Open, Arthroscopic, and Percutaneous Cheilectomy for Hallux Rigidus

First metatarsophalangeal joint arthroscopy: Unearthing clinical evidence - A systematic review

PURPOSE

Arthroscopy of the first metatarsophalangeal joint (1 MTP) has gained increasing attention in the last two decades. Despite numerous studies describing the surgical technique, only a few provide clinical or radiological outcome data. This systematic review aimed to analyze studies presenting objectively measurable clinical outcomes of patients who underwent 1 MTP arthroscopy as the primary procedure, categorizing results by indication pathology.

METHODS

Following PRISMA guidelines, PubMed and Cochrane databases were searched for studies reporting outcomes of primary 1 MTP arthroscopy, regardless of underlying pathology. The selected articles were thoroughly assessed to extract data regarding the demographics of included patients, pathology, preoperative and postoperative clinical and radiological outcomes, complications, and reinterventions.

RESULTS

Fourteen articles, involving 405 patients (419 halluces), were included. Common indications were hallux valgus and hallux rigidus. Notably, Hallux Valgus Angle improved from 28.9° to 12.7°, and Intermetatarsal Angle improved from 13.8° to 9.2°, where reported. In hallux rigidus patients, range of motion increased from 25.15° to 71.3° post-surgery. Temporary or permanent sensory loss occurred in 3% of treated halluces, with 4.28% requiring reoperation.

CONCLUSIONS

Evidence on 1 MTP arthroscopy as the primary procedure is limited. It is most effective for hallux rigidus, while in hallux valgus cases, it can achieve satisfactory angular corrections but has a relatively high recurrence and reoperation rate. Although this technique is generally safe, further research should compare it with traditional surgical approaches to provide comprehensive insights.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Treatment of hallux rigidus with percutaneous metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis: a case series with a minimum follow-up of 2 years

BACKGROUND

Percutaneous metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis is an option for the treatment of hallux rigidus in more advanced cases. The aim of this study was to investigate the clinical and radiographic results at least 2 years after percutaneous metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis in patients with hallux rigidus.

METHODS

This is a case series of consecutive patients undergoing percutaneous metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis in patients with hallux rigidus grades III and IV with a minimum of 24 months of clinical and radiographic follow-up. The primary outcome was clinical assessment using the Visual Analog Scale for Pain (VAS). Secondary outcomes included American Orthopedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, patient satisfaction, complications, and bone healing (radiographic analysis).

RESULTS

Between August 2017 and February 2020, 29 feet (24 patients) underwent percutaneous metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis. The mean follow-up was 38.4 (range 24-54) months. There was an improvement in the pain (VAS) from 7.8 to 0.6 (p < 0.001) and in the AOFAS score from 49.9 to 83.6 (p < 0.001). There was a rate of bone union of 82.8% and screw removal of 13.8%. All patients considered the result to be excellent or good.

CONCLUSION

The treatment of grade III and IV hallux rigidus with percutaneous metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis demonstrated high patient satisfaction and significantly improves in clinical outcomes but the nonunion rate was higher than reported outcomes for open 1st metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, case series.

Percutaneous arthroscopically assisted cheilectomy combined to percutaneous proximal phalanx osteotomy in hallux rigidus: Clinical and radiological outcomes in 30 feet at a 48-month follow-up

BACKGROUND

Hallux rigidus is a degenerative condition affecting the middle age population. It affects patients by limiting their first metatarsophalangeal range of motion (ROM) and also, their shoe wear. The objective of our work was to present an original operative technique which preserves the native joint and improves pain with minimal complications.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective multicenter cohort study of 28 patients (30 feet) suffering from moderate hallux rigidus, operated between October 2010 and October 2017 with at least 48months of follow-up. Clinical and radiological assessments included pre- and postoperative ROM, the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score and forefoot radiological evaluation. No patients were lost to follow-up.

