Effects of inhibitions by sodium ion and ammonia and different inocula on acetate-utilizing methanogenesis: Methanogenic activity and succession of methanogens

Combined inhibition of anaerobic digestion by sulfate, salinity, and ammonium: potential inhibitory factors in forward osmosis-concentrated municipal wastewater

This study investigated the combined and interactive effects of sulfate, salinity (NaCl), and ammonium on mesophilic anaerobic digestion using synthetic wastewater simulating concentrated municipal wastewater from the forward osmosis (FO) process. Batch anaerobic digestion experiments were conducted with varying concentrations of sulfate, NaCl, and ammonium. Complete sulfate reduction was observed in all test systems, regardless of the NaCl and ammonium concentration, indicating no significant inhibitory effect on sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB). However, the increased toxicity of hydrogen sulfide produced by SRB under high concentrations of sulfate, NaCl, and ammonium inhibited methanogenic activity, resulting in reduced methane production. Despite this, methanogens, primarily Methanosarcina, tolerated low and moderate levels of sulfate, NaCl, and ammonium; thus, their coexistence with SRB (Desulfotomaculales) enabled efficient acetate utilization and methane production. The enhanced Methanosarcina activity was further confirmed through the antagonistic effects between NaCl and ammonium. No significant decrease in methane production was observed in the co-presence of 0.5 g/L sulfate, 10 g/L NaCl, and 1 g/L ammonium-nitrogen compared to the reference condition without the addition of these components. This study identified the inhibitory mechanisms resulting from sulfate, NaCl, and ammonium interactions, which may occur in FO-concentrated municipal wastewater. These findings offer insights for optimizing the FO process to maintain sulfate, NaCl, and ammonium concentrations below inhibitory levels, thereby ensuring efficient methane production.

Selective evolution of methanogenic communities by β-lactam antibiotics promotes methane production

Biomethane, a clean energy source, plays a crucial role in addressing global energy and environmental challenges. However, its production has long been limited by the complexity of methanogenic precursor synthesis and the involvement of diverse microbial strains, creating a bottleneck in methane conversion. To address this, the present study explores the potential of the β-lactam antibiotic amoxicillin (AMX) to enhance methanogenesis by selectively shaping microbial communities while preserving core methanogenic pathways. Results indicate that the addition of AMX significantly improves methanogenic performance. By day 25, methane yield increased by 3.89-fold, and carbon substrate utilization efficiency improved by 15.5% compared to the control group. This enhancement is linked to the selective effect of AMX on the methanogenic community, leading to a 61.51% increase in the relative abundance of methanogenic archaea. This approach optimizes the process by bypassing three stages of methane precursor synthesis, reducing interfering bacteria, and improving methanogenic efficiency and process controllability, all while showing no significant negative environmental impacts from the added antibiotics.

IMPORTANCE

This study holds significant importance in advancing biomethane production, a clean and renewable energy source. By utilizing amoxicillin, the research promotes the selective growth of methane-producing microbes while suppressing harmful ones, resulting in faster and more efficient methane production with enhanced process control. In addition, amoxicillin degrades rapidly within the system, resulting in minimal negative environmental impact. This work provides a promising and eco-friendly approach to optimize biomethane production, offering a viable and sustainable solution for energy generation from waste.

Enhanced methane production from bloom algal biomass using hydrothermal and hydrothermal-alkaline pretreatment with anaerobic digestion

Coalbeds have the potential as geobioreactors for producing renewable natural gas from biomass derived from photosynthesis. This brings about a number of benefits, including support for sustainable energy and the sequestration of carbon dioxide in coal. In this study, freshwater bloom algae were employed as the substrate to examine the influence of hydrothermal and hydrothermal-alkaline pretreatment on methane production using an inoculum from an anaerobic digester. The morphology and chemical structures of the biomass, as well as the volatile fatty acids (VFAs) in the liquid fraction of the post-treatment and gas production, were analyzed to understand their relationship with the efficacy of methane yields and changes in microorganisms. The results revealed that both hydrothermal and hydrothermal-alkaline pretreatment, under the right conditions, can lead to an increase in methane production. Particularly, a pretreatment condition of 0.2 mol/L NaOH at 150 °C for 30 min resulted in a significant increase in methane yield by up to 303.9%. The addition of NaOH facilitated the hydrothermal-alkaline pretreatment, effectively destroying the cell structure of the bloom algae, promoting the dissolution of intracellular sugars and other substances, and reducing the loss of VFAs caused by heating. Moreover, hydrothermal-alkaline pretreatment was found to support the growth of acetoclastic methanogens and enhance methane production by mitigating pH drops. Overall, the results of this study suggest that hydrothermal-alkaline pretreatment offers significant advantages in methane production compared to hydrothermal pretreatment. These findings have important implications for harnessing bloom algae as a viable source for generating renewable natural gas.

