Long term study into surgical re-exploration of the 'free flap in difficulty'

Evidence-based Algorithms for Free Deep Inferior Epigastric Perforator Flap Salvage in Autologous Breast Reconstruction

Background

Breast reconstruction with the deep inferior epigastric perforator (DIEP) free flap has become the gold standard for autologous breast reconstruction. Flap take-back to the operating room (OR) is an uncommon but difficult situation, requiring prompt and accessible resources. We conducted a literature review and independent expert review to inform evidence-based perioperative algorithms in the event of DIEP flap compromise.

Methods

A review of the literature was conducted, including MEDLINE, Embase, Google Scholar, and Cochrane Controlled Register of Trials. Publications examining free flap re-exploration in breast reconstruction were used to inform evidence-based clinical algorithms. The algorithms then underwent expert review and revisions from 6 international experts in microsurgery.

Results

Three evidence-based management algorithms were created. The first algorithm outlines perioperative management strategies to optimize patient care and prompt return to the OR. Nonconstricting flap inset after take-back, salvage medical strategies and postoperative management following flap failure were additionally included. Algorithms 2 (venous congestion) and 3 (vascular thrombosis) provide specific intraoperative strategies surrounding mechanical decompression, pedicle exposure, assessment and extraction of thrombosis, identification and use of alternative recipient vessels, and the usage of intraoperative thrombolytics.

Conclusions

A coherent and stepwise approach to DIEP flap compromise in breast reconstruction was developed. These expert-reviewed algorithms provide an approachable and evidence-based structure to support return to the OR and serve as readily available resources.

Flap blood glucose measurement for flap monitoring and early detection of circulatory problems

Postoperative monitoring of skin flaps is subjective and cannot detect early circulatory problems in the flap. Early detection and rapid remedial re-exploration are important for flap salvage. We evaluated flap glucose measurement to monitor the flaps for early detection of circulatory problems. In total, 30 patients underwent cutaneous flap reconstruction. This is an easy, economic, objective, and reliable method for flap monitoring and can detect early venous congestion requiring remedial measures.

Surgical and demographic predictors of free flap salvage after takeback: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Microsurgical free tissue transfer (FTT) is a widely employed surgical modality utilized for reconstruction of a broad range of defects, including head and neck, extremity, and breast. Flap survival is reported to be 90%-95%. When FTT fails, salvage procedures aim at establishing reperfusion while limiting ischemia time-with salvage rates between 22% and 67%. There are limited data-driven predictors of successful salvage present in the literature. This systematic review aims to identify predictors of flap salvage.

METHODS

A systematic literature review was conducted per PRISMA guidelines. Articles included in the final analysis were limited to those investigating FTT salvage procedures and included factors impacting outcomes. Cohort and case series (>5 flaps) studies up until March 2021 were included. Chi-square tests and linear regression modeling was completed for analysis.

RESULTS

The patient-specific factors significantly associated with salvage included the absence of hypercoagulability (p < .00001) and no previous salvage attempts (p < .00001). Case-specific factors significantly associated with salvage included trunk/breast flaps (p < .00001), fasciocutaneous/osteocutaneous flaps (p = .006), venous compromise (p < .00001), and shorter time from index procedure to salvage attempt (R = .746). Radiation in the head and neck population was significantly associated with flap salvage failure.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the complexity and challenges surrounding free flap salvage procedures, the goal of this manuscript was to present data helping guide surgical decision-making. Based on our findings, patients without documented hypercoagulability, no previous salvage attempts, fasciocutaneous/osteocutaneous flaps, trunk/breast flaps, and a shorter time interval post-index operation are the best candidates for a salvage attempt.

The Optimal Length-of-Stay After Microvascular Breast Reconstruction: A Cost-Utility Analysis

BACKGROUND

Length-of-stay (LOS) can have a large impact on overall surgical costs. Several studies have demonstrated that a shortened LOS is safe and effective after microvascular breast reconstruction (MBR). The optimal LOS from a cost-utility perspective is not known.

METHODS

The authors used a decision tree model to evaluate the cost-utility, from the perspective of the hospital, of a variety of LOS strategies. Health state probabilities were estimated from an institutional chart review. Expected costs and quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) were assess using Monte Carlo simulation and sensitivity analyses.

