Separation of monomeric and dimeric phenolic compounds in lignosulphonate lignin on different stationary phases using ultrahigh-performance supercritical fluid chromatography

Separation of phenylpropionic acids both by strong anion exchange stationary phase and strong cation exchange stationary phase in supercritical fluid chromatography, using the same additive

This study demonstrates the expanded application of ion-exchange stationary phases (including strong cation exchange, SCX and strong anion exchange, SAX) in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), and more importantly, provides a deeper understanding of the retention mechanisms of these two stationary phases when using the same acidic additive. Phenylpropionic acid compounds (belonging to phenolic acids) were selected as probes. On the SCX column, the π-π and polar interactions originating from the bonded benzenesulfonic acid groups were important foundations for prolonging the retention time of solutes, but they were also the main reason for solutes' tailing profiles. It was found that adding 0.1 % phosphoric acid can generate sufficient strength of electrostatic repulsion to obtain satisfactory peak shapes. Here, phosphoric acid can be adsorbed on the surface of the stationary phase to accumulate more negative charges, and at the same time, the phosphate anion and the phenylpropionic acid in mobile phase might combine into the contact ion pair (CIP)- like through the polar interactions to form the apparently negatively charged solute. On the SAX column, phosphate anions generated by ionization of phosphoric acid, were considered as counterions to effectively mask the electrostatic attraction of quaternary ammonium groups, to significantly reduce the retention of phenylpropionic acids, but improve their resolution. Finally, utilizing two developed SFC methods, i.e., SCX with MeOH + 0.1 % phosphoric acid in CO2, or SAX with MeOH + 0.3 % phosphoric acid in CO2, the baseline separation of the extract of Lonicerae Japonicae Flos was achieved within 6 min and 10 min, respectively.

On the fractionation of lignin oligomers by stepwise gradient reversed-phase liquid chromatography

With the increased interest in lignin valorization, the analytical challenge to separate a complex mixture of a vast number of phenolics has made chromatography an indispensable step in lignin analysis. High-resolution separations, such as gas chromatography, reversed-phase liquid chromatography and supercritical fluid chromatography have typically been targeting low-molecular-weight compounds, while larger lignin oligomers have received less attention. These compounds have proven to be difficult to separate due to the inherent complexity of the high-molecular-weight fraction of lignins, in fact, even high-resolving linear reversed-phase gradients elute them as one wide zone. To tackle this, in this study we show that a crude fractionation of lignin oligomers can be achieved by applying stepwise reversed-phase gradients. A commonly employed reversed-phase system with water:acetonitrile mobile phase is evaluated for this task. Special attention was devoted to uncovering the molecular level explanation of the retention phenomenon. Our results indicate that separation is mainly governed by reversed-phase retention phenomena without any major exclusion or viscosity-related effects, shown by great fits to linear retention models (R2avg = 0.9599 for five different oligomers) and apparent differences in retentivity between different stationary phases. The influence of the gradient shape was demonstrated by the comparison of stepwise gradients with different number and frequency of steps, leading to the conclusion that gradients with a low number of steps yield fewer, but better resolved fractions, while finer multi-step gradients can be used to distinguish more fractions.

Examining functional group-dependent effects on the ionization of lignin monomers using supercritical fluid chromatography/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The chemical and biological conversion of biomass-derived lignin is a promising pathway for producing valuable low molecular weight aromatic chemicals, such as vanillin or guaiacol, known as lignin monomers (LMs). Various methods employing chromatography and electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) have been developed for LM analysis, but the impact of LM chemical properties on analytical performance remains unclear. This study systematically optimized ESI efficiency for 24 selected LMs, categorized by functionality. Fractional factorial designs were employed for each LM to assess ESI parameter effects on ionization efficiency using ultra-high-performance supercritical fluid chromatography/ESI-MS (UHPSFC/ESI-MS). Molecular descriptors were also investigated to explain variations in ESI parameter responses and chromatographic retention among the LMs. Structural differences among LMs led to complex optimal ESI settings. Notably, LMs with two methoxy groups benefited from higher gas and sheath gas temperatures, likely due to their lower log P and higher desolvation energy requirements. Similarly, vinyl acids and ketones showed advantages at elevated gas temperatures. The retention in UHPSFC using a diol stationary phase was correlated with the number of hydrogen bond donors. In summary, this study elucidates structural features influencing chromatographic retention and ESI efficiency in LMs. The findings can aid in developing analytical methods for specific technical lignins. However, the absence of an adequate number of LM standards limits the prediction of LM structures solely based on ESI performance data.

A powerful two-dimensional chromatography method for the non-target analysis of depolymerised lignin

BACKGROUND

Lignin is an abundant natural polymer obtained as a by-product from the fractionation of lignocellulosic biomass. In the name of a circular economy, lignin should be valorised into valuable chemicals or biomaterials and utilised instead of petrochemicals. For the development of efficient valorisation processes, the structural characterisation of lignin can be highly beneficial. However, this is an arduous task, as the isolated (and sometimes processed) lignin mainly consists of various neutral monomers but also oligomers. In addition, the material contains isomers, which can be especially problematic to separate and identify.

RESULTS

We present a powerful off-line comprehensive two-dimensional (2D) chromatography method combining liquid chromatography (LC), supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), and high-resolution mass spectrometry for the non-target analysis of depolymerised lignin. The implementation of a 1-aminoanthracene column in the second dimension enabled a class separation of potential lignin monomers, dimers, trimers, and tetramers with an additional separation based on the number of hydroxyl groups and steric effects. The pentafluorophenyl column in the first dimension additionally improved the separation based on hydrophobicity. The comparison of off-line 2D LC × SFC to 1D SFC showed that besides the overall improved performance, the first method is also superior for the separation of isomers. Advanced data analysis methods (MS-DIAL, SIRIUS, and Feature-Based Molecular Network) were integrated into the non-target workflow to rapidly visualise and study the detected compounds, which proved to be especially beneficial for the characterisation of the separated isomers.

SIGNIFICANCE

The method yielded the first 2D LC plot demonstrating a classification of lignin compounds, which can be applied to compare various lignin sources and processing methods. In addition, the technique demonstrated improved separation of compounds, including isomers, which was especially beneficial as 77 % of the detected compounds had at least one isomer in the same lignin sample.

Single-Standard Quantification Strategy for Lignin Dimers by Supercritical Fluid Chromatography with Charged Aerosol Detection

The increased interest in utilizing lignin as a feedstock to produce various aromatic compounds requires advanced chemical analysis methods to provide qualitative and quantitative characterization of lignin samples along different technology streamlines. However, due to the lack of commercially available chemical standards, routine quantification of industrially relevant lignin oligomers in complex lignin samples remains a challenge. This study presents a novel method for universal quantification of lignin dimers based on supercritical fluid chromatography with charged aerosol detection (CAD). A series of lignin-derived dimeric compounds that have been reported from reductive catalytic fractionation (RCF) were synthesized and used as standards. The applicability of using linear regression instead of quadratic calibration curves was evaluated over a concentration range of 15-125 mg/L, demonstrating that the former calibration method is as appropriate as the latter. The response factors of lignin dimeric compounds were compared to assess the uniformity of the CAD signal, revealing that the CAD response for the tested lignin dimers did not differ substantially. It was also found that the response factors were not dependent on the number of methoxy groups or linkage motifs, ultimately enabling the use of only one calibrant for these compounds. The importance of chromatographic peak resolution in CAD was stressed, and the use of a digital peak sharpening technique was adopted and applied to address this challenge. The developed method was verified and used for the quantification of lignin dimers in an oil obtained by a RCF of birch sawdust.