Stent and Leaflet Stresses in 29-mm Second-Generation Balloon-Expandable Transcatheter Aortic Valve

In silico fatigue optimization of TAVR stent designs with physiological motion in a beating heart model

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The rapid expansion of TAVR to younger, low-risk patients raises concerns regarding device durability. Necessarily, extended stent lifetime will become more critical for new generation devices. In vitro methods commonly used for TAVR stent fatigue testing exclude the effects of the beating heart. We present a more realistic in silico stent fatigue analysis utilizing a beating heart model in which TAVR stents experience complex, nonuniform dynamic loading.

METHODS

Virtual TAVR deployments were simulated in the SIMULIA Living Heart Human Model of a beating heart using stent models of the self-expandable nitinol 26-mm CoreValve and Evolut R devices, and a 27-mm PolyV-2. Stent deformation was monitored over three cardiac cycles, and fatigue resistance was evaluated for the nitinol stents using finite element analysis via ABAQUS/Explicit. The average strain and strain amplitude of each stent element were tracked, and established thresholds were applied to determine potential fatigue failure. Fatigue performance of control stents was compared to parametrically modified models with a 20% increase or decrease in strut width.

RESULTS

Stents with reduced strut width applied lower radial force against the contracting myocardium of the beating heart, resulting in larger displacements and higher strain values. Formulas relating in vivo strain to stent design do not account for this. In all models, there were elements in which strains exceeded fatigue failure. The PolyV-2 stent had far fewer failing elements since its struts were optimized to reduce the strain in stent joints, achieving better fatigue resistance in the stent crown and waist elements. Different stent sections showed markedly different fatigue resistance due to the varying loading conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

Our analysis indicates that previous studies underestimate strain amplitudes that may cause stent failure. This study demonstrates the utility of advanced in silico analysis of devices deployed within a beating heart that mimics in vivo loading, offering a cost-effective alternative to human or animal trials and establishing a platform to assess the impact of device design on device durability. The limited fatigue life of TAVR stents indicated here highlights a clinical complication that may eventually develop as younger, lower-risk TAVR patients, age.

Effect of TAVR commissural alignment on coronary flow: A fluid-structure interaction analysis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Coronary obstruction is a complication that may affect patients receiving Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement (TAVR), with catastrophic consequences and long-term negative effects. To enable healthy coronary perfusion, it is fundamental to appropriately position the device with respect to the coronary ostia. Nonetheless, most TAVR delivery systems do not control commissural alignment to do so. Moreover, no in silico study has directly assessed the effect of commissural alignment on coronary perfusion. This work aims to evaluate the effect of TAVR commissural alignment on coronary perfusion and device performance.

METHODS

A two-way computational fluid-structure interaction model is used to predict coronary perfusion at different commissural alignments. Moreover, in each scenario, hemodynamic biomarkers are evaluated to assess device performance.

RESULTS

Commissural misalignment is shown to reduce the total coronary perfusion by -3.2% and the flow rate to a single coronary branch by -6.8%. It is also observed to impair valvular function by reducing the systolic geometric orifice area by -2.5% and increasing the systolic transvalvular pressure gradients by +5.3% and the diastolic leaflet stresses by +16.0%.

CONCLUSIONS

The present TAVR patient model indicates that coronary perfusion, hemodynamic and structural performance are minimized when the prosthesis commissures are fully misaligned with the native ones. These results support the importance of enabling axial control in new TAVR delivery catheter systems and defining recommended values of commissural alignment in upcoming clinical treatment guidelines.

A review of numerical simulation in transcatheter aortic valve replacement decision optimization

BACKGROUND

Recent trials indicated a further expansion of clinical indication of transcatheter aortic valve replacement to younger and low-risk patients. Factors related to longer-term complications are becoming more important for use in these patients. Accumulating evidence indicates that numerical simulation plays a significant role in improving the outcome of transcatheter aortic valve replacement. Understanding mechanical features' magnitude, pattern, and duration is a topic of ongoing relevance.

METHODS

We searched the PubMed database using keywords such as "transcatheter aortic valve replacement" and "numerical simulation" and reviewed and summarized relevant literature.

FINDINGS

This review integrated recently published evidence into three subtopics: 1) prediction of transcatheter aortic valve replacement outcomes through numerical simulation, 2) implications for surgeons, and 3) trends in transcatheter aortic valve replacement numerical simulation.

INTERPRETATIONS

Our study offers a comprehensive overview of the utilization of numerical simulation in the context of transcatheter aortic valve replacement, and highlights the advantages, potential challenges from a clinical standpoint. The convergence of medicine and engineering plays a pivotal role in enhancing the outcomes of transcatheter aortic valve replacement. Numerical simulation has provided evidence of potential utility for tailored treatments.

