Technical evaluation of the first fully automated assay for the detection of TSH receptor autoantibodies

Risk of recurrence at the time of withdrawal of short- or long-term methimazole therapy in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism: a randomized trial and a risk-scoring model

PURPOSE

In Graves' disease, administration of low-dose methimazole for more than 60 months induces higher remission rates compared with the conventional duration of 12-18 months. However, the risk of recurrence and its predictors beyond 48 months of drug withdrawal are not known. The aims of this study were to determine the risk of recurrence during 84 months after withdrawal of short- or long-term methimazole therapy and a risk stratification for recurrence of hyperthyroidism.

METHODS

A total of 258 patients were treated with methimazole for a median of 18 months and randomized to discontinuation of the drug(conventional short-term group; n = 128) or continuation of the treatment up to 60-120 months(long-term group; n = 130). Patients were followed for 84 months after methimazole withdrawal. Cox proportional hazards modeling was performed to identify factors associated with relapse and develop a risk-scoring model at the time of discontinuing the treatment.

RESULTS

Hyperthyroidism recurred in 67 of 120(56%) of conventionally-treated patients versus 20 of 118(17%) of those who received long-term methimazole treatment, p < 0.001. Age, sex, goiter grade, triiodothyronine, thyrotropin, and thyrotropin receptor antibodies were significant predictors of recurrence in both "conventional" and "long-term" groups but free thyroxine just in the "long-term" group. The risk-scoring model had a good discrimination power (optimism corrected c-index = 0.78,95%CI = 0.73-0.82) with a range of 0-14 and sensitivity of 86% and specificity of 62% at the risk-score of eight.

CONCLUSION

A relapse-free state was achieved in 83% of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism 84 months after cessation of long-term methimazole treatment which could be predicted by some significant predictors in a simple risk-scoring system.

Predicting the Course of Graves' Orbitopathy Using Serially Measured TSH-Receptor Autoantibodies by Automated Binding Immunoassays and the Functional Bioassay

The aim of the study was to investigate the use of serial measurements of TSH-receptor autoantibodies (TRAb) with the newest available assay technology to predict the course of Graves' Orbitopathy (GO) during the first 24 months from disease onset. Serial serum samples from patients with GO (103 mild/135 severe) were collected between 2007 and 2017 and retrospectively analyzed. The course of GO were classified into mild/severe 12 months after manifestation (severe: NOSPECS≥5; mild<5). TRAb were measured with automated binding immunoassays (IU/l): TRAb Elecsys (Cobas, Roche), TRAb bridge assay (IMMULITE, Siemens), and a cell-based bioassay (percent of specimen to reference ratio - SRR%) (Thyretain, Quidel). Variable cut off levels of measured TRAb were calculated at specificity of 90% from receiver operator curve (ROC) analysis for several timepoints during the course of GO. To select one: 5-8 months after first GO symptoms, which is the timepoint for usual referals for treatment mild course could be predicted at cut offs of 1.5 IU/l (Elecsys), 0.8 IU/l (Immulite) and 402% SRR (Thyretain) and the risc of severe course has to be anticipated if TRAb are above 11.6 IU/l (Elecsys), 6.5 IU/l (Thyretain), and 714% SRR (Thyretain). The Thyretain bioassay showed the highest diagnostic sensitivity (using the commercial cut off's) over the entire follow up period. TRAb measurements during the 24-month follow up of GO provide added value to the GO clinical activity and severity scores and should be used especially in the event of an unclear decision-taking situation with regard to therapy.

Thyrotropin receptor antibodies and Graves' orbitopathy

CONTEXT AND PURPOSE

The thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) is the key autoantigen in Graves' disease (GD) and associated orbitopathy (GO). Antibodies targeting the TSHR (TSHR-Ab) impact the pathogenesis and the course of GO. This review discusses the role and clinical relevance of TSHR-Ab in GO.

METHODS

Review of the current and pertinent literature.

