Effects of different additives and aerobic composting factors on heavy metal bioavailability reduction and compost parameters: A meta-analysis

Meta-analysis addressing the potential of antibiotic resistance gene elimination through aerobic composting

The significant increase in antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in organic solid wastes (OSWs) has emerged as a major threat to the food chain. Aerobic composting is a widely used technology for OSW management, with the potential to influence the fate of AGRs. However, the variability of the ARG elimination effects reported in different studies has highlighted the uncertainty regarding the effects of composting on ARGs. To identify the potential of composting in reducing ARG and the factors (e.g., composting technologies and physiochemical properties) influence ARG changes, a meta-analysis was conducted with a database including 4,232 observations. The abundances of ARGs and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) can be substantially reduced by 74.3% and 78.8%, respectively, via aerobic composting. During composting, the ARG levels in chicken and swine manure tended to be reduced more significantly (81.7% and 78.0%) compared to those in cattle manure (52.3%) and sewage sludge (32.6%). The reduction rate of sulfonamide resistant genes was only 35.3%, which was much lower than those of other types. MGEs and composting duration (CD) were identified as the most important factors driving ARG changes during composting. These findings provide a comprehensive insight into the effects of composting on ARG reduction, which may help prevent the transmission in food systems.

Exploring the synergistic effects of indole acetic acid (IAA) and compost in the phytostabilization of nickel (Ni) in cauliflower rhizosphere

Heavy metals (HMs) contamination, owing to their potential links to various chronic diseases, poses a global threat to agriculture, environment, and human health. Nickel (Ni) is an essential element however, at higher concentration, it is highly phytotoxic, and affects major plant functions. Beneficial roles of plant growth regulators (PGRs) and organic amendments in mitigating the adverse impacts of HM on plant growth has gained the attention of scientific community worldwide. Here, we performed a greenhouse study to investigate the effect of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA @ 10- 5 M) and compost (1% w/w) individually and in combination in sustaining cauliflower growth and yield under Ni stress. In our results, combined application proved significantly better than individual applications in alleviating the adverse effects of Ni on cauliflower as it increased various plant attributes such as plant height (49%), root length (76%), curd height and diameter (68 and 134%), leaf area (75%), transpiration rate (36%), stomatal conductance (104%), water use efficiency (143%), flavonoid and phenolic contents (212 and 133%), soluble sugars and protein contents (202 and 199%), SPAD value (78%), chlorophyll 'a and b' (219 and 208%), carotenoid (335%), and NPK uptake (191, 79 and 92%) as compared to the control. Co-application of IAA and compost reduced Ni-induced electrolyte leakage (64%) and improved the antioxidant activities, including APX (55%), CAT (30%), SOD (43%), POD (55%), while reducing MDA and H2O2 contents (77 and 52%) compared to the control. The combined application also reduced Ni uptake in roots, shoots, and curd by 51, 78 and 72% respectively along with an increased relative production index (78%) as compared to the control. Hence, synergistic application of IAA and compost can mitigate Ni induced adverse impacts on cauliflower growth by immobilizing it in the soil.

Is Cr(III) re-oxidation occurring in Cr-contaminated soils after remediation: Meta-analysis and machine learning prediction

Whether Cr(III) in Cr(III)-containing sites formed after Cr(VI) reduction and stabilization remediation are re-oxidized and pose toxicity risks again has been a growing concern. In this study, 1030 data were collected to perform a meta-analysis to clarify the effects of various factors (oxidant type, soil and Cr(III) solid compound properties, aging conditions, and testing methods) on Cr(III) oxidation. We observed that the soil properties of clay, pH ≥ 8, the lower CEC capacity, easily reducible Mn content, and Cr(III) content, and the higher Eh value and Fe content can promote the re-oxidation of Cr(III). Publication bias and sensitivity analyses confirmed the stability and reliability of the meta-analysis. Subsequently, we used five machine learning algorithms to construct and optimize the models. The prediction results of the RF model (RMSE <1.36, R2 >0.71) with good algorithm performance showed that after ten years of remediation, the extractable Cr(VI) concentration in the soil was 0.0087 mg/L, indicating a negligible secondary pollution risk of Cr(III) re-oxidation. This study provides theoretical support for subsequent risk management and control after Cr(VI) soil remediation and provides a solution for the quantitative prediction of Cr(III) re-oxidation.

Effects of an assistive electric field on heavy metal passivation during manure composting

Composting is one of main technologies for treating and thus utilizing livestock manure and sludge. However, heavy metals are major concerns in compost utilization due to their potential environmental hazards and health risks. This study aimed to investigate the effects of electric field-assisted composting on the variations of heavy metals and the affecting factors. The results showed that electric field significantly reduced the contents of bioavailable heavy metals including Mn, Zn, Cu, Ni, and Cd, with their bioavailable concentrations decreasing by 61.7, 63.8, 64.9, 83.7, and 63.8 %, respectively. The heavy metals being transformed into stable states were increased, indicating that the electric field also passivated these heavy metals and reduced their biological toxicity and stabilized their forms. Spearman's correlation analysis revealed that the changes in substances, temperature, and organic matter were the dominant environmental factors affecting the forms of heavy metals. Microbial community analysis indicated an increase in the abundance of metal-resistant bacteria such as Pseudomonas and Bacillus during electric field-assisted composting, with their relative abundances being increased to 2.66 % and 15.63 % in the pile of electric field-assisted composting, respectively, compared to the values of 1.88 % and 4.36 % respectively in the conventional composting. The current study suggests that electric field-assisted composting can significantly reduce the availability of heavy metals in the compost, and thus mitigate the health risks associated with its application.

