In vitro permeability of a model protein across ocular tissues and effect of iontophoresis on the transscleral delivery

Latest trends & strategies in ocular drug delivery

Ocular drug delivery is one of the most challenging routes of administration, and this may be attributed to the complex interplay of ocular barriers and clearance mechanisms that restrict therapeutic payload residence. Most of the currently approved products that ameliorate ocular disease conditions are topical, i.e., delivering therapeutics to the outside anterior segment of the eye. This site of administration works well for certain conditions such as local infections but due to the presence of numerous ocular barriers, the permeation of therapeutics to the posterior segment of the eye is limited. Conditions such as age-related macular degeneration and diabetic retinopathy that contribute to an extreme deterioration of vision acuity require therapeutic interventions at the posterior segment of the eye. This necessitates development of intraocular delivery systems such as intravitreal injections, implants, and specialized devices that deliver therapeutics to the posterior segment of the eye. Frequent dosing regimens and high concentration formulations have been strategized and developed to achieve desired therapeutic outcomes by overcoming some of the challenges of drug clearance and efficacy. Correspondingly, development of suitable delivery platforms such as biodegradable and non-biodegradable implants, nano delivery systems, and implantable devices have been explored. This article provides an overview of the current trends in the development of suitable formulations & delivery systems for ocular drug delivery with an emphasis on late-stage clinical and approved product. Moreover, this work aims to summarize current challenges and highlights exciting pre-clinical developments, and future opportunities in cell and gene therapies that may be explored for effective ocular therapeutic outcomes.

Microneedles for advanced ocular drug delivery

In the field of ocular drug delivery, topical delivery remains the most common treatment option for managing anterior segment diseases, whileintraocular injectionsare the current gold standard treatment option for treating posterior segment diseases. Nonetheless, topical eye drops are associated with low bioavailability (<5%), and theintravitreal administration procedure is highly invasive, yielding poor patient acceptability. In both cases, frequent administration is currently required. As a result, there is a clear unmet need for sustained drug delivery to the eye, particularly in a manner that can be localised. Microneedles, which are patches containing an array of micron-scale needles (<1 mm), have the potential to meet this need. These platforms can enable localised drug delivery to the eye while enhancing penetration of drug molecules through key ocular barriers, thereby improving overall therapeutic outcomes. Moreover, the minimally invasive manner in which microneedles are applied could provide significant advantages over traditional intravitreal injections regarding patient acceptability. Considering the benefitsofthis novel ocular delivery system, this review provides an in-depth overviewofthe microneedle systems for ocular drug delivery, including the types of microneedles used and therapeutics delivered. Notably, we outline and discuss the current challenges associated with the clinical translation of these platforms and offer opinions on factors which should be considered to improve such transition from lab to clinic.

Ocular therapies with biomacromolecules: From local injection to eyedrop and emerging noninvasive delivery strategies

The last two decades have witnessed a continuously increasing number of biomacromolecules approved for the treatment of ocular diseases. The eye possesses multiple protective mechanisms to resist the invasion of exogenous substances, but meanwhile these physiological defense systems also act as strong barriers, impeding absorption of most biomacromolecules into the eye. As a result, local injections play predominant roles for posterior ocular delivery of biomacromolecules in clinical practice. To achieve safe and convenient application of biomacromolecules, alternative strategies to realize noninvasive intraocular delivery are necessary. Various nanocarriers, novel penetration enhancers and physical strategies have been explored to facilitate delivery of biomacromolecules to both anterior and posterior ocular segments but still suffered difficulties in clinical translation. This review compares the anatomical and physiological characteristics of the eyes from those frequently adopted experimental species and profiles the well-established animal models of ocular diseases. We also summarize the ophthalmic biomacromolecules launched on the market and put emphasis on emerging noninvasive intraocular delivery strategies of peptides, proteins and genes.

Non-Invasive Iontophoretic Delivery of Cytochrome c to the Posterior Segment and Determination of Its Ocular Biodistribution

The intact porcine eye globe model was used to demonstrate that transscleral iontophoresis could deliver a small protein, cytochrome c (Cyt c), to the posterior segment and to investigate post-iontophoretic biodistribution in the different ocular compartments. The effects of Cyt c concentration (1, 5, and 10 mg/mL), current density (3.5 and 5.5 mA/cm²), and duration of the current application (10 min and 1, 2, and 4 h) were evaluated. The data confirmed that transscleral iontophoresis enhanced the intraocular delivery of Cyt c under all conditions as compared to passive controls (same setup but without the current application). Increasing the Cyt c concentration resulted in a proportional enhancement in the Cyt c delivery. Increasing the current density from 3.5 to 5.5 mA/cm² increased iontophoretic delivery at a Cyt c concentration of 10 mg/mL but did not appear to do so at 5 mg/mL; this was attributed in part to the effect of melanin binding. Short duration iontophoresis (10 min, 3.5 mA/cm²) of a 10 mg/mL Cyt c solution created a depot in the sclera. When this was followed by a 4 h incubation period, post-iontophoretic Cyt c diffusion from the sclera resulted in a different biodistribution, and Cyt c could be quantified in the posterior segment.

