The correspondence between quantum and classical mechanics: an experimental demonstration of the smooth transition between the two regimes

Proton tunnelling in the hydrogen bonds of the benzoic acid dimer: (18)O substitution and isotope effects of the heavy atom framework

Field-cycling (1)H NMR relaxometry has been used to measure the rate of concerted double proton transfer in the hydrogen bonds of (16)O and (18)O isotopologues of benzoic acid dimers. The experiments have been conducted in the solid state at low temperature 13.3 ≤ T ≤ 80 K where the dynamics are dominated by incoherent proton tunnelling. The low temperature tunnelling rate in the (16)O isotopologue is observed to be approximately 15% faster than in the (18)O isotopologue. The difference is attributed to an isotope effect of the heavy atom framework of the benzoic acid dimer resulting from displacements of the oxygen atoms that accompany the proton transfer. Sources of systematic uncertainty have been minimized in the design of the experimental protocols and the experiments are critically appraised in formally assigning the measured differences to an effect of mass on the tunnelling dynamics.

1H-19F spin-lattice relaxation spectroscopy: proton tunnelling in the hydrogen bond studied by field-cycling NMR

Proton tunnelling in the hydrogen bonds of two fluorine substituted benzoic acid dimers has been investigated using field-cycling NMR relaxometry. The close proximity of the (19)F nuclei to the hydrogen bond protons introduces heteronuclear (19)F-(1)H dipolar interactions into the spin-lattice relaxation processes. This renders the (1)H magnetisation-recovery biexponential and introduces multiple spectral density components into the relaxation matrix characterised by frequencies that are sums and differences of the (19)F and (1)H Larmor frequencies. Using field-cycling NMR pulse sequences that measure the spin-lattice relaxation and cross-relaxation rates we demonstrate how some of these multiple spectral density components can be separately resolved. This leads to an accurate determination of the correlation times that characterise the proton tunnelling motion. A broad spectrum of relaxation behaviour is illustrated and explored in the chosen samples and the investigation is used to explore the theory and practise of field-cycling NMR relaxometry in cases where heteronuclear interactions are significant.

Field-cycling NMR investigations of (13)C-(1)H cross-relaxation and cross-polarisation: the nuclear solid effect and dynamic nuclear polarisation

A field-cycling NMR investigation of (1)H-(13)C polarisation transfer using cross-relaxation and the nuclear solid effect (NSE) is described. Dynamic nuclear polarisation (DNP) of the (13)C spins is observed when forbidden transitions are driven by r.f. irradiation at the sum and difference Larmor frequencies of the two nuclei. When the (1)H spins are pre-polarised, a significant transfer of polarisation to the (13)C nuclei is achieved in a time short compared with the spin-lattice relaxation time of (13)C. The cross-polarisation arising from the NSE is studied as a function of B-field and time. These results are compared with the solutions of the differential equations that govern the coupled system of (1)H-(13)C spins. The effects of cross-relaxation are incorporated into the model for the first time and good agreement between theory and experiment is obtained. The experiments have been conducted at 20K on a (13)C-enriched sample of benzoic acid.

Complex methyl group and hydrogen-bonded proton motions in terms of the Arrhenius and Schrödinger equations

Equations for the temperature dependence of the spectral densities J(is)(m)(momega(I) +/-omega(T)), where m=1, 2, omega(I) and omega(T) are the resonance and tunnel splitting angular frequencies, in the presence of a complex motion, have been derived. The spin pairs of the protons or deuterons of the methyl group perform a complex motion consisting of three component motions. Two of them involve mass transportation over the barrier and through the barrier. They are characterized by k((H)) (Arrhenius) and k((T)) (Schrödinger) rate constants, respectively. The third motion causes fluctuations of the frequencies (nomega(I)+/-omega(T)) and it is related to the lifetime of the methyl spin at the energy level influenced by the rotor-bath interactions. These interactions induce rapid transitions, changing the symmetry of the torsional sublevels either from A to E or from E(a) to E(b). The correlation function for this third motion (k((omega)) rate constant) has been proposed by Müller-Warmuth et al. The spectral densities of the methyl group hindered rotation (k((H)), k((T)) and k((omega)) rate constants) differ from the spectral densities of the proton transfer (k((H)) and k((T)) rate constants) because three compound motions contribute to the complex motion of the methyl group. The recently derived equation [Formula: see text] , where [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] are the fraction and energy of particles with energies from zero to E(H), is taken into account in the calculations of the spectral densities. This equation follows from Maxwell's distribution of thermal energy. The spectral densities derived are applied to analyse the experimental temperature dependencies of proton and deuteron spin-lattice relaxation rate in solids containing the methyl group. A wide range of temperatures from zero Kelvin up to the melting point is considered. It has been established that the motion characterized by k((omega)) influences the spin-lattice relaxation up to the temperature T(tun) only. This temperature is directly determined by the equation C(p)T=E(H) (thermal energy=activation energy), where C(p) is the molar heat capacity. Probably the cessation of the third motion is a result of the de Broglie wavelength related to this motion becoming too short. As shown recently, the potential barrier can be an obstacle for the de Broglie wave. The theoretical equations derived in this paper are compared to those known in the literature.