RESULTS

GO is the most common extrathyroidal manifestation of GD and is caused by persistent, unregulated stimulation of TSHR-expressing orbital target cells (e.g. fibroblasts and pre-adipocytes). Serum TSHR-Ab and more specifically, the stimulatory Ab (TSAb) are observed in the vast majority of patients with GD and GO. TSHR-Ab are a sensitive serological parameter for the differential diagnosis of GO. TSHR-Ab can be detected either with conventional binding immunoassays that measure binding of Ab to the TSHR or with cell-based bioassays that provide information on their functional activity and potency. Knowledge of the biological activity and not simply the presence or absence of TSHR-Ab has relevant clinical implications e.g. predicting de-novo development or exacerbation of pre-existing GO. TSAb are specific biomarkers of GD/GO and responsible for many of its clinical manifestations. TSAb strongly correlate with the clinical activity and clinical severity of GO. Further, the magnitude of TSAb indicates the onset and acuity of sight-threatening GO (optic neuropathy). Baseline serum values of TSAb and especially dilution analysis of TSAb significantly differentiate between thyroidal GD only versus GD + GO.

CONCLUSION

Measurement of functional TSHR-Ab, especially TSAb, is clinically relevant for the differential diagnosis and management of GO.

Predicting the Relapse of Hyperthyroidism in Treated Graves' Disease with Orbitopathy by Serial Measurements of TSH-Receptor Autoantibodies

The aim of this study was to investigate the potential of the new TSH-receptor antibody (TRAb) assays to predict remission or relapse of hyperthyroidism in patients with Graves' disease (GD) and Graves' orbitopathy (GO). TRAbs were measured retrospectively in sera from a cohort of GD patients with GO (n=117; remission n=38 and relapse n=79-Essen GO biobank) with automated binding immunoassays: TRAb Elecsys (Cobas Roche) and TRAb bridge assay (IMMULITE, Siemens), and the TSAb (thyroid stimulating Ab) cell-based bioassay (Thyretain, Quidel Corp.). To identify relapse risk/remission of hyperthyroidism patients were followed up at least 10 months after the end of antithyroid drug therapy (ATD) therapy. ROC plot analysis was performed to calculate cut-off levels of TRAb and TSAb for prediction of relapse and remission of hyperthyroidism. Cut-off serum levels are provided for timepoints around 3, 6, 10, and 15 months after the beginning of ATD. Repeated measurements of TRAb increase the rate of relapses predictions to 60% (Elecsys), 70% (IMMULITE), and 55% (Thyretain). Patients with remission have consistently TRAb levels below the cut off for relapse in repeated measurements. The cell-based bioassay was the most sensitive - and continued to be positive during follow up [at 15 months: 90% vs. 70% (IMMULITE) and 65% (Elecsys)]. Identification of relapsing hyperthyroidism is possible with automated immunoassays and cell-based bioassay especially with serial TRAb measurements during the course of ATD therapy. Patient who need eye surgery may profit from an early decision towards definitive treatment.

Practical applications of studies on the TSH receptor and TSH receptor autoantibodies

Studies on the TSH receptor (TSHR) have numerous practical applications in vitro and in vivo. For example human monoclonal autoantibodies (MAbs) to the TSHR are useful reagents for in vitro diagnostics. Measurement of TSHR autoantibodies (TRAbs) is helpful in diagnosis and management of autoimmune thyroid disease. Currently available highly sensitive and specific assays to measure TRAbs use the human TSHR MAb M22 instead of the TSH. Furthermore, preparations of the human TSHR MAb M22 are useful as the World Health Organisation International Standard for thyroid stimulating antibody and for calibration of the assays for measuring TRAbs. Preparations of thermostabilised TSHR extracellular domain have recently become available and this is likely to have an impact on improvements in specificity testing for TRAb assays. In addition the stable TSHR preparations have practical application for specific immunoadsorption of patient serum TRAbs. Human TSHR MAbs also have promising prospects as new therapeutics. Autoantibodies with TSHR antagonistic activities are "natural" inhibitors of TSHR stimulation and are expected to be helpful in controlling TSHR activity in patients with Graves' disease, Graves' ophthalmopathy and thyroid cancer.

