The Salto total ankle arthroplasty - Clinical and radiological outcomes at five years

Fixed-bearing versus mobile-bearing total ankle replacement survivorship. A meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Main objective of this research is to know if there is a different survival rate between fixed bearing (FB) and mobile bearing (MB) total ankle replacement (TAR). We hypothesized that there are no differences between the survival rates of both implants.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed in PubMed, Cochrane, EMBASE and ClinicalTrials.gov databases‎ to identify published studies from August 2018 to September 2022 including results for FB and MB TAR survivorship. Inclusion criteria included 1) primary TAR in one or both feet in which implant could be identified‎, 2) a minimum of 20 procedures reported, 3) reported implant survivorship or calculable and 4) a minimum of 12 months follow-up for level 1-3 studies or 60 months for level 4 studies.

RESULTS

3902 ankles in 28 studies were included. 719 were FB and 3104 MB with an overall survivorship of 94% (95% CI [0.89; 0.97]) and 89% (95% CI [0.86; 0.92]) respectively. After subgroup analysis, we did not find differences among both groups (p = ‎0.429‎). Meta-regression analysis showed that longer follow-up was associated with lower survival rates in MB group (p = 0.000) while no other relationships were found with other factors (age, level of evidence or conflict of interests).

CONCLUSIONS

No differences in survival rates between both groups were found. Age and other studied confounders were not found to be related with implant survivorship. However, longer follow-up was found to be related with lower survival rates. Studies with longer follow-up and higher level of evidence are needed to confirm results.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, systematic review of level I to IV studies.

Printable functionally graded tibial implant for TAR: FE study comparing implant materials, FGM properties, and implant designs

Tibial implants with functionally graded material (FGM) for total ankle replacement (TAR) can provide stiffness similar to the host tibia bone. The FGM implants with low stiffness reduce stress shielding but may increase implant-bone micromotion. A trade-off between stress shielding and implant-bone micromotion is required if FGMs are to substitute traditionally used Ti and CoCr metal implants. The FGM properties such as material gradation law and volume fraction index may influence the performance of FGM implants. Along with the FGM properties, the design of FGM implants may also have a role to play. The objective of this study was to examine FGM tibial implants for TAR, by comparing implant materials, FGM properties, and implant designs. For this purpose, finite element analysis (FEA) was conducted on 3D FE models of the intact and the implanted tibia bone. The tibial implants were composed of CoCr and Ti, besides them, the FGM of Ti and HA was developed. The FGM implants were modelled using exponential, power, and sigmoid laws. Additionally, for power and sigmoid laws, different volume fraction indices were taken. The effect of implant design was observed by using keel type and stem type TAR fixation designs. The results indicated that FGM implants are better than traditional metal implants. The power law is most suitable for developing FGM implants because it reduces stress shielding. For both power law and sigmoid law, low values of the volume fraction index are preferrable. Therefore, FGM implant developed using power law with 0.1 vol fraction index is ideal with the lowest stress shielding and marginally increased implant-bone micromotion. FGM implants are more useful for keel type fixation design than stem type design. To conclude, with FGMs the major complication of stress shielding can be solved and the longevity and durability of TAR implants can be enhanced.

Total Ankle Replacement Infections: A Systematic Review of the Literature

Periprosthetic infection (PJI) after TAR is a serious complication, often requiring further surgery, including revision arthroplasty, conversion to ankle arthrodesis, or even amputation. This systematic review aims to summarize the current evidence on the management of TAR PJI and provide a comprehensive overview of this topic, especially from an epidemiologic point of view. Three different databases (PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science) were searched for relevant articles, and further references were obtained by cross-referencing. Seventy-one studies met the inclusion criteria, reporting on cases of TAR PJI. A total of 298 PJIs were retrieved. The mean incidence of PJI was 3.8% (range 0.2-26.1%). Furthermore, 53 (17.8%) were acute PJIs, whereas most of them (156, 52.3%) were late PJIs. Most of the studies were heterogeneous regarding the treatment protocols used, with a two-stage approach performed in most of the cases (107, 35.9%). While the prevalence of ankle PJI remains low, it is potentially one of the most devastating complications of TAR. This review highlights the lack of strong literature regarding TAR infections, thus highlighting a need for multicentric studies with homogeneous data regarding the treatment of ankle PJI to better understand outcomes.

