High curvature promotes fusion of lipid membranes: Predictions from continuum elastic theory

Fusion of asymmetric membranes: the emergence of a preferred direction

The fusion of lipid membranes progresses through a series of intermediate steps with two significant energy barriers: hemifusion-stalk formation and fusion-pore expansion. The cell's ability to tune these energy barriers is crucial as they determine the rate of many biological processes involving membrane fusion. However, a mechanism that allows the cell to manipulate both barriers in the same direction remains elusive, since membrane properties that the cell could dynamically tune during its life cycle, such as the lipids' spontaneous curvatures and membrane tension, have an opposite effect on the two barriers: tension inhibits stalk formation while promoting fusion-pore expansion. In contrast, increasing the total membrane concentration of lipids with negative intrinsic curvatures, such as cholesterol, promotes hemifusion-stalk formation while inhibiting pore expansion, and vice versa for lipids with positive intrinsic curvatures. Therefore, changes in these membrane properties increase one energy barrier at the expense of the other, resulting in a mixed effect on the fusion reaction. A possible mechanism to change both barriers in the same direction is by inducing lipid composition asymmetry, which results in tension and spontaneous curvature differences between the monolayers. To test the feasibility of this mechanism, a continuum elastic model was used to simulate the fusion intermediates and calculate the changes in the energy barriers. The calculations showed that a reasonable lipid composition asymmetry could lead to a 10-20kBT difference in both energy barriers, depending on the direction from which fusion occurs. We further provide experimental support to the model predictions, demonstrating changes in the time to hemifusion upon asymmetry introduction. These results indicate that biological membranes, which are asymmetric, have a preferred direction for fusion.

Hemifusomes and interacting proteolipid nanodroplets mediate multi-vesicular body formation

The pleiomorphic structure and dynamic behavior of cellular endomembrane systems have been extensively studied using classical electron microscopy. However, fixation and staining constraints limit the in situ visualization of transient interactions, such as membrane fusion, scission, and intraluminal vesicle formation, potentially overlooking intermediate structures like membrane hemifusion. Using in situ cryo-electron tomography in four mammalian cell lines, we identify heterotypic hemifused vesicles featuring an extended hemifusion diaphragm consistently associated with a 42-nanometer proteolipid nanodroplet (PND). We designate these vesicular organelle complexes as "hemifusomes." Hemifusomes constitute up to 10% of vesicular organelles at the cell periphery but do not engage in canonical endocytic pathways. These structures exhibit diverse conformations and frequently contain intraluminal vesicles. Building on the continuum of related morphologies observed, we propose that hemifusomes serve as platforms for vesicular biogenesis, mediated by the PND. These findings provide direct in situ evidence of long-lived hemifused vesicle complexes and introduce an ESCRT-independent model for multivesicular body (MVB) formation.

Gymnema saponin-induced lipid flip-flop identifies rigid membrane phenotype of methicillin resistant S. aureus and enhances it's antibiotic susceptibility

Our previous study revealed that lipid flip-flop inducing phytochemicals from Gymnema sylvestre increase membrane permeability of antimicrobials in S. aureus. However, their lipid flipping and membrane permeabilizing effect on methicillin resistant S. aureus (MRSA) membrane that has intrinsically higher aminoacylated lipid content compared to methicillin sensitive S. aureus (MSSA) is poorly characterized. Gymnema saponins, gymnemic acid I and IV significantly increased the antibiotic susceptibility in both MSSA and MRSA. MRSA exhibited a rigid membrane with lipid diffusion coefficient 0.0002 μm2/s compared to the MSSA membrane lipids with diffusion coefficient 1.48 μm2/s. Further, unlike MSSA, MRSA cells inhibited fusion of fluid liposomes with their plasma membrane. In vitro assay on reconstituted membrane vesicles revealed that Gymnema saponins induced 60 % lipid flipping in MSSA membrane compared to only 20 % lipid flipping in MRSA, indicating significantly lower Gymnema saponin-induced trans-bilayer lipid mobility in MRSA. Gymnema saponins induced significantly lower crystal violet uptake, release of cellular protein, cell shrinkage and lysis in MRSA compared to MSSA. Gymnema saponins led to dose-dependent inhibition of lipid-aminoacylation in both MSSA and MRSA making their membranes more negative compared to untreated control cells. In silico analysis reveals binding of both gymnemic acid I and IV to multiple peptide resistance factor (binding energy ∼ 7.5 kCal), the protein responsible for lipid aminoacylation in S. aureus. For the first time, our study reveals that MRSA membrane with higher aminoacyl-PG compared to MSSA shows significantly lower rate of diffusion and trans-bilayer flip-flop of lipids. Further, gymnemic acids are useful probes for identification, characterization and drug sensitization of rigid membrane MRSA phenotypes.