Colloidal nanosystems with mucoadhesive properties designed for ocular topical delivery

Over the last years, the scientific interest about topical ocular delivery targeting the posterior segment of the eye has been increasing. This is probably due to the fact that this is a non-invasive administration route, well tolerated by patients and with fewer local and systemic side effects. However, it is a challenging task due to the external ocular barriers, tear film clearance, blood flow in the conjunctiva and choriocapillaris and due to the blood-retinal barriers, amongst other features. An enhanced intraocular bioavailability of drugs can be achieved by either improving corneal permeability or by improving precorneal retention time. Regarding this last option, increasing residence time in the precorneal area can be achieved using mucoadhesive polymers such as xyloglucan, poly(acrylate), hyaluronic acid, chitosan, and carbomers. On the other hand, colloidal particles can interact with the ocular mucosa and enhance corneal and conjunctival permeability. These nanosystems are able to deliver a wide range of drugs, including macromolecules, providing stability and improving ocular bioavailability. New pharmaceutical approaches based on nanotechnology associated to bioadhesive compounds have emerged as strategies for a more efficient treatment of ocular diseases. Bearing this in mind, this review provides an overview of the current mucoadhesive colloidal nanosystems developed for ocular topical administration, focusing on their advantages and limitations.

Lipid-Based Nanocarriers for Ophthalmic Administration: Towards Experimental Design Implementation

Nanotherapeutics based on biocompatible lipid matrices allow for enhanced solubility of poorly soluble compounds in the treatment of ophthalmic diseases, overcoming the anatomical and physiological barriers present in the eye, which, despite the ease of access, remains strongly protected. Micro-/nanoemulsions, solid lipid nanoparticles (SLN) or nanostructured lipid carriers (NLC) combine liquid and/or solid lipids with surfactants, improving drug stability and ocular bioavailability. Current research and development approaches based on try-and-error methodologies are unable to easily fine-tune nanoparticle populations in order to overcome the numerous constraints of ocular administration routes, which is believed to hamper easy approval from regulatory agencies for these systems. The predictable quality and specifications of the product can be achieved through quality-by-design (QbD) implementation in both research and industrial environments, in contrast to the current quality-by-testing (QbT) framework. Mathematical modelling of the expected final nanoparticle characteristics by variation of operator-controllable variables of the process can be achieved through adequate statistical design-of-experiments (DoE) application. This multivariate approach allows for optimisation of drug delivery platforms, reducing research costs and time, while maximising the understanding of the production process. This review aims to highlight the latest efforts in implementing the design of experiments to produce optimised lipid-based nanocarriers intended for ophthalmic administration. A useful background and an overview of the different possible approaches are presented, serving as a starting point to introduce the design of experiments in current nanoparticle research.

Ultrasonically and Iontophoretically Enhanced Drug-Delivery System Based on Dissolving Microneedle Patches

A multifunctional system comprised of hyaluronic acid microneedles was developed as an effective transdermal delivery platform for rapid local delivery. The microneedles can regulate the filling amount on the tip, by controlling the concentration of hyaluronic acid solution. Ultrasonication induces dissolution of the HA microneedles via vibration of acoustic pressure, and AC iontophoresis improves the electrostatic force-driven diffusion of HA ions and rhodamine B. The effect of ultrasound on rhodamine release was analyzed in vitro using a gelatin hydrogel. The frequency and voltage dependence of the AC on the ion induction transfer was also evaluated experimentally. The results showed that the permeability of the material acts as a key material property. The delivery system based on ultrasonication and iontophoresis in microneedles increases permeation, thus resulting in shorter initial delivery time than that required by delivery systems based on passive or ultrasonication alone. This study highlights the significance of the combination between ultrasonic waves and iontophoresis for improving the efficiency of the microneedles, by shortening the reaction duration. We anticipate that this system can be extended to macromolecular and dependence delivery, based on drug response time.

