [5.8%]). Of the patients with a subsequent surgery, 257,027 (83.6%) returned to the same surgeon and 50,358 (16.4%) changed surgeons. Multivariable analysis found factors associated with changing surgeon (in order of decreasing odds ration [OR]) to be: TFR as the second procedure (OR 2.98), time between surgeries greater than 2-years (OR 2.30), Elixhauser-Comorbidity Index (OR 1.14 per 2-point increase), and male sex (OR 1.06), with less likely hood of changing for those with Medicare (OR 0.95 relative to commercial insurance) (p<0.001 for each). Pertinent negatives included: age, Medicaid, and having a 90-day adverse event after the index procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

Over fifteen percent of patients who required a subsequent CTR or TFR following CTR did not return to the same surgeon. Understanding what factors lead to outmigration of patients form a practice may help direct efforts for patient retention.

Rate and Timing of Revision and Contralateral Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Relative to Index Surgery

Background

After anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR), ipsilateral ACL graft reinjury or contralateral ACL injury has been reported. The rate and predictors of such subsequent ACL injuries have not been reported in recent years and in large patient cohorts.

Purpose

The current study utilized a large, national, multi-insurance, administrative database to assess subsequent ACLR and factors associated with its occurrence.

Study Design

Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods

Using the PearlDiver M151 database, patients who underwent ACLR within the United States between 2015 and 2021 were abstracted. All included patients had ≥3 years of evaluation after initial ACLR. Patients who underwent a subsequent reconstruction (ipsilateral or contralateral) within 3 years were determined and the timing assessed. Using univariable and multivariable logistic regression, the factors associated with having a subsequent ACLR and the factors associated with returning for ipsilateral versus contralateral ACLR were examined.

Results

In total, 40,151 patients who underwent initial ACLR during the study period were identified. Of these, subsequent ACLR was performed for 1689 patients (4.2%). These included ipsilateral revision for 1018 (60.3%) and contralateral reconstruction for 671 (39.7%) patients. Patients returning for ipsilateral reconstruction did so sooner than patients needing a contralateral reconstruction. On multivariable analysis, the only factor independently associated with subsequent ACLR was younger age (odds ratio [OR] = 4.17 for 10-14 years relative to 25-29 years; P < .0001). Factors associated with returning for an ipsilateral revision ACLR as opposed to contralateral ACLR were earlier revision (OR = 1.49 within 1.5 years relative to after 1.5 years; P = .0001) and female sex (OR = 0.62 relative to male sex; P < .0001).

Conclusion

The overall rate of requiring a subsequent ACLR was found to be 4.2%, with 60.3% of these being to the ipsilateral ACL. This information may be helpful for evolving injury-prevention programs and patient counseling.

After Primary Total Shoulder Arthroplasty, Factors Associated with Returning to the Same Surgeon for Subsequent Total Shoulder Arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) is commonly done for degenerative conditions. Patients may need additional contralateral TSA or ipsilateral revision TSA. As a marker of patient satisfaction and practice integrity, factors associated with return to the same or different surgeon are of interest.

METHODS

Patients undergoing TSA were abstracted from the PearlDiver data set. Subsequent TSA within 2 years was identified. Factors analyzed included age, sex, comorbidity burden, prior depression diagnosis, insurance type, reverse versus anatomic TSA, ipsilateral versus contralateral surgery, and postoperative adverse events. Patients returning to the same surgeon versus different surgeon were compared with multivariable analysis.

RESULTS

98,048 TSA patients were identified, with 8483 patients (8.7%) undergoing subsequent TSA within 2 years. Of those, 1,237 (14.6%) chose a different surgeon. Factors associated with changing surgeons were revision surgery on the ipsilateral shoulder (OR:2.47), Medicaid insurance (OR:1.46), female sex (OR:1.36), any adverse events (OR:1.23), and higher Elixhauser Comorbidity Index (OR:1.07 per point), while prior depression diagnosis was associated with decreased odds (OR:0.74) of changing surgeon (P < 0.05 for all).

