Comparison of microscopic and endoscopic resection of third-ventricular colloid cysts: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Tailored Callosotomy in Third Ventricle Colloid Cyst Resection via Anterior Interhemispheric Transcallosal Approach

BACKGROUND

The colloid cyst represents a relatively uncommon intracranial lesion. It garners significant attention from neurosurgeons due to its benign nature, deep-seated location, and promising prognosis when identified early and surgically removed. A variety of surgical methods are used to treat these cysts, each with their strengths and weaknesses. The aim of this study is to introduce and assess a precise microsurgical technique for managing colloid cysts using the anterior interhemispheric transcallosal approach.

METHODS

The research involved a retrospective analysis of 14 cases between 2021 and 2023 treated with the anterior interhemispheric transcallosal approach by 2 experienced skull base surgeons. The evaluation encompassed demographic, clinical, radiological, histological, and surgical data. Additionally, the colloid cyst risk score was used to assess the risk of obstructive hydrocephalus. The procedure incorporated neuronavigation and ultrasound to determine the precise entry point and to plan the trajectory.

RESULTS

The minimally invasive microsurgical technique was effectively employed in all 14 cases, with no reported postoperative complications. Postsurgery magnetic resonance imaging scans confirmed complete cyst removal, with an average callosotomy measurement of 5.4 ± 2.5 mm. Importantly, none of the patients experienced disconnection syndrome associated with callosotomy.

CONCLUSIONS

The adapted microsurgical approach via the anterior interhemispheric transcallosal method emerges as a secure and efficient way to address colloid cysts. It ensures comprehensive cyst removal while minimizing complications, boasting advantages such as reduced invasiveness, enhanced visibility, and minimal tissue disturbance, thereby confirming its role in colloid cyst surgical interventions.

Recurrence After Microsurgical Excision of Third Ventricular Colloid Cysts in a Contemporary Cohort of 84 Patients

OBJECTIVE

To examine recurrence rates in patients undergoing microsurgical excision of colloid cysts of the third ventricle with long-term serial clinical and imaging follow-up and to identify risk factors for cyst recurrence.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, we analyzed a single-surgeon cohort of 84 patients who underwent microsurgical excision of a third ventricular colloid cyst between 1994 and 2018 and who were followed for at least 12 months after surgery. The primary outcome of interest was recurrence (asymptomatic and symptomatic).

RESULTS

The mean age at surgery was 33.8 years (range, 8-65 years). Of 84 patients, 82 (97.6%) were symptomatic and 71 (84.5%) had obstructive hydrocephalus. The mean tumor size was 15.2 mm (range, 7-35 mm). A total or near-total excision was achieved in 76 patients (90.5%). The median clinical follow-up duration was 89.5 months (range, 12-340 months). A total of 81 (96.4%) had follow-up imaging. Overall, recurrence occurred in 25 cases (29.8%), with 7 (8.3%) experiencing symptomatic recurrence. No specific risk factors for recurrence were identified. Longer follow-up was associated with a higher detection of recurrences. The 5-year recurrence free survival rate was 81.6%, which dropped to 66.5% at 10-year follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Periodic imaging surveillance is essential after excision of third ventricular colloid cysts to detect asymptomatic recurrences because these lesions may recur several years after presumed total or near-total excision. Recurrences associated with clinical symptoms or demonstrated growth on serial follow-up require intervention; however, reoperation may be cautiously deferred in patients with stable asymptomatic recurrences.

Neurocognitive Safety of Endoscopic Colloid Cyst Resection: Paired Pre- and Post-Operative Cognitive Function from an Exploratory Cohort

OBJECTIVE

Resection of colloid cysts, a rare third ventricle pathology, is accepted clinical practice. Owing to their location proximal to deep gray nuclei and forniceal columns, colloid cysts have been theorized to contribute to cognitive decline. Comprehensive pre- and post-operative cognitive testing, however, has rarely been implemented.

