Nickel spiking to improve the methane yield of sewage sludge

Abiotic and biotic roles of metals in the anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge: A review

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is a promising technique for sludge treatment and resource recovery. Metals are very important components of sludge and can have substantial effects on its complex nature and microbial activity. However, systematic reviews have not addressed how metals in sludge affect AD and how they can be regulated to improve AD. This paper comprehensively reviews the effects of metals on the AD of sludge from both abiotic and biotic perspectives. First, we introduce the contents and basic characteristics (e.g., chemical forms) of intrinsic metals in sewage sludge. Then, we summarise the main mechanism by which metals influence sludge properties and the methods for removing metals and thus improving AD. Next, we analyze the effects of both intrinsic and exogenous metals on the enzymes and microbial communities involved in anaerobic bioconversion, focusing on the types, critical concentrations and valence states of the metals. Finally, we propose ideas for future research on the roles of metals in the AD of sludge. In summary, this review systematically clarifies the roles of metals in the AD of sludge and provides a reference for improving AD by regulating these metals.

Planktonic/benthic Bathyarchaeota as a "gatekeeper" enhance archaeal nonrandom co-existence and deterministic assembling in the Yangtze River

Archaea, the third proposed domain of life, mediate carbon and nutrient cycling in global natural habitats. Compared with bacteria, our knowledge about archaeal ecological modes in large freshwater environments subject to varying natural and human factors is limited. By metabarcoding analysis of 303 samples, we provided the first integrate biogeography about archaeal compositions, co-existence networks, and assembling processes within a 6000 km continuum of the Yangtze River. Our study revealed that, among the major phyla, water samples owned a higher proportion of Thaumarchaeota (62.8%), while sediments had higher proportions of Euryarchaeota (33.4%) and Bathyarchaeota (18.8%). A decline of polarization in phylum abundance profile was observed from plateau/mountain/hill to basin/plain areas, which was attributed to the increase of nutrients and metals. Planktonic and benthic Bathyarchaeota tended to co-occur with both major (e.g., methanogens or Thermoplasmata) and minor (e.g., Asgard or DPANN) taxa in the non-random networks, harboring the highest richness and abundances of keystone species and contributing the most positively to edge number, node degree, and nearest neighbor degree. Furthermore, we noted significantly positive contributions of Bathyarchaeota abundance and network complexity to the dominance of deterministic process in archaeal assembly (water: 65.3%; sediments: 92.6%), since higher carbon metabolic versatility of Bathyarchaeota would benefit archaeal symbiotic relations. Stronger deterministic assembling was identified at the lower-reach plain, and higher concentrations of ammonium and aluminum separately functioning as nutrition and agglomerator were the main environmental drivers. We lastly found that the Three Gorges Dam caused a simultaneous drop of benthic Bathyarchaeota abundance, network co-existence, and deterministic effects immediately downstream due to riverbed erosion as a local interference. These findings highlight that Bathyarchaeota are a "gatekeeper" to promote fluvial archaeal diversity, stability, and predictability under varying macroscopic and microscopic factors, expanding our knowledge about microbial ecology in freshwater biogeochemical cycling globally.

Magnetite Alters the Metabolic Interaction between Methanogens and Sulfate-Reducing Bacteria

It is known that the presence of sulfate decreases the methane yield in the anaerobic digestion systems. Sulfate-reducing bacteria can convert sulfate to hydrogen sulfide competing with methanogens for substrates such as H2 and acetate. The present work aims to elucidate the microbial interactions in biogas production and assess the effectiveness of electron-conductive materials in restoring methane production after exposure to high sulfate concentrations. The addition of magnetite led to a higher methane content in the biogas and a sharp decrease in the level of hydrogen sulfide, indicating its beneficial effects. Furthermore, the rate of volatile fatty acid consumption increased, especially for butyrate, propionate, and acetate. Genome-centric metagenomics was performed to explore the main microbial interactions. The interaction between methanogens and sulfate-reducing bacteria was found to be both competitive and cooperative, depending on the methanogenic class. Microbial species assigned to the Methanosarcina genus increased in relative abundance after magnetite addition together with the butyrate oxidizing syntrophic partners, in particular belonging to the Syntrophomonas genus. Additionally, Ruminococcus sp. DTU98 and other species assigned to the Chloroflexi phylum were positively correlated to the presence of sulfate-reducing bacteria, suggesting DIET-based interactions. In conclusion, this study provides new insights into the application of magnetite to enhance the anaerobic digestion performance by removing hydrogen sulfide, fostering DIET-based syntrophic microbial interactions, and unraveling the intricate interplay of competitive and cooperative interactions between methanogens and sulfate-reducing bacteria, influenced by the specific methanogenic group.