Cation concentration represents an appropriate inhibition indicator for anaerobic acetate and propionate oxidation under mesophilic conditions

Volatile fatty acid accumulation is a common issue encountered in anaerobic digestion, indicating potential process failure through the inhibition of microorganisms consuming those acids. However, the related inhibition mechanisms and thresholds remain poorly characterized for digesters treating concentrated feedstocks such as food waste. Considering two inocula adapted to high ammonia concentration, this study assessed the inhibition of acetate or propionate consumers exposed to various salts (NH4HCO3, NaHCO3 or KHCO3) under mesophilic conditions in a range of total cation concentration between 0.23 and 0.86 mol.L-1. For each inocula, a single inhibition model could explain most variance (>92 %) of the methanogenic activity reduction without considering the substrate (i.e., acetate or propionate) nor the cation nature (i.e., K+, Na+ or NH4+). This result highlights that the total salt concentration had a predominant impact compared to the specific nature of the ions in solution, supporting osmotic pressure as principal cause of the inhibition.

Effects of sulfamethazine on microbially-mediated denitrifying anaerobic methane oxidation in estuarine wetlands

Nitrite/nitrate-dependent anaerobic methane oxidation (n-DAMO) is an important methane (CH4) consumption and nitrogen (N) removal pathway in estuarine and coastal wetlands. Antibiotic contamination is known to affect microbially mediated processes; however, its influences on n-DAMO and the underlying molecular mechanisms remain poorly understood. In the present study, using 13CH4 tracer method combined with molecular techniques, we investigated the responses of n-DAMO microbial abundance, activity, and the associated microbial community composition to sulfamethazine (SMT, a sulfonamide antibiotic, with exposure concentrations of 0.05, 0.5, 5, 20, 50, and 100 µg L-1). Results showed that the effect of SMT exposure on n-DAMO activity was dose-dependent. Exposure to SMT at concentrations of up to 5 µg L-1 inhibited the potential n-DAMO rates (the average rates of nitrite- and nitrate-DAMO decreased by 92.9 % and 79.2 % relative to the control, respectively). In contrast, n-DAMO rates tended to be promoted by SMT when its concentration increased to 20-100 µg L-1 (the average rates of nitrite- and nitrate-DAMO increased by 724.1 % and 630.1 % relative to the low-doses, respectively). Notably, low-doses of SMT suppressed nitrite-DAMO to a greater extent than nitrate-DAMO, indicating that nitrite-DAMO was more sensitive to SMT than nitrate-DAMO. Molecular analyses suggest that the increased n-DAMO activity under high-doses SMT exposure may be driven by changes in microbial communities, especially because of the promotion of methanogens that provide more CH4 to n-DAMO microbes. Moreover, the abundances of n-DAMO microbes at high SMT exposure (20 and 50 µg L-1) were significantly higher than that at low SMT exposure (0.05-5 µg L-1). These results advance our understanding of the ecological effects of SMT on carbon (C) and N interactions in estuarine and coastal wetlands.

Inhibitory impact of the anticancer drug doxorubicin on anaerobic microbial community

The inhibitory effect of the anticancer drug doxorubicin (DOX) on biogas production was evaluated in short-term and long-term exposure assays. The short-term assays reached the DOX IC50 value on 648 ± 50 µg·L-1. In addition, it was found that inhibition caused by the exposure of 10×103 µg·L-1 was reversible after removing DOX from the feeding synthetic medium. Furthermore, DOX can be rapidly sorbed by the biomass (despite the low Kow), which might contribute to the inhibitory effect. The results of long-term exposure assays, when the DOX volumetric loading rate was increased from 100 µgDOX·L-1·day-1 to 200 µgDOX·L-1·day-1, showed that biogas production and COD removal decreased rapidly. However, the methanogenic Archaeas could recover from this exposure, corroborating the results on short-term exposure assays. In conclusion, DOX can play a key role in inhibiting biological wastewater treatment processes if its concentration in hospital wastewater treatment plants increases abruptly.

