Incomplete immunity in a natural animal-microbiota interaction selects for higher pathogen virulence

Within-host competition causes pathogen molecular evolution and perpetual microbiota dysbiosis

Pathogens newly invading a host must compete with resident microbiota. This within-host microbial warfare could lead to more severe disease outcomes or constrain the evolution of virulence. By passaging a widespread pathogen (Staphylococcus aureus) and a natural microbiota community across populations of nematode hosts, we show that the pathogen displaced microbiota and reduced species richness, but maintained its virulence across generations. Conversely, pathogen populations and microbiota passaged in isolation caused more host harm relative to their respective no-host controls. For the evolved pathogens, this increase in virulence was partly mediated by enhanced biofilm formation and expression of the global virulence regulator agr. Whole genome sequencing revealed shifts in the mode of selection from directional (on pathogens evolving in isolation) to fluctuating (on pathogens evolving in host microbiota). This approach also revealed that competitive interactions with the microbiota drove early pathogen genomic diversification. Metagenome sequencing of the passaged microbiota shows that evolution in pathogen-infected hosts caused a significant reduction in community stability (dysbiosis), along with restrictions on the co-existence of some species based on nutrient competition. Our study reveals how microbial competition during novel infection could determine the patterns and processes of evolution with major consequences for host health.

'Re-Wilding' an Animal Model With Microbiota Shifts Immunity and Stress Gene Expression During Infection

The frequency of emerging disease is growing with ongoing human activity facilitating new host-pathogen interactions. Novel infection outcomes can also be shaped by the host microbiota. Caenorhabditis elegans nematodes experimentally colonised by a wild microbiota community and infected by the widespread animal pathogen, Staphylococcus aureus, have been shown to suffer higher mortality than those infected by the pathogen alone. Understanding the host responses to such microbiota-pathogen ecological interactions is key to pinpointing the mechanism underlying severe infection outcomes. We conducted transcriptomic analyses of C. elegans colonised by its native microbiota, S. aureus and both in combination. Correlations between altered collagen gene expression and heightened mortality in co-colonised hosts suggest the microbiota modified host resistance to infection. Furthermore, microbiota colonised hosts showed increased expression of immunity genes and variable expression of stress response genes during infection. Changes in host immunity and stress response could encompass both causes and effects of severe infection outcomes. 'Re-wilding' this model nematode host with its native microbiota indicated that typically commensal microbes can mediate molecular changes in the host that are costly when challenged by a novel emerging pathogen.

Defense Heterogeneity in Host Populations Gives Rise to Pathogen Diversity

AbstractHost organisms can harbor microbial symbionts that defend them from pathogen infection in addition to the resistance encoded by the host genome. Here, we investigated how variation in defenses, generated from host genetic background and symbiont presence, affects the emergence of pathogen genetic diversity across evolutionary time. We passaged the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa through populations of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans varying in genetic-based defenses and prevalence of a protective symbiont. After 14 passages, we assessed the amount of genetic variation accumulated in evolved pathogen lineages. We found that diversity begets diversity. An overall greater level of pathogen whole-genome and per-gene genetic diversity was measured in pathogens evolved in mixed host populations compared with those evolved in host populations composed of one type of defense. Our findings directly demonstrate that symbiont-generated heterogeneity in host defense can be a significant contributor to pathogen genetic variation.

Pathogen evolution: Protective microbes act as a double-edged sword

Vaccines and infection can sometimes cause incomplete immunity, which allows for pathogen re-infection with decreased disease severity but also contributes to the evolution of pathogen virulence. A new study demonstrates that incomplete immunity from resident protective microbes results in similar evolutionary trajectories.