Prospective Multicenter Study of Salto Talaris Ankle Arthroplasty With Minimum 4-Year Follow-Up

BACKGROUND

Total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) continues to be investigated as a primary treatment for end-stage ankle arthritis. The objective of this study is to report mid- to long-term results of the Salto Talaris TAA using prospectively collected patient-reported outcomes and implant survival rates with 4- to 13-year follow-up.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study of prospectively collected data from 2 multicenter cohort studies from 3 centers. Three hundred fourteen subjects who received a Salto Talaris TAA from 2005 to 2015 were included in the study. Follow-up ranged 4-13 years following index procedure. Outcomes included 36-Item Short Form Health Survey (SF-36) mental and physical component summary scores, pain scores, and adverse events including additional surgeries, revision, or removal of components.

RESULTS

Significant improvements were seen in pain and physical function scores at 2-year follow-up and were generally maintained through most recent follow-up. The survival rate of the prosthesis was >95% (n = 30/32 at >10 years, n = 272/282 at 4.5-10 years). Thirteen patients (4.1%) underwent revision or removal of their prosthesis. Time to revision ranged from 2 months to 6.5 years following the index procedure. Twenty-two patients (7.0%) had additional surgery that did not involve revision or removal of components.

CONCLUSION

Treatment of end-stage ankle arthritis with this implant provided patients with improved pain and functional outcome scores at mid- to long-term follow-up. The significant improvements reported at 2-4 years appeared to endure through the extended follow-up period.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective cohort study.

Computed Tomography Derived Patient-specific Instrumentation Total Ankle Arthroplasty Survivorship Outcomes

Computed tomography (CT) derived patient-specific total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) systems have been utilized for improved accuracy and reproducible implant alignment. The purpose of the present study was to report the overall implant survivorship as well as radiographic analysis of patients who underwent primary TAA utilizing CT-derived patient-specific instrumentation. A retrospective review of medical charts and radiographs were performed on patients who had undergone primary TAA at a single institution in the Midwest region from March 2013 to October 2020. Radiographic analysis included preoperative, initial postoperative, and final follow-up coronal and sagittal tibiotalar alignment as well as periprosthetic radiolucency. A total of 96 patients with a mean follow-up of 3 years (range, 0.3-7.3 years) were included. Implant survivorship was found to be 92% at median follow-up of 3 years. A total of 8 cases (8.3%) required revision/reoperation, with 6 (6.3%) of these reoperations directly related for failure of one of the metallic implant components. There was significant improvement in both coronal and sagittal tibiotalar alignment from preoperative to initial postoperative follow-up (p < .001). At latest postoperative follow-up, there were 88% of TAAs that remained in a neutral alignment following surgery. A total of 10 cases were found to have radiolucency at latest follow-up. In conclusion, the use of CT derived patient-specific TAA showed high implant survivorship with significant improvement of sagittal and coronal tibiotalar alignment. With better implant alignment and position, it potentially reduces the risk of early implant failure or implant loosening in long-term follow-up.

Time to Revision After Periprosthetic Joint Infection in Total Ankle Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review

While not a common complication after total ankle arthroplasty (TAA), periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) presents a significant risk of implant failure. The primary aim of this systematic review was to evaluate time to revision after PJI in patients who had undergone TAA. An extensive search strategy via electronic databases initially captured 11,608 citations that were evaluated for relevance. Ultimately, 12 unique articles studying 3040 implants met inclusion criteria. The time to revision surgery due to PJI was recorded for each study and a weighted average obtained. The prevalence of PJI was 1.12% (n = 34). We found that the average time to revision due to PJI was 30.7 months, or approximately 2.6 years after the index TAA procedure. By literature definitions, the majority of cases (91.2%, n = 31) were beyond the "acute" PJI phase. The population was divided into 2 groups for further analysis of chronic infections. PJIs before the median were classified as "early" and those after as "late" chronic. The majority of cases (61.8%) were late chronic with an average time to revision of 44.3 months. A smaller number were early chronic (29.4%) with revision within 10.8 months. After summarizing the rates of infection and times to revision reported in the literature, we suggest modifying the current PJI classification to include early chronic and late chronic subgroups so that the total ankle surgeon is better prepared to prudently diagnose and treat PJIs.

