Value of a radiographic score for the assessment of healing of nailed femoral and tibial shaft fractures: A retrospective preliminary study

Fracture nonunion and delayed union

Delayed union and nonunion of fractures exist in the pediatric population. Fracture healing requires the synergistic collaboration of mechanical support and robust biological processes to allow endochondral ossification, reestablishment of bone continuity, and subsequent remodeling to strong lamellar bone. Failure of either mechanical stability or biology may manifest as delayed fracture healing. While early recognition of potential metabolic and pharmacologic risk factors may be addressed by pre-emptive treatment using nutritional and vitamin D supplements, definitive treatment of established nonunion requires a comprehensive approach.

Key Concepts

(1)Delayed unions and nonunions are more common in adult bone but can also occur in pediatric bone.(2)Fracture healing requires synergistic collaboration of mechanical support and robust biological processes; treatment of nonunions should address both the biological and mechanical factors.(3)Vitamin D is an integral component of calcium absorption and bone health.

Reliability of the Modified Radiographic Union Score for Tibia Fractures (mRUST) for Femoral Shaft Fractures

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the interobserver and intraobserver reliability of the modified Radiographic Union Score for Tibia Fractures (mRUST) and the effect of rater experience in evaluation of femoral fractures.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Single Level 1 trauma center.

PATIENTS/PARTICIPANTS

Patients 18-55 years of age with a femur shaft fracture.

INTERVENTION

Intramedullary nail fixation.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENT

Interobserver and intraobserver reliability using the intraclass correlation coefficient.

RESULTS

The overall interobserver reliability was 0.96. Among fellowship-trained evaluators, the interobserver reliability was 0.94, and it was 0.92 among trainees. The overall intraobserver reliability was 0.98. The intraobserver reliability was 0.97 among fellowship-trained evaluators and 0.96 for trainees.

CONCLUSIONS

These results show high interobserver and intraobserver reliability of mRUST in the evaluation of radiographic healing for femur shaft fractures treated with intramedullary nail. This high reliability was further demonstrated throughout different postoperative healing time frames. In addition, mRUST appears to be reliable when used both by trainees and experienced surgeons for the evaluation of femur shaft fractures.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Diagnostic Level I. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

The treatment of a femoral shaft fracture in patients with a previous post-traumatic femoral deformity using a Clamshell osteotomy

The aim of this study was to assess the safety and clinical outcome of patients with a femoral shaft fracture and a previous complex post-traumatic femoral malunion who were treated with a clamshell osteotomy and fixation with an intramedullary nail (IMN). The study involved a retrospective analysis of 23 patients. All had a previous, operatively managed, femoral shaft fracture with malunion due to hardware failure. They were treated with a clamshell osteotomy between May 2015 and March 2020. The mean age was 42.6 years (26 to 62) and 15 (65.2%) were male. The mean follow-up was 2.3 years (1 to 5). Details from their medical records were analyzed. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the quality of correction of the deformity, functional recovery, the healing time of the fracture, and complications. The mean length of time between the initial injury and surgery was 4.5 years (3 to 10). The mean operating time was 2.8 hours (2.05 to 4.4)), and the mean blood loss was 850 ml (650 to 1,020). Complications occurred in five patients (21.7%): two with wound necrosis, and three with deep vein thrombosis. The mean coronal deformity was significantly corrected from 17.78° (SD 4.62°) preoperatively to 1.35° (SD 1.72°) postoperatively (p < 0.001), and the mean sagittal deformity was significantly corrected from 20.65° (SD 5.88°) preoperatively to 1.61° (SD 1.95°; p < 0.001) postoperatively. The mean leg length discrepancy was significantly corrected from 3.57 cm (SD 1.27) preoperatively to 1.13 cm (SD 0.76) postoperatively (p < 0.001). All fractures healed at a mean of seven months (4 to 12) postoperatively. The mean Lower Extremity Functional Scale score improved significantly from 45.4 (SD 9.1) preoperatively to 66.2 (SD 5.5) postoperatively (p < 0.001). Partial cortical nonunion in the deformed segment occurred in eight patients (34.8%) and healed at a mean of 2.4 years (2 to 3) postoperatively. A clamshell osteotomy combined with IMN fixation in the treatment of patients with a femoral shaft fracture and a previous post-traumatic femoral malunion achieved excellent outcomes. Partial cortical nonunions in the deformed segment also healed satisfactorily.