Leaflet Stresses During Full Device Simulation of Crimping to 6 mm in Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation, TAVI

BACKGROUND

With continuing growth in transcatheter aortic valve implantation for the treatment of a failing aortic valve, there is increasing interest in prosthetic valve durability and the potential damage caused to leaflets by stress. Whilst most available research into the computational prediction of leaflet stresses using finite element analysis, FEA, has focussed on variations during dynamic loading, very little appears to have been reported for the impact of crimping, even though awareness of this effect is widespread. Potentially, this has been due to the difficulty of performing full model simulations of crimping to clinically meaningful diameters.

METHOD

A full model comprising a self-expanding frame, skirt and leaflets has been developed and crimped to a final diameter of 6 mm. A detailed description is provided of the FEA setup, emphasising the importance of the skirt definition needed to successfully crimp to this small diameter. Then, an analysis of leaflet folding and stresses is presented, particularly with respect to the differences produced between leaflet thicknesses of 0.20, 0.25 and 0.30 mm and for bioprosthetic and polymeric leaflet material models.

RESULTS

In all cases, peak stresses occurred close to the modelled suture lines joining the leaflets and the skirt and high stresses were also present along axially aligned folds in the leaflets. Stresses were lower for the polymeric leaflets.

CONCLUSION

Successful simulation of crimping requires a finely resolved skirt mesh. Leaflet stresses during crimping are dependent on leaflet thickness, material properties and the ratio of leaflet volume to the available volume inside the crimped valve.

Impact of Transcatheter Aortic Valve Size on Leaflet Stresses: Implications for Durability and Optimal Grey Zone Sizing

Aims

As indications for transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) continue to expand towards younger and lower-risk patients, durability becomes an increasingly important question. Durability decreases as leaflet stresses increase, but the impact of transcatheter heart valve (THV) size on stress is unknown. Patient annulus sizes can fall within "grey zones" between 2 TAVR sizes. Our aim was to examine the impact of balloon-expandable THV size on leaflet stresses.

Methods and Results

SapienXT 23mm, 26mm, and 29mm sizes (Edwards Lifesciences, Inc) underwent micro-computed tomography scanning to create THV computational models then loaded to systemic pressure using finite element software. THV leaflet maximum principal stresses were 1.69MPa (23mm), 1.70MPa (26mm), and 2.12MPa (29mm) at mean arterial pressure. For intermediate annulus sizes, undersizing the larger THV yielded lower leaflet stresses than oversizing the smaller THV.

Conclusions

Increasing THV size yielded greater leaflet maximum principal stresses, which could suggest a relationship between THV size and long-term durability.. For annulus "grey zones" sizes, undersizing the larger THV resulted in lower leaflet stresses than oversizing the smaller THV. These results may influence optimal device sizing, as THV durability remains an important, unanswered question.

Stent and leaflet stresses across generations of balloon-expandable transcatheter aortic valves

OBJECTIVES

Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) is established therapy for severe aortic stenosis patients with intermediate-, high- and prohibitive-risk for surgery. A significant challenge when expanding TAVR to low-risk and younger patients is the unknown long-term durability. High leaflet stresses have been associated with surgical bioprosthetic valve degeneration. In this study, we examined the impact of changes in valve design across 3 generations of same-sized TAVR devices on stent and leaflet stresses.

METHODS

The 26-mm Edwards SAPIEN, 23, 26 and 29 mm SAPIEN XT (XT) and 26 mm SAPIEN 3 (S3) (n = 1 each) underwent micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) scanning. Dynamic finite element computational simulations of 23-26 mm SAPIEN, 23-29 mm XT and 23-29 mm S3 were performed with physiological loading and micro-CT or scaled geometries.

RESULTS

Peak stresses were concentrated in the commissure area and along the bottom of the suture, representing areas most likely to develop structural valve degeneration across TAVR generations. Latest-generation S3 showed greatest 99th percentile principal stress on commissural leaflets for 26 and 29 mm, and increased stresses over XT for 23 mm. Percentage of higher stress areas within the leaflets steadily increased across generations, 3.8%, 3.9% and 5.7%, respectively, for 26 mm SAPIEN, XT and S3 with similar trend for 29-mm valves.

CONCLUSIONS

Using computational simulations based on high-fidelity modelling of balloon-expandable TAVRs, our study demonstrated that maximum stress areas existed in similar leaflet locations across SAPIEN generations, while the latest model S3 had the highest magnitude for both 26- and 29-mm valves. S3 also had the largest area of higher stresses than other generations, which would be prone to degeneration. Our study coupled with future long-term clinical outcomes >10 years will provide insight on biomechanics of TAVR degeneration.

On the Modeling of Patient-Specific Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement: A Fluid-Structure Interaction Approach

PURPOSE

Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) is a minimally invasive treatment for high-risk patients with aortic diseases. Despite its increasing use, many influential factors are still to be understood and require continuous investigation. The best numerical approach capable of reproducing both the valves mechanics and the hemodynamics is the fluid-structure interaction (FSI) modeling. The aim of this work is the development of a patient-specific FSI methodology able to model the implantation phase as well as the valve working conditions during cardiac cycles.