Serum Ratio of Free Triiodothyronine to Thyroid-Stimulating Hormone: A Novel Index for Distinguishing Graves' Disease From Autoimmune Thyroiditis

OBJECTIVE

Graves' disease (GD) and autoimmune thyroiditis (AIT) are two major causes of thyrotoxicosis that require correct diagnosis to plan appropriate treatment. The objectives of this study were to evaluate the usefulness of thyroid-related parameters for distinguishing GD from AIT and identify a novel index for differential diagnosis of thyrotoxicosis.

DESIGN

This retrospective study was performed using electronic medical records in Peking University People's Hospital (Beijing, China).

METHODS

In total, 650 patients with GD and 155 patients with AIT from December 2015 to October 2019 were included in cohort 1. Furthermore, 133 patients with GD and 14 patients with AIT from December 2019 to August 2020 were included in cohort 2 for validation of the novel index identified in cohort 1. All patients were of Chinese ethnicity and were newly diagnosed with either GD or AIT. Thyroid-related clinical information was collected before intervention by reviewing the patients' electronic medical records. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was used to identify the optimal cutoff for distinguishing GD from AIT.

RESULTS

In cohort 1, thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) receptor antibody was identified as the best indicator for distinguishing GD from AIT. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve was 0.99(95% confidence interval: 0.98-0.99, p<0.0001)and the optimal cutoff was 0.84 IU/l (98% sensitivity and 99% specificity). The free triiodothyronine (FT3)/TSH ratio (FT3/TSH) was the second -best for distinguishing GD from AIT, the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of FT3/TSH was 0.86 (95% confidence interval: 0.84-0.88, p<0.0001); its optimal cutoff was 1.99 pmol/mIU (79% sensitivity and 80% specificity). Its effectiveness was confirmed in cohort 2 (81% sensitivity and 100% specificity).

CONCLUSIONS

The FT3/TSH ratio is a new useful index for differential diagnosis of thyrotoxicosis, especially when combined with TRAb.

Predicting outcomes and complications following radioiodine therapy in Graves' thyrotoxicosis

OBJECTIVE

Radioiodine (RAI) is an effective treatment for Graves' thyrotoxicosis but is associated with a failure rate of 15% and may be a risk factor for thyroid eye disease (TED) and weight gain. We sought to examine predictors of RAI failure, weight gain, TED and patient satisfaction.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

PATIENTS

A total of 655 episodes of RAI in Graves' thyrotoxicosis patients (2006-2015).

MEASUREMENTS

Biochemical assessment, including TFTs and thyrotropin receptor antibodies (TRAb), clinical features (eg, TED, weight and thionamide use) and patient questionnaire.

RESULTS

The treatment failure rate was 17%. Failure was greater with higher fT4 (P = 0.002) and higher TRAb (P = 0.004). Failure rate was 42.2% when TRAb >40 U/L. Median weight gain was 3.2 kg in those with normal fT4 prior to RAI and 5.8 kg when fT4 was elevated (P < 0.001). New TED developed in 7.6% but was not associated with post-RAI dysthyroidism. Treatment satisfaction was generally high (median response 8/10).

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment failure after RAI occurs in predictable groups and this should be reflected in the information provided to patients. Weight gain is common and may not entirely be explained by a return to pre-thyrotoxic baseline. We were unable to detect any significant impact of post-RAI dysthyroidism on weight gain, TED or thyroid symptoms in this large cohort.