Application of Schrödinger Equation to Study the Tunnelling Dynamics of Proton Transfer in the Hydrogen Bond of 2,5-Dinitrobenzoic Acid: Proton T1, T1ρ, and Deuteron T1 Relaxation Methods

Temperature measurements of proton T1 (24.7 MHz), deuteron (deuterated hydroxyl group) T1 (55.2 MHz), and proton T1(rho) (B1 = 9 G) spin-lattice relaxation times of 2,5-dinitrobenzoic acid have been performed. An analysis of present experimental data together with previously published proton T1 (55.2 MHz) data has revealed the following molecular motions: proton/deuteron transfer in the hydrogen bond and two-site hopping of the whole dimer. It is shown that the proton-transfer dynamics are characterized by two correlation times tau(ov) and tau(tu), describing two fundamentally different motional processes, namely, thermally activated jumps over the barrier and tunneling through the barrier. The temperature dependence of 1/tau(tu) is the solution of Schrödinger's equation, which also yields the temperature T(tun), where begins the tunnel pathway for proton transfer. A new equation for the spectral density function of complex motion consisting of the three motions is derived. The third motion (two-site hopping of the whole dimer characterized by tau(lib) correlation time) is responsible for a proton T1(rho) minimum in high temperatures, just below the melting point. Such a minimum is not reached by T1 temperature dependencies. The minimum of T1(rho) assigned to the classical hopping of a hydrogen-bonded proton occurs in the same low-temperature regime in which the flattening of the temperature dependencies of T1 points to the dominance of incoherent tunneling. This experimental fact denies the known theories predicting the intermediate temperature regime where a smooth transition between classical and quantum tunneling dynamics is expected. The fit of the derived theoretical equations to the experimental data T1(rho) and T1 is satisfactory. The correlation times obtained for deuterons indicate deuteron-transfer dynamics much slower than proton-transfer dynamics. It is concluded that the classical proton transfer takes place over the whole temperature regime, while the incoherent tunneling occurs below 46.5 (hydrogen) or 87.2 K (deuterium) only.

Proton tunneling in a hydrogen bond measured by cross-relaxation field-cycling NMR

A field-cycling NMR pulse sequence is described for studying cross-relaxation between unlike nuclear spins in the solid state. The technique has been applied to study proton tunneling in the hydrogen bonds of a carboxylic acid containing 19F and 1H spins. By studying the B-field dependence of the off-diagonal element of the relaxation matrix that characterizes the longitudinal polarizations, an accurate measure of the proton transfer rate is obtained.

A 13C field-cycling NMR relaxometry investigation of proton tunnelling in the hydrogen bond: dynamic isotope effects, the influence of heteronuclear interactions and coupled relaxation

Concerted double proton transfer in the hydrogen bonds of a carboxylic acid dimer has been studied using 13C field-cycling NMR relaxometry. Heteronuclear 13C-1H dipolar interactions dominate the 13C spin-lattice relaxation which is significantly influenced by the polarisation state of the 1H Zeeman reservoir. The methodology of field-cycling experiments for such heteronuclear spin-coupled systems is studied experimentally and theoretically, including an investigation of various saturation-recovery and polarisation-recovery pulse sequence schemes. A theoretical model of the spin-lattice relaxation of this coupled system is presented which is corroborated by experiment. Spectral density components with frequencies omega(C), omega(C) + omega(H), and omega(C) - omega(H) are mapped out experimentally from the magnetic field dependence of the 13C and 1H spin-lattice relaxation and the proton transfer rate at low temperature is determined from their widths. Any dynamic isotope effect on the proton tunnelling in the hydrogen bond arising from 13C enrichment in the skeletal framework of the dimer is found to be smaller than experimental uncertainties (approximately 5%).