Length change pattern of the ankle deltoid ligament during physiological ankle motion

The Anatomy and Function of the Individual Bands of the Deltoid Ligament—and Implications for Stability Assessment of SER Ankle Fractures

Background:

Deltoid ligament injury occurs often with supination-external rotation (SER) ankle trauma. SER fibula fractures with concomitant deltoid ligament injury are considered unstable—requiring operative fixation. Recent studies have questioned this general practice with emphasis on better defining the medial side ankle ligamentous injury. The function of the individual bands of the deltoid ligament, and the interplay between them, are not fully understood. We undertook this study to develop a better understanding of these complex ligamentous structures and ultimately aid assessment and treatment choice of SER ankle fractures with concomitant deltoid ligament injuries.

Methods:

Ten fresh-frozen cadaveric foot and ankle specimens were studied. We identified the various ligament bands and did a functional analysis by assessment of ligament length and tension at predefined angles of ankle dorsi-plantarflexion combined with valgus/varus and rotation. The results were determined by manual evaluation with calipers and goniometers, manual stress, and direct visualization.

Results:

We recorded primarily 5 different bands of the deltoid ligament: the tibionavicular (TNL; 10/10) tibiospring (TSL; 9/10), tibiocalcaneal (TCL; 10/10), deep anterior tibiotalar (dATTL; 9/10), and deep posterior tibiotalar (dPTTL; 10/10) ligaments. The tibiospring ligament was tense in plantarflexion, while the tibiocalcaneal and deep posterior tibiotalar ligaments were tense in dorsiflexion. The superficial layer ligaments and the deep anterior tibiotalar ligament length and tension were largely affected by changes in varus/valgus and rotation. The deep posterior tibiotalar ligament length and tension was altered predominantly by changes in dorsi-plantarflexion; varus/valgus positioning had a minor effect on this band.

Conclusions:

We confirmed the finding of previous studies that dorsi-plantarflexion affects the tensile engagement of the separate ligament bands differently. Likewise, combined movements with varus/valgus and rotation seem to affect the separate ligament bands differently. Our results suggest that the TNL, TSL, and dATTL are at risk of injury, whereas the TCL and particularly the dPTTL are protected in the event of an SER-type ankle fracture mechanism of injury.

Level of Evidence

Level V, cadaveric study.