RESULTS

The mean AOFAS score increased from 59 (range, 51 to 67) preoperatively to 84 (range, 80 to 88) at final follow-up. A total of 37 patients (97%) were satisfied. From a ROM point of view, this remained relatively unchanged between preoperative and postoperative values.

CONCLUSION

The percutaneous arthroscopically assisted cheilectomy combined with a percutaneous proximal phalanx osteotomy, significantly improves pain in hallux rigidus with index minus in patients with Coughlin stage I and II after a mean of 4-year follow-up.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Dorsal Cheilectomy Using Great Toe Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthroscopy for the Treatment of Hallux Rigidus

Great toe metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthroscopy has been described in the literature for more than 50 years for treatment of a multitude of first MTPJ pathologies, including hallux rigidus, hallux valgus, and osteochondritis dissecans, among others. Despite this, the use of great toe MTPJ arthroscopy has not become widely used for treatment of these conditions as the result of reported difficulties with adequate visualization of the joint surface and manipulation of surrounding soft-tissue structures with the instruments available. We propose a simple technique with illustrations of the operating room setup and procedural steps to perform a dorsal cheilectomy in those with early-stage hallux rigidus using great toe MTPJ arthroscopy and a minimally invasive surgical burr in a way that is reproducible by foot and ankle surgeons.

Needle Arthroscopy Cheilectomy for Hallux Rigidus in the Office Setting

Hallux rigidus is a progressive degenerative process of the first metatarsophalangeal joint characterized by altered joint mechanics and formation of dorsal osteophytes. Cheilectomy is the preferred operative intervention at early stages. Technologic advances, patient preference, and cost considerations combine to stimulate the development of minimally invasive and in-office interventions. This Technical Note highlights our technique for needle arthroscopy cheilectomy for hallux rigidus, which can be used either in the operating room or in the wide-awake office setting.

Hallux rigidus - Osteoarthritis of the first MTP-joint. Surgical and patient-reported results from Swefoot

BACKGROUND

Swefoot is a Swedish national registry, that covers surgery in the foot and ankle. Surgical treatment of hallux rigidus (HR) vary within and between countries. The aim of this study was to report baseline variables for patients with HR.

METHODS

We extracted baseline characteristics, surgical procedures and patient-reported data for patients with HR entered in the registry during the period January 2014 to August 2019.

RESULTS

By August 2019, 1818 patients were reported in the registry. 68.9% of the patients were women, the average age was 58 years, the mean BMI was 26.4kg/m². 41.9% of the patients underwent a cheilectomy,19.8% a metatarsal osteotomy, 34.3% a fusion, 0.2% an arthroplasty, 0.3% Keller's procedure and 3.5% other methods. The preoperative summary score for SEFAS (Self-reported Foot and Ankle Score) was 26 and for EQ-5D (Euroqol-5 Dimension) 0.60.

CONCLUSION

This study is the first report from Swefoot regarding HR.

Great Toe Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthroscopy: Simple Technique for Painful Nonunion

Great toe metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) arthroscopy was first described as a viable technique for a multitude of first MTPJ pathologies in the early 1970s; however, with improving arthroscopic technique and technology, these indications will continue to expand. Arthroscopy of the first MTPJ has increasingly become a new pursuit for foot and ankle specialists. Therefore, we have proposed a simple technique and illustration from our operating room setup to traction and to our procedural technique to make great toe arthroscopy simple and reproducible for arthroscopic foot and ankle surgeons.

Minimally Invasive Dorsal Cheilectomy and Hallux Metatarsal Phalangeal Joint Arthroscopy for the Treatment of Hallux Rigidus

Background:

Hallux rigidus (HR) is a common source of forefoot pain and disability. For those who fail nonoperative treatment, minimally invasive dorsal cheilectomy (MIDC) is an increasingly popular alternative to the open approach with early positive results. Early failures may be due to lose bone debris from the MIDC as well as other intra-articular pathology that cannot be addressed with MIDC alone. Metatarsophalangeal (MTP) arthroscopy can be used in addition to MIDC to assess the joint after MIDC and address any intra-articular pathology while still maintaining the benefits of minimally invasive surgery. We report our clinical outcomes following MIDC combined with MTP arthroscopy.