METHODS

We analyzed formal neuropsychological testing performed in 20 patients undergoing endoscopic cyst resection. Pre- and post-operative performance was compared either for each individual patient or according to aggregated neuropsychological factor scores grouped via expert census. A change in performance was deemed significant if (i) it reached statistical significance and (ii) was greater than 1.5 pre-operative standard deviations.

RESULTS

Twenty patients with colloid cysts (average diameter 13.3 ± 1.3 mm) underwent matched pre- and post-operative testing. No patient had a significant change in cognitive performance. Neurocognitive metrics assessing cognitive functions typically subsumed by the temporal (p = 0.35), extratemporal (p = 0.20), occipitoparietal (p = 0.31), or frontal lobes (p = 0.11) did not change post-operatively. Similarly, no differences emerged when factor scores were generated according to composite scores of different neurocognitive domains: attention (p = 0.32), executive function (p = 0.14), language (p = 0.98), and visuospatial function (p = 0.42).

CONCLUSIONS

Neuropsychological testing allows for the careful monitoring of cognitive status before and after surgery and for the identification of patients who may benefit from pre- and post-operative cognitive rehabilitation. It should also be used as a valuable surgical psychometric marker and adjuvant. No significant cognitive decline was observed in this cohort.

Interhemispheric Transcallosal Resection of Large Colloid Cyst Through Nondilated Foramen with Use of Microblade Retractor: 2-Dimensional Operative Video

Patients who present with a large colloid cyst (CC) and nondilated ventricles represent a therapeutic challenge.1-3 Although transcallosal approaches provide reliable access to the lateral ventricle and foramen of Monro, direct visualization of the vascular attachment of the CC to the roof of the third ventricle is not always possible. This can be especially true with CCs located more posteriorly and superiorly.4 Opening of the choroidal fissure can improve access and visualization to the posterior third ventricle; however, this maneuver is associated with some element of risk.5 There is a paucity of operative video in the literature illustrating the technique of gentle, microblade elevation of the fornix to improve visualization into the third ventricle and, on occasion, avoid the need to open the choroidal fissure.6 We report the case of a 28-year-old woman who presented with headaches and progressive short-term memory dysfunction (Video 1). Magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated a 17-mm CC associated with distortion and thinning of the bilateral fornices without hydrocephalus. The patient was offered interhemispheric, transcallosal resection. Intraoperatively, gentle elevation of the fornix with a microblade retractor facilitated access to the vascular attachment of the colloid cyst-obviating the need to open the choroidal fissure. The index operative video discusses the technical nuances associated with trans-callosal resection of CC with use of the microblade retractor. Special emphasis is placed on the intricate relationship of neighboring anatomic structures. The patient consented to the procedure and the publication of her image.

Endoscopic ultrasonic aspirator-assisted removal of a third ventricular colloid cyst

BACKGROUND

Colloid cysts are benign tumors usually located on the roof of the third ventricle. Cyst removal is the treatment of choice. It can be accomplished microsurgically through a transcortical- or transcallosal approach, or endoscopically. There is a lack of consensus regarding the best strategy for cyst removal. One of the challenges of the traditional endoscopic technique is dealing with the cyst content density. Hyperdensity on computed tomography scan and low signal on T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) cyst are correlated with high viscosity cystic content.

CASE REPORTS

We present a case of a colloid cyst of the third ventricle in a 15-year-old boy removed through a pure endoscopic transventricular approach. The cyst presented a low signal on T2 MRI; nevertheless, it was easily removed with the help of an endoscopic ultrasonic aspirator.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

The colloid cyst of the third ventricle can be safely treated by a purely endoscopic approach. The rationale of the use of the ultrasonic aspirator relies on the facilitation of aspiration of the content even when the consistency is extremely firm.