Laboratory Testing in Thyroid Conditions - Pitfalls and Clinical Utility

Thyroid disorders are common, affecting more than 10% of people in the US, and laboratory tests are integral in the management of these conditions. The repertoire of thyroid tests includes blood tests for thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH), free thyroxine, free triiodothyronine, thyroglobulin (Tg), thyroglobulin antibodies (Tg-Ab), thyroid peroxidase antibodies (TPO-Ab), TSH receptor antibodies (TRAb), and calcitonin. TSH and free thyroid hormone tests are frequently used to assess the functional status of the thyroid. TPO-Ab and TRAb tests are used to diagnose Hashimoto's thyroiditis and Graves' disease, respectively. Tg and calcitonin are important tumor markers used in the management of differentiated thyroid carcinoma and medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC), respectively. Procalcitonin may replace calcitonin as a biomarker for MTC. Apart from understanding normal thyroid physiology, it is important to be familiar with the possible pitfalls and caveats in the use of these tests so that they can be interpreted properly and accurately. When results are discordant, clinicians and laboratorians should be mindful of possible assay interferences and/or the effects of concurrent medications. In addition, thyroid function may appear abnormal in the absence of actual thyroid dysfunction during pregnancy and in critical illness. Hence, it is important to consider the clinical context when interpreting results. This review aims to describe the above-mentioned blood tests used in the diagnosis and management of thyroid disorders, as well as the pitfalls in their interpretation. With due knowledge and care, clinicians and laboratorians will be able to fully appreciate the clinical utility of these important laboratory tests.

Thyroid Stimulating Hormone Receptor Antibodies in Thyroid Eye Disease-Methodology and Clinical Applications

BACKGROUND

Thyroid stimulating hormone receptor antibodies (TSHR-Ab) cause autoimmune hyperthyroidism and are prevalent in patients with related thyroid eye disease (TED).

PURPOSE

To provide a historical perspective on TSHR-Ab and to present evidence-based recommendations for clinical contemporary use.

METHODS

The authors review the recent literature pertaining to TSHR-Ab in patients with TED and describe the various immunoassays currently used for detecting TSHR-Ab and their clinical applications.

RESULTS

We provide a historical summary and description of the various methods used to detect TSHR-Ab, foremost, the functional TSHR-Ab. Increasing experimental and clinical data demonstrate the clinical usefulness of cell-based bioassays for measurements of functional TSHR-Ab in the diagnosis and management of patients with autoimmune TED and in the characterization of patients with autoimmune-induced hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism. Thyroid stimulating hormone receptor antibodies, especially the functional stimulating antibodies, are sensitive, specific, and reproducible biomarkers for patients with autoimmune TED and correlate well with clinical disease activity and clinical severity. Unlike competitive-binding assays, bioassays have the advantage of indicating not only the presence of antibodies but also their functional activity and potency.

CONCLUSIONS

Measurement of TSHR-Ab (especially stimulating antibodies) is a clinically useful tool for the management of patients with TED.

Highly variable sensitivity of five binding and two bio-assays for TSH-receptor antibodies

PURPOSE

TSH-receptor (TSHR) antibodies (Ab) can be measured with binding or bio-assays. Sensitivity and specificity of five binding and two bio-assays were compared.

METHODS

TSHR-blocking (TBAb) and TSHR-stimulating (TSAb) Ab were measured with reporter bio-assays. Blocking activity was defined as percent inhibition of luciferase expression relative to induction with bTSH alone. TSAb was reported as percentage of specimen-to-reference ratio (SRR%). TSHR-binding inhibitory immunoglobulins (TBII) were measured with Kronus, Dynex, Kryptor, Cobas, and Immulite.

RESULTS

Sixty patients with Graves' disease (GD), 20 with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), and 20 healthy controls (C) were included. C tested negative in all assays (specificity 100 %) while all 60 hyperthyroid GD patients tested positive in the TSAb bio-assay (sensitivity 100 %). Among these 60 GD patients, 20 had low TSAb positivity (SRR% 140-279), but were TBII positive in only 20 (100 %), 7 (35 %), 9 (45 %), 11 (55 %), and 18 (90 %) using the Kronus, Dynex, Kryptor, Cobas, and Immulite, respectively. In 20 moderate TSAb-positive (SRR% 280-420) patients, TBII tested positive in 20 (100 %), 14 (70 %), 13 (65 %), 16 (80 %), and 19 (95 %), respectively. The high (SRR% > 420) TSAb-positive patients were all TBII positive. All 20 hypothyroid HT patients tested TBAb positive (sensitivity 100 %) in the bio-assay while they tested TBII positive in 20 (100 %), 18 (90 %), 20, 20, and 18, respectively. Results obtained with two luminometers correlated for TSAb positive (r = 0.99, p < 0.001), TBAb positive (r = 0.88, p < 0.001), and C (r = 0.86, p < 0.001). None of the binding assays differentiated between TSAb and TBAb.

