Interaction of synaptotagmin with lipid bilayers, analyzed by single-molecule force spectroscopy

Chain-Length Dependence of Peptide-Lipid Bilayer Interaction Strength and Binding Kinetics: A Combined Theoretical and Experimental Approach

Physical interactions between polypeptide chains and lipid membranes underlie critical cellular processes. Yet, despite fundamental importance, key mechanistic aspects of these interactions remain elusive. Bulk experiments have revealed a linear relationship between free energy and peptide chain length in a model system, but does this linearity extend to the interaction strength and to the kinetics of lipid binding? To address these questions, we utilized a combination of coarse-grained molecular dynamics (CG MD) simulations, analytical modeling, and atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based single molecule force spectroscopy. Following previous bulk experiments, we focused on interactions between short hydrophobic peptides (WLn, n = 1, ..., 5) with 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) bilayers, a simple system that probes peptide primary structure effects. Potentials of mean force extracted from CG MD recapitulated the linearity of free energy with the chain length. Simulation results were quantitatively connected to bulk biochemical experiments via a single scaling factor of order unity, corroborating the methodology. Additionally, CG MD revealed an increase in the distance to the transition state, a result that weakens the dependence of the dissociation force on the peptide chain length. AFM experiments elucidated rupture force distributions and, through modeling, intrinsic dissociation rates. Taken together, the analysis indicates a rupture force plateau in the WLn-POPC system, suggesting that the final rupture event involves the last 2 or 3 residues. In contrast, the linear dependence on chain length was preserved in the intrinsic dissociation rate. This study advances the understanding of peptide-lipid interactions and provides potentially useful insights for the design of peptides with tailored membrane-interacting properties.

Cofilin-Membrane Interactions: Electrostatic Effects in Phosphoinositide Lipid Binding

The actin cytoskeleton interacts with the cell membrane primarily through the indirect interactions of actin-binding proteins such as cofilin-1. The molecular mechanisms underlying the specific interactions of cofilin-1 with membrane lipids are still unclear. Here, we performed coarse-grain molecular dynamics simulations of cofilin-1 with complex lipid bilayers to analyze the specificity of protein-lipid interactions. We observed the maximal interactions with phosphoinositide (PIP) lipids, especially PIP₂ and PIP₃ lipids. A good match was observed between the residues predicted to interact and previous experimental studies. The clustering of PIP lipids around the membrane bound protein leads to an overall lipid demixing and gives rise to persistent membrane curvature. Further, through a series of control simulations, we observe that both electrostatics and geometry are critical for specificity of lipid binding. Our current study is a step towards understanding the physico-chemical basis of cofilin-PIP lipid interactions.

Polybasic Patches in Both C2 Domains of Synaptotagmin-1 Are Required for Evoked Neurotransmitter Release

Synaptotagmin-1 (Syt1) is a vesicular calcium sensor required for synchronous neurotransmitter release, composed of a single-pass transmembrane domain linked to two C2 domains (C2A and C2B) that bind calcium, acidic lipids, and SNARE proteins that drive fusion of the synaptic vesicle with the plasma membrane. Despite its essential role, how Syt1 couples calcium entry to synchronous release is poorly understood. Calcium binding to C2B is critical for synchronous release, and C2B additionally binds the SNARE complex. The C2A domain is also required for Syt1 function, but it is not clear why. Here, we asked what critical feature of C2A may be responsible for its functional role and compared this to the analogous feature in C2B. We focused on highly conserved poly-lysine patches located on the sides of C2A (K189-192) and C2B (K324-327). We tested effects of charge-neutralization mutations in either region (Syt1K189-192A and Syt1K326-327A) side by side to determine their relative contributions to Syt1 function in cultured cortical neurons from mice of either sex and in single-molecule experiments. Combining electrophysiological recordings and optical tweezers measurements to probe dynamic single C2 domain-membrane interactions, we show that both C2A and C2B polybasic patches contribute to membrane binding, and both are required for evoked release. The size of the readily releasable vesicle pool and the rate of spontaneous release were unaffected, so both patches are likely required specifically for synchronization of release. We suggest these patches contribute to cooperative membrane binding, increasing the overall affinity of Syt1 for negatively charged membranes and facilitating evoked release.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Synaptotagmin-1 is a vesicular calcium sensor required for synchronous neurotransmitter release. Its tandem cytosolic C2 domains (C2A and C2B) bind calcium, acidic lipids, and SNARE proteins that drive fusion of the synaptic vesicle with the plasma membrane. How calcium binding to Synaptotagmin-1 leads to release and the relative contributions of the C2 domains are unclear. Combining electrophysiological recordings from cultured neurons and optical tweezers measurements of single C2 domain-membrane interactions, we show that conserved polybasic regions in both domains contribute to membrane binding cooperatively, and both are required for evoked release, likely by increasing the overall affinity of Synaptotagmin-1 for acidic membranes.

