Engineering-scale application of sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification wetland for advanced treatment of municipal tailwater

Enhanced nitrogen removal from low C/N ratio wastewater by coordination of ternary electron donors of Fe0, carbon source and sulfur: Focus on oxic/anoxic/oxic process

Insufficient organics was the major obstacle for total nitrogen (TN) removal in conventional pre-anoxic denitrification when treating low carbon to nitrogen (C/N) ratio wastewater. This study constructed a novel ternary-electron donors (Fe0, organics and S0) enhanced oxic/anoxic/oxic (O/A/O) process, integrating simultaneous nitrification and denitrification and autotrophic denitrification (ADN), and evaluated its feasibility to achieve efficient nutrient removal under organics-deficient condition. Long-term operation results showed that TN removal was lower (9.9 %) when Fe0 added individually, then raised to 27.3 %∼46.0 % in simultaneous presence of Fe0 and organics. And the highest TN removal (82.0 %) was obtained by coordination of ternary-electron donors, with 8.46 ± 0.43 mg/L TN in effluent. Meanwhile, the O/A/O process exhibited excellent total phosphorous (TP) removal (84.8 %∼98.4 %) derived from chemical precipitation by Fe0, of which the effluent was <0.76 ± 0.04 mg/L TP. Metabolic characteristics indicated that the coordination of multi-electron donors improved microbial metabolism and denitrifying enzymatic activities, thereby promoting ammonia assimilation and enhancing TN removal. And the secretion of EPS was also stimulated, which favored the bio-utilization of Fe0 and S0 and alleviated organics dependence. Besides, the notable increase in abundances of aerobic denitrifiers (23.95 %∼27.37 %), autotrophic denitrifiers (9.31 %) and denitrifying genes further verified the synergy effect of multi-electron donors on TN removal. This study revealed the enhancement mechanism of O/A/O process by coordination of ternary-electron donors, verified its cost-effectiveness and provided innovative insights on low C/N ratio wastewater remediation.

Mixotrophic denitrification using thiocyanate as an electron donor: Role of thiocyanate under different C/N conditions

Thiocyanate (SCN-) is a highly toxic reducing inorganic compound commonly found in various nitrogen-rich wastewater and is also a promising electron donor for mixotrophic denitrification. However, its extent of involvement in mixotrophic denitrification under conditions of carbon limitation or excess remains unclear. In this study, five reactors were constructed to investigate the participation and microbial mechanisms of SCN- in mixotrophic denitrification under high C/N and low C/N conditions. The results showed that under low C/N conditions, SCN⁻ synergizes with organic electron donors to enhance denitrification, with mixotrophic systems exhibiting higher electron utilization efficiency and achieving 1.12 times the TN removal rate of autotrophic and heterotrophic systems combined. Under high C/N conditions, an ample supply of electron donors achieve 100% nitrate removal; however, SCN⁻ also participates in denitrification, competing with organic electron donors for NO3--N, which leads to the waste of organic matter. Additionally, high-throughput sequencing revealed that under low C/N mixotrophic conditions, SCN⁻ effectively promoted the growth of SCN⁻-degrading microorganisms such as Thiobacillus, with its abundance increasing from 0% to 8.86%, approximately 1.85 times higher than under autotrophic conditions. This enhancement strengthened the sulfur and nitrogen metabolic capabilities of the microbial community, enabling the system to utilize SCN- more fully for denitrification. This study provides novel insights for reducing the addition of external organic matter to nitrogen-rich wastewater containing SCN-, offering theoretical and technical support for energy-saving and emission reduction in denitrification processes of actual industrial wastewater treatment.

Insights into carbon-neutral treatment of rural wastewater by constructed wetlands: A review of current development and future direction

In recent years, with the global rise in awareness regarding carbon neutrality, the treatment of wastewater in rural areas is increasingly oriented towards energy conservation, emission reduction, low-carbon output, and resource utilization. This paper provides an analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of the current low-carbon treatment process of low-carbon treatment for rural wastewater. Constructed wetlands (CWs) are increasingly being considered as a viable option for treating wastewater in rural regions. In pursuit of carbon neutrality, advanced carbon-neutral bioprocesses are regarded as the prospective trajectory for achieving carbon-neutral treatment of rural wastewater. The incorporation of CWs with emerging biotechnologies such as sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification (SAD), pyrite-based autotrophic denitrification (PAD), and anaerobic ammonia oxidation (anammox) enables efficient removal of nitrogen and phosphorus from rural wastewater. The advancement of CWs towards improved removal of organic and inorganic pollutants, sustainability, minimal energy consumption, and low carbon emissions is widely recognized as a viable low-carbon approach for achieving carbon-neutral treatment of rural wastewater. This study offers novel perspectives on the sustainable development of wastewater treatment in rural areas within the framework of achieving carbon neutrality in the future.

