Biotrickling filter for the removal of volatile sulfur compounds from sewers: A review

Simultaneous removal of ammonia and sulfur odorants in biotrickling filters and N2O production

Research on the stability evaluation of biotrickling filters (BTFs) under harsh conditions and the bacterial adaptation process still needs to be improved. Herein, BTFs with polypropylene plastic (PP) and ceramic raschig rings (CRR) were investigated for a better understanding of the biodegradation of ammonia (NH3), hydrogen sulfide (H2S), and dimethyl sulfide (DMS). The results showed an excellent performance in removal efficiency (RE) for NH3 (91.6 %-99.9 %), H2S (RE: 55.3 %-99.5 %), and DMS (RE: 10.6 %-99.9 %). It was found that a more apparent positive correlation between N2O emission and pressure drop in CRR BTF (R2 = 0.92) than in PP BTF (R2 = 0.79) (P < 0.01). Low temperature promotes an increase in the abundance ofComamonasandBacillus. The polysaccharides in PP and CRR reactors decreased by 78.6 % and 68.1 % when temperature reduced from 25℃ to 8℃. This work provides a novel insight into understanding bacterial survival under harsh BTF environments.

Biofiltration of gaseous mixtures of dimethyl sulfide, dimethyl disulfide and dimethyl trisulfide: Effect of operational conditions and microbial analysis

The efficient removal of volatile sulfur compounds (VSCs), such as dimethyl sulfide (DMS), dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) and dimethyl trisulfide (DMTS), is crucial due to their foul odor and corrosive potential in sewer systems. Biofilters (BFs) offer promise for VSCs removal, but face challenges related to pH control and changing conditions at full scale. Two BFs, operated under acidophilic conditions for 78 days, were evaluated for their performance at varying inlet concentrations and empty bed residence times (EBRTs). BF1, incorporating 4-6 mm marble limestone for pH control, outperformed BF2, which used NaHCO3 in the nutrient solution. BF1 displayed better resilience, maintained a stable pH of 4.6 ± 0.6, and achieved higher maximum elimination capacities (ECmax, 41 mg DMS m-3 h-1 (RE 38.3%), 146 mg DMDS m-3 h-1 (RE 83.1%), 47 mg DMTS m-3 h-1 (RE 93.1%)) at an EBRT of 56 s compared to BF2 (9 mg DMS m-3 h-1 (RE 7.1%), 9 mg DMDS m-3 h-1 (RE 4.8%) and 11 mg DMTS m-3 h-1 (RE 26.6%)). BF2 exhibited pH stratification and decreased performance after feeding interruptions. The biodegradability of VSCs followed the order DMTS > DMDS > DMS, and several microorganisms were identified contributing to VSCs degradation in BF1, including Bacillus (14%), Mycobacterium (11%), Acidiphilium (7%), and Acidobacterium (3%).

Au- ZnFe2O4 hollow microspheres based gas sensor for detecting the mustard gas simulant 2-chloroethyl ethyl sulfide

Mustard gas, a representative of blister agents, poses a severe threat to human health. Although the structure of 2-chloroethyl ethyl sulfide (2-CEES) is similar to mustard gas, 2-CEES is non-toxic, rendering it a commonly employed simulant in related research. ZnFe2O4-based semiconductor gas sensors exhibit numerous advantages, including structural stability, high sensitivities, and easy miniaturization. However, they exhibit insufficient sensitivity at low concentrations and require high operating temperatures. Owing to the effect of electronic and chemical sensitization, the gas-sensing performance of a sensor may be remarkably enhanced via the sensitization method of noble metal loading. In this study, based on the morphologies of ZnFe2O4 hollow microspheres, a solvothermal method was adopted to realize different levels of Au loading. Toward 1 ppm of 2-CEES, the gas sensor based on 2 wt.% Au-loaded ZnFe2O4 hollow microspheres exhibited a response sensitivity twice that of the gas sensor based on pure ZnFe2O4; furthermore, the response/recovery times decreased. Additionally, the sensor displayed excellent linear response to low concentrations of 2-CEES, outstanding selectivity in the presence of several common volatile organic compounds, and good repeatability, as well as long-term stability. The Au-loaded ZnFe2O4-based sensor has considerable potential for use in detecting toxic chemical agents and their simulants.