Conductive materials enhance microbial salt-tolerance in anaerobic digestion of food waste: Microbial response and metagenomics analysis

Previous studies have shown that high salinity environments can inhibit anaerobic digestion (AD) of food waste (FW). Finding ways to alleviate salt inhibition is important for the disposal of the growing amount of FW. We selected three common conductive materials (powdered activated carbon, magnetite, and graphite) to understand their performance and individual mechanisms that relieve salinity inhibition. Digester performances and related enzyme parameters were compared. Our data revealed that under normal and low salinity stress conditions, the anaerobic digester ran steady without significant inhibitions. Further, the presence of conductive materials promoted conversion rate of methanogenesis. This promotion effect was highest from magnetite > powdered activated carbon (PAC) > graphite. At 1.5% salinity, PAC and magnetite are beneficial in maintaining high methane production efficiency while control and the graphite added digester acidified and failed rapidly. Additionally, metagenomics and binning were used to analyze the metabolic capacity of the microorganisms. Some species enriched by PAC and magnetite possessed higher cation transport capacities and were to accumulate compatible solutes. PAC and magnetite promoted direct interspecies electron transference (DIET) and syntrophic oxidation of butyrate and propionate. Also, the microorganisms had more energy available to cope with salt inhibition in the PAC and magnetite added digesters. Our data imply that the promotion of Na+/H+ antiporter, K+ uptake, and osmoprotectant synthesis or transport by conductive materials may be crucial for their proliferation in highly stressful environments. These findings will help to understand the mechanisms of alleviate salt inhibition by conductive materials and help to recover methane from high-salinity FW.

Accumulating ammoniacal nitrogen instead of melanoidins determines the anaerobic digestibility of thermally hydrolyzed waste activated sludge

Full-scale thermal hydrolysis processes (THP) showed an increase in nutrients release and formation of melanoidins, which are considered to negatively impact methanogenesis during mesophilic anaerobic digestion (AD). In this research, fractionation of THP-sludge was performed to elucidate the distribution of nutrients and the formed melanoidins over the liquid and solid sludge matrix. Degradation of the different fractions in subsequent AD was assessed, and the results were compared with non-pre-treated waste activated sludge (WAS). Results showed that the THP-formed soluble melanoidins were partially biodegradable under AD, especially the fraction with molecular weight under 1.1 kDa, which was related to protein-like substances. The use of THP in WAS increased the non-biodegradable soluble chemical oxygen demand (sCOD) after AD, from 1.1% to 4.9% of the total COD. The total ammoniacal nitrogen (TAN) concentration only slightly increased during THP without AD. However, after AD, TAN released was 34% higher in the THP-treated WAS compared to non-treated WAS, i.e., 36.7 ± 0.7 compared to 27.4 ± 0.4 mgTANreleased/gCODsubstrate, respectively. Results from modified specific methanogenic activities (mSMAs) tests showed that the organics solubilised during THP, were not inhibitory for acetotrophic methanogens. However, after AD of THP-treated sludge and WAS, the mSMA showed that all analysed samples presented strong inhibition on methanogenesis due to the presence of TAN and associated free ammonia nitrogen (FAN). In specific methanogenic activities (SMAs) tests with incremental concentration of TAN/FAN and melanoidins, TAN/FAN induced strong inhibition on methanogens, halving the SMA at around 2.5 gTAN/L and 100 mgFAN/L. Conversely, melanoidins did not show inhibition on the methanogens. Our present results revealed that when applying THP-AD in full-scale, the increase in TAN/FAN remarkably had a greater impact on AD than the formation of melanoidins.