Sulfur cycle-mediated biological nitrogen removal and greenhouse gas abatement processes: Micro-oxygen regulation tells the story

Sulfur-mediated autotrophic biological nitrogen removal (BNR) processes favor the reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions compared to heterotrophic BNR processes. Micro-oxygen environments are widely prevalent in practical BNR systems, and the mechanisms of GHG emissions mediated by multi-elements, including nitrogen (N), sulfur (S), and oxygen (O), remain to be systematically summarized. This review reveals the functional microorganisms involved in sulfur-mediated BNR processes under micro-oxygen regulation, elucidating their metabolic mechanisms and interactions. The GHG abatement potential of sulfur-mediated BNR processes under micro-oxygen regulation is highlighted, along with recent advances in multi-scenario applications. The fate of GHG in wastewater treatment systems is explored and insights into future multi-scale GHG regulatory strategies are provided. Overall, the application of sulfur-mediated BNR processes under micro-oxygen regulation exhibits great potential. This review can act as a guide for the effective implementation of strategies to mitigate the environmental impacts of GHG emissions from wastewater treatment processes.

Refractory degradable dissolved organic matter (R-DOM) driving nitrogen removal by the electric field coupled iron‑carbon biofilter (E-ICBF): Performance and microbial mechanisms

Researches on the advanced nitrogen (N) removal of municipal tailwater always overlooked the value of refractory degradable dissolved organic matter (R-DOM). In this study, a novel electric field coupled iron‑carbon biofilter (E-ICBF) was utilized to explore the performance and microbial changes with polyethylene glycol (PEG) as the representative R-DOM. Results demonstrated that the removal efficiencies of E-ICBF for nitrate nitrogen (NO3--N), ammonia nitrogen (NH4+-N), and total nitrogen (TN) improved by 28.76 %, 12.96 %, and 28.45 %, compared to quartz sand biofilter (SBF). Moreover, removal efficiencies of NO3--N and TN in E-ICBF with R-DOM went up by 12.11 % and 14.02 % compared to methanol. Additionally, both PEG and the electric field reduced the microbial richness and diversity. However, PEG promoted the increase of denitrifying bacteria abundance including unclassified_f_Comamonadaceae, Thauera, and unclassified_f_Gallionellaceae. The electric field improved the abundances of genes related to N removal (hao, nasC, nasA, nifH, nifD, nifK) and PEG further enhanced the effect. The abundances of key enzymes [EC:1.7.5.1], [EC:1.7.2.1], [EC:1.7.2.4], and [EC:1.7.2.5] decreased due to the addition of PEG and the electric field mitigated the negative influence. Additionally, the electric field changed relationships between microorganisms and pollutant removal, and improved interspecific relationships between denitrifying bacterial genera and other genera in E-ICBF.

Maximizing pollutant removal and greenhouse gas emission reduction in vertical flow constructed wetlands: an orthogonal experimental approach

Owing to the impact of the effluent C/N from the secondary structures of urban domestic wastewater treatment plants, the denitrification efficiency in constructed wetlands (CWs) is not satisfactory, limiting their widespread application in the deep treatment of urban domestic wastewater. To address this issue, we constructed enhanced CWs and conducted orthogonal experiments to investigate the effects of different factors (C/N, fillers, and plants) on the removal of conventional pollutants and the reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emission. The experimental results indicated that a C/N of 8, manganese sand, and calamus achieved the best denitrification efficiencies with removal efficiencies of 85.7%, 95.9%, and 88.6% for TN, NH4+-N, and COD, respectively. In terms of GHG emission reduction, this combination resulted in the lowest global warming potential (176.8 mg/m2·day), with N2O and CH4 emissions of 0.53 and 1.25 mg/m2·day, respectively. Characterization of the fillers revealed the formation of small spherical clusters of phosphates on the surfaces of manganese sand and pyrite and iron oxide crystals on the surface of pyrite. Additionally, the surface Mn (II) content of the manganese sand increased by 8.8%, and the Fe (III)/Fe (II) and SO42-/S2- on pyrite increased by 2.05 and 0.26, respectively, compared to pre-experiment levels. High-throughput sequencing indicated the presence of abundant autotrophic denitrifying bacteria (Sulfuriferula, Sulfuritalea, and Thiobacillus) in the CWs, which explains denitrification performance of the enhanced CWs. This study aimed to explore the mechanism of efficient denitrification and GHG emission reduction in the enhanced CWs, providing theoretical guidance for the deep treatment of urban domestic wastewater.