Methods:

From November 2017 to July 2020, a retrospective analysis of all MIDC cheilectomies with MTP arthroscopy performed by the 2 senior authors was done. Wound complications, infections, revision rates, need for future surgery, conversion to fusion rates, pre- and postoperative range of motion, visual analog scale (VAS) scores, time to return to normal shoe, intraoperative arthroscopic findings, and operative time were collected. Follow-up average was 16.5 months (range 3-33 months).

Results:

A total of 20 patients were included with an average follow-up of 16.5 months. The average VAS score improved from 7.05 preoperatively to 0.75 postoperatively ( P < .05). Average range of motion in dorsiflexion increased from 32 to 48 degrees ( P < .05) and plantarflexion increased from 15 to 19 degrees plantarflexion ( P < .05). All patients were weightbearing as tolerated immediately after surgery in a postoperative shoe and transitioned to a regular shoe at average of 2.1 weeks. We had no wound infections, wound complications, revision surgeries, tendon injuries or nerve damage. One patient required conversion to a fusion 3 years after the index procedure. Average tourniquet time was 30.39 minutes (range 17-60 minutes) and total average operating room time was 59.7 minutes (range 40-87 minutes). On arthroscopic evaluation of the MTP joint after MIDC, 100% of patients had bone debris, 100% had synovitis, 10% had loose bodies, and 30% had large cartilage flaps within the joint.

Conclusion:

MIDC and first MTP joint arthroscopy for treatment of hallux rigidus provide improved pain relief with minimal complications while still maintaining the benefits touted for minimally invasive operative procedures. Additionally, we have shown a high rate of intra-articular debris along with intra-articular pathology such as synovitis, loose chondral flaps, and loose bodies that exist after MIDC. This combined procedure has the potential for improving patient outcomes and may minimize risk of future revision surgeries compared with MIDC alone.

Level of Evidence:

Level IV, case series study.

Percutaneous Techniques in Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Surgery

This article presents the indications, contraindications, preoperative surgical planning, surgical technique, and postoperative management of some of the most common percutaneous procedures in orthopedic foot and ankle surgery. The background of each procedure also is presented, supported by the latest in published literature to educate surgeons. Such topics include percutaneous bunionectomy, lesser toe deformity and bunionette correction, calcaneal osteotomy, cheilectomy, and first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis.

Intermediate-term results of isolated minimally invasive arthroscopic cheilectomy in the treatment of hallux rigidus

AIM

The aim of this study was to determine the intermediate-term results of minimally invasive cheilectomy of the first MTPJ using a high-torque low-speed burr and arthroscopic debridement.

METHODS

A consecutive series of patients who underwent isolated unilateral minimally invasive cheilectomy of the first MTPJ were contacted by telephone. A questionnaire was used to assess patient satisfaction and complications. Patients with less than 2 years of follow-up were excluded.

RESULTS

Thirty-six patients completed the study. Mean patient age at time of surgery was 50.0 years (range 24.5-67.0). Mean follow-up was 4.69 years (range 2.0-7.3). Thirty patients (83%) reported they would recommend the procedure. Mean postoperative improvement in pain was 69% (range 0-100). Twenty-seven (84%) of patients reported either no pain (28%) or mild pain (56%). For patients who reported any pain, the mean pain experienced was rated as 3.4 out of 10 (range 1-9). Twenty-nine (81%) patients reported they could wear a 'fashionable' shoe postoperatively. One patient experienced a delayed rupture of the extensor hallucis longus at 6 months postsurgery. One patient underwent further arthroscopic cheilectomy. No patient required conversion to fusion of the first MTPJ.