Subtrochanteric femoral fractures and intramedullary nailing complications: a comparison of two implants

INTRODUCTION

Intramedullary (IM) nails are considered the 'gold' standard treatment for subtrochanteric femoral fractures. The incidence and risk factors for re-operation in subtrochanteric fractures remain unclear. Furthermore, no studies have compared the outcomes of different nailing systems used to treat subtrochanteric fractures in the same study population.

AIMS/OBJECTIVES

Our study aimed to (i) investigate the cumulative incidence and factors associated with an increased risk of re-operation in subtrochanteric fractures treated with a long intramedullary (IM) nail, (ii) compare the outcomes of subtrochanteric fractures treated with long Affixus and Gamma nails, and (iii) establish whether the addition of a proximal anti-rotation screw in the Affixus nail confers any clinical benefit.

METHODS

A retrospective review of all adult patients admitted to a level 1 trauma centre with a subtrochanteric femur fracture treated with a long cephalomedullary IM nail over an 8-year period was conducted. Exclusion criteria were primary surgery performed at another institution, prophylactic nailing because of tumours, incomplete fractures, and patients who were lost to follow-up or died before fracture healing. Data variables were assessed for normality prior to determining the use of either parametric or non-parametric tests. Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify potential factors associated with re-operation. For the comparison between the two nail types, patients were matched into two groups of 119 each by age (10-year intervals), gender and mechanism of injury (low energy, high energy and pathological fractures). A p-value < 0.05 was considered significant. The Kaplan-Meier nail survival curve was used to demonstrate the survival of each nail. Data were analysed using the statistical package R (R version 3.6.0).

RESULTS

A total of 309 subtrochanteric fractures were treated with a distally locked long IM nail (re-operation rate: 22.33%) over an 8-year period. Logistic regression identified six factors associated with an increased risk of re-operation, including age < 75 years old, use of a long Gamma nail, pre-injury coxa-vara femoral neck shaft angles, an immediate post-operative reduction angle of > 10° varus, deep wound infection and non-union. Following matching, we compared the two long cephalomedullary nailing systems used (Gamma versus Affixus nail). The only differences identified from the unadjusted analysis were a higher overall incidence of nail failure in Gamma nails due to any cause, re-operation, and impingement of the nail tip distally against the anterior femoral cortex. When we corrected for covariates, no significant differences remained evident between the two nails. From the Kaplan-Meier nail survival curves, however, the Affixus nail demonstrated better survivorship up to 5 years post-implantation in terms of nail failure and re-operation for all causes. Finally, the addition of a proximal anti-rotation screw in the Affixus nail did not seem to confer any benefit.

CONCLUSION

We reported a 22.3% re-operation rate in our cohort of subtrochanteric fractures treated with a long IM nail. We have identified six risk factors associated with re-operation: age < 75 years old, pre-injury femoral neck shaft angle, choice of nail, varus reduction angle, fracture-related infection and non-union. The addition of a proximal anti-rotation screw in the Affixus nail did not confer any benefit.

The Butterfly Fragment in Wedge-Shaped Femoral Shaft Fracture: Comparison of Two Different Surgical Methods

Objective

Our study compared the results of wedge‐shaped femoral shaft fracture following intramedullary (IM) nailing with or without fixation of the third fragment.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed patients presenting with femoral shaft fracture with AO/OTA type 32‐B from 2011 to 2016. Patients were divided into two groups: closed reduction without touching the third fragment and open reduction with fixation of the third fragment. The fragment ratio, fragment length, nail size, dynamization or not, mRUST scores, union rate, and union time were compared between the two groups. Risk factors of non‐union were also investigated, including sex, age, fracture pattern, fracture location, dynamization, nail size, fragment ratio, fragment size, and postoperative fragment displacement.

