Unidirectional regulation of the F1FO-ATP synthase nanomotor by the ζ pawl-ratchet inhibitor protein of Paracoccus denitrificans and related α-proteobacteria

Fo·F1 ATP-synthase/ATPase of Paracoccus denitrificans: Mystery of Unidirectional Catalysis

Fo·F1 ATP synthases/ATPases (Fo·F1) catalyze ATP synthesis by consuming energy of electrochemical potential of hydrogen ions (pmf), or ATP hydrolysis resulting in the pmf formation. It is generally accepted to consider Fo·F1 as a reversible chemomechanical-electrical molecular machine, however: (i) the mechanism of energy-dependent ATP synthesis is based only on the data on hydrolytic activity of the enzyme, (ii) Fo·F1 from a number of organisms effectively synthesize, but is unable to hydrolyze ATP, which indicates non-observance of the principle of microreversibility and requires development of a new hypotheses concerning the enzyme mechanism. Since 1980, the group of A. D. Vinogradov has been developing a concept according to which the elementary catalysis stages of ATP hydrolysis and ATP synthesis do not coincide, and there are two independently operating forms of Fo·F1 in the coupled membranes - pmf-generating ATPase and pmf-consuming ATP synthase. Fo·F1 of P. denitrificans as a natural model of an irreversibly functioning enzyme is a convenient object for experimental verification of the hypothesis of unidirectional energy conversion. The review considers modern concepts of the molecular mechanisms of regulation of Fo·F1 ATP synthase/ATPase of P. denitrificans and development of the hypothesis of two forms of Fo·F1.

Inhibitory to non-inhibitory evolution of the ζ subunit of the F1FO-ATPase of Paracoccus denitrificans and α-proteobacteria as related to mitochondrial endosymbiosis

Introduction: The ζ subunit is a potent inhibitor of the F1FO-ATPase of Paracoccus denitrificans (PdF1FO-ATPase) and related α-proteobacteria different from the other two canonical inhibitors of bacterial (ε) and mitochondrial (IF1) F1FO-ATPases. ζ mimics mitochondrial IF1 in its inhibitory N-terminus, blocking the PdF1FO-ATPase activity as a unidirectional pawl-ratchet and allowing the PdF1FO-ATP synthase turnover. ζ is essential for the respiratory growth of P. denitrificans, as we showed by a Δζ knockout. Given the vital role of ζ in the physiology of P. denitrificans, here, we assessed the evolution of ζ across the α-proteobacteria class. Methods: Through bioinformatic, biochemical, molecular biology, functional, and structural analyses of several ζ subunits, we confirmed the conservation of the inhibitory N-terminus of ζ and its divergence toward its C-terminus. We reconstituted homologously or heterologously the recombinant ζ subunits from several α-proteobacteria into the respective F-ATPases, including free-living photosynthetic, facultative symbiont, and intracellular facultative or obligate parasitic α-proteobacteria. Results and discussion: The results show that ζ evolved, preserving its inhibitory function in free-living α-proteobacteria exposed to broad environmental changes that could compromise the cellular ATP pools. However, the ζ inhibitory function was diminished or lost in some symbiotic α-proteobacteria where ζ is non-essential given the possible exchange of nutrients and ATP from hosts. Accordingly, the ζ gene is absent in some strictly parasitic pathogenic Rickettsiales, which may obtain ATP from the parasitized hosts. We also resolved the NMR structure of the ζ subunit of Sinorhizobium meliloti (Sm-ζ) and compared it with its structure modeled in AlphaFold. We found a transition from a compact ordered non-inhibitory conformation into an extended α-helical inhibitory N-terminus conformation, thus explaining why the Sm-ζ cannot exert homologous inhibition. However, it is still able to inhibit the PdF1FO-ATPase heterologously. Together with the loss of the inhibitory function of α-proteobacterial ε, the data confirm that the primary inhibitory function of the α-proteobacterial F1FO-ATPase was transferred from ε to ζ and that ζ, ε, and IF1 evolved by convergent evolution. Some key evolutionary implications on the endosymbiotic origin of mitochondria, as most likely derived from α-proteobacteria, are also discussed.

F1·Fo ATP Synthase/ATPase: Contemporary View on Unidirectional Catalysis

F1·Fo-ATP synthases/ATPases (F1·Fo) are molecular machines that couple either ATP synthesis from ADP and phosphate or ATP hydrolysis to the consumption or production of a transmembrane electrochemical gradient of protons. Currently, in view of the spread of drug-resistant disease-causing strains, there is an increasing interest in F1·Fo as new targets for antimicrobial drugs, in particular, anti-tuberculosis drugs, and inhibitors of these membrane proteins are being considered in this capacity. However, the specific drug search is hampered by the complex mechanism of regulation of F1·Fo in bacteria, in particular, in mycobacteria: the enzyme efficiently synthesizes ATP, but is not capable of ATP hydrolysis. In this review, we consider the current state of the problem of “unidirectional” F1·Fo catalysis found in a wide range of bacterial F1·Fo and enzymes from other organisms, the understanding of which will be useful for developing a strategy for the search for new drugs that selectively disrupt the energy production of bacterial cells.