Atomic Force Microscopy for Structural and Biophysical Investigations on Nuclear Pore Complexes

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) enables simultaneous generation of topographical and biophysical maps of surfaces of biological samples at nanoresolution in physiologically relevant environments. Here, we describe the application of AFM to study nuclear pore complexes from structural and biophysical aspects.

Synaptotagmin-1 membrane binding is driven by the C2B domain and assisted cooperatively by the C2A domain

Synaptotagmin interaction with anionic lipid (phosphatidylserine/phosphatidylinositol) containing membranes, both in the absence and presence of calcium ions (Ca²⁺), is critical to its central role in orchestrating neurotransmitter release. The molecular surfaces involved, namely the conserved polylysine motif in the C2B domain and Ca²⁺-binding aliphatic loops on both C2A and C2B domains, are known. Here we use surface force apparatus combined with systematic mutational analysis of the functional surfaces to directly measure Syt1-membrane interaction and fully map the site-binding energetics of Syt1 both in the absence and presence of Ca²⁺. By correlating energetics data with the molecular rearrangements measured during confinement, we find that both C2 domains cooperate in membrane binding, with the C2B domain functioning as the main energetic driver, and the C2A domain acting as a facilitator.

Membrane Association and Functional Mechanism of Synaptotagmin-1 in Triggering Vesicle Fusion

Upon Ca²⁺ influx, synaptic vesicles fuse with the presynaptic plasma membrane (PM) to release neurotransmitters. Membrane fusion is triggered by synaptotagmin-1, a transmembrane protein in the vesicle membrane (VM), but the mechanism is under debate. Synaptotagmin-1 contains a single transmembrane helix (TM) and two tandem C2 domains (C2A and C2B). This study aimed to use molecular dynamics simulations to elucidate how Ca²⁺-bound synaptotagmin-1, by simultaneously associating with VM and PM, brings them together for fusion. Although C2A stably associates with VM via two Ca²⁺-binding loops, C2B has a propensity to partially dissociate. Importantly, an acidic motif in the TM-C2A linker competes with VM for interacting with C2B, thereby flipping its orientation to face PM. Subsequently, C2B readily associates with PM via a polybasic cluster and a Ca²⁺-binding loop. The resulting mechanistic model for the triggering of membrane fusion by synaptotagmin-1 reconciles many experimental observations.

Nanoscale Phenotypic Textures of Yersinia pestis Across Environmentally-Relevant Matrices

The persistence of bacterial pathogens within environmental matrices plays an important role in the epidemiology of diseases, as well as impacts biosurveillance strategies. However, the adaptation potentials, mechanisms for survival, and ecological interactions of pathogenic bacteria such as Yersinia pestis are largely uncharacterized owing to the difficulty of profiling their phenotypic signatures. In this report, we describe studies on Y. pestis organisms cultured within soil matrices, which are among the most important reservoirs for their propagation. Morphological (nanoscale) and phenotypic analysis are presented at the single cell level conducted using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM), coupled with biochemical profiles of bulk populations using Fatty Acid Methyl Ester Profiling (FAME). These studies are facilitated by a novel, customizable, 3D printed diffusion chamber that allows for control of the external environment and easy harvesting of cells. The results show that incubation within soil matrices lead to reduction of cell size and an increase in surface hydrophobicity. FAME profiles indicate shifts in unsaturated fatty acid compositions, while other fatty acid components of the phospholipid membrane or surface lipids remained consistent across culturing conditions, suggesting that phenotypic shifts may be driven by non-lipid components of Y. pestis.

Synaptotagmin 1 clamps synaptic vesicle fusion in mammalian neurons independent of complexin

Synaptic vesicle (SV) exocytosis is mediated by SNARE proteins. Reconstituted SNAREs are constitutively active, so a major focus has been to identify fusion clamps that regulate their activity in synapses: the primary candidates are synaptotagmin (syt) 1 and complexin I/II. Syt1 is a Ca2+ sensor for SV release that binds Ca2+ via tandem C2-domains, C2A and C2B. Here, we first determined whether these C2-domains execute distinct functions. Remarkably, the C2B domain profoundly clamped all forms of SV fusion, despite synchronizing residual evoked release and rescuing the readily-releasable pool. Release was strongly enhanced by an adjacent C2A domain, and by the concurrent binding of complexin to trans-SNARE complexes. Knockdown of complexin had no impact on C2B-mediated clamping of fusion. We postulate that the C2B domain of syt1, independent of complexin, is the molecular clamp that arrests SVs prior to Ca2+-triggered fusion.