CONCLUSIONS

Sensitivity is highly variable between binding and bio-assays for TSHR-Abs.

Thyrotropin Receptor Antibody Levels at Diagnosis and After Thionamide Course Predict Graves' Disease Relapse

BACKGROUND

Thionamides are associated with a high risk of recurrence following cessation. Thyrotropin receptor-stimulating antibody (TRAb) levels at diagnosis and/or after thionamides may be biomarkers of this risk. This study assesses the natural history of Graves' thyrotoxicosis following thionamide withdrawal and factors that predict recurrence, particularly TRAb levels at diagnosis and cessation.

METHODS

An observational study was conducted of patients with a first presentation of Graves' disease, who were prescribed (and completed) a course of primary thionamide treatment (n = 266) in a university teaching hospital endocrine clinic. Recurrence rates over four years and factors predictive of recurrent thyrotoxicosis were assessed.

RESULTS

The relapse rate was 31% at one year and 70% at four years. Younger age (39 years [range 30-49 years] vs. 47 years [range 37-53 years]; p = 0.011), higher TRAb levels at diagnosis (8.8 IU/L [range 5.3-17.0 IU/L] vs. 5.7 IU/L [range 4.1-9.1 IU/L]; p = 0.003), and higher TRAb levels at cessation of therapy (1.2 IU/L [range 0-2.3 IU/L] vs. <0.9 IU/L [range 0-1.3 IU/L]; p = 0.003) were associated with a higher risk of relapse. By four years, cessation TRAb <0.9 IU/L was associated with a 58% risk of recurrence compared with 82% with TRAb >1.5 IU/L (p = 0.001). TRAb at diagnosis >12 IU/L was associated with an 84% risk of recurrence over four years compared with 57% with TRAbs <5 IU/L (p = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

High TRAb at diagnosis and/or positive TRAb at cessation of therapy suggest a high likelihood of relapse, mostly within the first two years. They stratify patients likely to need definitive therapy (radioiodine or surgery).

Mechanisms of Action of TSHR Autoantibodies

The availability of human monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to the TSHR has enabled major advances in our understanding of how TSHR autoantibodies interact with the receptor. These advances include determination of the crystal structures of the TSHR LRD in complex with a stimulating autoantibody (M22) and with a blocking type autoantibody (K1-70). The high affinity of MAbs for the TSHR makes them particularly suitable for use as ligands in assays for patient serum TSHR autoantibodies. Also, M22 and K1-70 are effective at low concentrations in vivo as TSHR agonists and antagonists respectively. K1-70 has important potential in the treatment of the hyperthyroidism of Graves' disease and Graves' ophthalmopathy. Small molecule TSHR antagonists described to date do not appear to have the potency and/or specificity shown by K1-70. New models of the TSHR ECD in complex with various ligands have been built. These models suggest that initial binding of TSH to the TSHR causes a conformational change in the hormone. This opens a positively charged pocket in receptor-bound TSH which attracts the negatively charged sulphated tyrosine 385 on the hinge region of the receptor. The ensuing movement of the receptor's hinge region may then cause activation. Similar activation mechanisms seem to take place in the case of FSH and the FSHR and LH and the LHR. However, stimulating TSHR autoantibodies do not appear to activate the TSHR in the same way as TSH.

Applications of cell-based bioassays measuring the induced expression of endogenous genes

Cell-based bioassays are used to determine the biological activity of complex biotherapeutic products, to assign potency and to assure the quality and consistency of the manufacturing process. Clinically, these assays are used to assess bioactivity in patient samples, particularly for the detection of antidrug neutralizing antibodies. Owing to their versatility, cellular assays that measure endogenous gene expression by quantitative reverse transcription PCR offer a rapid and automatable alternative to assays measuring functional, late-stage responses. Notably, detection of immediate early gene expression represents a direct response of the cell to receptor ligation by the biotherapeutic. We review current developments in the use of this approach and demonstrate its application to the detection of receptor-binding autoantibodies using, as a case study, the detection of autoantibodies to the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor.