Interaction of Venturicidin and Fo·F1-ATPase/ATP Synthase of Tightly Coupled Subbacterial Particles of Paracoccus denitrificans in Energized Membranes

Proton-translocating F_o×F₁-ATPase/synthase that catalyzes synthesis and hydrolysis of ATP is commonly considered to be a reversibly functioning complex. We have previously shown that venturicidin, a specific F_o-directed inhibitor, blocks the synthesis and hydrolysis of ATP with a significant difference in the affinity [Zharova, T. V. and Vinogradov, A. D. (2017) Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1858, 939-944]. In this paper, we have studied in detail inhibition of F_o×F₁-ATPase/synthase by venturicidin in tightly coupled membranes of Paracoccus denitrificans under conditions of membrane potential generation. ATP hydrolysis was followed by the ATP-dependent succinate-supported NAD+ reduction (potential-dependent reverse electron transfer) catalyzed by the respiratory chain complex I. It has been demonstrated that membrane energization did not affect the affinity of F_o×F₁-ATPase/synthase for venturicidin. The dependence of the residual ATP synthase activity on the concentration of venturicidin approximated a linear function, whereas the dependence of ATP hydrolysis was sigmoidal: at low inhibitor concentrations venturicidin strongly inhibited ATP synthesis without decrease in the rate of ATP hydrolysis. A model is proposed suggesting that ATP synthesis and ATP hydrolysis are catalyzed by two different forms of F_o×F₁.

Evolution of the Inhibitory and Non-Inhibitory ε, ζ, and IF1 Subunits of the F1FO-ATPase as Related to the Endosymbiotic Origin of Mitochondria

The F1FO-ATP synthase nanomotor synthesizes >90% of the cellular ATP of almost all living beings by rotating in the “forward” direction, but it can also consume the same ATP pools by rotating in “reverse.” To prevent futile F1FO-ATPase activity, several different inhibitory proteins or domains in bacteria (ε and ζ subunits), mitochondria (IF1), and chloroplasts (ε and γ disulfide) emerged to block the F1FO-ATPase activity selectively. In this study, we analyze how these F1FO-ATPase inhibitory proteins have evolved. The phylogeny of the α-proteobacterial ε showed that it diverged in its C-terminal side, thus losing both the inhibitory function and the ATP-binding/sensor motif that controls this inhibition. The losses of inhibitory function and the ATP-binding site correlate with an evolutionary divergence of non-inhibitory α-proteobacterial ε and mitochondrial δ subunits from inhibitory bacterial and chloroplastidic ε subunits. Here, we confirm the lack of inhibitory function of wild-type and C-terminal truncated ε subunits of P. denitrificans. Taken together, the data show that ζ evolved to replace ε as the primary inhibitor of the F1FO-ATPase of free-living α-proteobacteria. However, the ζ inhibitory function was also partially lost in some symbiotic α-proteobacteria and totally lost in some strictly parasitic α-proteobacteria such as the Rickettsiales order. Finally, we found that ζ and IF1 likely evolved independently via convergent evolution before and after the endosymbiotic origin mitochondria, respectively. This led us to propose the ε and ζ subunits as tracer genes of the pre-endosymbiont that evolved into the actual mitochondria.

Computational Design of Inhibitors Targeting the Catalytic β Subunit of Escherichia coli FOF1-ATP Synthase

With the uncontrolled growth of multidrug-resistant bacteria, there is an urgent need to search for new therapeutic targets, to develop drugs with novel modes of bactericidal action. FoF1-ATP synthase plays a crucial role in bacterial bioenergetic processes, and it has emerged as an attractive antimicrobial target, validated by the pharmaceutical approval of an inhibitor to treat multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. In this work, we aimed to design, through two types of in silico strategies, new allosteric inhibitors of the ATP synthase, by targeting the catalytic β subunit, a centerpiece in communication between rotor subunits and catalytic sites, to drive the rotary mechanism. As a model system, we used the F1 sector of Escherichia coli, a bacterium included in the priority list of multidrug-resistant pathogens. Drug-like molecules and an IF1-derived peptide, designed through molecular dynamics simulations and sequence mining approaches, respectively, exhibited in vitro micromolar inhibitor potency against F1. An analysis of bacterial and Mammalia sequences of the key structural helix-turn-turn motif of the C-terminal domain of the β subunit revealed highly and moderately conserved positions that could be exploited for the development of new species-specific allosteric inhibitors. To our knowledge, these inhibitors are the first binders computationally designed against the catalytic subunit of FOF1-ATP synthase.