Occurrence and transformation of heavy metals during swine waste treatment: A full scale study

This study tracked the fate of nine detected heavy metals in an industrial swine farm with integrated waste treatment, including anoxic stabilization, fixed-film anaerobic digestion, anoxic-oxic (A/O), and composting. Results show that heavy metals exhibited different transformation behaviors in the treatment streamline with Fe, Zn, Cu and Mn as the most abundant ones in raw swine waste. The overall removal of water-soluble heavy metals averaged at 30 %, 24 % and 42 % by anoxic stabilization, anaerobic digestion and A/O unit, respectively. In particular, anoxic stabilization could effectively remove Cu, Mn and Ni; while A/O unit was highly effective for Fe, Cr and Zn elimination from water-soluble states. As such, the environmental risk of liquid products for agricultural irrigation decreased gradually to the safe pollution level in swine waste treatment. Furthermore, heavy metals in the solid (slurry) phase of these bioprocesses could be immobilized with the passivation rate in the range of 42-70 %. Nevertheless, heavy metals preferably transformed from liquid to biosolids to remain their environmental risks when biosolids were used as organic fertilizer in agriculture, thereby requiring effective strategies to advance their passivation in all bioprocesses, particularly composting as the last treatment unit.

A potential heavy metals detoxification system in composting: Biotic and abiotic synergy mediated by shell powder

Regulating heavy metal resistance genes (HMRGs) was an effective method for heavy metal resistant bacteria (HMRB) to cope with heavy metal stress during dairy manure composting. This research aimed to investigate heavy metal detoxification mediated by shell powder (SP) in composting and the response of HMRB and HMRGs to changes in heavy metal bioavailability during composting. Research showed that SP additive reduced the bioavailability of Zu, Cu, and Mn by 10.64%, 13.90% and 14.14%, respectively. SP increased the composition percentage of humic acid (HA) in humus (HS) by 8%. SP enhanced the resistance of Actinobacteria to heavy metals and improved the regulation of HMRGs. Correlation analysis demonstrated that the bioavailability of heavy metals was positively correlated with most HMRGs. HA was significantly negatively correlated with the bioavailability of Zn, Cu and Mn. Therefore, SP additive could be a novel strategy for heavy metals detoxification during composting.

Is the co-application of self-produced compost and natural zeolite interesting to reduce environmental and toxicological availability in metal-contaminated kitchen garden soils?

Composting can turn organic waste into a valuable soil amendment that can improve physical, chemical, and biological soil quality. Compost amendments can also contribute to the remediation of areas anthropogenically degraded by metals. However, it is well known that compost, particularly self-produced compost, can show enrichment in metals. An experimental study was conducted to examine the short- and long-term distribution and the mobility of metals in soils amended with a self-produced compost when it was added alone or in combination with different doses of a natural zeolite to soil. The aim was also to study the interest of managing moderately metal-contaminated kitchen garden soils by assessing the chemical extractability, phytoavailability, and oral bioaccessibility of metals. When zeolite was added to compost alone, it had the tendency to better reduce extractability of Cd and Zn at 25%, and those of Pb at 15%. When the self-produced compost alone or in co-application with zeolite at these doses was applied to soils, the results showed (1) a decrease of NH4NO3-extractable Zn; (2) a reduction of Pb environmental availability, but not Pb bioaccessibility, and (3) an increase of ryegrass biomass. Nevertheless, the risk posed by the self-produced compost was minimal when applied at the proper rate (0.6% w/w). In the selected experimental conditions, the study recommends that self-produced compost be mixed with 15% zeolite to maximize vegetal biomass and minimize environmental risk. The question of sustainability of the results with repeated compost addition is also raised.

Independent and combined effects of sepiolite and palygorskite on humus spectral properties and heavy metal bioavailability during chicken manure composting

The effects of the independent and combined addition strategies of sepiolite and palygorskite on humification and heavy metals (HMs) during chicken manure composting were evaluated. Results showed that clay mineral addition showed a favorable effect on composting, prolonged the duration of the thermophilic phase (5-9 d) and improved the TN content (14%-38%) compared to CK. Independent strategy enhanced the humification degree in equal measures with the combined strategy. Carbon nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (¹³C NMR) and fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) confirmed that aromatic carbon species increased by 31%-33% during composting process. Excitation-emission matrix (EEM) fluorescence spectroscopy showed that humic acid-like compounds increased by 12%-15%. In addition, the maximum passivation rate of Cr, Mn, Cu, Zn, As, Cd, Pb and Ni were 51.35%, 35.98%, 30.39%, 32.46%, -87.02%, 36.61% and 27.62%, respectively. The independent addition of palygorskite exhibits the most potent effects for most HMs. Pearson correlation analysis indicated that pH and aromatic carbon were the key determinants of the HMs passivation. This study provided preliminary evidence and perspective of the application of clay minerals on the humification and safety of composting.

Performance assessment of in-vessel composter through heavy metal immobilization and humification of Parthenium hysterophorus

The bioconversion of Parthenium hysterophorus was performed through rotary drum composter and examined the mechanism of humification and heavy metals immobilization in the process. The 20th day compost contains a significant increase in humic substances of 28.7% compared to the initial day mix. The bioavailable fractions of heavy metals have reduced by 30 to 55% in the 20th day compost compared to the initial day mix. The leaching potential of cadmium has been reduced by 69% in the 20th day compost. The immobile fractions (F5) of Cd, Ni and Pb have been increased to 100, 99 and 78% in the 20th day compost. The mitotic index was increased by 1.7 and 51.6% in 25% dosed compost extract compared to the control and P. hysterophorus extract respectively. The transition of heavy metals to immobile fraction indicated the biodegradation capability of P. hysterophorus through rotary drum composting.