Collagenase Clostridium histolyticum Treatment Improves Degree of Curvature in Peyronie's Disease with Calcified Plaques

Injection therapy in the acute phase of Peyronie's disease: a systematic review of current evidence

BACKGROUND

Injection therapy has emerged as a possible treatment for the acute phase of Peyronie's disease (PD).

AIM

To systematically review the current evidence on the efficacy and safety of injection therapy for patients in the acute phase of PD.

METHODS

A comprehensive bibliographic search on the MEDLINE, Scopus, and Web of Science Core Collection databases was conducted in June 2024. Articles were selected if they included patients with PD in acute phase (P) undergoing injection therapy (I) with or without comparison with other treatments (C), evaluating its efficacy or safety (O). Prospective and retrospective original studies were included (S). Articles were assessed for risk of bias using Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for randomized trials version 2, risk of bias in non-randomized studies-of interventions, and Joanna Briggs Institute critical appraisal tool. Data were synthesized narratively.

OUTCOMES

Primary outcomes were penile curvature, penile pain, and adverse events.

RESULTS

A total of 20 studies (1291 patients) were included, with 4 (20%) being randomized controlled trials. The mean/median duration of PD symptoms ranged from 2.0 to 18.6 months across the papers. The injectable agents tested included calcium channel blockers, hyaluronic acid, Collagenase Clostridium histolyticum, interferon, and corticosteroids. In most studies, improvements in penile curvature and pain were observed, with variable magnitude and in a varying percentage of patients. Adverse events were mostly mild and localized, including bruising, swelling, and ecchymosis. No severe complications were reported in any of the studies.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

Limited evidence support the feasibility of injection therapy for the acute phase of PD.

STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS

The first systematic review on injection therapy for acute PD. Low-to-intermediate quality and heterogeneous methodology of primary studies, impossibility of reliable quantitative data synthesis.

CONCLUSION

Injection therapy for the acute phase of PD demonstrates variable efficacy depending on the agent used and a relatively favorable safety profile; however, the overall quality of evidence remains low and is characterized by significant methodological limitations.

An illustrated description of a modified collagenase Clostridium histolyticum protocol for Peyronie's disease

BACKGROUND

Our team recently published outcomes of a novel technique for the administration of Collagenase Clostridium histolyticum (CCH), which resulted in improved curvature outcomes and reduced number of CCH injections required.

AIM

To provide a detailed and illustrated description of our CCH-administration technique.

METHODS

A descriptive summary is provided of the technique, including drug administration, protocol modifications, and post-treatment protocols. Additional details are provided on measurement techniques and disease classification.

OUTCOMES

Key outcomes include a written and illustrated description of the injection technique and pre-, and postinjection management.

RESULTS

The use of a modified CCH-administration technique has previously been shown to result in mean improvements of 54%-58% in penile curvature while significantly reducing the total number of injections applied. These findings represent the largest improvements published to date. Key aspects of the technique include back-to-back day administration of 0.9 mg suspended in 0.8 mL, application to an ~3 × 1 cm region, inclusion of the dorsal septum (exempting ventral curves), administration during a full erection (day 1), repeat artificial erections with the first injection of each series, in-office modeling (day 2), and post-treatment use of PDE5s and Restorex traction. Appropriate patient counseling on expectations and necessity of complying with all treatment protocols (including post-treatment wrapping) is critical to optimizing outcomes. Common side effects may include ecchymoses, hematomas, blood blisters, impacts on erections and penile sensation, bronzing of the skin, and skin scarring, while more severe complications are rare (<1%).

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

The current manuscript provides a more detailed description of previously published techniques to aid providers in implementation and to mitigate potential adverse events.

STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS

Strengths include reliance on the largest single-team series published on CCH outcomes, rigorous study methodology, prospective/sequential series, and step-wise improvements. Limitations include data obtained from a single center.

CONCLUSION

The current manuscript provides a detailed narrative and illustrated description of our current CCH-administration technique.

In vitro efficacy of intralesional Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum for the treatment of calcified Peyronie's disease plaques

Peyronie's disease (PD) is defined by penile plaque formation and curvature causing sexual dysfunction. The only FDA-approved intralesional treatment is Collagenase Clostridium histolyticum (CCh). CCh contains two collagenases, AUX1 and AUXII, that break down the type I and type III collagen contained in plaques, leading to plaque dissolution and reduction in penile curvature. Peyronie's plaques, however, also contain fibrin and calcium, which CCh cannot digest. It is unclear if plaque calcification prevents CCh from breaking down plaques. We collected ten tissue samples: five calcified penile plaques and five control samples of corpus cavernosum. They were incubated in CCh or PBS. Soluble collagen measurements and collagen staining assays were completed to measure tissue breakdown. Calcified plaques incubated in CCh showed significantly higher levels of soluble collagen (301.07 ug ± 21.28 vs. PBS: 32.82 ug ± 3.68, p = 0.02), and significantly lower levels of collagen (type I and III) compared to tissues incubated in PBS (0.12 ± 0.08, vs. 0.44 ± 0.17, p = 0.002). When comparing different tissues (calcified vs. control) incubated in CCh and PBS solutions, there were no significant differences in collagen staining or breakdown. Although higher collagen staining was seen in the calcified group, soluble collagen showed no significant differences between control and calcified tissues in the CCh group (control: 0.08 ± 0.02 vs. calcified: 0.17 ± 0.09, p = 0.08) or the PBS group (control: 0.50 ± 0.23 vs. calcified: 0.39 ± 0.39, p = 0.23). CCh exposure led to significantly more tissue breakdown in both tissue groups when compared to PBS however, there was no significant difference in plaque digestion found between calcified and control tissue exposed to CCh or PBS. This suggests that plaque calcification does not affect the action of CCh. Further research into CCh for calcified plaques is necessary to inform clinicians as to the optimal management of this population.

