Fast-tumbling bicelles constructed from native Escherichia coli lipids

Expanding the Toolbox for Bicelle-Forming Surfactant–Lipid Mixtures

Bicelles are disk-shaped models of cellular membranes used to study lipid–protein interactions, as well as for structural and functional studies on transmembrane proteins. One challenge for the incorporation of transmembrane proteins in bicelles is the limited range of detergent and lipid combinations available for the successful reconstitution of proteins in model membranes. This is important, as the function and stability of transmembrane proteins are very closely linked to the detergents used for their purification and to the lipids that the proteins are embedded in. Here, we expand the toolkit of lipid and detergent combinations that allow the formation of stable bicelles. We use a combination of dynamic light scattering, small-angle X-ray scattering and cryogenic electron microscopy to perform a systematic sample characterization, thus providing a set of conditions under which bicelles can be successfully formed.

Dilute Bicelles for Glycosyltransferase Studies, Novel Bicelles with Phosphatidylinositol

Solution-state NMR can be used to study protein-lipid interactions, in particular, the effect that proteins have on lipids. One drawback is that only small assemblies can be studied, and therefore, fast-tumbling bicelles are commonly used. Bicelles contain a lipid bilayer that is solubilized by detergents. A complication is that they are only stable at high concentrations, exceeding the CMC of the detergent. This issue has previously been addressed by introducing a detergent (Cyclosfos-6) with a substantially lower CMC. Here, we developed a set of bicelles using this detergent for studies of membrane-associated mycobacterial proteins, for example, PimA, a key enzyme for bacterial growth. To mimic the lipid composition of mycobacterial membranes, PI, PG, and PC lipids were used. Diffusion NMR was used to characterize the bicelles, and spin relaxation was used to measure the dynamic properties of the lipids. The results suggest that bicelles are formed, although they are smaller than "conventional" bicelles. Moreover, we studied the effect of MTSL-labeled PimA on bicelles containing PI and PC. The paramagnetic label was shown to have a shallow location in the bicelle, affecting the glycerol backbone of the lipids. We foresee that these bicelles will be useful for detailed studies of protein-lipid interactions.

Bicelles and nanodiscs for biophysical chemistry

Membrane nanoobjects are very important tools to study biomembrane properties. Two types are described herein: Bicelles and Nanodiscs. Bicelles are obtained by thorough water mixing of long chain and short chain lipids and may take the form of membranous discs of 10-50 nm. Temperature-composition-hydration diagrams have been established for Phosphatidylcholines and show limited domains of existence. Bicelles can be doped with charged lipids, surfactants or with cholesterol and offer a wide variety of membranous platforms for structural biology. Internal dynamics as measured by solid-state NMR is very similar to that of liposomes in their fluid phase. Because of the magnetic susceptibility anisotropy of the lipid chains, discs may be aligned along or perpendicular to the magnetic field. They may serve as weak orienting media to provide distance information in determining the 3D structure of soluble proteins. In different conditions they show strong orienting properties which may be used to study the 3D structure, topology and dynamics of membrane proteins. Lipid Bicelles with biphenyl chains or doped with lanthanides show long lasting remnant orientation after removing the magnetic field due to smectic-like properties. An alternative to pure lipid Bicelles is provided by nanodiscs where the half torus composed by short chain lipids is replaced by proteins. This renders the nano-objects less fragile as they can be used to stabilize membrane protein assemblies to be studied by electron microscopy. Internal dynamics is again similar to liposomes except that the phase transition is abolished, possibly due to lateral constrain imposed by the toroidal proteins limiting the disc size. Advantages and drawbacks of both nanoplatforms are discussed.