Bio-promoter mediated denitrification recovery from Cd(II) stress: Microbial activity resilience, electron behavior enhancement and microbial community evolution

Denitrification is fragile to toxic substances, while currently there are few regulation strategies for toxic substance-stressed denitrification. This study proposed a combined bio-promoter composed of basic bio-promoter (cytokinin, biotin, L-cysteine, and flavin adenine dinucleotide) and phosphomolybdic acid (PMo12) to recover cadmium(II) (Cd(II)) stressed denitrification. By inhibiting 58.02% and 48.84% of nitrate reductase and nitrite reductase activities, Cd(II) caused all the influent nitrogen to accumulate as NO3--N and NO2--N. Combined bio-promoter shortened the recovery time by 21 cycles and improved nitrogen removal efficiency by 10% as the synergistic effect of basic bio-promoter and PMo12. Basic bio-promoter enhanced antioxidant enzyme activities for reactive oxygen species clearance and recovered 23.30% of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide for sufficient electron donors. Meanwhile, PMo12 recovered electron carriers contents, increasing the electron transfer activity by 60.81% compared with self-recovery. Bio-promoters enhanced the abundance of denitrifiers Seminibacterium and Dechloromonas, which was positively correlated with rapid recovery of denitrification performance.

The role of the combined nitrogen-sulfur-carbon cycles for efficient performance of anammox-based systems

The combined anammox/mixotrophic denitrification process was conducted in two granular sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) during a 200-day operation. Both reactors were fed with synthetic medium, but SBR2 was enriched with additional sulfate (SO42-) which influenced sulfate reduction ammonium oxidation (SRAO) and heterotrophic reduction of SO42- by sulfate reducing bacteria. It was hypothesized that the addition of SO42- could positively impact the removal rates of N-S-C compounds. A low C/N ratio (0.4-1.6) was maintained to prevent inhibition of anaerobic ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AnAOB), and alternating chemical oxygen demand (COD) on/off conditions were used to regenerate AnAOB during COD-off phases and heterotrophic denitrifiers during COD-on phases. Stoichiometric analysis showed that introducing SO42- in SBR2 enhanced the ammonium utilization rate, which was approximately 10 % higher compared to SBR1 in the final stage of the experiment (25.8 vs. 22.8 mg N/(g VSS·h)). The total nitrogen removal efficiencies ranged from 62 % to 99 % in both reactors, with SBR2 consistently exhibiting approximately 4 % higher efficiency than SBR1. In SBR2, the maximum overall SO42- utilization efficiency reached 27 % under COD-off conditions, while overall COD utilization was almost complete under COD-on conditions. A strong correlation (R2 = 0.98) was observed between SO42- production and COD utilization. The key players responsible for N and S transformations in response to SO42- addition were Candidatus Brocadia and Chloroflexi - Anaerolineae. This study highlights the potential to enhance the overall efficiency of N-S-C removal by implementing an integrated anammox/mixotrophic denitrification process. The combination of cycles emerges as a sustainable approach for treating wastewater rich in N-S-C compounds.

Advanced electrolysis sulfur-based biofiltration for simultaneous total nitrogen removal and estrogen toxicity reduction from low carbon-to-nitrogen ratio wastewater

A sulfur-based biofilter enhanced by phosphate modified activated carbon as particle electrodes was constructed to simultaneously remove total nitrogen (TN) and estrogen from low carbon-to-nitrogen ratio (C/N) wastewater containing 1 mg/L 17-alpha-ethinylestradiol (EE2). Results showed that the enhanced biofilter achieved outstanding performance in EE2 removal (93.2 %) and TN reduction (effluent < 5 mg/L), demonstrating robustness against C/N fluctuations. It was noteworthy that it successfully reduced both acute toxicity (59.5 %) and estrogenic activity (88.6 %). Comprehensive characterization investigations and microbial community structure analysis revealed that enhanced electron transfer and increased microbial abundance likely contributed to improved biofilter performance. Core microorganisms, such as Pseudomonas and Chryseobacterium were identified as key contributors to synergistic estrogen degradation and denitrification. This study presented a feasible and promising strategy of combined process with three-dimensional electrodes and sulfur-based biofilter, highlighting substantial potential for advanced purification and safe reuse of wastewater.