Membrane-Binding Cooperativity and Coinsertion by C2AB Tandem Domains of Synaptotagmins 1 and 7

Synaptotagmin-1 (Syt-1) and synaptotagmin-7 (Syt-7) contain analogous tandem C2 domains, C2A and C2B, which together sense Ca²⁺ to bind membranes and promote the stabilization of exocytotic fusion pores. Syt-1 triggers fast release of neurotransmitters, whereas Syt-7 functions in processes that involve lower Ca²⁺ concentrations such as hormone secretion. Syt-1 C2 domains are reported to bind membranes cooperatively, based on the observation that they penetrate farther into membranes as the C2AB tandem than as individual C2 domains. In contrast, we previously suggested that the two C2 domains of Syt-7 bind membranes independently, based in part on measurements of their liposome dissociation kinetics. Here, we investigated C2A-C2B interdomain cooperativity with Syt-1 and Syt-7 using directly comparable measurements. Equilibrium Ca²⁺ titrations demonstrate that the Syt-7 C2AB tandem binds liposomes lacking phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate (PIP₂) with greater Ca²⁺ sensitivity than either of its individual domains and binds to membranes containing PIP₂ even in the absence of Ca²⁺. Stopped-flow kinetic measurements show differences in cooperativity between Syt-1 and Syt-7: Syt-1 C2AB dissociates from PIP₂-free liposomes much more slowly than either of its individual C2 domains, indicating cooperativity, whereas the major population of Syt-7 C2AB has a dissociation rate comparable to its C2A domain, suggesting a lack of cooperativity. A minor subpopulation of Syt-7 C2AB dissociates at a slower rate, which could be due to a small cooperative component and/or liposome clustering. Measurements using an environment-sensitive fluorescent probe indicate that the Syt-7 C2B domain inserts deeply into membranes as part of the C2AB tandem, similar to the coinsertion previously reported for Syt-1. Overall, coinsertion of C2A and C2B domains is coupled to cooperative energetic effects in Syt-1 to a much greater extent than in Syt-7. The difference can be understood in terms of the relative contributions of C2A and C2B domains toward membrane binding in the two proteins.

The high-affinity calcium sensor synaptotagmin-7 serves multiple roles in regulated exocytosis

MacDougall et al. review the structure and function of the calcium sensor synaptotagmin-7 in exocytosis.

Synaptotagmin (Syt) proteins comprise a 17-member family, many of which trigger exocytosis in response to calcium. Historically, most studies have focused on the isoform Syt-1, which serves as the primary calcium sensor in synchronous neurotransmitter release. Recently, Syt-7 has become a topic of broad interest because of its extreme calcium sensitivity and diversity of roles in a wide range of cell types. Here, we review the known and emerging roles of Syt-7 in various contexts and stress the importance of its actions. Unique functions of Syt-7 are discussed in light of recent imaging, electrophysiological, and computational studies. Particular emphasis is placed on Syt-7–dependent regulation of synaptic transmission and neuroendocrine cell secretion. Finally, based on biochemical and structural data, we propose a mechanism to link Syt-7’s role in membrane fusion with its role in subsequent fusion pore expansion via strong calcium-dependent phospholipid binding.

Single-molecule force spectroscopy of protein-membrane interactions

Many biological processes rely on protein–membrane interactions in the presence of mechanical forces, yet high resolution methods to quantify such interactions are lacking. Here, we describe a single-molecule force spectroscopy approach to quantify membrane binding of C2 domains in Synaptotagmin-1 (Syt1) and Extended Synaptotagmin-2 (E-Syt2). Syts and E-Syts bind the plasma membrane via multiple C2 domains, bridging the plasma membrane with synaptic vesicles or endoplasmic reticulum to regulate membrane fusion or lipid exchange, respectively. In our approach, single proteins attached to membranes supported on silica beads are pulled by optical tweezers, allowing membrane binding and unbinding transitions to be measured with unprecedented spatiotemporal resolution. C2 domains from either protein resisted unbinding forces of 2–7 pN and had binding energies of 4–14 k_BT per C2 domain. Regulation by bilayer composition or Ca²⁺ recapitulated known properties of both proteins. The method can be widely applied to study protein–membrane interactions.