Results

A total of 80 patients met inclusion criteria, 20 patients with wedge‐shaped shaft femoral fracture were managed with IM nailing and open reduction with fixation of the third fragment. Sixty patients were treated with IM nail without touching the third fragment. The union rate for the fixation and non‐fixation groups were 60.0% and 81.7%, respectively. The mean union time for the fixation group was 19 months vs 14 months for the non‐fixation group. Multi‐regression analysis showed larger nail size (odds ratio: 2.26) and fixation of the third fragment (odds ratio: 0.18) influenced fracture healing.

Conclusions

Fixation of the third fragment in wedge‐shaped shaft femoral fracture results in a longer union time and lower union rate. In the management of femoral fracture with a third fragment, a larger nail size is recommended and fixation should be performed in a closed manner. Fixation of the fragment may achieve better fracture reduction. However, disruption of the vasculature and surrounding structures may further result in nonunion of the fracture site.

Role of open cerclage wiring in patients with comminuted fractures of the femoral shaft treated with intramedullary nails

Introduction

The role of open cerclage wiring in comminuted femoral shaft fracture treatment with intramedullary nails remains unclear. Here, we analyzed the effect of open cerclage wiring and the risk factors for nonunion after interlocking nailing in comminuted femoral shaft fracture treatment. We hypothesized that open cerclage wiring can be applied in patients with severe comminuted femoral shaft fractures without affecting bone healing.

Patients and methods

This retrospective cohort study used data from consecutive patients who underwent interlocking nail fixation of a comminuted femoral shaft fracture between January 1, 2009, and December 31, 2016. First, eligible patients were divided into the wire and no wire groups according to the surgical technique used, and their union rate was recorded. The patients were then divided into the union and nonunion groups, and their perioperative data were analyzed.

Results

In total, 71 comminuted femoral shaft fractures treated with interlocking nail fixation were included: 38 fractures (53.5%) augmented with the open wiring technique and 33 reduced with closed or mini-open techniques without wiring. The wire group demonstrated significant improvements in fracture reduction compared with the no wire group, whereas no significant difference was observed in the union rate between the wire and no wire groups (p = 0.180). Moreover, 46 (65%) of 71 fractures achieved union smoothly, and no significant difference was observed in any perioperative data between the union and nonunion groups.

Discussion

Augmentation with open cerclage wiring is indicated for comminuted femoral shaft fractures treated with intramedullary nails, even when the fragments are large or greatly displaced. Thus, open cerclage wiring can be used for fracture treatment without decreasing the union rate.

Percutaneous administration of allogeneic bone-forming cells for the treatment of delayed unions of fractures: a pilot study

Background

Overall, 5–10% of fractures result in delayed unions or non-unions, causing major disabilities and a huge socioeconomic burden. Since rescue surgery with autologous bone grafts can cause additional challenges, alternative treatment options have been developed to stimulate a deficient healing process. This study assessed the technical feasibility, safety and preliminary efficacy of local percutaneous implantation of allogeneic bone-forming cells in delayed unions of long bone fractures.

Methods

In this phase I/IIA open-label pilot trial, 22 adult patients with non-infected delayed unions of long bone fractures, which failed to consolidate after 3 to 7 months, received a percutaneous implantation of allogeneic bone-forming cells derived from bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (ALLOB; Bone Therapeutics) into the fracture site (50 × 10⁶ to 100 × 10⁶ cells). Patients were monitored for adverse events and need for rescue surgery for 30 months. Fracture healing was monitored by Tomographic Union Score (TUS) and modified Radiographic Union Score. The health status was evaluated using the Global Disease Evaluation (GDE) score and pain at palpation using a visual analogue scale. The presence of reactive anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies was evaluated.

Results

During the 6-month follow-up, three serious treatment-emergent adverse events were reported in two patients, of which two were considered as possibly treatment-related. None of the 21 patients in the per-protocol efficacy population needed rescue surgery within 6 months, but 2/21 (9.5%) patients had rescue surgery within 30 months post-treatment. At 6 months post-treatment, an improvement of at least 2 points in TUS was reached in 76.2% of patients, the GDE score improved by a mean of 48%, and pain at palpation at the fracture site was reduced by an average of 61% compared to baseline. The proportion of blood samples containing donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies increased from 8/22 (36.4%) before treatment to 13/22 (59.1%) at 6 months post-treatment, but no treatment-mediated allogeneic immune reactions were observed.