RESULTS

Over a ten-year period, our overall flap loss and take-back rates were 1.6% and 4.9%, respectively. After rollback, a 3-day LOS was identified as the most cost-effective strategy, with an expected cost of $41,680.19 and an expected health utility of 25.68 QALYs. Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis confirmed that discharge on POD3 was the most cost-effective strategy in the majority of simulations when the willingness-to-pay threshold varied from $50,000-$130,000/QALY gained.

CONCLUSION

This cost-utility analysis suggests that a 3-day LOS is the most cost-effective strategy after MBR.

Heparin-induced thrombocytopenia and thrombosis in primary lymphedema patients who underwent vascularized lymph node transplantations

BACKGROUND

Heparin-induced thrombocytopenia and thrombosis (HITT) may result in microsurgical flap failure. This study investigated the outcomes of HITT in primary lymphedema patients who underwent vascularized lymph node transplantations (VLNT).

METHODS

Between 2012 and 2019, primary lymphedema patients who underwent VLNTs were retrospectively included. The 4Ts score was used to categorize patients into HITT (scores of 5-7) and non-HITT (score < 5) groups. Outcome evaluations included the re-exploration rate, success rate, circumferential differences, cellulitis episodes, and Lymphedema Specific Quality of Life Questionnaire (LYMQoL) scores.

RESULTS

Twenty-six and 15 patients with 31 and 16 VLNTs were included in the HITT and non-HITT groups, respectively. The HITT group had significantly greater first, second and third re-exploration rates of 38.7% (12/31), 25.7% (8/31), and 6.5% (2/31) than the non-HITT group (6.3%, 0%, and 0%, all p < 0.01), respectively. The platelet counts significantly decreased by 21.0% in the HITT group compared with the non-HITT group (14%) on postoperative Day one (p < 0.01) with a cutoff value of 17% and AUC = 0.88.

CONCLUSIONS

HITT may cause a high re-exploration rate of VLNTs in primary lymphedema patients. The 17% reduction in platelets on postoperative day one was an early sign for detecting HITT.

Multidisciplinary reconstructive management of residual recalcitrant empyema cavity: A retrospective observational cohort study

BACKGROUND

Patients with stage III empyema require chest wall fenestration to enable lung re-expansion and continuous drainage of the persisting empyema cavity. This chronic wound negatively affects patients' exercise tolerance, ability to carry out activities of daily living, and quality of life.

METHODS

Eight consecutive patients underwent chest wall reconstruction following fenestration and were followed up over a minimum of 12 months. This study included adult patients (over 18 years of age). There were no exclusion criteria. Data were collected retrospectively.

RESULTS

Eight patients (six male and two female), with a mean age of 56 years (range, 22-76), were included. All of them had comorbidities including history of neoplasia (n = 6), atrial fibrillation (n = 3), and hypertension (n = 2). Aetiology of empyema included lung cancer resection complicated by bronchopleural fistula (n = 4), pneumonia (n = 2), and pleural effusion (n = 2). Five patients had a low metabolic reserve evident by a low BMI (range, 16-22), and a median malnutrition universal screen tool (MUST) score of 2 (range, 1-4). Following intensive infection control and nutritional support, patients underwent reconstruction 11 months (median; range 5-51) after fenestration. Seven patients were followed up and had no recurrence of empyema and bronchopleural fistula. They all reported significant improvements in their quality of life, and their Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) performance status improved from three to one. One patient died 56 days post-reconstruction from cardiorespiratory failure, which required readmission to hospital.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrate that free tissue reconstruction including multidisciplinary input and optimisation at all stages of care successfully closes residual recalcitrant empyema cavity without recurrence and leads to significant improvements in the quality of life.

Increased salvage rates with early reexploration: A retrospective analysis of 547 free flap cases

BACKGROUND

Free flap complications are generally rare, but not negligible since they may exert paramount impact on both patients and care providers. The aim of the study was to identify risk factors for reexploration and assess predictors associated with increased salvage rates.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was conducted for free flaps performed between 2006 and 2015. Patient demographics, indications and flap types were analyzed together with complications and time to reexploration.

RESULTS

Among 547 consecutive free flaps, 11.5% required acute reexploration. Hematoma together with vascular compromise was the main cause (41.9%) for reexploration, followed by hematoma only (19.4%), venous (16.1%) and arterial (6.5%) thrombosis. Hematoma was associated with an increased risk for concomitant vascular complication (p < 0.02). The incidence of total and partial flap necrosis was 3.5% and 3.7% respectively. There was an overall 71.4% salvage rate. The median time from detection of a compromised flap to reexploration was 3.0 h. Significantly higher salvage rates were observed for cases reexplored within (82.4%) compared to after (57.1%) 3.0 h (OR 3.50 (95% CI 1.10 to 11.13, p = 0.034)).