Diagnosis and management of Graves disease: a global overview

Graves disease is an autoimmune disorder characterized by goitre, hyperthyroidism and, in 25% of patients, Graves ophthalmopathy. The hyperthyroidism is caused by thyroid hypertrophy and stimulation of function, resulting from interaction of anti-TSH-receptor antibodies (TRAb) with the TSH receptor on thyroid follicular cells. Measurements of serum levels of TRAb and thyroid ultrasonography represent the most important diagnostic tests for Graves disease. Management of the condition currently relies on antithyroid drugs, which mainly inhibit thyroid hormone synthesis, or ablative treatments ((131)I-radiotherapy or thyroidectomy) that remove or decrease thyroid tissue. None of these treatments targets the disease process, and patients with treated Graves disease consequently experience either a high rate of recurrence, if receiving antithyroid drugs, or lifelong hypothyroidism, after ablative therapy. Geographical differences in the use of these therapies exist, partially owing to the availability of skilled thyroid surgeons and suitable nuclear medicine units. Novel agents that might act on the disease process are currently under evaluation in preclinical or clinical studies, but evidence of their efficacy and safety is lacking.

Predictors of treatment failure, incipient hypothyroidism, and weight gain following radioiodine therapy for Graves' thyrotoxicosis

BACKGROUND

Following radioiodine ((131)I) therapy, both late recognition of hypothyroidism and treatment failure may result in adverse outcomes.

AIM

We sought to assess indicators of both incipient hypothyroidism and treatment failure following (131)I and determine factors predictive of weight gain.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Retrospective study of 288 patients receiving (131)I for treatment of Graves' thyrotoxicosis. Primary outcome measures were thyroid status and weight change at 1 yr following (131)I.

RESULTS

The treatment failure rate at 1 yr was 13.5%. Hypothyroidism developed in 80.9%, with 58.5% of patients having levels of free T4 (fT4) <6 pmol/l at diagnosis. Patients receiving thionamides before and after (131)I had significantly higher levels of treatment failure (23.3%) than those with no thionamide exposure (6.3%, p=0.003), but also had more active Graves' disease. Following (131)I, development of a detectable TSH or low-normal fT4 levels was not associated with recurrent thyrotoxicosis. Median weight gain was 5.3 kg, although patients with nadir fT4 levels <6 pmol/l gained an average 2 kg more than those with levels >6 pmol/l (p=0.05). The main predictor of weight gain was fT4 level immediately prior to treatment; those in the lowest tertile gained a median 3.1 kg whilst those in the highest tertile gained 7.4 kg (median difference 4.3 kg; 95% confidence interval: 2.5-6.2).

CONCLUSIONS

Marked hypothyroidism following (131)I is common and often occurs early. Simple biochemical parameters may help identify incipient hypothyroidism and potentially limit excess weight gain. Treatment failure is common in patients with severe thyrotoxicosis and in such cases larger doses of (131)I may be warranted.

Novel chimeric thyroid-stimulating hormone-receptor bioassay for thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulins

Thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulins (TSI) are a functional biomarker of Graves' disease (GD). To develop a novel TSI bioassay, a cell line (MC4-CHO-Luc) was bio-engineered to constitutively express a chimeric TSH receptor (TSHR) and constructed with a cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP)-dependent luciferase reporter gene that enables TSI quantification. Data presented as percentage of specimen-to-reference ratio (SRR%) were obtained from 271 patients with various autoimmune and thyroid diseases and 180 controls. Sensitivity of 96% and specificity of 99% for untreated GD were attained by receiver operating characteristic analysis, area under the curve 0·989, 95% confidence interval 0·969-0·999, P = 0·0001. Precision testing of manufactured reagents of high, medium, low and negative SRR% gave a percentage of coefficient-of-variation of 11·5%, 12·8%, 14·5% and 15·7%, respectively. There was no observed interference by haemoglobin, lipids and bilirubin and no non-specific stimulation by various hormones at and above physiological concentrations. TSI levels from GD patients without (SRR% 406 ± 134, mean ± standard deviation) or under anti-thyroid treatment (173 ± 147) were higher (P < 0·0001) compared with TSI levels of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (51 ± 37), autoimmune diseases without GD (24 ± 10), thyroid nodules (30 ± 26) and controls (35 ± 18). The bioassay showed greater sensitivity when compared with anti-TSHR binding assays. In conclusion, the TSI-Mc4 bioassay measures the functional biomarker accurately in GD with a standardized protocol and could improve substantially the diagnosis of autoimmune diseases involving TSHR autoantibodies.