Conclusion

This pilot study showed that the percutaneous implantation of allogeneic bone-forming cells was technically feasible and well tolerated in patients with delayed unions of long bone fractures. Preliminary efficacy evidence is supporting the further development of this treatment.

Trial registration

NCT02020590. Registered on 25 December 2013. ALLOB-DU1, A pilot Phase I/IIa, multicentre, open proof-of-concept study on the efficacy and safetyof allogeneic osteoblastic cells (ALLOB®) implantation in non-infected delayed-union fractures.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13287-021-02432-4.

Squat and smile assessment in predicting healing of lower limb fractures fixed with a SIGN nail

BACKGROUND

Irrespective of the treatment method, union is the ultimate goal of any fracture treatment. However, nowadays, rather than the physician-based clinico-radiological methods, the patient-reported outcome measurements assessing their quality of life and function are gaining much popularity. This is specifically true in the part of the world where the patient needs almost complete degree of hip/knee flexion - for social, cultural, religious or occupational reason(s). The ability to squat can assess the mobility and stability of joints and thus the quality of squatting is a proxy reflection of the functional outcome after fixation of lower limb fracture. Thus, we studied to determine the inter-observer and intra-observer reliability of Radiographic Union Score for Tibia (RUST) and Squat and Smile (S & S) test in clinical photograph. We further calculated the sensitivity and specificity of S & S test in predicting healing of lower limb fracture fixed by intramedullary interlocking nail considering RUST as the gold standard.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study of prospectively collected data of solid Surgical Implant Generation Network (SIGN) intramedullary interlocking nailing from a single, university-based, high volume tertiary center where 56 consecutive adults with either tibial or femoral shaft fractures fixed with a SIGN nail within one year and not requiring any surgery till minimum of eighteen-month follow-up were included. Cases without either Anterior-Posterior (AP) view and/or Lateral (Lat.) view follow-up x-ray(s) or proper S & S clinical photograph (at least 1.5-year post fixation) were excluded. The x-rays (RUST criteria) and clinical photograph (S & S grading) were scored by two independent and blinded observers each and repeated after 1 month.

RESULTS

The overall intra-observer reliability was from 0.773 to 0.825 and inter-observer reliability from 0.635 to 0.757 for RUST scoring which was from 0.687 to 0.785 and from 0.301 to 0.650 respectively for S & S scoring. The sensitivity and specificity of S & S in predicting fracture healing were up to 82.22% and 63.64% respectively.

CONCLUSION

The S & S test is reliable to predict the healing of lower limb fracture fixed with an intramedullary nail. The test is more useful to determine healed fractures than to determine non-healed ones. (sensitivity being higher than specificity).

Is the compressive nail method capable of accelerating bone union in patients with femoral distal diaphysis fracture?

OBJECTIVES

This study was conducted to evaluate clinically and radiologically the patients for whom compressive and non-compressive intramedullary nails were applied and to analyse the compression effectiveness in adult femur distal diaphysis fractures.

HYPOTHESIS

The compressive locked nails shortened the union period in the distal diaphysis fractures, and it was found to be an effective method, as the pseudoarthrosis rate was lower.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective study was conducted among 59 patients for whom the compressive and non-compressive IMNs were applied to treat femur distal diaphysis fractures. Thirty-one for whom the non-compressive IMN was applied were categorised as group I, and 28 for whom the compressive nail was applied were categorised as group II. Finite element analysis was performed using 1.5mm compression, and a mean stress value of 34.67Mpa.

RESULTS

The mean values of union period were calculated as 13.6±2.4 weeks (range: 11-20 months) and functional score was 79.2, respectively in group I, and they were evaluated as a good grade. In group II, the respective mean values of union period were 11.5±2.6 weeks (range: 10-17 months) and functional score was 86, and they were evaluated as excellent.

CONCLUSION

Radiological and functional scores were determined to be better with interlocking compressive nails and shortened the fracture union period in the follow-up in adult femur distal diaphysis fractures.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III; retrospective cohort study.