Bioenergetics: To the dark side and back with cyanobacterial ATP synthase

F₁F_O ATP synthases are remarkable because of their strict reversibility and the diverse mechanisms that prevent back reactions and futile cycling. Cyanobacteria power both the photosynthetic and respiratory electron transport chains in the same membrane system using a novel regulatory polypeptide that is expressed only at night.

Complex effects of macrolide venturicidins on bacterial F-ATPases likely contribute to their action as antibiotic adjuvants

Bacterial energy metabolism is now recognized as a critical factor for the efficacy of antibiotics. The F-type ATPase/ATP synthase (F_OF₁) is a central player in cellular bioenergetics of bacteria and eukaryotes, and its potential as a selective antibiotic target has been confirmed by the success of bedaquiline in combatting multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. Venturicidin macrolides were initially identified for their antifungal properties and were found to specifically inhibit F_OF₁ of eukaryotes and bacteria. Venturicidins alone are not effective antibacterials but recently were found to have adjuvant activity, potentiating the efficacy of aminoglycoside antibiotics against several species of resistant bacteria. Here we discovered more complex effects of venturicidins on the ATPase activity of F_OF₁ in bacterial membranes from Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Our major finding is that higher concentrations of venturicidin induce time- and ATP-dependent decoupling of F₁-ATPase activity from the venturicidin-inhibited, proton-transporting F_O complex. This dysregulated ATPase activity is likely to be a key factor in the depletion of cellular ATP induced by venturicidins in prior studies with P. aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus. Further studies of how this functional decoupling occurs could guide development of new antibiotics and/or adjuvants that target the F-type ATPase/ATP synthase.

Regulation of bacterial ATP synthase activity: A gear-shifting or a pawl-ratchet mechanism?

The F₁ F_o -ATP synthase, a widely distributed nanomotor responsible of ATP synthesis, rotates its central rotor reversibly: In the clockwise direction when viewed from the Fo (with the observer facing the positive side of the energy transducing membrane and looking down into the negative side of the membrane), it functions as ATP synthase, while in counterclockwise sense, it operates as a proton-pumping ATP hydrolase. Regulation exerted by naturally occurring inhibitory proteins of the enzyme appears to function by avoiding ATP hydrolysis while preserving ATP synthesis. The work of Liu et al. describes an unbiased, elegant analytical pipeline that provides important insights into the inhibitory role of the ε-subunit of the bacterial F₁ F_o -ATP synthase in vivo. We discuss if a gear-shifting versus a pawl-ratchet mechanism may explain the regulatory role of the ε-subunit.

The 3 × 120° rotary mechanism of Paracoccus denitrificans F1-ATPase is different from that of the bacterial and mitochondrial F1-ATPases

The rotation of Paracoccus denitrificans F₁-ATPase (PdF₁) was studied using single-molecule microscopy. At all concentrations of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) or a slowly hydrolyzable ATP analog (ATPγS), above or below K _m, PdF₁ showed three dwells per turn, each separated by 120°. Analysis of dwell time between steps showed that PdF₁ executes binding, hydrolysis, and probably product release at the same dwell. The comparison of ATP binding and catalytic pauses in single PdF₁ molecules suggested that PdF₁ executes both elementary events at the same rotary position. This point was confirmed in an inhibition experiment with a nonhydrolyzable ATP analog (AMP-PNP). Rotation assays in the presence of adenosine diphosphate (ADP) or inorganic phosphate at physiological concentrations did not reveal any obvious substeps. Although the possibility of the existence of substeps remains, all of the datasets show that PdF₁ is principally a three-stepping motor similar to bacterial vacuolar (V₁)-ATPase from Thermus thermophilus This contrasts with all other known F₁-ATPases that show six or nine dwells per turn, conducting ATP binding and hydrolysis at different dwells. Pauses by persistent Mg-ADP inhibition or the inhibitory ζ-subunit were also found at the same angular position of the rotation dwell, supporting the simplified chemomechanical scheme of PdF₁ Comprehensive analysis of rotary catalysis of F₁ from different species, including PdF₁, suggests a clear trend in the correlation between the numbers of rotary steps of F₁ and F_o domains of F-ATP synthase. F₁ motors with more distinctive steps are coupled with proton-conducting F_o rings with fewer proteolipid subunits, giving insight into the design principle the F₁F_o of ATP synthase.