CONCLUSIONS

The current study highlights the importance of early intervention, including evacuation of hematomas that may lead to vascular compromise. Adequate monitoring of venous outflow was found necessary to improve flap salvage rates, whereas arterial complications were mainly related to persistent arterial injury in traumatized extremities with reduced salvage rates. Free flap surgery requires trained staff and immediate access to operating facilities to ensure high flap survival rates.

Free Flap Monitoring, Salvage, and Failure Timing: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

 Microsurgical free tissue transfer has become a reliable technique with success rates around 99% and around 5% requiring exploration for vascular compromise. Protocols for flap monitoring between plastic surgery units vary. We aimed to elucidate the time period when monitoring is crucial for flap salvage.

METHODS

 A systematic search of literature was performed in PubMed, Cochrane Library, Medline, and Scopus databases from 1966 to July 2018 according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, identifying 3,844 studies with mention of free flap and monitoring or timing or salvage or compromise. Studies were screened for relevance according to predetermined inclusion criteria. Data was extracted from included studies relating to flap type, monitoring, timing and reason for failure, and success of salvage intervention.

RESULTS

 A total of 109 studies featuring 44,031 free flaps were included. A total of 2,549 (5.8%) flaps required return to theater for compromise; 926 (2.1%) were lost and 1,654 (3.7%) were salvaged. In the first 24 hours postoperatively 93.8% of explored flaps are successfully salvaged, by day 2: 83.33%, day 3: 12.1%, and beyond day 4: none were successful. Of the 355 flaps where the cause of failure was reported, 59.5% was venous, 27.9% was arterial, 2.3% was a combination of both, and 10.2% was hematoma or infection. The proportion of flap failures at various recipient sites was highest in the trunk/viscera (7%, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.00, 0.36), followed by limbs (5%, 95% CI 0.02, 0.08), head and neck (3%, 95% CI 0.02, 0.04), and breast (<1%; 95% CI 0.00, 0.02).

CONCLUSION

 Close flap monitoring is of most value in the first 48 hours postoperatively, facilitating rapid detection of vascular compromise, early salvage, and better outcomes. The location of the flap has implications on its success and certain recipient sites may need particular attention to improve chances of success.

A Simplified Cost-Utility Analysis of Inpatient Flap Monitoring after Microsurgical Breast Reconstruction and Implications for Hospital Length of Stay

BACKGROUND

The number of free flap take-backs and successful salvages following microsurgical breast reconstruction decreases as time from surgery increases. As a result, the cost of extended inpatient monitoring to achieve a successful flap salvage rises rapidly with each postoperative day. This study introduces a simplified cost-utility model of inpatient flap monitoring and identifies when cost-utility exceeds the thresholds established for other medical treatments.

METHODS

A retrospective review of a prospectively maintained database was performed of patients who underwent microsurgical breast reconstruction to identify flap take-back and salvage rates by postoperative day. The number of patients and flaps that needed to be kept on an inpatient basis each day for monitoring to salvage a single failing flap was determined. Quality-of-life measures and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios for inpatient flap monitoring following microsurgical breast reconstruction were calculated and plotted against a $100,000/quality-adjusted life-year threshold.

RESULTS

A total of 1813 patients (2847 flaps) were included. Overall flap take-back and salvage rates were 2.4 percent and 52.3 percent, respectively. Of the flaps taken back, the daily take-back and salvage rates were 56.8 and 60.0 percent (postoperative day 0 to 1), 13.6 and 83.3 percent (postoperative day 2), 11.4 and 40.0 percent (postoperative day 3), 9.1 and 25.0 percent (postoperative day 4), and 9.1 and 0.0 percent (>postoperative day 4), respectively. To salvage a single failing flap each day, the number of flaps that needed to be monitored were 121 (postoperative day 0 to 1), 363 (postoperative day 2), 907 (postoperative day 3), 1813 (postoperative day 4), and innumerable for days beyond postoperative day 4. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of inpatient flap monitoring begins to exceed a willingness-to-pay threshold of $100,000/quality-adjusted life-year by postoperative day 2.