Semi-quantitative CT scoring of nailed shaft fractures during normal healing and in non-unions: comparison with radiographic scoring

PURPOSE

To compare tomographic (TUS) with radiographic (RUS) union scores in nailed shaft fractures during normal healing and in non-unions.

METHODS

Two radiologists blinded to fracture age separately determined RUS and TUS in nailed femoral or tibial shaft fractures by analyzing the radiographic and CT examinations obtained in 47 patients during normal healing (early fracture group; 24 study participants, 17 men,19 tibias, mean fracture-CT delay 109 ± 57 days [42-204 days]) and in surgically proven non-united fractures (late fracture group, 23 patients, 14 men, 12 tibias, mean fracture-CT delay 565 ± 519 days[180-1983 days]). In both study groups, we determined the inter- and intra-observer agreement of RUS and TUS and compared TUS with RUS.

RESULTS

Intra- and inter-observer agreement of RUS and TUS was very good in the early fracture group and good in the late fracture group for both readers. TUS correlated with RUS substantially in the early fracture group and only weakly in the late fracture group. TUS was statistically significantly lower than RUS in study participants with RUS ≥ 8 or 9 for R2 only and ≥ 10 for both readers in the early fracture group and in patients with RUS ≥ 8, 9 or 10 in the late fracture group for both readers.

CONCLUSION

RUS and TUS of nailed shaft fractures during normal healing or in non-unions are both feasible and reproducible. They yield similar values in fractures with no or limited callus. TUS yields lower values than RUS in fractures with callus.

Epidemiology, Clinical Assessments, and Current Treatments of Nonunions

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The failure of bony union following a fracture, termed a fracture nonunion, has severe patient morbidity and economic consequences. This review describes current consensuses and future directions of investigation for determining why, detecting when, and effective treatment if this complication occurs.

RECENT FINDINGS

Current nonunion investigation is emphasizing an expanded understanding of the biology of healing. This has led to assessments of the immune environment, multiple cytokines and morphogenetic factors, and the role of skeletogenic stem cells in the development of nonunion. Detecting biological markers and other objective diagnostic criteria is also a current objective of nonunion research. Treatment approaches in the near future will likely be dominated by the development of specific adjunct therapies to the nonunion surgical management, which will be informed by an expanded mechanistic understanding of nonunion biology. Current consensus among orthopedists is that improved diagnosis and treatment of nonunion hinges first on discoveries at the bench side with later translation to the clinic.

Treatment of fracture-related infection of the lower extremity with antibiotic-eluting ceramic bone substitutes: case series of 35 patients and literature review

INTRODUCTION

The current treatment concepts of fracture-related infection (FRI) [Consensus Conference (Anti-Infection Task Force (AITF)) on the definition of acute or chronic osteomyelitis (cOM)] are associated with unsolved challenges and problems, underlining the need for ongoing medical research.

METHOD

Literature review of treatments for FRI and description of own cases.

RESULTS

We could include eight papers with 394 patients reporting treatments and outcome in FRI. The infection was resolved in 92.9% (mean) of all treatments. The mean follow-up was 25 months with a persistent non-union in 7% of the patients. We diagnosed 35 (19f/16m; 56.4 ± 18.6 years) patients with bone infections anatomically allocated to the proximal and distal femur (12×), the pelvis (2×), distal tibia (3×), tibial diaphysis (11×), the ankle joint (4×) and calcaneus (3×). These 35 patients were treated (1) with surgical debridement; (2) with antibiotic-eluting ceramic bone substitutes; (3) bone stabilization (including nail fixation, arthrodesis nails, plates, or external ring fixation), (4) optionally negative pressure wound therapy (NPWT) and (5) optionally soft tissue closure with local or free flaps. The mean follow-up time was 14.9 ± 10.6 months (min/max: 2/40 month). The overall recurrence rate is low (8.5%, 3/35). Prolonged wound secretion was observed in six cases (17.1%, 6/35). The overall number of surgeries was a median of 2.5.

CONCLUSION

The results in the literature and in our case series are explicitly promising regarding the treatment of posttraumatic fracture-related infection.