Single-Molecule Peptide-Lipid Affinity Assay Reveals Interplay between Solution Structure and Partitioning

Interactions between short protein segments and phospholipid bilayers dictate fundamental aspects of cellular activity and have important applications in biotechnology. Yet, the lack of a suitable methodology for directly probing these interactions has hindered the mechanistic understanding. We developed a precision atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy assay and probed partitioning into lipid bilayers by measuring the mechanical force experienced by a peptide. Protein segments were constructed from the peripheral membrane protein SecA, a key ATPase in bacterial secretion. We focused on the first 10 amino-terminal residues of SecA (SecA2-11) that are lipophilic. In addition to the core SecA2-11 sequence, constructs with nearly identical chemical composition but with differing geometry were used: two copies of SecA2-11 linked in series and two copies SecA2-11 linked in parallel. Lipid bilayer partitioning interactions of peptides with differing structures were distinguished. To model the energetic landscape, a theory of diffusive barrier crossing was extended to incorporate a superposition of potential barriers with variable weights. Analysis revealed two dissociation pathways for the core SecA2-11 sequence with well-separated intrinsic dissociation rates. Molecular dynamics simulations showed that the three peptides had significant conformational differences in solution that correlated well with the measured variations in the propensity to partition into the bilayer. The methodology is generalizable and can be applied to other peptide and lipid species.

Direct quantitative detection of Doc2b-induced hemifusion in optically trapped membranes

Ca²⁺-sensor proteins control the secretion of many neuroendocrine substances. Calcium-secretion coupling may involve several mechanisms. First, Ca²⁺-dependent association of their tandem C2 domains with phosphatidylserine may induce membrane curvature and thereby enhance fusion. Second, their association with SNARE complexes may inhibit membrane fusion in the absence of a Ca²⁺ trigger. Here we present a method using two optically trapped beads coated with SNARE-free synthetic membranes to elucidate the direct role of the C2AB domain of the soluble Ca²⁺-sensor Doc2b. Contacting membranes are often coupled by a Doc2b-coated membrane stalk that resists forces up to 600 pN upon bead separation. Stalk formation depends strictly on Ca²⁺ and phosphatidylserine. Real-time fluorescence imaging shows phospholipid but not content mixing, indicating membrane hemifusion. Thus, Doc2b acts directly on membranes and stabilizes the hemifusion intermediate in this cell-free system. In living cells, this mechanism may co-occur with progressive SNARE complex assembly, together defining Ca²⁺-secretion coupling.

Membrane fusion in cells is triggered by an increase in Ca²⁺ and involves SNARE complexes and calcium-sensing proteins, but the mechanism underlying the Ca²⁺-sensors' role in fusion remains unclear. Here the authors show in vitro that the Ca²⁺-sensor Doc2b acts directly on membranes and induces a hemifusion intermediate in the presence of calcium.

Copper binding affinity of the C2B domain of synaptotagmin-1 and its potential role in the nonclassical secretion of acidic fibroblast growth factor

Fibroblast growth factor 1 (FGF1) is a heparin-binding proangiogenic protein. FGF1 lacks the conventional N-terminal signal peptide required for secretion through the endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-Golgi secretory pathway. FGF1 is released through a Cu(2+)-mediated nonclassical secretion pathway. The secretion of FGF1 involves the formation of a Cu(2+)-mediated multiprotein release complex (MRC) including FGF1, S100A13 (a calcium-binding protein) and p40 synaptotagmin (Syt1). It is believed that the binding of Cu(2+) to the C2B domain is important for the release of FGF1 into the extracellular medium. In this study, using a variety of biophysical studies, Cu(2+) and lipid interactions of the C2B domain of Syt1 were characterized. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) experiments reveal that the C2B domain binds to Cu(2+) in a biphasic manner involving an initial endothermic and a subsequent exothermic phase. Fluorescence energy transfer experiments using Tb(3+) show that there are two Cu(2+)-binding pockets on the C2B domain, and one of these is also a Ca(2+)-binding site. Lipid-binding studies using ITC demonstrate that the C2B domain preferentially binds to small unilamellar vesicles of phosphatidyl serine (PS). Results of the differential scanning calorimetry and limited trypsin digestion experiments suggest that the C2B domain is marginally destabilized upon binding to PS vesicles. These results, for the first time, suggest that the main role of the C2B domain of Syt1 is to serve as an anchor for the FGF1 MRC on the membrane bilayer. In addition, the binding of the C2B domain to the lipid bilayer is shown to significantly decrease the binding affinity of the protein to Cu(2+). The study provides valuable insights on the sequence of structural events that occur in the nonclassical secretion of FGF1.