Isolated entrapment of the lateral ventricle after neuroendoscopic resection of colloid cysts: single - center experience and management

BACKGROUND

A minimally invasive option of colloid cyst surgical treatment is endoscopic resection, well validated in various reports and clinical practice. A rare complication of the surgical treatment, previously reported only once in literature, is the entrapment of the lateral ventricle. In this study we aim to outline our experience in the management of this occurrence, hypothesizing possible etiopathogenetic causes.

METHODS

Among patients who underwent neuroendoscopic resection for a colloid cysts at our Institution between 2013 and 2022, cases who developed a postoperative lateral ventricle entrapment were retrospectively reviewed and included. Clinical history, imaging and treatment were reported.

RESULTS

Among 34 patients treated for a colloid cysts, two (5.9 %) patients developed an ipsilateral ventricular entrapment with dilation from two to five months after the resection. Both patients were substantially asymptomatic and neurologically intact, and therefore treated conservatively. One case underwent complete spontaneous radiological resolution one month later, and the other one has remained neurological asymptomatic at follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Isolated asymptomatic ventricular entrapment with significant dilation after endoscopic colloid cyst resection is a rare occurrence which can be plausibly caused by scar tissue at the level of the foramen of Monro. Because they can have an indolent course with spontaneous resolution, conservative treatment is a viable option, with strict radiological and clinical follow - up. Given the rarity of the occurrence, further studies with larger cohorts are warranted to confirm the etiopathogenetic hypothesis and validate the clinical management.

Intracranial Neuroendoscopy in Children and Adults: Where Do the Differences Lie?

BACKGROUND

Intraventricular neuroendoscopy has evolved into an essential adjunct in neurosurgery and is used across all age groups for various indications. However, studies comparing neuroendoscopic procedures between children and adults are scarce. The aim of this study is to compare various aspects between adults and children undergoing neuroendoscopy.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the data from consecutive patients dichotomized into 2 cohorts, pediatric (age <18 years) and adult (age ≥18 years) groups, in whom intracranial neuroendoscopy was performed between 2013 and 2020 (pediatric group) and 2010 and 2020 (adult group).

RESULTS

Of 132 patients who underwent intracranial neuroendoscopic surgery, 47 (35.6%) were children and 85 (64.4%) were adults. The most common indications for the children and adults were intraventricular or paraventricular tumors (23.4%) and aqueduct stenosis (40%), respectively. Their clinical condition at the last follow-up was unchanged or improved for 90.5% of the children and 92.1% of the adults. An increased endoscopic third ventriculostomy success score was predictive of endoscopic third ventriculostomy success in the pediatric cohort (odds ratio, 1.073; P = 0.043). The postoperative rates of transient (pediatric, 23.4%; adult, 18.8%) and permanent (pediatric, 0%; adult, 1.2%) complications were comparable. The rate of secondary surgery was higher for the pediatric cohort (38.3%) than for the adult cohort (17.6%).

CONCLUSIONS

The indications for neuroendoscopy vary between adults and children, although the long-term clinical outcome is comparable. The rate of secondary surgery is significantly higher for pediatric patients, especially for those aged <1 year. Because neuroendoscopy is considerably more frequent in pediatric patients, including pediatric neurosurgeons in adult neuroendoscopic cases could potentially help lower the complication rates and increase the success rates.

Endoscopic versus Microsurgical Resection of Third Ventricle Colloid Cysts: A Single-Center Case Series of 140 Consecutive Patients

BACKGROUND

Both endoscopic and microsurgery transcortical resection methods are used for colloid cysts of the third ventricle but they have not been compared regarding benefits and pitfalls.

METHODS

Data of patients who underwent surgical resection of third ventricle colloid cyst via either endoscopic or microsurgery approach by a single surgeon from 2005 to 2020 were retrospectively collected. After administration of criteria, 140 records were retrieved (60 patients through endoscopic resection and 80 patients by a transcranial microsurgery approach). Clinical and surgical measures were compared between the 2 types of surgery after adjustment for confounders.

