Prostate Surgery for Men with Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms: Do We Need Urodynamics to Find the Right Candidates? Exploratory Findings from the UPSTREAM Trial

Urodynamics in the Evaluation and Management of Bothersome Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms in Men With a Prostate

INTRODUCTION

Despite their utility, urodynamics (UDS) are associated with medical risks and patient discomfort. Therefore, it is crucial to select patients for UDS where the results are likely to change clinical decision-making or solidify diagnostic confidence. This narrative review aims to assess the indications, benefits and limitations of UDS in men with a prostate who have refractory lower urinary tract symptoms.

METHODS

A comprehensive review of the literature was conducted, focusing on studies evaluating the utility, patient perspectives, and clinical guidelines related to the use of UDS.

RESULTS

UDS are beneficial in specific clinical scenarios, such as in patients with neurogenic lower urinary tract dysfunction (NLUTD) or when the likelihood of successful intervention is uncertain. For men with suspected BPH, routine UDS before surgical intervention may not be necessary unless there are comorbid conditions such as frailty or a history of radiation that exacerbate risk of surgery or in the presence of significant diagnostic uncertainty, such as in men with suspected neurogenic lower urinary tract dysfunction.

CONCLUSIONS

UDS should be selectively utilized in clinical practice to maximize their diagnostic and therapeutic benefits while minimizing patient discomfort and risks. In men with suspected BPH, UDS should be considered in cases with diagnostic uncertainty or in the presence of significant comorbidities. Further research is needed to refine the indications for UDS and to develop noninvasive alternatives that can provide similar diagnostic insights.

What Is the Role of Invasive Urodynamics in the Assessment of Male Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms/Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia

Invasive urodynamics (iUDS) should be selectively performed in male patients with lower urinary tract symptoms before invasive treatment for benign prostatic obstruction. Recent evidence highlights the relevance of iUDS, particularly in patients with mixed symptomatology or significant comorbidities. Parameters such as the maximum flow rate, Bladder Outlet Obstruction Index, Bladder Contractility Index play a crucial role in predicting surgical outcomes, which emphasizes the importance of meticulous patient selection to maximize therapeutic efficacy.

Five-year Follow-up of the Urodynamics for Prostate Surgery Trial; Randomised Evaluation of Assessment Methods-A Noninferiority Randomised Controlled Trial of Urodynamics

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) are a key indication for surgery in older men. The Urodynamics for Prostate Surgery Trial; Randomised Evaluation of Assessment Methods (UPSTREAM) study evaluated the diagnostic pathway for men considering surgery to treat LUTS and reported the outcomes at 18 mo. This long-term follow-up study reports the symptoms and rates of prostate surgery at 5 yr.

METHODS

UPSTREAM participants who had consented to long-term follow-up received postal questionnaires at 5 yr after randomisation (October 2019-December 2021). The primary outcome was the patient-reported International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS, scale 0-35). Rates of surgery, derived from the National Health Service (NHS) England routine data, were a key secondary outcome. An intention-to-treat analytic approach was utilised.

KEY FINDINGS AND LIMITATIONS

At 5 yr, 211/427 (49.4%) participants in the intervention group and 204/393 (51.9%) in the routine care group completed the questionnaires, with routine data obtained for 801/820 (97.7%). The mean IPSS at 5 yr did not differ between randomised groups (adjusted difference 0.41, 95% confidence interval -1.10, 1.93), nor did the rates of surgery (0.96 [0.71, 1.28]). Urinary and sexual symptoms also showed no differences between the randomised groups. The main limitation is the reduced numbers of men in follow-up. In UPSTREAM, men were randomised to routine care diagnostic tests plus invasive urodynamics (intervention) or routine care only for LUTS. Treatment choice was made by the participants, advised by their clinicians.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

Five-year follow-up does not support the routine use of invasive urodynamics in reducing LUTS or rates of prostate surgery. Urodynamics should be used selectively in the evaluation of uncomplicated LUTS.

Beyond urodynamics: non-invasive approaches to diagnosing detrusor underactivity in men with lower urinary tract symptoms - a systematic review

BACKGROUND

To evaluate and synthesize existing evidence on non-invasive methods for diagnosing detrusor underactivity (DU) in men presenting with lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS), focusing on their feasibility and diagnostic accuracy.

METHODS

A systematic search of PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases was conducted for original articles reporting on non-invasive diagnostic tests for DU in men with LUTS. Data extraction focuses on study characteristics, diagnostic methods, and accuracy. The risk of bias was assessed using the QUADAS-2 tool.