DISCUSSION

When pursuing a subsequent TSA, only a minority of patients changed to a different surgeon. Factors identified associated with changing to a different surgeon may help guide measures to improve patient satisfaction and practice integrity.

Total Knee Arthroplasty: Variables Affecting 90-day Overall Reimbursement

BACKGROUND

Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is commonly considered to address symptomatically limiting knee osteoarthritis. With increasing utilization, understanding the variability and related drivers may help the healthcare system optimize delivery to the large numbers of patient to whom it is offered.

METHODS

A total of 1,066,327 TKA patients who underwent primary TKA were isolated from a 2010 to 2021 PearlDiver national dataset. Exclusion criteria included patients less than 18 years old and traumatic, infectious, or oncologic indications. Overall, 90-day reimbursements and variables associated with the patient, surgical procedure, region, and perioperative period were abstracted. Multivariable linear regressions were performed to determine independent drivers of reimbursement.

RESULTS

The 90-day postoperative reimbursements had an average (standard deviation) of $11,212.99 ($15,000.62), a median (interquartile range) of $4,472.00 ($13,101.00), and a total of $11,946,962,912. Variables independently associated with the greatest increase in overall 90-day reimbursement were related to admission (in-patient index-procedure [+$5,695.26] or hospital readmission [+$18,495.03]). Further drivers were region (Midwest +$8,826.21, West +$4,578.55, South +$3,709.40; relative to Northeast), insurance (commercial +$4,492.34, Medicaid +$1,187.65; relative to Medicare), postoperative emergency department visits (+$3,574.57), postoperative adverse events (+$1,309.35), (P < .0001 for each).

CONCLUSION

The current study assessed over a million TKA patients and found large variations in reimbursement/cost. The largest increases in reimbursement were associated with admission (readmission or index procedure). This was followed by region, insurance, and other postoperative events. These results underscore the necessity to balance performing out-patient surgeries in appropriate patients versus the risk of readmissions and defined other areas for cost containment strategies.

What are the Causes, Costs and Risk-Factors for Emergency Department Visits Following Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty? An Analysis of 1,018,772 Patients

BACKGROUND

Well-powered studies analyzing the relationship and nature of emergency department (ED) visits following primary total hip arthroplasties (THAs) are limited. The aim of this study was to: 1) compare baseline demographics of patients with/without an ED visit; 2) determine leading causes of ED visits; 3) identify patient-related risk factors; and 4) quantify 90-day episode-of-care healthcare costs divided by final diagnosis.

METHODS

Patients undergoing primary THA between January 1, 2010 and October 1, 2020 who presented to the ED within 90-days postoperatively were identified using the Mariner dataset of PearlDiver, yielding 1,018,772 patients. This included 3.9% (n = 39,439) patients who did and 96.1% (n = 979,333) who did not have an ED visit. Baseline demographics between the control/study cohorts, ED visit causes, risk-factors, and subsequent costs-of-care were analyzed. Using Bonferroni-correction, a P-value less than 0.002 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

Patients who presented to the ED post-operatively were most often aged 65-74 years old (41.09%) or female sex (55.60%). Nonmusculoskeletal etiologies comprised 66.8% of all ED visits. Risk factors associated with increased ED visits included alcohol abuse, depressive disorders, congestive heart failure, coagulopathy, and electrolyte/fluid derangements (P < .001 for all). Pulmonary ($28,928.01) and cardiac ($28,574.69) visits attributed to the highest costs of care.

CONCLUSION

Nonmusculoskeletal causes constituted the majority of ED visits. The top five risk factors associated with increased odds of ED visits were alcohol abuse, electrolyte/fluid derangements, congestive heart failure, coagulopathy, and depression. This study highlights potential areas of pre-operative medical optimization that may reduce ED visits following primary THA.