Boosting Lipofection Efficiency Through Enhanced Membrane Fusion Mechanisms

Gene transfection is a fundamental technique in the fields of biological research and therapeutic innovation. Due to their biocompatibility and membrane-mimetic properties, lipid vectors serve as essential tools in transfection. The successful delivery of genetic material into the cytoplasm is contingent upon the fusion of the vector and cellular membranes, which enables hydrophilic polynucleic acids to traverse the hydrophobic barriers of two intervening membranes. This review examines the critical role of membrane fusion in lipofection efficiency, with a particular focus on the molecular mechanisms that govern lipoplex-membrane interactions. This analysis will examine the key challenges inherent to the fusion process, from achieving initial membrane proximity to facilitating final content release through membrane remodeling. In contrast to viral vectors, which utilize specialized fusion proteins, lipid vectors necessitate a strategic formulation and environmental optimization to enhance their fusogenicity. This review discusses recent advances in vector design and fusion-promoting strategies, emphasizing their potential to improve gene delivery yield. It highlights the importance of understanding lipoplex-membrane fusion mechanisms for developing next-generation delivery systems and emphasizes the need for continued fundamental research to advance lipid-mediated transfection technology.

Hemifusomes and Interacting Proteolipid Nanodroplets Mediate Multi-Vesicular Body Formation

The complex, pleiomorphic membrane structure of the vesicular components within the endolysosomal system has been appreciated through decades of classical electron microscopy. However, due to the heavy fixation and staining required in these approaches, in situ visualization of fragile intermediates between early endosomes, late endosomes and ultimately multivesicular bodies (MVBs), remains elusive, raising the likelihood that other structures may have also been overlooked. Here, using in situ cryo-electron tomography in four mammalian cell lines, we discover heterotypic hemifused vesicles that share an extended hemifusion diaphragm, associated with a 42nm proteolipid nanodroplet (PND). We term this previously undescribed vesicular organelle-complex, "hemifusome". Hemifusomes make up approximately 10% of the organelle pool of the endolysosomal system, but do not participate directly in transferrin-mediated endocytosis. Hemifusomes exist in compound conformations and also contain intraluminal vesicles. Based on their range of morphologies, and the consistent presence of the PND at sites of compound hemifused vesicles, we propose that hemifusomes function as platforms for vesicular biogenesis mediated by the PND. These findings offer direct in situ evidence for a long-lived hemifusion diaphragm, and a new, ESCRT-independent model for the formation of late endosomes containing intraluminal vesicles and ultimately MVBs.

Sphingolipids containing very long-chain fatty acids regulate Ypt7 function during the tethering stage of vacuole fusion