Bioaugmentation with marine sediment-derived microbial consortia in mesophilic anaerobic digestion for enhancing methane production under ammonium or salinity stress

Ammonium (NH₄⁺) and salinity (NaCl) inhibit CH₄ production in anaerobic digestion. However, whether bioaugmentation using marine sediment-derived microbial consortia can relieve the inhibitory effects of NH₄⁺ and NaCl stresses on CH₄ production remains unclear. Thus, this study evaluated the effectiveness of bioaugmentation using marine sediment-derived microbial consortia in alleviating the inhibition of CH₄ production under NH₄⁺ or NaCl stress and elucidated the underlying mechanisms. Batch anaerobic digestion experiments under 5 gNH₄-N/L or 30 g/L NaCl were performed with or without augmentation using two marine sediment-derived microbial consortia pre-acclimated to high NH₄⁺ and NaCl. Compared with non-bioaugmentation, bioaugmentation reinforced CH₄ production. Network analysis revealed the joint effects of microbial connections by Methanoculleus, which promoted the efficient consumption of propionate accumulated under NH₄⁺ and NaCl stresses. In conclusion, bioaugmentation with pre-acclimated marine sediment-derived microbial consortia can mitigate the inhibition under NH₄⁺ or NaCl stress and enhance CH₄ production in anaerobic digestion.

Biological saccharification coupled with anaerobic digestion using corn straw for sustainable methane production

In this study, accumulated fermentable sugars from biosaccharified corn straw were used to generate methane through anaerobic digestion (AD). The results showed that reducing sugars from biosaccharification expanded corn straw (BECS) treated with Clostridium thermocellum XF811 accumulated with yields of 94.9 mg/g. The BECS used for AD was converted into a high methane yield (7436 mL), which was 49.3 % higher than that of expanded corn straw (ECS). High-throughput microbial analysis suggested that Methanoculleus and Methanobacterium greatly contributed to the high methane yield. Industrial experiments demonstrated that the methane production from BECS by AD was 72,955 m³, which increased by 13.2 % compared to that from ECS. Biosaccharification pretreatment accelerated ECS destruction and accumulated sugars, thereby increasing methane yields. This study provides a strategy for producing clean energy from lignocellulose biomass.

Key players in syntrophic propionate oxidation revealed by metagenome-assembled genomes from anaerobic digesters bioaugmented with propionic acid enriched microbial consortia

Propionic acid (HPr) is frequently accumulated in anaerobic digesters due to its thermodynamically unfavorable degradation reaction. Here, we identify key players in HPr oxidation and organic overloading recovery from metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) recovered from anaerobic digesters inoculated with HPr-enriched microbial consortia before initiating organic overloading. Two independent HPr-enrichment cultures commonly selected two uncultured microorganisms represented with high relative abundance: Methanoculleus sp002497965 and JABUEY01 sp013314815 (a member of the Syntrophobacteraceae family). The relative abundance of JABUEY01 sp013314815 was 60 times higher in bioaugmented bioreactors compared to their unaugmented counterparts after recovery from organic overloading. Genomic analysis of JABUEY01 sp013314815 revealed its metabolic potential for syntrophic propionate degradation when partnered with hydrogenotrophic methanogens (e.g., Methanoculleus sp002497965) via the methylmalonyl-CoA pathway. Our results identified at least two key species that are responsible for efficient propionate removal and demonstrate their potential applications as microbial cocktails for stable AD operation.

Effects of draw solutes on an integrated forward osmosis-Microbial fuel cell system treating a synthetic wastewater

Microbial fuel cells (MFCs) and forward osmosis (FO) are both attractive and versatile wastewater treatment technologies that possess disadvantageous qualities that prevent their optimal performance. This study aimed to investigate how draw solute selection for FO treatment would affect MFC performance in a coupled FO-MFC system. Two types of draw solutes, NH₄ HCO₃ and NaCl, were studied, and it was found that 1.0 M NH₄ HCO₃ (FO-MFC-A) and 0.68 M NaCl (FO-MFC-B) had similar water fluxes of 6.04 to 3.39 LMH and 6.25 to 3.54 LMH, respectively. The reverse salt flux from the draw decreased the feed solution resistance for both draw solutes, but the FO-MFC-A system (0.32 W m^-2 ) had a higher maximum power density than the FO-MFC-B system (0.26 W m^-2 ). The current density for the FO-MFC-B system increased due to continuous solution resistance decrease, whereas it remained constant for the FO-MFC-A. The difference in Coulombic efficiencies (32.8% vs. 25.6%) but similar Coulombic recoveries (10.2% vs. 11.4%) between the FO-MFC-A and FO-MFC-B systems suggested that the FO-MFC-A might have the inhibited microbial activity by high ammonium/ammonia. The FO-MFC-A system had the lower energy consumption for nutrient removal (2.01 kWh kg^-1 NH₄ ⁺ -N) and recovery (8.87 kWh kg^-1 NH₄ ⁺ -N). These results have shown that NH₄ HCO₃ as a draw solute can have advantages of higher power density, higher Coulombic efficiency, and recoverability for draw regeneration, but its potential inhibition on microbial activity must also be considered. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Forward osmosis can be connected to microbial fuel cells for wastewater treatment. Water recovery by forward osmosis can greatly reduce the wastewater volume to microbial fuel cells. Ammonium draw solutes can result in lower volumetric energy consumption. Ammonia inhabitation of anode microbes will decrease organic removal.