CONCLUSION

The health care cost associated with inpatient flap monitoring following microsurgical breast reconstruction begins to rise rapidly after postoperative day 2.

Challenges in global microsurgery: A six year review of outcomes at an East African hospital

BACKGROUND

Free tissue transfer is an invaluable resource for reconstruction of complex defects. There is very little evidence as to the feasibility and outcomes of microsurgery performed in East Africa. This study will analyse outcomes of 114 consecutive free flaps, performed over 6 years at a single plastic surgery unit in Uganda. It aims to demonstrate that despite its challenges, successful microsurgical practice can be set up in East Africa.

METHODS AND PATIENTS

The notes of 100 consecutive patients who underwent 114 free flaps between 01/06/2009 and 01/07/2015 at CoRSU Hospital, Uganda were analysed.

RESULTS

One hundred and fourteen free flaps were performed on 100 patients. The types of free flaps used included free fibula (n = 41), ALT (n = 30), gracillis (n = 8), radial forearm (n = 7), latissimus dorsi (n = 9) and rectus (n = 7) amongst others (n = 12). The most common indications for surgery were head and neck cancer (n = 50), trauma (n = 19), osteomyelitis (n = 18), burns (n = 13), head and neck infection (n = 6). Over the six year period there was an overall 76% survival of the flaps. However in the last two years of the series there was a flap survival rate of over 93% (n = 50). There were 40 non-microsurgical complications including wound infection (n = 10) and graft loss (n = 8).

CONCLUSION

This is one of the first studies to report on the outcomes of free flaps performed at an East African centre. There is a steep but surmountable learning curve to improve microsurgery delivery in East Africa. This study identifies challenges in patient demographics, surgical experience and resources that have been overcome to improve outcomes.

Failure by congestion of pedicled and free flaps for reconstruction of lower limbs after trauma: the role of negative-pressure wound therapy

Lower limb reconstruction with pedicled or free flaps can be commonly compromised by venous insufficiency. This complication often leads to partial/complete flap necrosis and increases the risk of superinfection. Negative-pressure wound therapy (NPWT) is known to increase local blood flow, decrease edema, promote tissue granulation, and reduce the likelihood of soft tissue infection. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of NPWT in the treatment of congested pedicled and free flaps of the lower limb after reconstructions in lower limb traumas. A retrospective analysis was performed on four congested (pedicled and free) flaps on the lower limbs. NPWT was applied in all cases after partial flap debridement. NPWT was able to improve and resolve tissue edema and venous insufficiency, avoid further flap necrosis, and promote granulation. On NPWT removal, a split-thickness skin graft was applied on the wound, achieving complete and uneventful healing. NPWT is a useful instrument in managing flaps affected by venous insufficiency in lower limb reconstruction, although larger studies are necessary to better define the effectiveness and indications of NPWT in this setting.

Free tissue transfers at Hutt Hospital

BACKGROUND

  The Wellington Regional Plastic, Maxillofacial & Burns Unit based at Hutt Hospital provides comprehensive reconstructive services to central New Zealand with a population of 1.1 million. Free tissue transfer procedures in the Unit were audited to determine the indications and rate of usage in our population, our success and complication rates, and how these compare with published series.

METHODS

  Prospectively collected data on all free tissue transfer procedures between January 2006 and September 2010 were analysed.

RESULTS

  Two hundred and seven free flaps including 17 flap types being performed on 186 consecutive patients including 199 primary and 8 salvage flaps. Eighty-three percent were elective and 17% were acute cases. The majority of the flaps were used for head and neck (48%) and breast (31.5%) reconstruction. Ulnar forearm flap was the most commonly used fasciocutaneous flap. 18.8% of patients had major complications requiring return to theatre. Microsurgical revision was performed in nine (4.3%) flaps of which six were successfully salvaged. Overall, 13 flaps (6.3%) failed completely, giving an overall success rate of 93.7%. Haematoma requiring formal drainage occurred in 12 (5.8%) cases.

DISCUSSION

  The wide variety of flaps used reflects the very broad range of defects requiring free flap reconstruction. We show a free flap success rate of 93.7% in our medium-sized regional unit. Our microsurgical revision rate of 4.3% is lower than the revision rate of 10% in reported series with high overall success rates. More consistent early detection of failing flaps is likely to further improve our overall success rate.