Sphingolipids are essential in membrane trafficking and cellular homeostasis. Here, we show that sphingolipids containing very long-chain fatty acids (VLCFAs) promote homotypic vacuolar fusion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The elongase Elo3 adds the last two carbons to VLCFAs that are incorporated into sphingolipids. Cells lacking Elo3 have fragmented vacuoles, which is also seen when WT cells are treated with the sphingolipid synthesis inhibitor Aureobasidin-A. Isolated elo3Δ vacuoles show acidification defects and increased membrane fluidity, and this correlates with deficient fusion. Fusion arrest occurs at the tethering stage as elo3Δ vacuoles fail to cluster efficiently in vitro. Unlike HOPS and fusogenic lipids, GFP-Ypt7 does not enrich at elo3Δ vertex microdomains, a hallmark of vacuole docking prior to fusion. Pulldown assays using bacterially expressed GST-Ypt7 showed that HOPS from elo3Δ vacuole extracts failed to bind GST-Ypt7 while HOPS from WT extracts interacted strongly with GST-Ypt7. Treatment of WT vacuoles with the fluidizing anesthetic dibucaine recapitulates the elo3Δ phenotype and shows increased membrane fluidity, mislocalized GFP-Ypt7, inhibited fusion, and attenuated acidification. Together these data suggest that sphingolipids contribute to Rab-mediated tethering and docking required for vacuole fusion.

Hemifusomes and Interacting Proteolipid Nanodroplets: Formation of a Novel Cellular Organelle Complex

Within cells, vesicle fusion, scission, and the formation of intraluminal vesicles are critical processes that facilitate traffic, degradation, and recycling of cellular components, and maintenance of cellular homeostasis. Despite significant advancements in elucidating the molecular mechanisms that drive these dynamic processes, the direct in situ visualization of membrane remodeling intermediates remains challenging. Here, through the application of cryo-electron tomography in mammalian cells, we have identified a previously undescribed vesicular organelle complex with unique membrane topology: heterotypic hemifused vesicles that share extended hemifusion diaphragms (HDs) with a 42 nm proteolipid nanodroplet (PND) at their rim. We have termed these organelle complexes "hemifusomes". The HDs of hemifusomes exhibit a range of sizes and curvatures, including the formation of lens-shaped compartments encapsulated within the membrane bilayer. The morphological diversity of the lens-shaped vesicle aligns with a step-wise process of their intraluminal budding, ultimately leading to their scission and the generation of intraluminal vesicles. We propose that hemifusomes function as versatile platforms for protein and lipid sorting and as central hubs for the biogenesis of intraluminal vesicles and the formation of multivesicular bodies.

The local variation of the Gaussian modulus enables different pathways for fluid lipid vesicle fusion

Viral infections, fertilization, neurotransmission, and many other fundamental biological processes rely on membrane fusion. Straightforward calculations based on the celebrated Canham-Helfrich elastic model predict a large topological energy barrier that prevents the fusion process from being thermally activated. While such high energy is in accordance with the physical barrier function of lipid membranes, it is difficult to reconcile with the biological mechanisms involved in fusion processes. In this work, we use a Ginzburg-Landau type of free energy that recovers the Canham-Helfrich model in the limit of small width-to-vesicle-extension ratio, with the additional ability to handle topological transitions. We show that a local modification of the Gaussian modulus in the merging region both dramatically lowers the elastic energy barrier and substantially changes the minimal energy pathway for fusion, in accordance with experimental evidence. Therefore, we discuss biological examples in which such a modification might play a crucial role.

How Cell-Penetrating Peptides Behave Differently from Pore-Forming Peptides: Structure and Stability of Induced Transmembrane Pores

Peptide-induced transmembrane pore formation is commonplace in biology. Examples of transmembrane pores include pores formed by antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) in bacterial membranes and eukaryotic membranes, respectively. In general, however, transmembrane pore formation depends on peptide sequences, lipid compositions, and intensive thermodynamic variables and is difficult to observe directly under realistic solution conditions, with structures that are challenging to measure directly. In contrast, the structure and phase behavior of peptide-lipid systems are relatively straightforward to map out experimentally for a broad range of conditions. Cubic phases are often observed in systems involving pore-forming peptides; however, it is not clear how the structural tendency to induce negative Gaussian curvature (NGC) in such phases is quantitatively related to the geometry of biological pores. Here, we leverage the theory of anisotropic inclusions and devise a facile method to estimate transmembrane pore sizes from geometric parameters of cubic phases measured from small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and show that such estimates compare well with known pore sizes. Moreover, our model suggests that although AMPs can induce stable transmembrane pores for membranes with a broad range of conditions, pores formed by CPPs are highly labile, consistent with atomistic simulations.