METHODS

The patient-specific domain, which included the aortic root, native valve and calcifications, was reconstructed from CT images, while the CAD model of the device, metallic frame and pericardium, was drawn from literature data. Ventricular and aortic pressure waveforms, derived from the patient's data, were used as boundary conditions. The proposed method was applied to two real clinical cases, which presented different outcomes in terms of paravalvular leakage (PVL), the main complication after TAVR.

RESULTS

The results confirmed the clinical prognosis of mild and moderate PVL with coherent values of regurgitant volume and effective regurgitant orifice area. Moreover, the final release configuration of the device and the velocity field were compared with postoperative CT scans and Doppler traces showing a good qualitative and quantitative matching.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the development of realistic and accurate FSI patient-specific models can be used as a support for clinical decisions before the implantation.

Age-Related 2-Year Mortality After Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement: the YOUNG TAVR Registry

OBJECTIVE

To comparatively assess the natural history of patients of different ages undergoing transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

For this study, we used the YOUNG TAVR, an international, multicenter registry investigating mortality trends up to 2 years in patients with aortic valve stenosis treated by TAVR, classified according to 3 prespecified age groups: 75 years or younger (n=179), 76 to 86 years (n=602), and older than 86 years (n=221). A total of 1002 patients undergoing TAVR were included. Demographic, clinical, and outcome data in the youngest group were compared with those of patients 76 to 86 years and older than 86 years. Patients were followed up for up to 2 years.

RESULTS

Compared with patients 75 years or younger (reference group), patients aged 76 to 86 years and older than 86 years had nonsignificantly different 30-day mortality (odds ratio, 0.76; 95% CI, 0.41-1.38; P=.37 and odds ratio, 1.27; 95% CI, 0.62-2.60; P=.51, respectively) and 1-year mortality (hazard ratio (HR), 0.72; 95% CI, 0.48-1.09; P=.12 and HR, 1.11; 95% CI, 0.88-1.40; P=.34, respectively). Mortality at 2 years was significantly lower among patients aged 76 to 86 years (HR, 0.62; 95% CI, 0.42-0.90; P=.01) but not among the older group (HR, 1.06; 95% CI, 0.68-1.67; P=.79). The Society of Thoracic Surgeons 30-day mortality score was lower in younger patients who, however, had a significantly higher prevalence of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (P=.005 vs the intermediate group and P=.02 vs the older group) and bicuspid aortic valves (P=.02 vs both older groups), larger left ventricles, and lower ejection fractions.

CONCLUSION

In the present registry, mortality at 2 years after TAVR among patients 75 years or younger was higher compared with that of patients aged 75 to 86 years and was not markedly different from that of patients older than 86 years. The findings are attributable at least in part to a greater burden of comorbidities in the younger age group that are not entirely captured by current risk assessment tools.

Stent and leaflet stresses in 26-mm, third-generation, balloon-expandable transcatheter aortic valve

OBJECTIVES

Transcatheter aortic valve replacement has proven successful in treating intermediate-risk, high-risk, and inoperable patients with severe aortic stenosis. Third-generation, balloon-expandable transcatheter aortic valves were developed with an outer sealing skirt to reduce paravalvular leakage. As transcatheter aortic valve replacement use expands, long-term durability questions remain. Valve design influences durability, where regions of increased leaflet stress are vulnerable to early degeneration. However, third-generation transcatheter aortic valve stresses are unknown. Our goals were to determine the stent and leaflet stresses of third-generation, balloon-expandable transcatheter aortic valves.

METHODS

The commercial 26-mm Edwards SAPIEN 3 valve (Edwards Lifesciences, Inc, Irvine, Calif) underwent high-resolution micro-computed tomography scanning to develop a precise 3-dimensional geometric mesh of the stent and valve. Leaflet material properties were obtained from surgical bioprostheses, and stent material properties were based on cobalt-chromium. Simulations of systemic pressure loading were performed, and stress was calculated using finite element analyses.

RESULTS

At diastole, maximum and minimum principal stresses on transcatheter aortic valve leaflets were 2.7 MPa and -0.47 MPa, respectively. Peak leaflet stresses were observed at upper leaflet commissures, at their connection to the stent. Maximum and minimum principal stresses for the stent were 38.2 MPa and -44.4 MPa, respectively, at 80 mm Hg and were located just below the commissural stent.

CONCLUSIONS

Stress analysis of the 26-mm SAPIEN 3 valve using exact geometry from high-resolution scans demonstrated that peak stresses for both transcatheter aortic valve stent and leaflets were present at commissural tips where leaflets were attached. These regions would be most likely to initiate degeneration. The Dacron skirt had minimal effect on stresses on leaflets and stent.