Utilization of nanoparticles for biogas production focusing on process stability and effluent quality

Abstract

One of the most important techniques for converting complex organic waste into renewable energy in the form of biogas and effluent is anaerobic digestion. Several issues have been raised related to the effectiveness of the anaerobic digestion process in recent years. Hence nanoparticles (NPs) have been used widely in anaerobic digestion process for converting organic wastes into useful biogas and effluent in an effective way. This review addresses the knowledge gaps and summarizes recent researchers’ findings concentrating on the stability and effluent quality of the cattle manure anaerobic digestion process using single and combinations nanoparticle. In summary, the utilization of NPs have beneficial effects on CH4 production, process optimization, and effluent quality. Their function, as key nutrient providers, aid in the synthesis of key enzymes and co-enzymes, and thus stimulate anaerobic microorganism activities when present at an optimum concentration (e.g., Fe NPs 100 mg/L; Ni NPs 2 mg/L; Co NPs 1 mg/L). Furthermore, utilizing Fe NPs at concentrations higher than 100 mg/L is more effective at reducing H2S production than increasing CH4, whereas Ni NPs and Co NPs at concentrations greater than 2 mg/L and 1 mg/L, respectively, reduce CH4 production. Effluent with Fe and Ni NPs showed stronger fertilizer values more than Co NPs. Fe/Ni/Co NP combinations are more efficient in enhancing CH4 production than single NPs. Therefore, it is possible to utilize NPs combinations as additives to improve the effectiveness of anaerobic digestion.

Article highlights

Nanomaterials for biogas augmentation towards renewable and sustainable energy production: A critical review

Nanotechnology is considered one of the most significant advancements in science and technology over the last few decades. However, the contemporary use of nanomaterials in bioenergy production is very deficient. This study evaluates the application of nanomaterials for biogas production from different kinds of waste. A state-of-the-art comprehensive review is carried out to elaborate on the deployment of different categories of nano-additives (metal oxides, zero-valent metals, various compounds, carbon-based nanomaterials, nano-composites, and nano-ash) in several kinds of biodegradable waste, including cattle manure, wastewater sludge, municipal solid waste, lake sediments, and sanitary landfills. This study discusses the pros and cons of nano-additives on biogas production from the anaerobic digestion process. Several all-inclusive tables are presented to appraise the literature on different nanomaterials used for biogas production from biomass. Future perspectives to increase biogas production via nano-additives are presented, and the conclusion is drawn on the productivity of biogas based on various nanomaterials. A qualitative review of relevant literature published in the last 50 years is conducted using the bibliometric technique for the first time in literature. About 14,000 research articles are included in this analysis, indexed on the Web of Science. The analysis revealed that the last decade (2010–20) was the golden era for biogas literature, as 84.4% of total publications were published in this timeline. Moreover, it was observed that nanomaterials had revolutionized the field of anaerobic digestion, methane production, and waste activated sludge; and are currently the central pivot of the research community. The toxicity of nanomaterials adversely affects anaerobic bacteria; therefore, using bioactive nanomaterials is emerging as the best alternative. Conducting optimization studies by varying substrate and nanomaterials’ size, concentration and shape is still a field. Furthermore, collecting and disposing nanomaterials at the end of the anaerobic process is a critical environmental challenge to technology implementation that needs to be addressed before the nanomaterials assisted anaerobic process could pave its path to the large-scale industrial sector.

Critical Review on Nanomaterials for Enhancing Bioconversion and Bioremediation of Agricultural Wastes and Wastewater

Anaerobic digestion (AD), microalgae cultivation, and microbial fuel cells (MFCs) are the major biological processes to convert organic solid wastes and wastewater in the agricultural industry into biofuels, biopower, various biochemical and fertilizer products, and meanwhile, recycle water. Various nanomaterials including nano zero valent irons (nZVIs), metal oxide nanoparticles (NPs), carbon-based and multicompound nanomaterials have been studied to improve the economics and environmental sustainability of those biological processes by increasing their conversion efficiency and the quality of products, and minimizing the negative impacts of hazardous materials in the wastes. This review article presented the structures, functionalities and applications of various nanomaterials that have been studied to improve the performance of AD, microalgae cultivation, and MFCs for recycling and valorizing agricultural solid wastes and wastewater. The review also discussed the methods that have been studied to improve the performance of those nanomaterials for their applications in those biological processes.