Altering the edge chemistry of bicelles with peptoids

Cell function is tied to the interactions that occur within and across the cell membrane. Therefore, understanding membrane-affiliated interactions is important to many biomedical applications. Advancing the body of knowledge about these interactions will lead to discoveries in biomarker detection and therapeutic targets for disease detection and treatment. Model membrane systems are an effective way to study membrane proteins for such discoveries, allowing for stable protein structure and maintaining native activity. Bicelles, disc-shaped lipid bilayers created by combining long- and short-chain phospholipids, are the model membrane system of focus in this study. Bicelles are accessible from both sides and have a wide size range, which makes them attractive for studying membrane interactions without affecting function. In this work, bicelles were functionalized with peptoids to alter the edge chemistry. Peptoids are suitable for this application because of the large diversity of available side chain chemistries that can be easily incorporated in a sequence-specific manner. The peptoid sequence consists of three functional regions to promote insertion into the edge of bicelles. The insertion sequence at the C-terminus contains two alkyl chains and two hydrophobic, chiral aromatic groups that anchor into the bicelle edge. The facially amphipathic helix contains chiral aromatic groups on one side that interact with the lipid tails and positively charged groups on the other side, which interact with the lipid head groups. Thiol groups are included at the N-terminus to allow for visualization of peptoid location in the bicelle. Bicelle morphology and size were assessed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and dynamic light scattering (DLS). Peptoid location in the bicelle was determined by attachment of gold nanoparticles, which confirmed preferential incorporation of the peptoid into the bicelle edge with 82% specificity. Additionally, the peptoid-functionalized bicelles are of similar size and morphology to non-functionalized bicelles. Results from this study show that peptoid-functionalized bicelles are a promising model membrane system with potential applications in biosensors or bioseparations.

Probing the effect of membrane contents on transmembrane protein-protein interaction using solution NMR and computer simulations

The interaction between the secondary structure elements is the key process, determining the spatial structure and activity of a membrane protein. Transmembrane (TM) helix-helix interaction is known to be especially important for the function of so-called type I or bitopic membrane proteins. In the present work, we present the approach to study the helix-helix interaction in the TM domains of membrane proteins in various lipid environment using solution NMR spectroscopy and phospholipid bicelles. The technique is based on the ability of bicelles to form particles with the size, depending on the lipid/detergent ratio. To implement the approach, we report the experimental parameters of "ideal bicelle" models for four kinds of zwitterionic phospholipids, which can be also used in other structural studies. We show that size of bicelles and type of the rim-forming detergent do not affect substantially the spatial structure and stability of the model TM dimer. On the other hand, the effect of bilayer thickness on the free energy of the dimer is dramatic, while the structure of the protein is unchanged in various lipids with fatty chains having a length from 12 to 18 carbon atoms. The obtained data is analyzed using the computer simulations to find the physical origin of the observed effects.

Behavior of Most Widely Spread Lipids in Isotropic Bicelles

Isotropic bicelles are a widely used membrane mimetic for structural studies of membrane proteins and their transmembrane domains. Simple and cheap in preparation, they contain a patch of lipid bilayer that reproduces the native environment of membrane proteins. Despite the obvious power of bicelles in reproducing the various kinds of environments, the vast majority of structural studies employ the single lipid/detergent system. On the other hand, even if the alternative bicelle composition is used, the properties of mixtures are not characterized, and the mere presence of lipid bilayer and discoidal shape of bicelle particles is not confirmed. Here we present an extensive investigation of various bicellar mixtures and describe the behavior of bicelles with lipids other than classical DMPC, namely sphingomyelins (SM), phosphatidylethanolamines (PE), phosphatidylglycerols (PG), phosphatidylserines (PS), and cholesterol. These lipids are rarely used in modern structural biology, but can help a lot in understanding the influence of the membrane composition on the properties of both integral and peripheral membrane proteins. Additionally, the ability of diheptanoylphosphatidylcholine (DH7PC) to serve as a rim-forming agent was investigated. We followed the phase transitions as revealed by ³¹P NMR and size of particles measured by ¹H NMR diffusion as the criteria of the proper morphology and structure of bicelles. As an outcome, we state that SM exclusively, and PG/PS in mixtures with zwitterionic lipids can form small isotropic bicelles, which reproduce the key features of lipid behavior in bilayers. Mixtures, containing exclusively the anionic lipids, fail to reveal the lipid phase transition and do not follow the size predicted for the ideal bicelle particles. PE and DH7PC are the unwanted components of bicellar mixtures, and cholesterol can be added to bicelles, however, with certain precautions. In combination with our several most recent works, this study provides a practical guide for the preparation of small isotropic bicelles.