Accuracy of receptor-based methods for detection of thyrotropin-receptor autoantibodies: a new automated third-generation immunoassay shows higher analytical and clinical sensitivity for the differential diagnosis of hyperthyroidism

PURPOSE

Specific autoantibodies acting as TSH receptor agonists (TRAb) are responsible for Graves' disease (GD). In the last 30 years three generations of assay methods for the detection of TRAb have become available. The aim of this multicentre study was to evaluate the analytical sensitivity, precision and diagnostic accuracy of TRAb measurement using a new automated assay in comparison with a second-generation standard method.

METHODS

Serum samples from patients with GD (n=82), autoimmune thyroiditis (AIT, n=57) or hyperthyroidism (HT, n=292), from 106 healthy subjects and from 57 patients with infectious diseases were analysed using a third-generation TRAb immunoassay (anti-TSHR, RAD 120; Radim, Italy) based on the human monoclonal TSH receptor antibody M22.

RESULTS

Using a cut-off value of 1.25 mIU/l, established by ROC curve analysis, 80/82 GD patients (97.5%), 68/292 HT patients (23.2%), and 6/57 AIT patients (10.5%) were TRAb-positive with the M22-based automated assay. The percentages of TRAb positivity were lower in the same patients when the measurements were done with the second-generation method (95.1%, 18.9%, 7.0%, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The M22-based automated immunoassay shows high functional sensitivity (0.4 mIU/l) and high diagnostic specificity, is more sensitive than the standard second-generation method and is less time-consuming and labourintensive, and is therefore the up-to-date technology for TRAb detection in clinical practice.

Clinical review about TRAb assay's history

Commercial assays to measure thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) receptor (TSHR) autoantibodies (TRAb) have been available for the serological diagnosis of autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) for several years. The widespread assessment of this parameter has identified Graves' disease (GD) as a common organ-specific autoimmune disease. Within the present article we aim to review immunobiological and epidemiological aspects as well as diagnostic methods available for the detection of TRAb. Over the last decade, TRAb detection in GD became more sensitive since TRAb assays were being largely improved by named research groups. Therefore, functional assay (fas) and diagnostic sensitivity of current TRAb assays will be discussed. Within the second part of this review we will focus on clinical applications of TRAb measurement for outcome prediction of GD as well as the importance of this method to distinguish GD from other AITD.

A novel thyroid stimulating immunoglobulin bioassay is a functional indicator of activity and severity of Graves' orbitopathy

CONTEXT

Immunoglobulins stimulating the TSH receptor (TSI) influence thyroid function and likely mediate extrathyroidal manifestations of Graves' disease (GD).

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to assess the clinical relevance of TSI in GD patients with or without Graves' orbitopathy (GO), to correlate the TSI levels with activity/severity of GO, and to compare the sensitivity/specificity of a novel TSI bioassay with TSH receptor (TSH-R) binding methods (TRAb).

DESIGN

TSI were tested in two reporter cell lines designed to measure Igs binding the TSH-R and transmitting signals for cAMP/CREB/cAMP regulatory element complex-dependent activation of luciferase gene expression. Responsiveness to TSI of the novel chimeric (Mc4) TSH-R (amino acid residues 262-335 of human TSH-R replaced by rat LH-R) was compared with the wild-type (wt) TSH-R.

