Spinal fusion without instrumentation - Experimental animal study

Effects of nucleotomy on segmental flexibility: A numerical analysis

Nucleotomy, a common treatment for disc herniations, aims to relieve pressure on spinal structures. While effective in alleviating symptoms, this intervention can compromise spinal stability. However, previous in vivo studies in sheep have demonstrated conflicting results with significant long-term stiffening of the spine following nucleotomy, with occasional spontaneous fusion of the affected motion segment. The objective of this study was to investigate the mechanical regulation of tissue adaptation processes post-nucleotomy using computational modeling. A parametric finite element model of the L4-L5 ovine spinal motion segment, developed previously, was modified to simulate surgical procedures that have been performed in prior in vivo studies. An iterative approach was used to simulate post-surgical tissue healing and adaptation processes. Two loading scenarios were simulated: one with combined axial compression and flexion moments, and the other incorporating axial rotation. An initial decrease in stability, with stiffness reduced by up to 50% due to disc decompression and nucleus removal, was followed by a gradual increase in stiffness over time as a consequence of bone healing and remodeling, with the most pronounced stiffening - up to 350% of the intact state - observed in axial rotation. The findings align with previous in vivo observations, suggesting that spontaneous fusion and increased rigidity may be natural consequences of mechano-biological adaptation. The results of this study highlight that healing processes accompanied by adaptive bone remodeling are directed towards restoration of spinal stability after nucleotomy. These findings align with previous in vivo observations, suggesting that spontaneous fusion and increased rigidity may be a natural consequence of post-nucleotomy mechano-biological adaptation. On the other hand, the results indicate a critical role of an appropriate loading regime on the outcome of these processes.

Numerical simulations of bone remodelling and formation following nucleotomy

Nucleotomy is the gold standard treatment for disc herniation and has proven ability to restore stability by creating a bony bridge without any additional fixation. However, the evolution of mineral density in the extant and new bone after nucleotomy and fixation techniques has to date not been investigated in detail. The main goal of this study is to determine possible mechanisms that may trigger the bone remodelling and formation processes. With that purpose, a finite element model of the L4-L5 spinal segment was used. Bone mineral density (BMD), new tissue composition, and endplate deflection were determined as indicators of lumbar fusion. A bone-remodelling algorithm and a tissue-healing algorithm, both mechanically driven, were implemented to predict vertebral bone alterations and fusion patterns after nucleotomy, internal fixation, and anterior plate placement. When considering an intact disc height, neither nucleotomy nor internal fixation were able to provide the necessary stability to promote bony fusion. However, when 75% of the disc height was considered, bone fusion was predicted for both techniques. By contrast, an anterior plate allowed bone fusion at all disc heights. A 50% disc-height reduction led to osteophyte formation in all cases. Changes in the intervertebral disc tissue caused BMD alterations in the endplates. From this observations it can be drawn that fusion may be self-induced by controlling the mechanical stabilisation without the need of additional fixation. The amount of tissue to be removed to achieve this stabilisation remains to be determined.

Is the sheep a suitable model to study the mechanical alterations of disc degeneration in humans? A probabilistic finite element model study

Intervertebral disc degeneration is one major source of low back pain, which because of its complex multifactorial nature renders the treatment challenging and thus necessitates extensive research. Experimental animal models have proven valuable in improving our understanding of degenerative processes and potentially promising therapies. Currently, the sheep is the most frequently used large animal in vivo model in intervertebral disc research. However, despite its undoubted value for investigations of the complex biological and cellular aspects, to date, it is unclear whether the sheep is also suited to study the mechanical aspects of disc degeneration in humans. A parametric finite element (FE) model of the L4-5 spinal motion segment was developed. Using this model, the geometry and the material properties of both the human and the ovine spinal segment as well as different appearances of disc degeneration can be depicted. Under pure and combined loads, it was investigated whether degenerative changes to both the human and the ovine model equivalent caused the same mechanical response. Different patterns of degeneration resulted in large variations in the ranges of motion, intradiscal pressure, ligament and facet loads. In the human, but not in the ovine model, all these results differed significantly between different degrees of degeneration. This FE model study highlighted possible differences in the mechanical response to disc degeneration between human and ovine intervertebral discs and indicates the necessity of further, more detailed, investigations.

Effects of Level, Loading Rate, Injury and Repair on Biomechanical Response of Ovine Cervical Intervertebral Discs

A need exists for pre-clinical large animal models of the spine to translate biomaterials capable of repairing intervertebral disc (IVD) defects. This study characterized the effects of cervical spinal level, loading rate, injury and repair with genipin-crosslinked fibrin (FibGen) on axial and torsional mechanics in an ovine cervical spine model. Cervical IVDs C2-C7 from nine animals were tested with cyclic tension-compression (- 240 to 100 N) and cyclic torsion (± 2° and ± 4°) tests at three rates (0.1, 1 and 2 Hz) in intact, injured and repaired conditions. Intact IVDs from upper cervical levels (C2-C4) had significantly higher torque range and torsional stiffness and significantly lower axial range of motion (ROM) and tensile compliance than IVDs from lower cervical levels (C5-C7). A tenfold increase in loading rate significantly increased torque range and torsional stiffness 4-8% (depending on amplitude) (p < 0.001). When normalized to intact, FibGen significantly restored torque range (FibGen: 0.96 ± 0.14, Injury: 0.88 ± 0.14, p = 0.03) and axial ROM (FibGen: 1.00 ± 0.05, Injury: 1.04 ± 0.15, p = 0.02) compared to Injury, with a values of 1 indicating full repair. Cervical spinal level must be considered for controlling biomechanical evaluations, and FibGen restored some torsional and axial biomechanical properties to intact levels.