CONCLUSION

Minimally invasive cheilectomy of the first MTPJ using high-torque low-speed burr and arthroscopic debridement results in high patient satisfaction with a low rate of complications at intermediate follow-up.

Comparison of Complication and Reoperation Rates for Minimally Invasive Versus Open Cheilectomy of the First Metatarsophalangeal Joint

BACKGROUND

Dorsal cheilectomy of the first metatarsophalangeal joint is an accepted treatment to alleviate dorsal impingement, pain, and reduced dorsiflexion in hallux rigidus. Traditionally performed via an open incision, this procedure has more recently been performed using minimally invasive techniques despite limited supportive published evidence.

METHODS

From December 2012 through December 2017, a retrospective analysis of all cheilectomies performed in our institution was done. The surgical technique was recorded along with any subsequent procedures performed for either persistent or recurrent pain, and complications were also noted. A comparison between open and minimally invasive outcomes was performed. In total, 171 cheilectomies were performed during this period. There were 38 open and 133 minimally invasive procedures.

RESULTS

At a mean 3-year follow-up, the reoperation rates of the 2 groups were different with only 1 (2.6%) of the open group requiring a fusion, while 17 (12.8%) of the minimally invasive surgical (MIS) group required further surgery (relative risk, 4.86; P = .059). In the open group, there was 1 (2.6%) complication, compared with 15 (11.3%) in the minimally invasive group (relative risk, 4.29; P = .076).

CONCLUSION

While patients may opt for MIS cheilectomy with a proposed faster recovery time and better cosmesis, they should be counseled about the risks and benefits of both methods, and that the technique of MIS cheilectomy utilized in this study appears to have an increased relative risk of requiring a further procedure.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective comparative series.

Clinical Outcomes Following Minimally Invasive Dorsal Cheilectomy for Hallux Rigidus

BACKGROUND:

Following failure of conservative treatment, a dorsal cheilectomy can be performed for patients in early stages of hallux rigidus by a traditional open approach or by a minimally invasive technique. We report our clinical outcomes following minimally invasive dorsal cheilectomy (MIDC).

METHODS:

Eighty-nine patients (98 feet) with symptomatic hallux rigidus treated between 2011 and 2016 were included in this study. The average age was 54 years. Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOxFQ) scores and visual analog scale (VAS) pain scores were collected. The mean follow-up was 50 months.

RESULTS:

The average VAS score improved from 8.0 preoperatively to 3 postoperatively. The mean MOxFQ summary index score decreased from 58.6 preoperatively to 30.5 postoperatively. All 3 MOxFQ domains also improved. Swelling took an average of 5.3 weeks to settle. There were 2 wound infections and 2 delayed wound healings. Two patients had transient nerve paraesthesia, while 2 patients had permanent numbness in the dorsomedial cutaneous nerve distribution. Twelve patients (12%) underwent reoperation, of which 7 had a first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis for ongoing pain, 4 had repeat cheilectomy for residual impingement, and 1 had an open removal of loose bone.

CONCLUSION:

Our results suggest that MIDC resulted in improvement in patient-reported outcome measures and was a safe technique with minimal complications. The complications were similar to open cheilectomy. There was an associated learning curve as 5 of our reoperations were due to incomplete cheilectomy. Coughlin grade 1 did well with MIDC as with open cheilectomy as none went onto an arthrodesis. However, 10% (7/65) of our grade 2 and 3 cases went on to an arthrodesis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE:

Level IV, retrospective case series.