Food waste anaerobic digestion plants: Underestimated air pollutants and control strategy

Food waste management is an important global issue, and anaerobic digestion (AD) is a sustainable technology for treating food waste and developing a circular economy. Odor and health problems in AD plants have drawn increasing public attention. Therefore, this study investigated the odor characteristics and health risks in different workshops of food waste AD plants. At each site, the treatment capacities for kitchen and restaurant waste were 200 and 200-250 tons per day, respectively. Among the detected odorants, ethanol was the dominant component in terms of concentrations, while methanethiol, propanethiol, H2S, and acetaldehyde were the major odor contributors in different workshops. The odor contribution of propanethiol had been previously overlooked in several workshops. The unloading, pretreatment, and bio-hydrolysis workshops were identified as major areas requiring odor control. Besides odor, carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risks commonly existed in food waste AD plants. The carcinogenic risk of acetaldehyde had been underestimated previously, and it was identified as the dominant carcinogen. Furthermore, benzene was a potential carcinogen. Non-carcinogenic risks were mainly caused by acetaldehyde, H2S, and ethyl acetate. The health risks were not always consistent with odor nuisance. Based on the odor and health risk assessments, several air pollution control strategies for food waste AD plants were proposed, including food waste source control, in-situ pollution control, and ex-situ pollution control.

Regenerative one-stage catalytic absorption process with cupric ions for removal of reduced sulfur compounds in polluted air

Reduced volatile sulfur compounds emitted from e.g. livestock production and biogas production facilities contribute to general air pollution and local odour nuisance. Improved technologies are required to mitigate the emissions of both hydrogen sulfide and organic sulfur compounds. The present study examines the oxidative absorption of reduced sulfur compounds, i.e. hydrogen sulfide, methanethiol and dimethyl sulfide in a wet oxidation process with cupric chloride. It was found that this process efficiently removes both hydrogen sulfide and methanethiol with removal efficiencies >94% under all process conditions tested, while the removal of dimethyl sulfide was in the range 20-40%. The main products determined were dimethyl disulfide, dimethyl trisulfide and elemental sulfur. It was shown that the process was more efficient than the similar process with ferric ions and higher removal could be obtained with lower residence times. Furthermore, though employing cupric ion as metal catalysts results in the production of gaseous sulfur compounds, it is estimated that this process is efficient for deodorization due to the higher odour threshold values of the product compounds and the pH range is optimal for gas streams containing CO2.

Synthetic microbial consortia to enhance the biodegradation of compost odor by biotrickling filter

Composting generates odorous gases, including ammonia (NH3), hydrogen sulfide (H2S), and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). The Biological Trickling Filter (BTF) is effective for odor treatment, but it may have limitations with hydrophobic VOCs. In this study, a strain of Bacillus subtilis with ammonia-reducing ability, a strain of Bacillus cereus with desulfurization ability and a strain of Schizophyllum commune with the ability to degrade dimethyl disulfide were isolated and screened. The three strains were combined to create synthetic microbial consortia for enhancing odor treatment in the BTF. Compared to the activated sludge control, the BTF with synthetic microbial consortia removed 92.43% ammonia, 92.75% hydrogen sulfide. Furthermore, it demonstrated a significant improvement in the removal rates of p-methyl mercaptan, methyl sulfide, and dimethyl disulfide. High-throughput sequencing was conducted on the fillers of the synthetic microbial consortia-inoculated BTF to analyze the microbial community composition.

Insight into the enhancement effect of amino functionalized carbon nanotubes on the H2S removal performance of nanofluid system

By constructing nanofluid system, trace functionalized nanoparticles can significantly enhance the absorption performance of basic liquid. In this work, amino functionalized carbon nanotubes (ACNTs) and carbon nanotubes (CNTs) were introduced into alkaline deep eutectic solvents to build nanofluid systems and used for the dynamic absorption of H2S. The experiment results showed that the introduction of nanoparticles can significantly enhance the H2S removal performance of original liquid. When performing H2S removal experiments, the optimal mass concentrations of ACNTs versus CNTs were 0.05 % and 0.01 %, respectively. The characterization showed that the surface morphology and structure of the nanoparticles unchanged significantly during the absorption-regeneration process. A double mixed gradientless gas-liquid reactor was used to explore the gas-liquid absorption kinetics characteristics of the nanofluid system. It was found that the gas-liquid mass transfer rate increased significantly after the addition of nanoparticles. The highest total mass transfer coefficient of the nanofluid system of ACNTs was increased to more than 400 % of the value before the addition of nanoparticles. The analysis showed that the shuttle effect and hydrodynamic effect of nanoparticles play important role in the process of enhancing gas-liquid absorption, and the amino functionalization enhanced the shuttle effect of nanoparticles significantly.

