The Current Status of Xenotransplantation

Somatic cell nuclear transfer in pigs: recent achievements and future possibilities

During the past 6 years, considerable advancement has been achieved in experimental embryology of pigs. This process was mainly generated by the rapidly increasing need for transgenic pigs for biomedical research purposes, both for future xenotransplantation to replace damaged human organs or tissues, and for creating authentic animal models for human diseases to study aetiology, pathogenesis and possible therapy. Theoretically, among various possibilities, an established somatic cell nuclear transfer system with genetically engineered donor cells seems to be an efficient and reliable approach to achieve this goal. However, as the result of unfortunate coincidence of known and unknown factors, porcine embryology had been a handicapped branch of reproductive research in domestic animals and a very intensive and focused research was required to eliminate or minimise this handicap. This review summarises recent achievements both in the background technologies (maturation, activation, embryo culture) and the actual performance of the nuclear replacement. Recent simplified methods for in vivo development after embryo transfer are also discussed. Finally, several fields of potential application for human medical purposes are discussed. The authors conclude that although in this early phase of research no direct evidence can be provided about the practical use of transgenic pigs produced by somatic cell nuclear transfer as organ donors or disease models, the future chances even in medium term are good, and at least proportional with the efforts and sums that are invested into this research area worldwide.

Lack of evidence for PERV expression after apoptosis-mediated horizontal gene transfer between porcine and human cells

Evidence for porcine endogenous retrovirus (PERV) infection of human cells has provoked a public health debate over the proposed use of porcine xenografts to alleviate the worldwide shortage of human allografts. Nevertheless, the potential relevance of PERV transmission by apoptosis-mediated horizontal DNA transfer, a documented means of infection-independent retrovirus delivery, appears to have been overlooked in this discussion. To examine the hypothesis that apoptotic cell death during porcine xenograft rejection is capable of fostering horizontal DNA transfer, we have now assessed in vitro cocultures, consisting of phagocytic human fibroblasts and apoptotic or necrotic porcine B-lymphoblastoid cells, for evidence of cross-species PERV exchange and eventual replication. Using real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays, designed to differentiate nuclear and cytoplasmic DNA derived from either porcine or human cells, we now report evidence for the presence of porcine DNA, including PERV, in the nucleus of human fibroblasts exposed to apoptotic porcine cells. This novel demonstration of apoptosis-mediated horizontal PERV transfer is characterized by a low efficiency of transfer and a transient nature, being present in only 0.22% of the cocultured human cells and disappearing to undetectable levels within 4 weeks of exposure to apoptotic porcine cells. In contrast, using PERV-specific real-time reverse-transcriptase PCR (RT-PCR) and ultra-sensitive product-enhanced reverse transcriptase (PERT) assays, we find no evidence for human fibroblast-derived cellular PERV RNA or coculture supernatant-based RT-activity, indicating a lack of subsequent PERV replication. Together, these results suggest that apoptosis-mediated horizontal PERV transfer does not present an overt hazard within the framework of porcine xenotransplantation. However, we also present arguments against extrapolation of these in vitro observations directly to clinical circumstances.