RESULTS

Eighteen studies involving 7390 patients, of whom 3194 were diagnosed with DU, were included in our analysis. The evaluated diagnostic methods included ultrasound parameters, biomarkers, uroflowmetry results, symptom questionnaires, and clinical characteristics. Developed models, including those based on artificial intelligence (AI), and nomograms were also assessed. The symptom questionnaire DUA-SQ showed the highest sensitivity of 95.8%, while ultrasound measurements, such as detrusor wall thickness showed 100% specificity but limited sensitivity (42%). Models incorporating clinical variables achieved sensitivity rates of over 75%. Uroflowmetry parameters, particularly presence of "sawtooth" and "interrupted" waveforms, demonstrated sensitivity of 80% and specificity of 87%. Biomarkers, including serum adiponectin and urine NO/ATP ratio, achieved sensitivity of 79% and 88.5%, respectively. AI models showed potential, with sensitivities ranging from 65.9% to 79.7%. Due to the poor quality of the studies and data heterogeneity, meta-analysis was not performed.

CONCLUSIONS

Non-invasive diagnostic methods for DU, particularly DUA-SQ, ultrasound measurements, and AI models, demonstrate potential, though their accuracies vary. Further research is needed to standardize these methods and enhance their diagnostic reliability.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

The study protocol was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42024556425).

CLINICAL TRIAL NUMBER

not applicable.

Is It Possible to Regenerate the Underactive Detrusor? Part 2. Electrical Stimulation Therapies, Treatment of Bladder Outlet Obstruction, Constipation, and Pelvic Floor Disorders - ICI-RS 2024

INTRODUCTION

Detrusor muscle weakness is commonly noted on urodynamics in patients with refractory voiding difficulty. No clinical therapy has been proven to augment the strength of a detrusor contraction.

METHODS

This subject was discussed at a think-tank at the International Consultation on Incontinence-Research Society (ICI-RS) held in Bristol, June 2024. The discussions of the think-tank are being published in two parts. This second part discusses the role of electrical stimulation therapies, treatment of bladder outlet obstruction, constipation, and pelvic floor disorders, in the enhancement of strength of a detrusor contraction.

RESULTS

Electrical stimulation therapies, specifically sacral neuromodulation, have long been used in the salvage of patients with refractory nonobstructive voiding dysfunction. Clinical improvements can be noted in men following bladder outlet resistance reduction surgery especially, though not limited to those with demonstrable obstruction. Some patients may also show improvement with pelvic floor relaxation therapies and constipation care. However, there is a lack of high-quality urodynamic data to demonstrate an improvement in the strength of a detrusor contraction with these therapies. The think-tank recommends standards for future clinical studies examining treatments aimed at improving an underactive detrusor.

CONCLUSIONS

Studies need to examine whether clinical improvement following treatment of patients with an underactive detrusor is associated with improvement in strength of the detrusor contraction. New therapeutic options should apply specified standards for assessing and reporting the impact on detrusor contraction.

Efficacy and durability of holmium laser enucleation of the prostate in the management of acute and chronic urinary retention A retrospective study

INTRODUCTION

Our study aimed to assess the efficacy and durability of holmium laser enucleation of the prostate (HoLEP) in managing acute urinary retention (AUR), neurogenic chronic urinary retention (NCUR), and non-neurogenic chronic urinary retention (NNCUR). We also sought to compare outcomes in patients with preoperative urinary retention (UR) to those without.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective analysis using prospectively gathered data from men who underwent HoLEP at our institution between October 2017 and July 2022. Patient demographics and outcome measures were recorded, including indications for the procedure, median urinary volume drained, or median postvoid residual urine volume (PVR) before catheterization or HoLEP. Chronic urinary retention (CUR) was defined as PVR >300 mL in males able to void; and initial catheter drainage >1000 mL in males unable to void, in the absence of pain. NCUR and NNCUR were differentiated based on the presence of any significant illness or injury with a neurologic impact on the bladder. All patients had postoperative followup visits at one, three, six, and 12 months. Our evaluation included the International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), quality of life (QoL) assessment, maximum urinary flow rate (Qmax), PVR, and catheter-free status.