Bruch's membrane allows unhindered passage of up to 2 μm latex beads in an in vivo porcine model

PURPOSE

It has been proposed that changes in the permeability of Bruch's membrane play a role in the pathogenesis of age-related macular degeneration (AMD). This paper investigates, in an in vivo porcine model, the migration of fluorescent latex beads across the Bruch's membrane after subretinal injection.

METHODS

Forty-one healthy eyes of 33 three-month-old domestic pigs received a subretinal injection of 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, or 4.0 μm fluorescent latex beads. Between three hours and five weeks after injection evaluations were performed with fundus photographs and histology. Fluorescent beads were identified in unstained histologic sections using the rhodamine filter with the light microscope.

RESULTS

The fluorescent latex beads relocated from the subretinal space. Intact beads up to 2.0 μm were found in the choroid, sclera, and extrascleral space. The smaller beads were also found inside choroidal and extrascleral blood vessels. In contrast, the larger beads of 4.0 μm did not pass the Bruch's membrane.

CONCLUSION

Subretinally implanted beads up to 2.0 μm pass the Bruch's membrane intact and cross the blood-ocular barrier. The intact beads are found in the choroid, sclera and inside blood vessels. The results give reason to consider the role of subretinal clearance and passage of Bruch's membrane in the development of AMD.

Controlled non-invasive iontophoretic delivery of triamcinolone acetonide amino acid ester prodrugs into the posterior segment of the eye

This study investigated short duration transscleral iontophoretic delivery of four triamcinolone acetonide (TA) amino acid ester prodrugs (TA-AA) (alanine, Ala; arginine, Arg; isoleucine, Ile and lysine, Lys) using whole porcine eyes globes in vitro. Post-iontophoretic biodistribution of TA was quantified by UHPLC-MS/MS in the different ocular compartments (cornea, aqueous humor, sclera, ciliary body, choroid and retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE), neural retina and vitreous humor). Transscleral iontophoresis (3 mA/cm² for 10 min) increased total drug delivery of the TA-AA prodrugs by 14-30-fold as compared to passive diffusion. The TA-AA prodrugs had distinct biodistribution profiles - the penetration depth achieved was dependent on their physicochemical properties (e.g. lipophilicity for TA-Ile) and susceptibility to hydrolysis (e.g. TA-Arg). Intraocular drug distribution was also influenced by prodrug binding to melanin (TA-Lys). Interestingly, under conditions of equivalent charge (6 mA/cm² for 5 min vs. 1.5 mA/cm² for 20 min, i.e. 1.44 C respectively) the longer duration (20 min) at lower current density resulted in ∼6 times more TA delivery into the vitreous humor. Overall, the study provided further evidence of the potential of transscleral iontophoresis for the non-invasive treatment of posterior segment inflammatory diseases.

Implications of melanin binding in ocular drug delivery

Pigmented ocular tissues contain melanin within the intracellular melanosomes. Drugs bind to melanin at varying extent that ranges from no binding to extensive binding. Binding may lead to drug accumulation to the pigmented tissues and prolonged drug retention in the melanin containing cells. Therefore, melanin binding is an important feature that affects ocular drug delivery and biodistribution, but this topic has not been reviewed since 1998. In this review, we present current knowledge on ocular melanin, melanosomes and binding of drugs to pigmented cells and tissues. In vitro, in vivo and in silico methods in the field were critically evaluated, because the literature in this field can be confusing if the reader does not properly understand the methodological aspects. Literature analysis includes a comprehensive table of literature data on melanin binding of drugs. Furthermore, we aimed to give some insights beyond the current literature by making a chemical structure based classification model for melanin binding of drugs and kinetic simulations that revealed significant interplay between melanin binding and drug permeability across the melanosomal and plasma membranes. Overall, more mechanistic and systematic research is needed before the impact of melanin binding on ocular drug delivery can be properly understood and predicted.

Overcoming ocular drug delivery barriers through the use of physical forces

Overcoming the physiological barriers in the eye remains a key obstacle in the field of ocular drug delivery. While ocular barriers naturally have a protective function, they also limit drug entry into the eye. Various pharmaceutical strategies, such as novel formulations and physical force-based techniques, have been investigated to weaken these barriers and transport therapeutic agents effectively to both the anterior and the posterior segments of the eye. This review summarizes and discusses the recent research progress in the field of ocular drug delivery with a focus on the application of physical methods, including electrical fields, sonophoresis, and microneedles, which can enhance penetration efficiency by transiently disrupting the ocular barriers in a minimally or non-invasive manner.

