Molecular basis for the substrate selectivity of bicyclic and monocyclic extradiol dioxygenases

Engineering non-conservative substrate recognition sites of extradiol dioxygenase: Computation guided design to diversify and accelerate degradation of aromatic compounds

Extradiol dioxygenases (EDOs) catalyzing meta-cleavage of catecholic compounds promise an effective way to detoxify aromatic pollutants. This work reported a novel scenario to engineer our recently identified Type I EDO from Tcu3516 for a broader substrate scope and enhanced activity, which was based on 2,3-dihydroxybiphenyl (2,3-DHB)-liganded molecular docking of Tcu3516 and multiple sequence alignment with other 22 Type I EDOs. 11 non-conservative residues of Tcu3516 within 6 Å distance to the 2,3-DHB ligand center were selected as potential hotspots and subjected to semi-rational design using 6 catecholic analogues as substrates; the mutants V186L and V212N returned with progressive evolution in substrate scope and catalytic activity. Both mutants were combined with D285A for construction of double mutants and final triple mutant V186L/V212N/D285A. Except for 2,3-DHB (the mutant V186L/D285A gave the best catalytic performance), the triple mutant prevailed all other 5 catecholic compounds for their degradation; affording the catalytic efficiency kcat/Km value increase by 10-30 folds, protein Tm (structural rigidity) increase by 15 °C and the half-life time enhancement by 10 times compared to the wild type Tcu3516. The molecular dynamic simulation suggested that a stabler core and a more flexible entrance are likely accounting for enhanced catalytic activity and stability of enzymes.

Biochemical and genetic characterization comparison of four extradiol dioxygenases in Rhizorhabdus wittichii RW1

Rhizorhabdus (previously Sphingomonas) wittichii RW1 uses a diverse array of aromatic organic compounds as energy and carbon sources, including some extremely recalcitrant compounds such as dibenzo-p-dioxin and dibenzofuran. Extradiol dioxygenases play a key role in the metabolism of dibenzofuran (DBF), dibenzo-p-dioxin (DBD), PCBs, and various other aromatic compounds. In this study, a detailed kinetic analysis of four extradiol dioxygenases identified in R. wittichii RW1 (DbfB, Edo2, Edo3, and Edo4) showed all of them to be typical 2,3dihydroxybiphenyl (DHB) dioxygenases with DHB as preferred substrate (k_cat/K_m values of 0.13-188 (µM ^-1 s^-1)) and only slightly lower activity against trihydroxybiphenyl (THB) whereas monocyclic substrates were, to different extents, poor substrates due to high k_m values. All extradiol dioxygenases analyzed were subject to mechanism-based inactivation by 2,2`,3-trihydroxybiphenylether (THBE) the intermediate of DBD degradation. However, Edo4 was superior as reflected by the relatively high partition ratio and the comparably low efficiency of inactivation. Significant differences were observed with respect to their inactivation by 3-chlorocatechol. The absence of any significant mechanism-based inactivation makes Edo3 a perfect candidate for being recruited for chlorobiphenyl degradation where inactivation of extradiol dioxygenases by this intermediate creates significant metabolic problems. KEY POINTS: • Characterization of additional extradiol dioxygenases encoded by RW1 • Identification of differences in 2,2`,3-trihydroxybiphenylether transformation • Identification of differences in inhibition by 3-chlorocatechol.

L-DOPA Dioxygenase Activity on 6-Substituted Dopamine Analogues

Dioxygenase enzymes are essential protein catalysts for the breakdown of catecholic rings, structural components of plant woody tissue. This powerful chemistry is used in nature to make antibiotics and other bioactive materials or degrade plant material, but we have a limited understanding of the breadth and depth of substrate space for these potent catalysts. Here we report steady-state and pre-steady-state kinetic analysis of dopamine derivatives substituted at the 6-position as substrates of L-DOPA dioxygenase, and an analysis of that activity as a function of the electron-withdrawing nature of the substituent. Steady-state and pre-steady-state kinetic data demonstrate the dopamines are impaired in binding and catalysis with respect to the cosubstrate molecular oxygen, which likely afforded spectroscopic observation of an early reaction intermediate, the semiquinone of dopamine. The reaction pathway of dopamine in the pre-steady state is consistent with a nonproductive mode of binding of oxygen at the active site. Despite these limitations, L-DOPA dioxygenase is capable of binding all of the dopamine derivatives and catalyzing multiple turnovers of ring cleavage for dopamine, 6-bromodopamine, 6-carboxydopamine, and 6-cyanodopamine. 6-Nitrodopamine was a single-turnover substrate. The variety of substrates accepted by the enzyme is consistent with an interplay of factors, including the capacity of the active site to bind large, negatively charged groups at the 6-position and the overall oxidizability of each catecholamine, and is indicative of the utility of extradiol cleavage in semisynthetic and bioremediation applications.