Intermediate to long-term clinical outcomes and survival analysis of the Salto Mobile Bearing total ankle prothesis

INTRODUCTION

Osteoarthritis of the ankle is a major burden to affected patients. While tibio-talar arthrodesis has been the gold-standard regarding the treatment of osteoarthritis of the ankle joint for many years, at present total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) provides appealing clinical outcomes and is continually gaining popularity. The aim of this study was to evaluate the intermediate- to long-term clinical outcome including the survival rate of Salto Mobile Bearing TAA (Tonier SA, Saint Ismier, France).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In this retrospective study intermediate- to long-term outcomes measures [Ankle Range of Motion (ROM), American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Score (AOFAS score) and survival rate] of 171 consecutive TAA were analysed and compared before and after surgery. Revision was defined as secondary surgery with prothesis component removal, while reoperation was defined as a non-revisional secondary surgery involving the ankle.

RESULTS

At a mean follow-up (FU) period of 7.2 ± 2.7 years (range 2.0 to 14.1 years) there was a significant improvement in ankle ROM (total ROM improved from 25.0° ± 15.0° to 28.7° ± 11.3°, p = 0.015; plantarflexion improved from 18.4° ± 11.7° to 20.6° ± 8.2°, p = 0.044; dorsiflexion improved from 6.6° ± 5.7° to 8.1° ± 4.9°, p = 0.011). AOFAS score increased significantly by 41 ± 15 points after surgery (43.3 ± 11.1 before and 84.3 ± 12.0 after surgery, p < 0.001). Overall survival rate within the FU was 81.3% (95% CI 75.3% to 87.3%) with any secondary surgery, 89.9% (95% CI 84.1% to 93.6%) with revision and 93.6% (95% CI 89.8% to 97.3%) with reoperation as endpoint.

CONCLUSION

This study endorses the previously reported appealing intermediate- to long-term outcomes of the Salto Mobile Bearing TAA. There was a significant increase in ROM and AOFAS score as well as decent implant survival at final FU.

Intermediate to Long-Term Follow-up of the Salto Talaris Fixed-Bearing Total Ankle Prosthesis

BACKGROUND

Total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) remains a viable option for recalcitrant, end-stage ankle arthritis. Among the various Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved prosthetic options is the fixed-bearing Salto Talaris implant. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the intermediate to long-term clinical outcomes and radiographic complications following implantation of the Salto Talaris TAA.

METHODS

Nineteen Salto Talaris total ankle implants were included in the present retrospective study. Medical records were reviewed to determine pre- and postoperative visual analog scale (VAS) pain scores, and both medical records and radiographs were utilized to assess for complications. Telephone interviews were then conducted to assess for overall patient satisfaction.

RESULTS

At a mean follow of 6.9 years (range, 3.5-12 years), there was a 21% complication rate according to the classification system described by Glazebrook et al. The reoperation rate was low at 10.5%, and there was 100% survivorship of the total ankle implant. The average pain decreased from 9.1 (range, 7-10) preoperatively to 2.6 (range, 0-10) postoperatively. Patients reported a 95% satisfaction rate, and 16% of patients reported using a brace postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

The Salto Talaris arthroplasty was associated with low complication and reoperation rates, and a high survivorship at intermediate to long-term follow-up.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

4.

Post-operative management after total ankle arthroplasty: A systematic review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Currently, there is no consensus on the most appropriate post-operative management for patients undergoing total ankle arthroplasty. The aim of this study is therefore to offer a systematic review of the pertaining literature to identify current post-operative protocols and describe possible differences.