Functional keystone taxa promote N and P removal of the constructed wetland to mitigate agricultural nonpoint source pollution

Characterized by irregular spatial and temporal variations of pollutant loading and complex occurrence mechanisms, agricultural nonpoint source pollution (ANPSP) has always been a great challenge in field restoration worldwide. Returning farmlands to wetlands (RFWs) as an ecological restoration mode among various constructed wetlands was selected to manage ANPSP in this study. Triarrhena lutarioriparia, Nelumbo nucifera and Zizania latifolia monocultures were designed and the water pollutants was monitored. N. nucifera and Z. latifolia could reach the highest TN (53.28 %) and TP (53.22 %) removal efficiency, respectively. By 16s high-throughput sequencing of rhizosphere bacteria, 45 functional species were the main contributors for efficient N and P removal, and 38 functional keystone taxa (FKT) were found with significant ecological niche roles and metabolic functions. To our knowledge, this is the first study to explore the microbial driving N and P removal mechanism in response to ANPSP treated by field scale RFWs.

Effect of hydraulic regime on sulfur-packed bed performance: Denitrification and disproportionation

Sulfur-packed beds (SPBs) have been increasingly incorporated into constructed wetland systems to overcome limitations in achieving satisfactory nitrate removal efficiency. However, the underlying impact of hydraulic regimes on SPB performance remains understudied. This study investigated the performance of a pilot-scale SPB, encompassing sulfur autotrophic denitrification (SAD) and sulfur disproportionation (SDP) processes, under various horizontal flow (HF) and vertical flow (VF) regimes. The HF regime exhibited superior SAD efficiency, achieving 3.1-4.4 mg-N/L of nitrate removal compared to 0.9-2.8 mg-N/L under VF regimes. However, greater sulfide production of 3.8-5.6 mg/L was observed, in contrast to only 1.5-2.3 mg/L under VF regimes when SDP occurred. Employing current computational fluid dynamics simulations could predict general regimes but lacked precision in detailing sulfur layer dynamics. In contrast, determining the spatial distribution of SAD substrates and SDP products offered a viable solution, revealing stagnate, short-circuit, and back flows. Moreover, the feasibility of an aeration approach to reduce sulfide emissions below 0.5 mg/L in case of accidental SDP occurrence was confirmed. This study offers a method for assessing detailed hydraulic regimes within SPBs. Additionally, it provides guidance on optimizing the packing of sulfur-based materials when implementing SPBs in constructed wetland systems and presents a strategy for mitigating excessive sulfide emissions.

Simultaneous nitrate and chromium removal mechanism in a pyrite-involved mixotrophic biofilter

Microbially mediated NO3--N and Cr(VI) reduction is being recognized as an eco-friendly and cost-effective remediation strategy. Iron sulfide mineral, as a natural inorganic electron donor, has a strong influence on NO3--N and Cr(VI) transformation, respectively. However, little is known about the simultaneous nitrate and chromium removal performance and underlying mechanism in an iron sulfide mineral-involved mixotrophic biofilter. This study demonstrated that the NO3--N and Cr(VI) removal efficiencies were stable at 62 ± 8% and 56 ± 10%, and most of them were eliminated in the 0-100-mm region of the biofilter. Cr(VI) was reduced to insoluble Cr(III) via microbial and chemical pathways, which was confirmed by the SEM-EDS morphology and the XPS spectra of biofilm and pyrite particles. SO42- was as a main byproduct of pyrite oxidation; however, the bacterial SO42- reduction synchronously occurred, evidenced by the variations of TOC and SO42- concentrations. These results suggested that there were complicated and intertwined biochemical relations between NO3--N/Cr(VI)/SO42-/DO (electron acceptors) and pyrite/organics (electron donors). Further investigation indicated that both the maximal biomass and greatest denitrifiers' relative abundances in microbial sample S1 well explained why the pollutants were removed in the 0-100-mm region. A variety of denitrifiers such as Pseudoxanthomona, Acidovorax, and Simplicispira were enriched, which probably were responsible for both NO3--N and Cr(VI) removal. Our findings advance the understanding of simultaneous nitrate and chromium removal in pyrite-involved mixotrophic systems and facilitate the new strategy development for nitrate and chromium remediation.