RESULTS

All hyperthyroid GD/GO patients were TSI-positive. TSI were detected in 150 of 155 (97%, Mc4) and 148 of 155 (95%, wt) GO patients, in six of 45 (13%, Mc4) and 20 of 45 (44%, wt) mostly treated GD subjects, and in 0 of 40 (Mc4) and one of 40 (wt) controls. Serum TSI titers were 3- and 8-fold higher in GO vs. GD and control, respectively. All patients with diplopia and optic neuropathy and smokers were TSI-positive. TSI strongly correlated with GO activity (r = 0.87 and r = 0.7; both P < 0.001) and severity (r = 0.87 and r = 0.72; both P < 0.001) in the Mc4 and wt bioassays, respectively. Clinical sensitivity (97 vs. 77%; P < 0.001) and specificity (89 vs. 43%; P < 0.001) of the Mc4/TSI were greater than TRAb in GO. All 11 of 200 (5.5%) TSI-positive/TRAb-negative patients had GO, whereas all seven of 200 (3.5%) TSI-negative/TRAb-positive subjects had GD only.

CONCLUSION

The novel Mc4/TSI is a functional indicator of GO activity and severity.

First automated assay for thyrotropin receptor autoantibodies

BACKGROUND

Hyperthyroidism in Graves' disease (GD) is often associated with the production of autoantibodies (TRAb) to the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR). Current manual second generation TRAb assays demonstrate high clinical sensitivity, but are labor-intensive and time consuming. Until recently, technical difficulties prevented the availability of an automatic TRAb assay.

METHODS

Development of a fast and fully automated TRAb assay on the Elecsys/cobas e electrochemiluminescence immunoassay platform.

RESULTS

A labeled thyroid-stimulating human monoclonal TSHR autoantibody (M22) was used in an automated M22-binding inhibition assay. TRAb are detected by their ability to competitively inhibit M22-binding to solubilized porcine TSHR (pTSHR). High clinical sensitivity could be maintained by assembling multiple TSHR binding sites within a soluble oligomeric immunocomplex for improved TRAb binding. Requirement of sufficient on board stability of the delicate TSHR structure in solution for several days was met by pre-complexation of the pTSHR with a capture antibody to its C-terminus in combination with the use of structure-stabilizing chemical chaperones. Total imprecision coefficient of variation (CV) at 1.71 (approximate cut-off) was found to be 11.4%. TRAb results were available within 30 min.

CONCLUSIONS

Availability of a fast and automatic TRAb assay offers an attractive alternative to the manual TRAb assays for the differential diagnosis of hyperthyroidism.

Clinical value of M22-based assays for TSH-receptor antibody (TRAb) in the follow-up of antithyroid drug treated Graves' disease: comparison with the second generation human TRAb assay

BACKGROUND

We compared the clinical performances of two new M22-based assays for TSH-receptor antibody (TRAb) with those of the human TRAb assay (hTRAK) in Graves' disease patients at the end of treatment.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Sera were obtained from 128 Graves' patients treated for 18 months with antithyroid drugs. Sixty-six remained in remission and sixty-two had relapse of hyperthyroidism in a 3-year follow-up after discontinuing treatment. TRAbs were measured using two M22-based methods (electrochemiluminescence using the Cobas or ELISA using the Medizym TRAb clone) and with the hTRAK.

RESULTS

At T18, the results were significantly higher by the Cobas assay (median: 2.7 IU/L, range: 1.1-18.5 IU/L) or lower by ELISA (median: 0.56 IU/L, range: 0.22-14.8 IU/L) than those obtained for the hTRAK (median: 1.5 IU/L, range: 0.9-9.8 IU/L). The use of cut-off limits at 1.9 IU/L, 3.2 IU/L and 0.94 IU/L gave similar and higher prevalences of TRAb-positive patients in the group of relapse as compared to the remission group. However, some patients remained misclassified in each remission or relapse group.

CONCLUSIONS

The M22-based TRAb assays did not improve the predictive value of relapse obtained with the hTRAK measured at the end of treatment. High inter-method variability requires assay harmonization for correct interpretation of results.