RESULTS

Three hundred sixty-eight males who underwent HoLEP were included in our study. The UR group consisted of 189 patients (70 AUR, 42 NCUR, and 77 NNCUR), and the lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) group was comprised of 179 individuals. There were no statistically significant differences between the NCUR and NNCUR subgroups regarding demographics and outcomes. At 12 months postoperative, the AUR group had a higher catheter-free rate than the CUR group (p=0.04), and other outcome variables were comparable between the two cohorts. The UR group had a significantly lower QoL score at one month (p=0.01) and a significantly lower IPSS score at one and 12 months (p=0.034 and p=0.018, respectively) than the LUTS cohort. During all followup visits, the UR group had a significantly higher PVR than the LUTS cohort. The successful first trial of void (TOV) rate for the UR and LUTS groups was 81% and 83.2%, respectively. At 12 months postoperative, the catheter-free rate for the UR and LUTS cohorts was 96.3% and 99.4%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

HoLEP is an effective and durable treatment for UR with a high catheter-free rate and comparable outcomes when performed to manage LUTS.

Can we predict and manage persistent storage and voiding LUTS following bladder outflow resistance reduction surgery in men? ICI-RS 2023

AIMS

Lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) persist in up to 50% of patients after bladder outflow resistance reduction surgery (BORRS) in men. Our think tank aims to address the predictive factors for persistent LUTS after BORRS and to propose the recommendations for future research to enable improved better patient counseling and selection by more accurate prediction of treatment outcome.

METHODS

A think tank of ICI-RS gathered in 2023, Bristol, UK, to discuss the pre and postsurgical clinical and urodynamic evaluation of men undergoing BORRS and whether it is possible to predict which men will have persistent LUTS after BORRS.

RESULTS

Our think tank agrees that due to the multifactorial, and still not fully understood, etiology of male LUTS it is not possible to precisely predict in many men who will have persistent LUTS after BORRS. However, severe storage symptoms (overactive bladder, OAB) in association with low volume and high amplitude detrusor overactivity and low bladder capacity in preoperative urodynamics, increase the likelihood of persistent OAB/storage symptoms after BORRS. Furthermore, patients who are clearly obstructed and have good bladder contractility on preoperative pressure flow studies do better postoperatively compared to their counterparts. However, the benefit of pressure flow studies is decreased in patients who do not acceptably void during the study. Poor voiding after BORRS may occur due to persistent obstruction or detrusor underactivity.

CONCLUSION

Future research is needed to increase our understanding of why male LUTS persist after surgery, and to enable better patient selection and more precise patient counseling before BORRS.

Can we predict whether a man with acute or chronic urinary retention will void after bladder outflow resistance reduction surgery? ICI-RS 2023

AIMS

To address the predictive factors of a successful voiding after bladder outflow resistance reduction surgery (BORRS) in men presenting with acute or chronic urinary retention (UR).

METHODS

A think tank (TT) of ICI-RS was gathered in 2023, Bristol, UK, to discuss several aspects of the problem, such as the pathophysiology of UR, the clinical and urodynamic evaluation of men with UR and whether it is possible to predict which men will be able to successfully void after treatment with contemporary surgical options.

RESULTS

The TT agreed that successful voiding after BORRS depends on several factors but that a strong recommendation cannot be made regarding preoperative evaluation and whether there are predictive factors of success because of the heterogeneity of patients and methodology in published trials. The diagnosis of obstruction in men with UR may be challenging when there is apparent reduced detrusor contraction during urodynamic studies. Even in the absence of bladder contractility there is documentation of such cases that have voided adequately after BORRS. Still, detrusor underactivity and inadequate relief of prostatic obstruction are the main causes of an unsuccessful voiding after BORRS. Conventional resection and enucleation methods remain the most successful surgeries in relieving UR in men, whereas the efficacy of minimally invasive surgical treatments needs to be assessed further.

CONCLUSION

Research is needed to understand the pathophysiology of UR and the predictors of successful voiding after different types of BORRS in men with UR.

MRI-based radiomic features of the urinary bladder wall identify patients with moderate-to-severe international prostate symptom score

BACKGROUND

The International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) is a patient-reported measurement to assess the lower urinary tract symptoms of bladder outlet obstruction. Bladder outlet obstruction induces molecular and morphological alterations in the urothelium, suburothelium, detrusor smooth muscle cells, detrusor extracellular matrix, and nerves. We sought to analyze MRI-based radiomics features of the urinary bladder wall and their association with IPSS.

METHOD

In this retrospective study, 87 patients who had pelvic MRI scans were identified. A biomarker discovery approach based on the optimal biomarker (OBM) method was used to extract features of the bladder wall from MR images, including morphological, intensity-based, and texture-based features, along with clinical variables. Mathematical models were created using subsets of features and evaluated based on their ability to discriminate between low and moderate-to-severe IPSS (less than 8 vs. equal to or greater than 8).