Membrane Tension Inhibits Lipid Mixing by Increasing the Hemifusion Stalk Energy

Fusion of biological membranes is fundamental in various physiological events. The fusion process involves several intermediate stages with energy barriers that are tightly dependent on the mechanical and physical properties of the system, one of which is membrane tension. As previously established, the late stages of fusion, including hemifusion diaphragm and pore expansions, are favored by membrane tension. However, a current understanding of how the energy barrier of earlier fusion stages is affected by membrane tension is lacking. Here, we apply a newly developed experimental approach combining micropipette-aspirated giant unilamellar vesicles and optically trapped membrane-coated beads, revealing that membrane tension inhibits lipid mixing. We show that lipid mixing is 6 times slower under a tension of 0.12 mN/m compared with tension-free membranes. Furthermore, using continuum elastic theory, we calculate the dependence of the hemifusion stalk formation energy on membrane tension and intermembrane distance and find the increase in the corresponding energy barrier to be 1.6 kBT in our setting, which can explain the increase in lipid mixing time delay. Finally, we show that tension can be a significant factor in the stalk energy if the pre-fusion intermembrane distance is on the order of several nanometers, while for membranes that are tightly docked, tension has a negligible effect.

A microfluidic platform for the controlled synthesis of architecturally complex liquid crystalline nanoparticles

Soft-matter nanoparticles are of great interest for their applications in biotechnology, therapeutic delivery, and in vivo imaging. Underpinning this is their biocompatibility, potential for selective targeting, attractive pharmacokinetic properties, and amenability to downstream functionalisation. Morphological diversity inherent to soft-matter particles can give rise to enhanced functionality. However, this diversity remains untapped in clinical and industrial settings, and only the simplest of particle architectures [spherical lipid vesicles and lipid/polymer nanoparticles (LNPs)] have been routinely exploited. This is partially due to a lack of appropriate methods for their synthesis. To address this, we have designed a scalable microfluidic hydrodynamic focusing (MHF) technology for the controllable, rapid, and continuous production of lyotropic liquid crystalline (LLC) nanoparticles (both cubosomes and hexosomes), colloidal dispersions of higher-order lipid assemblies with intricate internal structures of 3-D and 2-D symmetry. These particles have been proposed as the next generation of soft-matter nano-carriers, with unique fusogenic and physical properties. Crucially, unlike alternative approaches, our microfluidic method gives control over LLC size, a feature we go on to exploit in a fusogenic study with model cell membranes, where a dependency of fusion on particle diameter is evident. We believe our platform has the potential to serve as a tool for future studies involving non-lamellar soft nanoparticles, and anticipate it allowing for the rapid prototyping of LLC particles of diverse functionality, paving the way toward their eventual wide uptake at an industrial level.

How cell penetrating peptides behave differently from pore forming peptides: structure and stability of induced transmembrane pores

Peptide induced trans-membrane pore formation is commonplace in biology. Examples of transmembrane pores include pores formed by antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and cell penetrating peptides (CPPs) in bacterial membranes and eukaryotic membranes, respectively. In general, however, transmembrane pore formation depends on peptide sequences, lipid compositions and intensive thermodynamic variables and is difficult to observe directly under realistic solution conditions, with structures that are challenging to measure directly. In contrast, the structure and phase behavior of peptide-lipid systems are relatively straightforward to map out experimentally for a broad range of conditions. Cubic phases are often observed in systems involving pore forming peptides; however, it is not clear how the structural tendency to induce negative Gaussian curvature (NGC) in such phases is quantitatively related to the geometry of biological pores. Here, we leverage the theory of anisotropic inclusions and devise a facile method to estimate transmembrane pore sizes from geometric parameters of cubic phases measured from small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and show that such estimates compare well with known pore sizes. Moreover, our model suggests that whereas AMPs can induce stable transmembrane pores for membranes with a broad range of conditions, pores formed by CPPs are highly labile, consistent with atomistic simulations.