Identification of key steps and associated microbial populations for efficient anaerobic digestion under high ammonium or salinity conditions

Ammonium (NH₄⁺) and salinity are major inhibitors of CH₄ production in anaerobic digestion. This study evaluated their inhibitory effects on CH₄ production and explored the key populations for efficient CH₄ production under high NH₄⁺ and NaCl concentrations to understand their inhibition mechanisms. Comparative batch experiments for mesophilic anaerobic digestion were conducted using three seeding sludges under different concentrations of NH₄⁺ (1-5 gNH₄-N/L) and NaCl (10-30 g/L). Although all sludges tolerated 3 gNH₄-N/L and 10 g/L NaCl, NH₄⁺ or NaCl concentrations higher than these substantially reduced CH₄ production, depending on the seeding sludge, primarily by impairing the initial hydrolysis and methanogenesis steps. In addition, propionate was found to be a deterministic factor affecting CH₄ production. Based on microbial community analysis, Candidatus Brevefilum was identified as a potential syntrophic propionate-oxidizing bacterium that facilitates the mitigation of propionate accumulation, allowing the maintenance of unaffected CH₄ production under high inhibitory conditions.

Effect of magnetite supplementation on mesophilic anaerobic digestion of phenol and benzoate: Methane production rate and microbial communities

Anaerobic sequential batch tests treating phenol and benzoate were conducted to evaluate the potential of magnetite supplementation to improve methanogenic degradation of phenol and benzoate, and to identify active microbial communities under each condition. Specific CH₄ production rates during anaerobic digestion were 218.5 mL CH₄/g VSS/d on phenol and 517.6 mL CH₄/g VSS/d on benzoate. Magnetite supplementation significantly increased methanogenic degradation of phenol by 9.0-68.0% in CH₄ production rate, and decreased lag time by 7.9-48.0%, with no significant reduction in CH₄ yield. Syntrophorhabdus, Sporotomaculum, Syntrophus, Syntrophomonas, Peptoclostridium, Soehngenia, Mesotoga, Geobacter, Methanosaeta, Methanoculleus, and Methanospirillum were revealed as active microbial communities involved in anaerobic digestion of phenol and benzoate. Magnetite-mediated direct interspecies electron transfer between Geobacter, Peptoclostridium, and Methanosaeta harundinacea could contribute to this improvement.

Anaerobic digestion beyond biogas

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is a matured technology for waste (water) remediation/stabilization and bioenergy generation in the form of biogas. AD technology has several inherent benefits ranging from generating renewable energy, remediating waste (water), and reducing greenhouse gas emission to improving health/hygiene and the overall socio-economic status of rural communities in developing nations. In recent years, there has been a paradigm shift in applications of AD technology beyond biogas. This special issue (SI) entitled, "Anaerobic Digestion Beyond Biogas (ADBB-2021)," was conceptualized to incorporate some of the recent advances in AD in which the emphasis is beyond biogas, such as anaerobic biorefinery, chain elongation, treatment of micropollutants, toxicity and system stability, digestate as biofertilizer, bio-electrochemical systems, innovative bioreactors, carbon sequestration, biogas upgrading, microbiomes, waste (water) remediation, residues/waste pre-treatment, promoter addition, and modeling, process control, and automation, among others. This VSI: ADBB-2021 contains 53 manuscripts (14 critical reviews and 39 research). The key findings of each manuscript are briefly summarized here, which can serve as a valuable resource for AD researchers to learn of major advances in AD technology and identify future research directions.