METHODS

A systematic review to identify recent studies concerning the post-operative management after total ankle arthroplasty was conducted. Five topics were analyzed: length of hospital stay, type and duration of immobilization, weight-bearing management, post-operative pharmacological therapies, adopted rehabilitation scheme.

RESULTS

Eighty-four studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in the review process. Most of the papers appear to have conflicting opinions with no consensus and homogeneous protocols.

CONCLUSION

Due to various methodological limitations, it is not possible to provide sufficiently supported evidence-based recommendations, and it is therefore difficult to determine the superiority of one post-operative protocol over the others after total ankle arthroplasty.

Revision Rates After Total Ankle Replacement: A Comparison of Clinical Studies and Arthroplasty Registers

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of total ankle replacement (TAR) regarding revision rates by comparing clinical studies of the last decade to data displayed in arthroplasty registers. The secondary aim was to evaluate whether dependent clinical studies show a superior outcome to independent publications. Additionally, revision rates of mobile bearing implants (MB-TARs) were compared to those of fixed bearing implants (FB-TARs).

METHODS

Clinical studies on TARs between 2010 and 2020 were systematically reviewed, with the endpoint being a revision for any reason. The parameter "revision rate per 100 observed component years (CYs)" was calculated for each publication. The pooled revision rate for clinical studies was compared to the data reported in arthroplasty registers. In a second step, revision rates were subdivided and analyzed for independent and dependent publications and for FB-TARs and MB-TARs.

RESULTS

A total of 43 publications met the inclusion criteria comprising 5806 TARs. A revision rate of 1.8 per 100 observed CYs was calculated, corresponding to a 7-year revision rate of 12.6%. The 3 arthroplasty registers included showed revision rates ranging from 8.2% to 12.3% after 7 years. No significant difference between dependent and independent publications nor between FB-TARs and MB-TARs was detected.

CONCLUSION

Revision rates of clinical studies and arthroplasty registers are comparable. Surgeons can compare their own revision rates with those from this study. Dependent studies do not seem to be biased, and no superiority for one bearing type can be described.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, systematic review of level III studies.

Three-Year Rates of Reoperation and Revision Following Mobile Versus Fixed-Bearing Total Ankle Arthroplasty: A Cohort of 302 Patients with 2 Implants of Similar Design

BACKGROUND

Currently, the implants utilized in total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) are divided between mobile-bearing 3-component and fixed-bearing 2-component designs. The literature evaluating the influence of this mobility difference on implant survival is sparse. The purpose of the present study was therefore to compare the short-term survival of 2 implants of similar design from the same manufacturer, surgically implanted by the same surgeons, in fixed-bearing or mobile-bearing versions.

METHODS

All patients were enrolled who underwent TAA with either the mobile-bearing Salto (Tornier and Integra) or the fixed-bearing Salto Talaris (Integra) in 3 centers by 2 surgeons between January 2004 and March 2018. All patients who underwent TAA from January 2004 to April 2013 received the Salto implant, and all patients who underwent TAA after November 2012 received the Salto Talaris implant. The primary outcome was time, within 3 years, to first all-cause reoperation, revision of any metal component, and revision of any component, including the polyethylene insert. Secondary outcomes included the frequency, cause, and type of reoperation.

RESULTS

A total of 302 consecutive patients were included, of whom 171 received the mobile-bearing and 131 received the fixed-bearing implant. The adjusted hazard ratio for all-cause reoperation was 1.42 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.67 to 3.00; p = 0.36); for component revision, 3.31 (95% CI, 0.93 to 11.79; p = 0.06); and for metal component revision, 2.78 (95% CI, 0.58 to 13.33; p = 0.20). A total of 31 reoperations were performed in the mobile-bearing group compared with 14 in the fixed-bearing group (p = 0.07). More extensive reoperation procedures were performed in the mobile-bearing group.