A conserved strategy to attack collagen: The activator domain in bacterial collagenases unwinds triple-helical collagen

Bacterial collagenases are important virulence factors, secreted by several pathogenic Clostridium, Bacillus, Spirochaetes, and Vibrio species. Yet, the mechanism by which these enzymes cleave collagen is not well understood. Based on biochemical and mutational studies we reveal that collagenase G (ColG) from Hathewaya histolytica recognizes and processes collagen substrates differently depending on their nature (fibrillar vs. soluble collagen); distinct dynamic interactions between the activator and peptidase domain are required based on the substrate type. Using biochemical and circular dichroism studies, we identify the presumed noncatalytic activator domain as the single-domain triple helicase that unwinds collagen locally, transiently, and reversibly.

Changes in Point of Maximal Curvature During Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum Injections for Peyronie's Disease

OBJECTIVE

To determine change in the point of maximal curvature (POMC) during Collagenase Clostridium histolyticum (CCH) injections for Peyronie's disease (PD).

METHODS

A prospective database has been maintained of all men undergoing CCH injections since March 2014. For the current study, data were abstracted on the POMC with each curve assessment and correlated with demographic and clinical factors. Maximal changes were defined as the largest change in POMC from baseline.

RESULTS

Six hundred and eighteen men underwent ≥1 series of CCH, with 313 having a baseline and subsequent POMC measurements available. Median baseline curvature was 60.0° and POMC 2.8 cm. Among 189 men who were satisfied or completed 8 CCH injections, the median improvement in penile curvature was -27.5° (40.9%). The median maximal change in POMC during CCH treatment was 1.0 cm (interquartile range, 0.5, 1.8). Overall, 55.6% had changes in POMC of ≥1 cm, 23.6% ≥2 cm, 8.9% ≥3 cm, and 3.8% ≥4 cm. Multivariate logistic regression identified ventral curvature as a predictor of larger change in POMC, after controlling for other variables. Study limitations included the observational, non-randomized study design and potential for intra- and inter-individual measurement variability. Strengths are the inclusion of an all-comer population, large series, prospective database, and routine objective assessments.

CONCLUSION

Approximately half of men with PD undergoing CCH experience ≥1 cm of change in POMC during the treatment course, with nearly 1/4 experiencing ≥2 cm. Findings suggest that patients may benefit from repeat curvature assessments with each CCH series to optimize accuracy of drug administration.

Expanded Utilization of Intralesional Therapies for Treatment of Peyronie's Disease

Purpose

In this narrative review we explore additional indications for which intralesional collagenase Clostridium histolyticum (CCH) injection therapy may be used, in addition to those utilized in the IMPRESS trials. The goal is to provide updated assessment of available intralesional therapies and justify whether to expand clinical indications based on advancements over the last decade.

Results

Patients receiving CCH in the acute phase of PD have shown significant improvement in penile curvature - which may be even more significant than reported due to progressive curvature over the longitudinal course of injection therapy. Across studies, patients with ventral plaques achieved the greatest curvature improvement (~30°) compared to PD patients with dorsal or lateral plaques. Patients with curvature > 90° have been minimally documented. However, the concept of patients with higher degree of curvature achieving more significant degrees of improvement prevails across studies. Studies including PD patients with volume loss deformities or indentation(s) focus on curvature improvement and do not gauge improvement in these girth loss or indentation features specifically. PD patients with calcification may benefit from CCH, however, critical analysis of included study designs and results compared to placebo do not lend for strong support of CCH in PD at this time.

Conclusion

Based on the most recent research, the use of CCH in the acute phase of PD and patients with ventral penile plaques may be effective and safe. The limited available research on the efficacy of CCH on calcified plaque(s) and curvature greater than 90° is promising, however, more research is needed to ensure safety and success in this patient cohort. Finally, the current literature continues to show the use of CCH is not effective in PD patients with volume loss, indentation, or hourglass deformity. When expanding the use of CCH to patients not originally included in the IMPRESS trials, providers must prioritize minimizing chances of potential injury to urethral tissue. Finally, further investigation is required to determine whether CCH has utility for curvature greater than 90° or calcified plaques, although the limited available literature is promising.