A retrospective bicenter comparative study of surgical outcomes of atypical femoral fracture: Potential effect of teriparatide on fracture healing and callus formation

BACKGROUND

The main purpose of the present study was to assess the radiologic effect of teriparatide on fracture healing, including union rate, union time, and callus formation, by quantitative measurements using serial follow-up X-ray imaging examinations in patients with complete atypical femoral fractures (AFFs) treated using closed intramedullary nailing.

METHODS

From January 2010 to October 2017, 58 consecutive patients with complete AFF who were treated with intramedullary nailing at two institutions were enrolled. Patients were classified into two groups: those who received teriparatide therapy (group A) and those who did not (group B). Teriparatide (Forsteo®; Eli Lily Co., Indianapolis, IN, USA) at a once-daily 20 μg dose was prescribed as continuous treatment of osteoporosis or with the expectation of better bone healing. Surgical outcomes, including union rate, union time, modified radiologic union score (mRUS), and callus formation at 3, 6, and 12 months postoperatively, were assessed to evaluate the effect of teriparatide on fracture healing. Quantitative measurement of callus formation was performed using the region of interest (ROI) tool in the picture archiving communication system (PACS).

RESULTS

Non-union was not observed in group A, whereas two patients had non-union in group B. Union time was 18.3 ± 4.8 (range, 12-28) weeks in group A and 23.6 ± 9.5 (range, 12-64) weeks in group B and was significantly shorter in group A than group B (p = 0.010). The average mRUSs during periods A (3-4 months postoperatively), B (6-8 months postoperatively), and C (12-14 months postoperatively) were 10.0, 13.9, and 15.9 in group A, and 8.7, 12.0, and 14.9 in group B, respectively. The average mRUSs during periods A and B were significantly different (p = 0.027 and 0.011, respectively). The medial, posterior, and total callus areas during periods A and B were also significantly greater in group A than in group B. No difference was observed in the union rate between the two groups (p = 0.492).

CONCLUSION

Teriparatide may improve callus formation and shorten union time in patients with complete diaphyseal AFF who underwent closed intramedullary nailing.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III retrospective comparative study.

Virtual Mechanical Testing Based on Low-Dose Computed Tomography Scans for Tibial Fracture: A Pilot Study of Prediction of Time to Union and Comparison with Subjective Outcomes Scoring

BACKGROUND

Quantitative outcomes assessment remains a persistent challenge in orthopaedic trauma. Although patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) and radiographic assessments such as Radiographic Union Scale for Tibial Fractures (RUST) scores are frequently used, very little evidence has been presented to support their validity for measuring structural bone formation or biomechanical integrity.

METHODS

In this pilot study, a sequential cohort of patients with a tibial shaft fracture were prospectively recruited for observation following standard reamed intramedullary nailing in a level-I trauma center. Follow-up at 6, 12, 18, and 24 weeks included radiographs and completion of PROMs (EuroQol 5-Dimension [EQ-5D] and pain scores). Low-dose computed tomography (CT) scans were also performed at 12 weeks. Scans were reconstructed in 3 dimensions (3D) and subjected to virtual mechanical testing via the finite element method to assess torsional rigidity in the fractured limb relative to that in the intact bone.

RESULTS

Patients reported progressive longitudinal improvement in mobility, self-care, activity, and health over time, but the PROMs were not correlated with structural bone healing. RUST scoring showed moderate intrarater agreement (intraclass coefficient [ICC] = 0.727), but the scores at 12 weeks were not correlated with the time to union (R = 0.104, p = 0.193) and were only moderately correlated with callus structural integrity (R = 0.347, p = 0.010). In contrast, patient-specific virtual torsional rigidity (VTR) was significantly correlated with the time to union (R = 0.383, p = 0.005) and clearly differentiated 1 case of delayed union (VTR = 10%, union at 36 weeks) from the cases in the normally healing cohort (VTR > 60%; median union time, 19 weeks) on the basis of CT data alone.

CONCLUSIONS

PROMs provide insight into the natural history of the patient experience after tibial fracture but have limited utility as a measure of structural bone healing. RUST scoring, although reproducible, may not reliably predict time to union. In contrast, virtual mechanical testing with low-dose CT scans provides a quantitative and objective structural callus assessment that reliably predicts time to union and may enable early diagnosis of compromised healing.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level IV. Please see Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.