CONCLUSIONS

With the largest comparison of 2 implants of similar design from the same manufacturer, the present study supports the use of a fixed-bearing design in terms of short-term failure. We found a 3-times higher rate of revision among mobile-bearing implants compared with fixed-bearing implants at 3 years after TAA. Reoperations, including first and subsequent procedures, tended to be less common and the causes and types of reoperations less extensive among fixed-bearing implants.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Establishing a New Patient-Specific Implantation Technique for Total Ankle Replacement: An In Vitro Study

BACKGROUND

Revision rates after total ankle replacements (TARs) are higher compared with other total joint replacements. The present study aimed to establish a new patient-specific implantation (PSI) technique for TAR.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 10 complete Caucasian cadaver legs had whole leg computed tomography scans. The individual geometrical ankle joint axis was determined, and based on this axis, the position of the prosthesis was planned. We assessed prosthesis placement, guiding block position, and preoperative and postoperative ankle rotational axes.

RESULTS

The guiding block position interobserver reliability was 0.37 mm 0.45 (mean ± SD) for the tibial guiding block. The value for the first talar guiding block was 1.72 ± 1.3 mm and for the second talar guiding block, 0.61 ± 0.39 mm. The tibial slope as well as the frontal angles of the anatomical tibial axis compared to the tibial and talar articular surfaces showed no statistically relevant differences with numbers available. The deviation of the assessed preoperative joint axis to the postoperative joint axis was 14.6° ± 7.8.

CONCLUSION

The present study describes the results of an establishing process of a new PSI technique for TAR. The reliability of guiding block positioning and, thereby, prosthesis placement is sufficient.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Biomechanical study.

Six year results of the Rebalance mobile bearing total ankle replacement

BACKGROUND

We report the outcomes of a prospective consecutive series of 267 total ankle replacements (TARs) using a new mobile bearing Rebalance® prosthesis.

METHODS

Between April 2011 and December 2018, 267 consecutive Rebalance® prostheses were implanted in 255 patients at 3 different centers. Estimated survival curves with 95% confidence intervals were produced with the Kaplan-Meier method. 110 ankles were followed for at least 5 years and clinical and radiological outcomes were assessed in 92 of these ankles.

RESULTS

Twenty-one ankles were revised at a mean of 34 (7-60) months. The estimated survival was 90% (95% CI 86-95) at 5 years and 88.3% (95% CI 83.-94 at 6 years. The ankles followed for at least 5 years demonstrated a median Likert score of 1 (1-4). Radiolucent zones were detected in 14% and osteolytic cysts in 3%.

CONCLUSION

The survival rate of the Rebalance prosthesis conforms with other reports of similar designs. The satisfaction rate was high. Radiological zones and osteolytic cysts were found at a lower rate than usually reported for mobile bearing TARs. These results favour further use of this implant.

Quality measure of total ankle replacement outcomes in a non-designer centre

Background

Total ankle replacement (TAR) is a high-risk procedure with significant revision rates, post-op complications and implant failures. Long term follow-up data is less available for TAR compared to other joint replacement surgeries. To identify optimal follow-up parameters for patients with TAR, we conducted a study on the clinical outcomes and patient-reported outcome measurements (PROMs) in patients who had TAR performed in a non-designer's centre belonging to one of the hospitals of East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust (ELHT).

Methods

60 TAR procedures were identified. Clinical outcomes being studied include post-op ankle range of movement (ROM), American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) Ankle-Hindfoot scores, reoperation/revision rates, radiological parameters and general surgical outcomes. A Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was also conducted. PROMs data included the EQ-5D index and the Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOX-FQ).

Results

Ankle range of movement and AOFAS scores improved from pre-op to post-op with statistical significance. The reoperation rate and revision rate were 3.3% and 8.3% respectively. 5-year survival of implant was 97.3% and 10-year survival was 84.2%. Overall PROMs data showed improvement from pre-op to post-op.

Conclusion

The clinical outcomes of TARs were comparable with conventional literature. Improvements in clinical, radiological and patient-reported outcomes were observed from pre-op to post-op. Further follow-up studies are required to assess the long-term survival of implants.