RESULTS

Of the 7,666 features per patient, four highest-ranking optimal features were derived (all texture-based features), which provided a classification accuracy of 0.80 with a sensitivity, specificity, and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.81, 0.81, and 0.87, respectively.

CONCLUSION

A highly independent set of urinary bladder wall features derived from MRI scans were able to discriminate between patients with low vs. moderate-to-severe IPSS with accuracy of 80%. Such differences in MRI-based properties of the bladder wall in patients with varying IPSS's might reflect differences in underlying molecular and morphological alterations that occur in the setting of chronic bladder outlet obstruction.

The Use of Uroflowmetry as a Diagnostic Test

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Uroflowmetry is widely used for initial non-invasive evaluation of lower urinary tract disorders. Current clinical use is mostly restricted to a scrutiny of the maximum flow rate and uroflow pattern recorded by a conventional flowmeter in a health care facility. There are several advancements in our understanding and in available technologies that promise to transform clinical utilization of this simple test.

RECENT FINDINGS

Several aspects of the uroflow test in addition to maximum flow rate and uroflow pattern show potential diagnostic utility. This includes flow acceleration, uroflow indices, uroflow-electromyography including lag time, stop uroflow test, and uroflow-based nomograms. There are initial attempts to use artificial intelligence in analysis. There is also new data with regard to factors influencing variability of uroflow testing that might influence the diagnostic value in as yet uncertain ways including diurnal variability, postural variability, locational variability, and operator variability. There are new technologies for uroflow testing in a home environment allowing for easy repetition. However, there are several challenges owing to a paucity of clinical data and standardization. There are also critical lacunae in terminology that need to be addressed. There are exciting new advancements in the field of uroflowmetry. However, there is need to standardize and validate the newer uroflow tracing analyses and technologies.

Efficacy of GreenLight laser prostatectomy in urinary retention

INTRODUCTION

The objective of our study was to evaluate the efficacy and durability of GreenLight laser prostatectomy for the management of acute urinary retention (AUR) and chronic urinary retention (CUR) and to determine outcomes compared to patients without preoperative urinary retention (UR).

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective study of prospectively collected data from individuals who underwent GreenLight laser prostatectomy at our institution from May 2018 to July 2022. Patient demographics and outcome measures were recorded, including indications for the procedure, median urinary volume drained, or median postvoid residual urine volume (PVR) before catheterization or GreenLight laser prostatectomy. CUR was defined as PVR >300 mL in males able to void and initial catheter drainage >1000 mL in males unable to void in the absence of pain. All patients had postoperative followup visits at one, three, six, and 12 months. Our evaluation included the International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), quality-of-life (QoL) assessment, maximum urinary flow rate (Qmax), PVR, and catheter-free status.

RESULTS

One hundred sixty-eight males who underwent GreenLight laser prostatectomy were included in our study. The UR group consisted of 88 patients (50 AUR and 38 CUR), and the lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) group was comprised of 80 individuals. There were no statistically significant differences between the AUR and CUR subgroups regarding demographics. The UR group had a significantly higher age and a significantly higher postoperative catheterization time compared to the LUTS cohort. The CUR subgroup had a significantly higher PVR at one, three, and six months compared to the AUR subgroup, although other outcome measures were similar between the two cohorts. During three- and six-month followup visits, the UR group had a significantly higher PVR than the LUTS cohort. At 12 months postoperative, the LUTS group had a higher catheter-free rate than the UR group (p=0.001). The successful first trial of void (TOV) rate for the UR and LUTS groups were 83% and 80%, respectively. At 12-month followup, the catheter-free rate for the UR and LUTS cohorts was 87.5% and 100%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

GreenLight laser prostatectomy is an effective and durable treatment for UR, with a high catheter-free rate and comparable outcomes when performed to manage LUTS.

Nomogram predicting the efficacy of transurethral surgery in benign prostatic hyperplasia patients

PURPOSE

This study aimed to develop and validate a nomogram for predicting the efficacy of transurethral surgery in benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) patients.

METHODS

Patients with BPH who underwent transurethral surgery in the West China Hospital and West China Shang Jin Hospital were enrolled. Patients were retrospectively involved as the training group and were prospectively recruited as the validation group for the nomogram. Logistic regression analysis was utilized to generate nomogram for predicting the efficacy of transurethral surgery. The discrimination of the nomogram was assessed using the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) and calibration plots were applied to evaluate the calibration of the nomogram.