Sulfur-aided aerobic biostabilization of swine manure and sawdust mixture: Humification and carbon loss

To investigate how sulfur addition affects humification and carbon loss during swine manure (SM) biostabilisation, various proportions of sulfur, i.e., 0 (CK), 0.2%-0.8% (S1-S4) were added to SM in a 70-day pilot-scale test. Compared to CK (16.07%), sulfur addition resulted in the mineralization of 17.05%-24.27% of the total organic carbon. Sulfur addition also reduced CH4 emissions, which were 3.7%-29.3% lower than that of CK. The total global warming potential values were in the range of 913.1-968.2 g CO2 eq kg-1 for all treatments. Although the sulfur-added treatments showed lower HA/FA ratios than CK after 70 days, no significant impact on the maturity of the final products was observed. Sulfur addition impacted the microbial community, CH4, CO2, N2O emissions, and affected the variation of temperature in biowaste biostabilization. These discoveries provided an important basis for understanding the function of sulfur in regulating the aerobic bio-decomposition of organic waste.

Integrating thermodynamics and mathematical modelling to investigate the stoichiometry and kinetics of sulphide oxidation-nitrate reduction with a special focus on partial autotrophic denitrification

In the present study, the stoichiometry of the Sulphur Oxidizing-Nitrate Reducing (SO-NR) process, with a focus on Partial Autotrophic Denitrification (PAD), has been evaluated through a thermodynamic-based study whereas a model-based approach has been adopted to assess process kinetics. Experimental data on process performance and biomass yields were available from a previous work achieving efficient PAD, where a biomass yield of 0.113 gVSS/gS was estimated. First, the free Gibbs energy dissipation method has been implemented, in order to provide a theoretical framework exploring the boundaries for sulphur oxidizing biomass yields. Second, a screening of available mathematical models describing SO-NR process was conducted and five published models were selected, in order to assess the most suitable model structure for describing the observed PAD kinetics. To the best of our knowledge, none of reported biomass yields are estimated in systems operating PAD as the main process and, analogously, none of the proposed models have been applied to case studies aiming at partial denitrification only. The work showed that the very low biomass yield of 0.117 ± 0.007 gVSS/gS, observed in a PAD system in our previous work, suggests that the conditions applied to achieve partial denitrification resulted in a high energy-dissipating metabolism compared to complete denitrification applications. Models' analysis revealed that nitrite accumulation can be described by a classical Monod kinetics if different μmax are adopted for each intermediate reaction, with Theil Inequality Coefficient values lower than 0.21 for both NO3- and NO2-. Nonetheless, adopting Haldane-type kinetics for nitrite uptake inferred higher identifiability to the model structure, resulting in confidence intervals below ±10% for all the parametric estimations. The thermodynamic and modelling outcomes support the experimental results obtained in the reference study and the critical comparison of model suitability to represent PAD process is believed pivotal to pave the way to its real-scale implementation.

Microelectrolysis-integrated constructed wetland with sponge iron filler to simultaneously enhance nitrogen and phosphorus removal

Integrating sponge iron (SI) and microelectrolysis individually into constructed wetlands (CWs) to enhance nitrogen and phosphorus removal are challenged by ammonia (NH₄⁺-N) accumulation and limited total phosphorus (TP) removal efficiency, respectively. In this study, a microelectrolysis-assisted CW using SI as filler surrounding the cathode (e-SICW) was successfully established. Results indicated that e-SICW reduced NH₄⁺-N accumulation and intensified nitrate (NO₃^--N), the total nitrogen (TN) and TP removal. The concentration of NH₄⁺-N in the effluent from e-SICW was lower than that from SICW in the whole process with 39.2-53.2 % decrease, and as the influent NO₃^--N concentration of 15 mg/L and COD/N ratio of 3, the removal efficiencies of NO₃^--N, TN and TP in e-SICW achieved 95.7 ± 1.9 %, 79.8 ± 2.5 % and 98.0 ± 1.3 %, respectively. Microbial community analysis revealed that hydrogen autotrophic denitrifying bacteria of Hydrogenophaga was highly enriched in e-SICW.