Interrelating EPS, soluble microbial products and metal solubility in a methanogenic consortium stressed by nickel and cobalt

The relationships between extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), soluble microbial product production, metal solubility, and methanogenic activity were investigated. The individual, and joint, toxic effects of nickel and cobalt on methanogenic consortia fed with glucose as model substrate were studied using biomethane potential assays. Cobalt was found to be less toxic to methanogens than nickel at each concentration tested, and the combined effects of Ni and Co on methane production in the bimetal experiment was higher than the sum of the effects of each metal alone. The protein content of EPS, and extracellular soluble protein fractions, decreased with increasing concentrations of total metals. Meanwhile, no significant change in response to metal stress was apparent for carbohydrate content of EPS or extracellular soluble carbohydrate. Decreasing protein content of EPS was accompanied by reduced methanogenic activity and an increase in the soluble metal fraction. The strong associations observed between these variables could be due to the critical role of EPS in protecting microbial cells against nickel and cobalt stress, possibly by capturing metal cations through their functional groups, thus reducing metal availability to the microbial cells in the methanogenic consortia underpinning the anaerobic digestion process.

Recent Advances and Perspectives of Nanotechnology in Anaerobic Digestion: A New Paradigm towards Sludge Biodegradability

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is the strategy of producing environmentally sustainable bioenergy from waste-activated sludge (WAS), but its efficiency was hindered by low biodegradability. Hence, the usage of nanomaterials was found to be essential in enhancing the degradability of sludge due to its nanostructure with specific physiochemical properties. The application of nanomaterials in sludge digestion was thoroughly reviewed. This review focused on the impact of nanomaterials such as metallic nanoparticles, metal oxide nanoparticles, carbon-based nanomaterials, and nanocomposite materials in AD enhancement, along with the pros and cons. Most of the studies detailed that the addition of an adequate dosage of nanomaterial has a good effect on microbial activity. The environmental and economic impact of the AD enhancement process is also detailed, but there are still many existing challenges when it comes to designing an efficient, cost-effective AD digester. Hence, proper investigation is highly necessary to assess the potency of utilizing the nanomaterials in enhancing AD under various conditions.

Multicomponent nanoparticles as means to improve anaerobic digestion performance

Sufficient quantity of trace metals is essential for a well performing anaerobic digestion (AD) process. Among the essential trace elements in active sites of multiple important enzymes for AD are iron and nickel ions. In the present study, iron and nickel in the form of Fe₂O₃ and NiO were coated on TiO₂ nanoparticles to be used in batch and continuous operation mode. The effect of TiO₂, Fe₂O₃-TiO₂, and NiO-TiO₂ nanoparticles on each step of AD process was assessed utilizing simple substrates (i.e. cellulose, glucose, acetic acid, and mixture of H₂-CO₂) as well as complex ones (i.e. municipal biopulp). The hydrolysis rate of cellulose substrate increased with higher dosages of the coated TiO₂ with both metals. For instance, the hydrolysis rate was increased up to 54% at Fe₂O₃-TiO₂ and at a concentration of 23.5 mg/L for NiO-TiO₂ it was increased up to 58%, while higher dosage suppressed the hydrolytic activity. Experimental results revealed that low dosages of NiO-TiO₂ increased the accumulated methane production up to 24% probably by increasing the enzymatic activity of acetoclastic methanogenesis. NiO-TiO₂ showed positive effect on batch and continuous AD of biopulp and improved methane yield up to 8%.

The role of conductive nanoparticles in anaerobic digestion: Mechanism, current status and future perspectives

In the current scenario, alternative energy sources are the need of the hour. Organic wastes having a larger fraction of biodegradable constituents present a sustainable bioenergy source. It has been reported that the calorific value of biogas generated by anaerobic digestion (AD) is 21-25 MJ/m³ with the treatment which makes it an excellent replacement of natural gas and fossil fuels and can reduce more than 80% greenhouse gas emission to the surroundings. However, there are some limitations associated with the AD process for instance ammonia build-up at the first stage reduces the rate of hydrolysis of biomass, whereas, in the last stage it interferes with methane formation. Owing to special physicochemical properties such as high activity, high reactive surface area, and high specificity, tailor-made conductive nanoparticles can improve the performance of the AD process. In the AD process, H₂ is used as an electron carrier, referred as mediated interspecies electron transfer (MIET). Due to the diffusion limitation of these electron carriers, the MIET efficiency is relatively low that limits the methanogenesis. Direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET), which enables direct cell-to-cell electron transport between bacteria and methanogen, has been considered an alternative efficient approach to MIET that creates metabolically favorable conditions and results in faster conversion of organic acids and alcohols into methane. This paper discusses in detail the application of conductive nanoparticles to enhance the AD process efficiency. Interaction between microbes in anaerobic conditions for electron transfer with the help of CNPs is discussed. Application of a variety of conductive nanomaterials as an additive is discussed with their potential biogas production and treatment enhancement in the anaerobic digestion process.