Hydrogen sulfide control in sewer systems: A critical review of recent progress

In sewer systems where anaerobic conditions are present, sulfate-reducing bacteria reduce sulfate to hydrogen sulfide (H₂S), leading to sewer corrosion and odor emission. Various sulfide/corrosion control strategies have been proposed, demonstrated, and optimized in the past decades. These included (1) chemical addition to sewage to reduce sulfide formation, to remove dissolved sulfide after its formation, or to reduce H₂S emission from sewage to sewer air, (2) ventilation to reduce the H₂S and humidity levels in sewer air, and (3) amendments of pipe materials/surfaces to retard corrosion. This work aims to comprehensively review both the commonly used sulfide control measures and the emerging technologies, and to shed light on their underlying mechanisms. The optimal use of the above-stated strategies is also analyzed and discussed in depth. The key knowledge gaps and major challenges associated with these control strategies are identified and strategies dealing with these gaps and challenges are recommended. Finally, we emphasize a holistic approach to sulfide control by managing sewer networks as an integral part of an urban water system.

Abatement of binary gaseous chlorinated VOC by biotrickling filter: Performance, interactions, and microbial community

The treatment of waste-gas containing chlorinated volatile organic compounds (CVOCs) has become a difficult issue in current air pollution control. Biotrickling filters (BTFs) have been recognized to be applicable for the treatment of CVOCs, but research on the biodegradation of binary gaseous CVOCs is rare. Herein, a BTF inoculated with Methylobacterium (M.) rhodesianum H13, Starkeya sp. T-2 and activated sludge was established to investigate the biodegradation of the gaseous dichloromethane (DCM) and 1,2-dichloroethane (1,2-DCE) and their interactions implicated. The bioaugmented BTF showed a faster startup (13 days), better removal efficiencies of DCM (80%) and 1,2-DCE (72%), and superior mineralization (65.9%) than that inoculated with activated sludge alone. The ECs of DCM and 1,2-DCE were positively related with the inlet load when the total inlet load was <50 g m^-3 h^-1. However, inlet loads higher than 50 g m^-3 h^-1 led to dramatic drop of the RE of DCM and 1,2-DCE due to the limitation of the degradation capacity of microorganisms and the toxic effect of high-concentration substrates. Besides, BTF could stand a lower shock load of 400 mg m^-3, while higher shock loads would deteriorate the RE of DCM and 1,2-DCE. And BTF showed better impact resistance toward DCM than 1,2-DCE, probably because the 1,2-DCE biodegrading bacteria was more sensitive to the concentration change. For the same reason, the removal recovery of DCM after starvation was quicker than 1,2-DCE. Kinetic interactions were quantified by the EC-SKIP model, results of which revealed that DCM cast negative effect on 1,2-DCE biodegradation, while 1,2-DCE could promote DCM biodegradation. Moreover, both the results of real-time PCR and high-throughput sequencing showed M. rhodesianum H13 had stronger competitiveness and adaptability than Starkeya sp. T-2. The survived M. rhodesianum H13 and Starkeya sp. T-2 after starvation robustly demonstrated the success of bioaugmentation as well as its great potential of engineering application.