Effects of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon Mixtures on Degradation, Gene Expression, and Metabolite Production in Four Mycobacterium Species

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are widespread environmental contaminants that are hazardous to human health. It has been demonstrated that members of the Mycobacterium genus are among the most effective degraders of PAHs, but few studies have focused on the degradation of PAH mixtures. In this study, single and mixed PAH metabolism was investigated in four phylogenetically distinct Mycobacterium species with respect to (i) parent compound degradation, (ii) bacterial growth, (iii) catabolic gene expression, and (iv) metabolite production. Synergistic and antagonistic effects on four model PAH compounds (benzo[a]pyrene, pyrene, fluoranthene, and phenanthrene) characterized degradation of mixtures in a strain- and mixture-dependent manner. The mixture of pyrene and phenanthrene, in particular, resulted in antagonized degradation by three out of four bacterial species, and further studies were narrowed to investigate the degradation of this mixture. Antagonistic effects persisted over time and were correlated with reduced bacterial growth. Antagonized degradation of PAH was not caused by preferential degradation of secondary PAHs, nor were mixture compounds or concentrations toxic to cells growing on sugars. Reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) studies of the characterized catabolic pathway of phenanthrene showed that in one organism, antagonism of mixture degradation was associated with downregulated gene expression. Metabolite profiling revealed that antagonism in mixture degradation was associated with the shunting of substrate through alternative pathways not used during the degradation of single PAHs. The results of this study demonstrate metabolic differences between single and mixed PAH degradation with consequences for risk assessment and bioremediation of PAH-contaminated sites.

IMPORTANCE

Mycobacterium species are promising organisms for environmental bioremediation because of their ubiquitous presence in soils and their ability to catabolize aromatic compounds. PAHs can be degraded effectively as single compounds, but mixed substrates often are subject to degradative inhibition, which may explain the persistence of these pollutants in soils. Single and mixed PAH degradation by diverse Mycobacterium species was compared, with associated bacterial growth, gene expression, and metabolite production. The results demonstrate that antagonism characterized degradation in a strain- and mixture-dependent manner. One strain that was versatile in its pathway use of single chemicals also efficiently degraded the mixture, whereas antagonism in other the strains was associated with altered metabolic profiles, indicating unusual pathway use. The impacts of this work on risk assessment and bioremediation modeling studies indicate the need to account for mixture-generated intermediates and to recognize mixture degradation as a property distinct from that of PAH substrate range.

Bacterial strategies for growth on aromatic compounds

Although the biodegradation of aromatic compounds has been studied for over 40 years, there is still much to learn about the strategies bacteria employ for growth on novel substrates. Elucidation of these strategies is crucial for predicting the environmental fate of aromatic pollutants and will provide a framework for the development of engineered bacteria and degradation pathways. In this chapter, we provide an overview of studies that have advanced our knowledge of bacterial adaptation to aromatic compounds. We have divided these strategies into three broad categories: (1) recruitment of catabolic genes, (2) expression of "repair" or detoxification proteins, and (3) direct alteration of enzymatic properties. Specific examples from the literature are discussed, with an eye toward the molecular mechanisms that underlie each strategy.

Exploring allosteric activation of LigAB from Sphingobium sp. strain SYK-6 through kinetics, mutagenesis and computational studies

The protocatechuate 4,5-dioxygenase (LigAB) from Sphingobium sp. strain SYK-6 is the defining member of the Type II extradiol dioxygenase superfamily (a.k.a. PCA Dioxygenase Superfamily or PCADSF) and plays a key aromatic ring-opening role in the metabolism of several lignin derived aromatic compounds. In our search for alternate substrates and inhibitors of LigAB, we discovered allosteric rate enhancement in the presence of non-substrate protocatechuate-like aldehydes such as vanillin. LigAB has the broadest substrate utilization profile of all protocatechuate (PCA) 4,5-dioxygenase described in the literature, however, the rate enhancement is only observed with PCA, with vanillin increasing kcat for LigAB by 36%. Computational docking has identified a potential site of allosteric binding near the entrance to the active site. Examination of a multiple sequence alignment reveals that many of the residues contributing to this newly identified allosteric pocket are highly conserved within the LigB family of the PCADSF. Point mutants of Phe103α and Ala18β, two residues located in the putative allosteric pocket, display altered rate enhancement as compared to LigAB-WT, providing support for the computationally identified allosteric binding site. Further investigation of this binding site may provide insight into the mechanism of this never before observed allosteric activation in extradiol dioxygenases.

The Ins and Outs of Ring-Cleaving Dioxygenases

Ring-cleaving dioxygenases catalyze the oxygenolytic fission of catecholic compounds, a critical step in the aerobic degradation of aromatic compounds by bacteria. Two classes of these enzymes have been identified, based on the mode of ring cleavage: intradiol dioxygenases utilize non-heme Fe(III) to cleave the aromatic nucleus ortho to the hydroxyl substituents; and extradiol dioxygenases utilize non-heme Fe(II) or other divalent metal ions to cleave the aromatic nucleus meta to the hydroxyl substituents. Recent genomic, structural, spectroscopic, and kinetic studies have increased our understanding of the distribution, evolution, and mechanisms of these enzymes. Overall, extradiol dioxygenases appear to be more versatile than their intradiol counterparts. Thus, the former cleave a wider variety of substrates, have evolved on a larger number of structural scaffolds, and occur in a wider variety of pathways, including biosynthetic pathways and pathways that degrade non-aromatic compounds. The catalytic mechanisms of the two enzymes proceed via similar iron-alkylperoxo intermediates. The ability of extradiol enzymes to act on a variety of non-catecholic compounds is consistent with proposed differences in the breakdown of this iron-alkylperoxo intermediate in the two enzymes, involving alkenyl migration in extradiol enzymes and acyl migration in intradiol enzymes. Nevertheless, despite recent advances in our understanding of these fascinating enzymes, the major determinant of the mode of ring cleavage remains unknown.