A Consecutive Case Series of 166 First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Fusions Using a Combination of Cup and Cone Reamers and Crossed Cannulated Screws

Fusion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) is the reference standard surgery for significant hallux rigidus. A number of different techniques for first MTPJ fusion have been reported. We describe our technique of first MTPJ fusion using cup and cone reamers for joint surface preparation and 2 crossed cannulated screws for fixation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the single largest series using this technique. The present study reports on a single-surgeon, consecutive series of 166 consecutive cases in 147 patients who had undergone first MTPJ fusion. The demographic data and comorbidities of the patients were collected from the digital medical records, and the radiographs were evaluated by 2 of us (S.Q., M.A.) independently to document fusion status. Radiologic nonunion was seen in 11 of 166 cases (6.6%). The mean duration of follow up was 60 ± 29.5 (minimum 26, maximum 183) days. However, only 4 of the 11 cases (36%) of nonunion were clinically symptomatic and underwent revision using a bone graft and locking plate. A statistically significant difference was found in union rates among males and females (p = .01). Other factors, such as diabetes (p = .2), inflammatory arthritis (p = .5), steroids (p = .6), smoking (p = .5), hallux valgus deformity (p = .5), and concomitant forefoot surgery, did not have a statistically significant (p = .3) effect on union in our study. The union rate of first MTPJ fusion with our technique was comparable to that of others, with the advantage of being simple and less expensive compared with the use of a plate.

[Minimally invasive cheilectomy]

OBJECTIVES

Treatment of hallux rigidus by minimally invasive resection of the dorsal osteophytes, synovectomy and resection of the dorsal part of the metatarsal head.

INDICATIONS

Hallux rigidus grades II and III CONTRAINDICATIONS: End-stage osteoarthritis of the first metatarsophalangeal joint with beginning ankylosis.

SURGICAL TECHNIQUE

Osteophytes around the metatarsophalangeal joint are removed using a 1 cm incision dorsomedial, approximately 3 cm proximal of the joint space. The dorsal third of the metatarsal head is resected with a burr to improve dorsiflexion. The extent of bone resection is checked with an image intensifier. Loose bone fragments removed with a rangeur. An arthroscopy can be performed to check the completeness of bone resection, the irrigation of the joint and, if needed, to extend the synovectomy.

POSTOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT

Removal of the sutures after 2 weeks. Depending on pain, the patient can change from the postoperative shoe to a normal soft, comfortable and wide shoe after 1-2 weeks. Nonsteroidal drugs can be prescribed as needed. Active and passive mobilization of the metatarsophalangeal joint is also recommended.

RESULTS

The technique allows a soft-tissue-preserving resection of the osteophytes and a partial resection of the metatarsal head. The main advantages are limited soft-tissue trauma and rapid rehabilitation. In all, 21 women and 17 men with hallux rigidus stages II and III (Vanore) underwent surgery. Minimum follow-up was 12 months. In 1 patient, injury of the extensor hallucis longus tendon was observed. Two patients underwent revision surgery. One patient was converted to a metatarsophalangeal fusion, while another patient received a resection arthroplasty. At the latest follow-up, the AOFAS (American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society) score averaged 88.7 points.

Ultrasound-guided arthroscopic management of hallux rigidus

Introduction

The use of metatarso-phalangeal joint arthroscopy in the treatment of osteochondritis dissecans was first described in 1988. The technique produces good results. However, it can be difficult to enter a joint when it is deformed by degenerative disease. Sonography is a modern visualisation modality which can be used in orthopaedic surgery.

Aim

To describe a method of intraoperative sonographic navigation during first metatarso-phalangeal joint arthroscopy.

Material and methods

The modality was used in 3 patients. The joint was visualised in the ultrasound scanner. After confirming the intra-articular position of the guide needle, a medial portal was established. The procedure started with the removal and vaporisation of the hypertrophic synovium. Gradual resection of the osteophytes was then carried out. The procedure was terminated after the ultrasound image showed that a smooth upper surface of the metatarsal head had been achieved.

Results

All 3 patients were satisfied with the procedure and function of the treated feet. Average surgery time was 81 min. No complications were found.

Conclusions

Mini-invasive treatment of hallux rigidus with sonography-guided arthroscopic cheilectomy appears to be a reproducible procedure leading to good clinical results. We encourage surgeons familiar with ultrasound visualisation of the joints to use the technique described in this paper in the arthroscopic treatment of hallux rigidus.