Superior dimethyl disulfide degradation in a microbial fuel cell: Extracellular electron transfer and hybrid metabolism pathways

To enhance the biological degradation of volatile organic sulfur compounds, a microbial fuel cell (MFC) system with superior activity is developed for dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) degradation. The MFC achieves a removal efficiency near 100% within 6 h (initial concentration: 90 mg L^-1) and a maximum biodegradation rate constant of 0.743 mM h^-1. The DMDS removal load attains 2.684 mmol h^-1 L^-1, which is 6.18-2440 times the loads of conventional biodegradation processes reported. Meanwhile, the maximum power density output and corresponding current density output are 5.40 W m^-3 and 40.6 A m^-3, respectively. The main mechanism of extracellular electron transfer is classified as mediated electron transfer, supplemented by direct transfer. Furthermore, the mass balance analysis indicates that methanethiol, S⁰, S^2-, SO₄^2-, HCHO, and CO₂ are the main intermediate and end products involved in the hybrid metabolism pathway of DMDS. Overall, these findings may offer basic information for bioelectrochemical degradation of DMDS and facilitate the application of MFC in waste gas treatment. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPLICATION: Dimethyl disulfide (DMDS), which features poor solubility, odorous smell, and refractory property, is a typical pollutant emitted from the petrochemical industry. For the first time, we develop an MFC system for DMDS degradation. The superior DMDS removal load per unit reactor volume is 6.18-2440 times those of conventional biodegradation processes in literature. Both the electron transfer route and the hybrid metabolism pathway of DMDS are cleared in this work. Overall, these findings give an in-depth understanding of the bioelectrochemical DMDS degradation mechanism and provide an efficient alternative for DMDS removal.

Performance of bioelectrochemical systems in treating exhaust gas with power generation: Effects of shock-load, shut-down episodes and microbial community

A diffusive packed anode-bioelectrochemical (Dpa-Bes) system was constructed by feeding waste gas from the cathode to the anode tank in DPa-Bes through a proton exchange membrane (PEM). The high removal of oxygen by the PEM and the effective combination of the two packing materials reduced the electron loss and enhanced the proton transfer capacity, promoting the removal of acetone from the exhaust gas and increasing the output power. The maximum acetone removal efficiency of the modified Dpa-Bes reached ∼99 % after seven days of closed-circuit operation, with a 3.2-fold increase in maximum power density and a 2.27-fold increase in closed-circuit voltage relative to those of the unmodified Dpa-Bes. When the acetone concentration was 2400 ppm, the removal efficiency was 73.22 % and the elimination capacity was at its highest value of 290.21 g/m³/h. Microbial analysis revealed that the conductive filter contained abundant facultative and anaerobic bacteria, whereas the non-conductive filter was rich in aerobic bacteria. The abundance of anaerobic and facultative microorganisms in Dpa-Bes was much higher than in the unmodified Dpa-Bes, and the dominant bacteria were Flavobacterium and Ferruginibacter.

Evaluation of bioscrubber and biofilter technologies treating wastewater foul air by a new approach of using odor character, odor intensity, and chemical analyses

The treatment of raw foul air that could escape to the atmosphere from the head space of the incoming wastewater into a Southern California Water Resource Recovery Facility was evaluated by using a 1/20th scale pilot unit consisting of five different biological media technologies, operating side by side, under different operating conditions. The removal of six different odor characters from eight chemical odorants present in the foul air were assessed. These were rotten egg (Hydrogen Sulfide), rotten vegetables (Methyl Mercaptan), canned corn (Dimethyl Sulfide), rotten garlic (Dimethyl Disulfide), earthy/musty (2-Methyl Isoborneol and 2-Isopropyl 3-Methyl Pyrazine) and fecal (Skatole and Indole). This is the first time a study evaluates specific odors by simultaneously employing sensory analyses using the Odor Profile Method, which defines the different odor characters and intensities, together with chemical analyses of the compounds causing these odors, known as odorants. The paper discusses the efficiencies in removing odor characters as well as odorants by two different bioscrubbers (reticulated polyurethane cube foam and polypropylene mesh with layered polyester foam) and three different biofilters (engineered media, seashells, and lava rock). The results show that the two bioscrubbers, even with greater empty bed gas retention times, did not provide significant improvement in odor intensity and odorant removal. However, the biofilters showed that larger empty bed gas retention times provided significant improvements in diminishing the odor intensities and better odorant removal. The biofilter with lava rock media at 45 s empty bed gas retention time provided the best treatment among the technologies tested, achieving the following odorant reductions: 99.8% for hydrogen sulfide, 98.4% for methyl mercaptan, 57.0% for dimethyl sulfide, and 52.7 for dimethyl disulfide. This biofilter also achieved the following odor intensity reductions: 47% for rotten vegetable odors, 50% for earthy/musty odors, and 100% for fecal odors. The odor panel detected odors by the Odor Profile Method that were below the detection limit of the corresponding chemical analytical method for specific chemical compounds causing these odors. Differences were observed between the performances of bioscrubbers and biofilters, based on odorant removal compared to those based on sensorial analyses, indicating that both analyses are required to understand more fully the odor dynamics. Furthermore, a total odor removal of 99.2% was observed by the dilution to threshold olfactometer method even though nearly half of the rotten vegetable and earthy/musty odors remained based upon the Odor Profile Method. This shows the olfactometer method did not correctly define the degree of odor nuisance in the foul air in this study. Bioscrubbers have in general a better economic return when used at low EBGRTs and as preliminary (first stage) treatment systems. Biofilters are more effective when used at high EBGRTs and can be used as stand-alone or polishing systems.