Evolution of the microbial community structure in biogas reactors inoculated with seeds from different origin

The aim of this work was to provide solid proofs regarding the achievement of "steady-state conditions", which means that the performance of the anaerobic digester is representative of the applied environmental conditions. For this reason, we investigated how, starting from different inoculum sources (i.e., municipal wastewater treatment, bio-waste treatment, and agricultural waste biogas plant), the microbial community adapted to the operational parameters and led to stable biogas production in thermophilic digesters treating the same influent feedstock. The results revealed that the different system achieved similar process performance and microbial community structure after a period that was equal to four hydraulic retention times, approved by a constant pH of 7.89 ± 0.08, 7.92 ± 0.05 and 7.85 ± 0.08, respectively, and stable TAN concentration of 1500 mg/L. Moreover, it was found that the microbial composition of the inocula was a key factor for the speed of achieving stable process performance; thus, a pre-adapted to the influent feedstock inoculum can shorten the stabilization process. On the contrary, after long term reactor operation, the microbial structure was shaped according to the chemical composition of the influent feedstock. The results of the study can also be used as a guide in future researches on anaerobic degradation, particularly in determining the time interval of an experiment to reflect changes in the microbial community of anaerobic digester.

Enhanced anaerobic digestion with the addition of chelator-nickel complexes to improve nickel bioavailability

Nickel (Ni) is one of the most essential trace elements in the anaerobic digestion system. In this study, green chelating agent Ethylenediamine-N, N'-disuccinic acid (EDDS), common chelating agents with low biodegradability nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) were respectively used as ligands of Ni (II) to inspect the feasibility of enhancing methane production and reducing Ni dosage. In practice, continuous stirred-tank reactors (37 °C, 120 rpm) were operated with a mixture of pig manure and food waste as the substrate, and were supplied with extra Ni in the form of Ni (II) (0, 2.5, and 5.0 mg/L) or chelator‑nickel (EDDS-Ni, NTA-Ni and EDTA-Ni) complexes (2.5 mg/L). The results showed that compared with that of adding Ni (2.5 mg/L) individually, the methane production increased of 23.34%, 31.26% and 16.07% with the addition of EDDS-Ni, NTA-Ni and EDTA-Ni complexes (2.5 mg/L), respectively. Accompanying with that, the EDDS-Ni and NTA-Ni supplementations both significantly increased the F430 concentration of 28% and 36% on the day of peak methane production (day five). The BCR sequential extraction analysis indicated that the sum of Ni in water soluble and exchangeable fractions after digestion were increased of 43.28%, 39.41%, and 24.29%, respectively. Further, the acid-volatile sulfide (AVS) and the simultaneously extracted nickels (SEMNi) content in sediments confirmed that the chelator‑nickel improved Ni bioavailability due to dissolution of nickel ions from their sulfides. This study demonstrated that the addition of chelator-Ni complexes was a practicable method to enhance methane production and reduced Ni dosage.

Potassium inhibition during sludge and biopulp co-digestion; experimental and model-based approaches

Process instability with consecutive low methane production are common challenges of the anaerobic digestion (AD) of municipal wastes. In the present study, the co-digestion of sewage sludge and municipal biopulp was investigated at batch and continuously fed digesters. At batch tests, the highest methane yield for co-digestion (467 ± 17 mLCH₄/gVS) was achieved when biopulp contributed to 80% of organic matter content and sludge the remaining 20%. At continuous mode operation, co-digestion achieved 0.91 ± 0.11 L/(L·d) methane productivity, while mono-digestion of sludge achieved 0.62 ± 0.05 L/(L·d). Potassium inhibition was investigated at the most efficient co-digestion scenario and was found that the half maximal inhibitory concentration (IC₅₀) occurred at 8 g-K⁺/L. Subsequently, the effect of K⁺ was investigated at different scenarios at continuous operation. Simulations based on BioModel described the inhibitory effect of K⁺ by introducing non-competitive inhibition of methanogens. Simulation results confirmed the strongly inhibitory effect of potassium to the AD process.