RESULTS

A total of 426 patients with BPH who underwent transurethral surgery were included in the study, and they were further divided into a training group (n = 245) and a validation group (n = 181). Age (OR 1.07, 95% CI 1.02-1.15, P < 0.01), the compliance of the bladder (OR 2.37, 95% CI 1.20-4.67, P < 0.01), the function of the detrusor (OR 5.92, 95% CI 2.10-16.6, P < 0.01), and the bladder outlet obstruction (OR 2.21, 95% CI 1.07-4.54, P < 0.01) were incorporated in the nomogram. The AUC of the nomogram was 0.825 in the training group, and 0.785 in the validation group, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The nomogram we developed included age, the compliance of the bladder, the function of the detrusor, and the severity of bladder outlet obstruction. The discrimination and calibration of the nomogram were confirmed by internal and external validation.

Predicting Prostate Surgery Outcomes from Standard Clinical Assessments of Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms To Derive Prognostic Symptom and Flowmetry Criteria

BACKGROUND

Assessment of male lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) needs to identify predictors of symptom outcomes when interventional treatment is planned.

OBJECTIVE

To develop a novel prediction model for prostate surgery outcomes and validate it using a separate patient cohort and derive thresholds for key clinical parameters.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

From the UPSTREAM trial of 820 men seeking treatment for LUTS, analysis of bladder diary (BD), International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), IPSS-quality of life, and uroflowmetry data was performed for 176 participants who underwent prostate surgery and provided complete data. For external validation, data from a retrospective database of surgery outcomes in a Japanese urology department (n = 227) were used.

OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

Symptom improvement was defined as a reduction in total IPSS of ≥3 points. Multiple logistic regression, classification tree analysis, and random forest models were generated, including versions with and without BD data.

RESULTS AND LIMITATIONS

Multiple logistic regression without BD data identified age (p = 0.029), total IPSS (p = 0.0016), and maximum flow rate (Qmax; p = 0.066) as predictors of outcomes, with area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) of 77.1%. Classification tree analysis without BD data gave thresholds of IPSS <16 and Qmax ≥13 ml/s (AUC 75.0%). The random forest model, which included all clinical parameters except BD data, had an AUC of 94.7%. Internal validation using the bootstrap method showed reasonable AUCs (69.6-85.8%). Analyses using BD data marginally improved the model fits. External validation gave comparable AUCs for logistic regression, classification tree analysis, and random forest models (all without BD; 70.9%, 67.3%, and 68.5%, respectively). Limitations include the significant number of men with incomplete baseline data and limited assessments in the external validation cohort.

CONCLUSIONS

Outcomes of prostate surgery can be predicted preoperatively using age, total IPSS, and uroflowmetry data, with prognostic thresholds of 16 for IPSS and 13 ml/s for Qmax.

PATIENT SUMMARY

This study identified key preoperative factors that can predict outcomes of prostate surgery for bothersome urinary symptoms, including which patients are at risk of a poor outcome.

Predictive factors for the success of trial without catheter for men with urinary retention

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the trial of spontaneous urination without catheter (TWOC) outcomes for men with acute urinary retention, determine successful TWOC predictors, and evaluate the impact of add-on medication therapy on TWOC.

METHODS

This retrospective study included men with acute urinary retention and post-void residual (PVR) >250 mL who underwent TWOC between July 2009 and July 2019. Patients were divided into a medicated group who received alpha1 blocker on urinary retention diagnosis and a naïve group who did not. The trial was defined as unsuccessful if the PVR was >150 mL or if the patient experienced difficulty emptying their bladder with abdominal discomfort or pain, and a transurethral catheter was reinserted.

RESULTS

Among 576 men with urinary retention, 269 (46.7%) constituted the medicated group and 307 (53.3%) the naïve. The naïve group comprised more elderly patients (P = 0.010) with higher Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status (PS) (P = 0.001) and smaller prostate volume (P = 0.028) than the other. In the medicated group, 153 men received additional oral medication before TWOC to increase the success rate. There were significant age differences (P = 0.041) in the medicated group and significant median PS differences (P = 0.010) in the naïve group between the successful and unsuccessful outcomes of TWOC. The multivariate logistic regression model demonstrated that age <80 years in medicated patients (P = 0.042, odds ratio [OR] 1.701) and PS <2 in naïve patients (P = 0.001, OR 2.710) were significant independent predictors of successful TWOC outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study classifying patients with urinary retention according to medication status. Both medicated and naïve groups had different patient backgrounds and TWOC outcome predictors, suggesting a discrepant etiology behind urinary retention. Hence, acute urinary retention management in men should vary based on medication status for male lower urinary tract symptoms when urinary retention is diagnosed.