Transscleral passive and iontophoretic transport: theory and analysis

INTRODUCTION

The sclera is considered the 'static barrier,' a main barrier for transscleral drug delivery. The characterization of passive and iontophoretic transport across the sclera in vitro is the first step toward our ability to predict transscleral drug delivery. Although previous studies have investigated this topic, the quantitative structure permeation relationships (QSPR) for passive and iontophoretic transscleral transport are not available.

AREAS COVERED

This review evaluated previous results of transscleral passive and iontophoretic transport in vitro and examined QSPR for transscleral permeation of small permeants and macromolecules. Passive permeation data in the literature were compared with respective to the animal species employed in the studies. Data variability was investigated. Electrotransport theory and the mechanisms of iontophoresis were reviewed and used to analyze the iontophoresis data.

EXPERT OPINION

QSPR was examined for passive transscleral permeation, showing correlations between logarithm of permeability coefficient and logarithm of molecular weight. Potential causes of data variability were proposed. QSPR were established for electroosmosis using the molecular weight of neutral permeants and for iontophoresis enhancement using the molecular weight and charge of ionic permeants. However, QSPR for charged macromolecules were empirical; iontophoretic flux enhancement was significantly smaller than Nernst-Planck model prediction due to complicating factors.

Non-invasive strategies for targeting the posterior segment of eye

The safe and effective treatment of eye diseases has been remained a global myth. Several advancements have been done and various drug delivery and treatment techniques have been suggested. The Posterior segment disorders are the leading cause of visual impairments and blindness. Targeting the therapeutic agents to the anterior and posterior segments of the eye has attracted extensive attention from the scientific community. Significant key factors in the success of ocular therapy are the development of safe, effective, economic and non-invasive novel drug delivery systems. These specialized non-invasive ocular drug delivery systems revolutionized the drug delivery strategies by overcoming the limitations, provided targeted delivery to the ocular tissues by avoiding larger doses, and reducing the toxicity encountered by the conventional approaches. These non-invasive systems are fabricated by ingredients encompassing biodegradability, biocompatibility, mucoadhesion, solubility and permeability enhancement and stimuli responsiveness. The variety of routes are utilized to provide minimally invasive drug delivery to the patients without any discomfort and pain. This review is focused on the brief introduction, types, significance, preparation techniques, components and mechanism of drug release of non-invasive systems, including in situ gelling systems, microspheres, iontophoresis, nanoparticles, nanosuspensions and specialized novel emulsions.

A flexible device for ocular iontophoretic drug delivery

In this work, a flexible ocular iontophoretic device, which can be fabricated by batch processing, is reported. In vivo experiments were conducted on rabbit eyes, and the results demonstrated this device could realize ocular iontophoresis effectively, simply, and conveniently. Compared to conventional eye cups, it can be placed under the eyelid and can deliver ions through a small area on the eyeball, reducing tissue damage caused by the drug during ion penetration. Owing to the flexibility of the device, the device can be easily seated under the eyelid stably during iontophoresis. Manganese ions as a tracer for detection of optic nerve damage were delivered into rabbit eyes by this iontophoretic device. Under 1 mA for 600 s, the average Mn(2+) concentration in the eye ball after iontophoresis was 102 ng/ml, while the one in the control group was 23 ng/ml. Using 2 mA for 600 s, the average concentration was 271 ng/ml, while it was 38 ng/ml in the control group. Thermal injury during iontophoresis was not observed under an applied current of no more than 2 mA for no longer than 10 min, with the local temperature less than 38 °C, measured by an infrared thermal imager.

Permeation of proteins, oligonucleotide and dextrans across ocular tissues: experimental studies and a literature update

Proteins and oligonucleotides represent powerful tools for the treatment of several ocular diseases, affecting both anterior and posterior eye segments. Despite the potential of these compounds, their administration remains a challenge. The last years have seen a growing interest for the noninvasive administration of macromolecular drugs, but still there is only little information of their permeability across the different ocular barriers. The aim of this work was to evaluate the permeation of macromolecules of different size, shape and charge across porcine ocular tissues such as the isolated sclera, the choroid Bruch's membrane and the cornea, both intact and de-epitelialized. Permeants used were two proteins (albumin and cytochrome C), an oligonucleotide, two dextrans (4 and 40 kDa) and a monoclonal antibody (bevacizumab). Obtained data and its comparison with the literature highlight the difficulties in predicting the behavior of macromolecules based on their physicochemical properties, because the interplay between the charge, molecular radius and conformation prevent their analysis separately. However, the data can be of great help for a rough evaluation of the feasibility of a noninvasive administration and for building computational models to improve understanding of the interplay among static, dynamic and metabolic barriers in the delivery of macromolecules to the eye.