Mitochondria: A Microcosm of Darwinian Competition

The prevalence of dementia in humans could be the result of a functional adaptation

In this paper we propose that high copy number of the mitochondrial genome in neurons is a functional adaptation. We simulated the proliferation of deletion mutants of the human mitochondrial genome in a virtual mitochondrion and recorded the cell loss rates due to deletions overwhelming the wild-type. Our results showed that cell loss increased with mtDNA copy number. Given that neuron loss equates to cognitive dysfunction, it would seem counterintuitive that there would be a selective pressure for high copy number over low. However, for a low copy number, the onset of cognitive decline, while mild, started early in life. Whereas, for high copy number, it did not start until middle age but progressed rapidly. There could have been an advantage to high copy number in the brain if it delayed the onset of cognitive decline until after reproductive age. The prevalence of dementia in our aged population is a consequence of this functional adaptation.

A comparison of mtDNA deletion mutant proliferation mechanisms

In this paper we use simulation methods to investigate the proliferation of deletion mutations of mitochondrial DNA in neurons. We simulate three mtDNA proliferation mechanisms, namely, random drift, replicative advantage and vicious cycle. For each mechanism, we investigated the effect mutation rates have on neuron loss within a human host. We also compare heteroplasmy of each mechanism at mutation rates that yield the levels neuron loss that would be associated with dementia. Both random drift and vicious cycle predicted high levels of heteroplasmy, while replicative advantage showed a small number of dominant clones with a low background of heteroplasmy.