Effects of Water Content and Irrigation of Packing Materials on the Performance of Biofilters and Biotrickling Filters: A Review

Biofilters (BFs) and biotrickling filters (BTFs) are two types of bioreactors used for treatment of volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Both BFs and BTFs use packing materials in which various microorganisms are immobilised. The water phase in BFs is stationary and used to maintain the humidity of packing materials, while BTFs have a mobile liquid phase. Optimisation of irrigation of packing materials is crucial for effective performance of BFs and BTFs. A literature review is presented on the influence of water content of packing materials on the biofiltration efficiency of various pollutants. Different configurations of BFs and BTFs and their influence on moisture distribution in packing materials were discussed. The review also presents various packing materials and their irrigation control strategies applied in recent biofiltration studies. The sources of this review included recent research articles from scientific journals and several review articles discussing BFs and BTFs.

Highly efficient degradation of hydrogen sulfide, styrene, and m-xylene in a bio-trickling filter

Controlling the release of malodorous gas discharged from wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) has become an urgent environmental problem in recent years. In this study, a bio-trickling filter (BTF) inoculated with microorganisms acclimated to activated sludge in a WWTP was used as the degradation equipment. A continuous degradation experiment with hydrogen sulfide, styrene, and m-xylene in the BTF lasted for 84 days (12 weeks). The degradation capacities of the BTF for hydrogen sulfide, styrene, and m-xylene were evaluated, and the synergy and inhibition among the substrates during biodegradation are discussed. The results indicated that the degradation efficiencies of the BTF were as high as 99.2% for hydrogen sulfide, 94.6% for styrene, and 100.0% for m-xylene. When the empty bed residence time was 30 s, the maximum elimination capacities (EC) achieved for hydrogen sulfide was 38 g m^-3 h^-1, for styrene was 200 g m^-3 h^-1, and for m-xylene was 75 g m^-3 h^-1. Furthermore, the microbial species and quantity of microorganisms in the middle and top of the BTF were much higher than those at the bottom of the BTF. A variety of microorganisms in the BTF can efficiently degrade the typical and highly toxic malodorous gases released from WWTPs. This study can help increase the understanding of the degradation of a mixture of sulfur-containing substances and aromatic hydrocarbons in BTF degradation and promote the development of technologies for the reduction of a complex mixture of malodorous gas emissions from organic wastewater treatment.

Hydrogen sulphide management in anaerobic digestion: A critical review on input control, process regulation, and post-treatment

Hydrogen sulphide (H₂S) in biogas is a problematic impurity that can inhibit methanogenesis and cause equipment corrosion. This review discusses technologies to remove H₂S during anaerobic digestion (AD) via: input control, process regulation, and post-treatment. Post-treatment technologies (e.g. biotrickling filters and scrubbers) are mature with >95% removal efficiency but they do not mitigate H₂S toxicity to methanogens within the AD. Input control (i.e. substrate pretreatment via chemical addition) reduces sulphur input into AD via sulphur precipitation. However, available results showed <75% of H₂S removal efficiency. Microaeration to regulate AD condition is a promising alternative for controlling H₂S formation. Microaeration, or the use of oxygen to regulate the redox potential at around -250 mV, has been demonstrated at pilot and full scale with >95% H₂S reduction, stable methane production, and low operational cost. Further adaptation of microaeration relies on a comprehensive design framework and exchange operational experience for eliminating the risk of over-aeration.