Unbinding and unfolding of adhesion protein complexes through stretching: interplay between shear and tensile mechanical clamps

Using coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations, we analyze mechanically induced dissociation and unfolding of the protein complex CD48-2B4. This heterodimer is an indispensable component of the immunological system: 2B4 is a receptor on natural killer cells whereas CD48 is expressed on surfaces of various immune cells. So far, its mechanostability has not been assessed either experimentally or theoretically. We find that the dissociation processes strongly depend on the direction of pulling and may take place in several pathways. Interestingly, the CD48-2B4 interface can be divided into three distinct patches that act as units when resisting the pulling forces. At experimentally accessible pulling speeds, the characteristic mechanostability forces are in the range between 100 and 200 pN, depending on the pulling direction. These characteristic forces need not be associated with tensile forces involved in the act of separation of the complex because prior shear-involving unraveling within individual proteins may give rise to a higher force peak.

Membrane modulates affinity for calcium ion to create an apparent cooperative binding response by annexin a5

Isothermal titration calorimetry was used to characterize the binding of calcium ion (Ca²⁺) and phospholipid to the peripheral membrane-binding protein annexin a5. The phospholipid was a binary mixture of a neutral and an acidic phospholipid, specifically phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine in the form of large unilamellar vesicles. To stringently define the mode of binding, a global fit of data collected in the presence and absence of membrane concentrations exceeding protein saturation was performed. A partition function defined the contribution of all heat-evolving or heat-absorbing binding states. We find that annexin a5 binds Ca²⁺ in solution according to a simple independent-site model (solution-state affinity). In the presence of phosphatidylserine-containing liposomes, binding of Ca²⁺ differentiates into two classes of sites, both of which have higher affinity compared with the solution-state affinity. As in the solution-state scenario, the sites within each class were described with an independent-site model. Transitioning from a solution state with lower Ca²⁺ affinity to a membrane-associated, higher Ca²⁺ affinity state, results in cooperative binding. We discuss how weak membrane association of annexin a5 prior to Ca²⁺ influx is the basis for the cooperative response of annexin a5 toward Ca²⁺, and the role of membrane organization in this response.

Mechanism for calcium ion sensing by the C2A domain of synaptotagmin I

The C2A domain is one of two calcium ion (Ca(2+))- and membrane-binding domains within synaptotagmin I (Syt I), the identified Ca(2+) sensor for regulated exocytosis of neurotransmitter. We propose that the mechanistic basis for C2A's response to Ca(2+) and cellular function stems from marginal stability and ligand-induced redistributions of protein conformers. To test this hypothesis, we used a combination of calorimetric and fluorescence techniques. We measured free energies of stability by globally fitting differential scanning calorimetry and fluorescence lifetime spectroscopy denaturation data, and found that C2A is weakly stable. Additionally, using partition functions in a fluorescence resonance energy transfer approach, we found that the Ca(2+)- and membrane-binding sites of C2A exhibit weak cooperative linkage. Lastly, a dye-release assay revealed that the Ca(2+)- and membrane-bound conformer subset of C2A promote membrane disruption. We discuss how these phenomena may lead to both cooperative and functional responses of Syt I.

Exploring the mechanical stability of the C2 domains in human synaptotagmin 1

Human synaptotagmin 1 (Syt1) plays a crucial role in the bending of the membrane during neurotransmitter release at the synapse. Hence, resolving the structural details of Syt1 that underlie its biological function is fundamental for providing mechanistic insights into the nature of the synaptic response. We explored the unfolding micromechanics of Syt1 by analyzing the free energy landscape of the whole molecule and its C2A and C2B domains. We employed a self-organized polymer (SOP) model of a protein chain to carry out pulling simulations, accelerated on graphics processing units (GPUs), under experimental force loads. To resolve the atomic-level details, we complemented the SOP model simulations with atomistic simulations. On the basis of the results obtained, we hypothesize that (1) isolated single domains C2A and C2B present similar mechanical resistance against an applied pulling force but unfold following different kinetic pathways and that (2) C2B is more mechanically resistant in the C2AB complex due to stabilizing interactions with other domains. These findings correlate well with recent atomic force microscopy (AFM) studies on the Syt1 molecule, in which the increase in the unfolding force for C2B was detected when this domain was joined with C2A. Our results also suggest that the linkers (I27 domains) used in the experimental setup can modulate the mechanical behavior of this synaptic protein complex and alter not only the critical force for unfolding but also the unfolding pathways for the C2 domains. Interestingly, the presence of the C2A-C2B domain interface in the C2AB complex confers mechanical stability to either of the C2 domains. Our findings provide new insights into the relative conformational variability of the C2 domains, which we believe to be modulated, to a large extent, by intermolecular coupling with other proteins.