Phase Transitions in Small Isotropic Bicelles

Isotropic phospholipid bicelles are one of the most prospective membrane mimetics for the structural studies of membrane proteins in solution. Recent works provided an almost full set of data regarding the properties of isotropic bicelles; however, one major aspect of their behavior is still under consideration: the possible mixing between the lipid and detergent in the bilayer area. This problem may be resolved by studying the lipid phase transitions in bicelle particles. In the present work, we investigate two effects: phase transitions of bilayer lipids and temperature-induced growth of isotropic bicelles using the NMR spectroscopy. We propose an approach to study the phase transitions in isotropic bicelles based on the properties of ³¹P NMR spectra of bilayer-forming lipids. We show that phase transitions in small bicelles are "fractional", particles with the liquid-crystalline and gel bilayers coexist in solution at certain temperatures. We study the effects of lipid fatty chain type and demonstrate that the behavior of various lipids in bilayers is reproduced in the isotropic bicelles. We show that the temperature-induced growth of isotropic bicelles is not related directly to the phase transition but is the result of the reversible fusion of bicelle particles. In accordance with our data, rim detergents also have an impact on phase transitions: detergents that resist the temperature-induced growth provide the narrowest and most expressed transitions at higher temperatures. We demonstrate clearly that phase transitions take place even in the smallest bicelles that are applicable for structural studies of membrane proteins by solution NMR spectroscopy. This last finding, together with other data draws a thick line under the long-lasting argument about the relevance of small isotropic bicelles. We show with certainty that the small bicelles can reproduce the most fundamental property of lipid membranes: the ability to undergo phase transition.

New insights into the membrane association mechanism of the glycosyltransferase WaaG from Escherichia coli

Monotopic glycosyltransferases (GTs) interact with membranes via electrostatic interactions. The N-terminal domain is permanently anchored to the membrane while the membrane interaction of the C-terminal domain is believed to be weaker so that it undergoes a functionally relevant conformational change upon donor or acceptor binding. Here, we studied the applicability of this model to the glycosyltransferase WaaG. WaaG is involved in the synthesis of lipopolysaccharides (LPS) in Gram-negative bacteria and was previously categorized as a monotopic GT. We analyzed the binding of WaaG to membranes by stopped-flow fluorescence and NMR diffusion experiments. We find that electrostatic interactions are required to bind WaaG to membranes while mere hydrophobic interactions are not sufficient. WaaG senses the membrane's surface charge density but there is no preferential binding to specific anionic lipids. However, the binding is weaker than expected for monotopic GTs but similar to peripheral GTs. Therefore, WaaG may be a peripheral GT and this could be of functional relevance in vivo since LPS synthesis occurs only when WaaG is membrane-bound. We could not observe a C-terminal domain movement under our experimental conditions.

Contrast-Matched Isotropic Bicelles: A Versatile Tool to Specifically Probe the Solution Structure of Peripheral Membrane Proteins Using SANS

Obtaining structural information on integral or peripheral membrane proteins is currently arduous due to the difficulty of their solubilization, purification, and crystallization (for X-ray crystallography (XRC) application). To overcome this challenge, bicelles are known to be a versatile tool for high-resolution structure determination, especially when using solution and/or solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and, to a lesser extent, XRC. For proteins not compatible with these high-resolution methods, small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering (SAXS and SANS, respectively) are powerful alternatives to obtain structural information directly in solution. In particular, the SANS-based approach is a unique technique to obtain low-resolution structures of proteins in interactions with partners by contrast-matching the signal coming from the latter. In the present study, isotropic bicelles are used as a membrane mimic model for SANS-based structural studies of bound peripheral membrane proteins. We emphasize that the SANS signal coming from the deuterated isotropic bicelles can be contrast-matched in 100% D₂O-based buffer, allowing us to separately and specifically focus on the signal coming from the protein in interaction with membrane lipids. We applied this method to the DYS-R11-15 protein, a fragment of the central domain of human dystrophin known to interact with lipids, and we were able to recover the signal from the protein alone. This approach gives rise to new perspectives to determine the solution structure of peripheral membrane proteins interacting with lipid membranes and might be extended to integral membrane proteins.