RESULTS

Length of hospital stay, postoperative meningitis, operation time, cyst size, and baseline comorbidities were similar between two groups. Gross total resection (GTR) was achieved for all patients in the microsurgery group, whereas in the endoscopic group, resection was lower (90% vs. 100%; P = 0.005). Intraoperative hemorrhage occurred in 14 endoscopic patients (23.3%), whereas for the microscopic group, it was zero (P < 0.001). Postoperative shunt was required for 2 patients (one in the endoscopic group and the other in the microscopic group). Two patients had tumor recurrence, both of whom were in the endoscopic group. No mortality was detected in either group. Multivariate analyses were insignificant for confounding effects of clinical and demographic factors in occurrence of worse surgical outcomes (non-GTR and hemorrhage).

CONCLUSIONS

In our series, the rate of intraoperative hemorrhage was higher with the endoscopic method and GTR was lower, even after adjustment for other factors. This situation could be caused by technological shortcomings and limited space for resection maneuvers and management of complications.

Endoscopic resection of a giant colloid cyst in the velum interpositum: illustrative case

BACKGROUND

Colloid cysts are an unusual differential diagnosis for lesions in the lateral ventricles. Microsurgery is usually recommended for the treatment of giant colloid cysts. This case is the largest reported colloid cyst in this unusual location treated with an endoscope.

OBSERVATIONS

A 39-year-old woman with a history of pulsing headaches presented with nausea, vomiting, vision blurring, and paresthesia of the left leg. On the brain computed tomography, a huge, well-defined homogeneous hyperdense intraventricular lesion with hydrocephalus was observed. Magnetic resonance imaging showed a spherical lesion over the third ventricle inside the lateral ventricles, obstructing the Sylvius aqueduct. There was no enhancement and no diffusion restriction on diffusion-weighted images. Endoscopic third ventriculostomy was undertaken for hydrocephalus treatment. Then the lesion was resected grossly. The cyst wall was resected as much as it was safe. There was no clot or bloody product inside the lesion.

LESSONS

Colloid cyst is rarely encountered in the velum interpositum and lateral ventricles, but the authors' giant colloid cyst case along with similar cases led to considering it out of the third ventricle. According to their experience, endoscopic removal is a safe and efficient method for colloid cyst surgery, even in giant cases.

Resection of brain lesions with a neuroendoscopic ultrasonic aspirator - a systematic literature review

The development of minimally invasive neuroendoscopy has advanced in recent years. The introduction of the neuroendoscopic ultrasonic aspirator (NUA) increased the treatment spectrum of neuroendoscopy. This review aimed to present a systematic overview of the extent of resection, lesion characteristics, technical aspects, complications, and clinical outcomes related to using the NUA. Articles were identified by searching the PubMed/Medline, Embase, and Web of Science database through June 2022 with restriction to the last 20 years. We included case series, case reports, clinical trials, controlled clinical trials, meta-analyses, randomized controlled trials, reviews, and systematic reviews written in English. Studies reporting on endonasal approach or hematoma evacuation using the NUA were excluded. The references of the identified studies were reviewed as well. Nine full-text articles were included in the analysis, with a total of 40 patients who underwent surgery for a brain tumor using NUA. The most common underlying pathology treated by NUA was colloid cyst (17.5%), pilocytic astrocytoma (12.5%), subependymal giant cell astrocytoma (7.5%), subependymoma (7.5%), and craniopharyngioma (7.5%). Complete or near-total resection was achieved in 62.5%. The most frequently reported postoperative complication was secondary hydrocephalus (10%), meningitis/-encephalitis (7.5%), cognitive impairment (7.5%), and subdural hygroma (7.5%). In one case (2.5%), surgery-related death occurred due to a severe course of meningoencephalitis. According to the preliminary data, NUA seems to be a safe and efficient minimally invasive alternative to conventional microscopic resection of brain tumors. Further studies to investigate advantages and disadvantages of using the NUA are needed.