Enhanced butyrate production by transition metal particles during the food waste fermentation

Butyrate is an important precursor for fine chemicals and biofuels. The aim of this study is to investigate butyrate production as affected by transition metal addition of food waste fermentation including, nickel, Raney nickel and copper particles. Performance of fermentation showed nickel particles achieved the highest butyrate concentration, 7.3 g/L, which was 38.5% higher than that in the control trial. Raney nickel also showed similar effect on the enhancement of butyrate production. However, increased dosage of transition metal particle addition led to decreased butyrate production. The theoretical link between metal-assisted dark fermentation and butyrate production was tentatively explored. Redox potential affected by nickel addition was assumed to be an essential factor for butyrate production. Microbial community analysis found Clostridium sensu stricto 11 may be the dominant functional species for butyrate production. The study demonstrates that development on transition metal catalyst may contribute to waste biorefinery for added value products/energy production.

Biosolids and sludge management

The advancements in the field of sludge and biosolids have been made over the past year. This review outlines the major contributions of researchers that have been published in peer-reviewed journals and conference proceedings throughout 2018. The review is organized in sections including regulatory developments and market analysis; analysis and quantification of characteristics including microconstituents and metals; treatment advances for the conversion of sludge to biosolids including pretreatment and sludge minimization, conditioning and dewatering, digestion, composting, and innovative technologies; product development and reuse including adsorbents and thermal products, agricultural and other uses, and innovative uses; odor and air emissions; and energy factors. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Summary of advances in the field of residuals and biosolids research in 2018. This review outlines the major contributions of researchers that have been published in peer-reviewed journals and conference proceedings. Topics covered range from regulation to innovation.

Application of nano-structured materials in anaerobic digestion: Current status and perspectives

Nanotechnology is gaining more attention in biotechnological applications as a research area with a huge potential. Nanoparticles (NPs) can influence the rate of anaerobic digestion (AD) as the nano-sized structures, with specific physicochemical properties, interact with substrate and microorganisms. The present work has classified the various types of additives used to improve the AD processes. Nanomaterials as new additives in AD process are classified into four categories: Zero-valent metallic NPs, Metal oxide NPs, Carbon based nanomaterials, and Multi-compound NPs. In the following, application of nanomaterials in AD process is reviewed and negative and positive effects of these materials on the AD process and subsequently biogas production rate are discussed. This study confirms that design and development of new nano-sized compounds can improve the performances of the AD processes.

Synergistic effect of activated carbon and encapsulated trace element additive on methane production from anaerobic digestion of food wastes - Enhanced operation stability and balanced trace nutrition

Laboratory semi-continuous anaerobic digestion (AD) experiments were performed to investigate the effects of different supplements on the AD performance of food waste, specifically activated carbon (AC), encapsulated trace element additive (ETEA) and a combination of AC + ETEA. Results indicated that the operation stability of AD was enhanced through the addition of the additives. Compared with the control digester without any additive, AC, ETEA, and AC + ETEA increased the average methane yield by 34%, 22% and 50%, respectively. Chemical speciation analyses indicated that AC + ETEA supplementation increased the proportion of water soluble form of Ni by 11-23%, compared to ETEA single addition. Real-time PCR analyses showed that AC and ETEA supplementation synergistically facilitated the growth of bacterial and archaeal communities. Microbial community structure analysis revealed that AC + ETEA favored the enrichment of hydrolytic, acidogenic and acetogenic bacteria and methanogens.

ADM1 based mathematical model of trace element complexation in anaerobic digestion processes

In this study, a new model based on anaerobic digestion model no.1 (ADM1) approach has been proposed to simulate trace elements (TEs) complexation, precipitation and their effect on the anaerobic batch methane production. TEs complexation reactions with VFAs and EDTA have been incorporated in an extended ADM1 model which considers TE precipitation/dissolution reactions as well as biodegradation processes. The kinetic model tracks the dynamics of 90 state variables which constitute the components of the proposed anaerobic digestion (AD) model. The incorporation of the complexation reactions required the definition of new inorganic components (EDTA species) and new complexation process rates in the ADM1 framework. The charge balance was modified accordingly to consider the effects of the additional components. The new model is able to predict: a) the effect of TE-EDTA/VFA complexation on methane production, and b) the effect of the initial calcium and magnesium concentrations on process performance.