Clomiphene citrate intrauterine insemination (IUI) before gonadotropin IUI affects the pregnancy rate and the rate of high-order multiple pregnancies

Comparison of two cancellation strategies to lower the risk of multiple pregnancies in gonadotropin stimulated intrauterine insemination cycles

OBJECTIVE

To compare two cancellation policies in controlled ovarian stimulation-intrauterine insemination (COS-IUI) cycles to lower the risk of multiple pregnancies (MP).

DESIGN

We performed a bicentric retrospective cohort study in two academic medical centers: Angers (group A) and Besançon (group B) University Hospitals. We included 7056 COS-IUI cycles between 2011 and 2019. In group A, cancellation strategy was based on an algorithm taking into account the woman's age, the serum estradiol level, and the number of follicles of 14 mm or greater on ovulation trigger day. In group B, cancellation strategy was case-by-case and physician-dependent, based on the woman's age, number of follicles of 15 mm or greater, and the previous number of failed COS-IUI cycles, without any predefined cut-off. Our main outcome measures were the MP rate (MPR) and the live-birth rate (LBR).

RESULTS

We included 884 clinical pregnancies (790 singletons, 86 twins, and 8 triplets) obtained from 6582 COS-IUI cycles. MPR was significantly lower in group A compared with group B (8.1% vs 13.3%, P = 0.01), but LBR were comparable (10.8% vs 11.8%, P = 0.19). Multivariate logistic regression found the following to be risk factors for MP: the "cancellation strategy" effect (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 1.63, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.02-2.60) and the number of follicles of 14 mm or greater (aOR 1.39, 95% CI 1.16-1.66). Cycle cancellation rate for excessive response was significantly lower in group A compared with group B (1.3% vs 2.4%, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The use of an algorithm based on the woman's age, serum estradiol level and number of follicles of at least 14 mm on trigger day allows the MPR to be reduced without impacting the LBR.

Diminished Ovarian Reserve, Clomid, and Traditional Chinese Medicine: A Case Study

BACKGROUND

Infertility caused by diminished ovarian reserve (DOR) can result from an endocrinological imbalance. A rise in follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) and decrease in antral follicle count (AFC) for women age ≤35 can lower pregnancy rates to <5%, and increase miscarriage rates to >75%. Chinese medicine may improve FSH and AFC levels in patients with DOR. It is common for women to seek adjunctive Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) treatment with biomedical clomid treatment.

OBJECTIVE

This article reports the case of a female with DOR who had completed three multiple, serial clomid cycles from September to December 2005, and for whom clomid failed.

DESIGN SETTING AND PATIENT

This is a case study of a 34-year-old patient with a 5-year history of infertility caused by DOR. She was treated in a private practice in Bellevue, WA.

INTERVENTION

TCM treatment-including acupuncture and herbal therapy-lasted from from January 2007 to April 2007.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The main outcomes sought were improvements in this patient's reproductive hormone panel, including tests for FSH, estradiol, and AFC levels; in addition a pregnancy outcome was desired.

RESULTS

After 4 months of TCM treatment, the patient returned to biomedical care. Pregnancy was not achieved during three more clomid cycles, although she had improvements her levels of FSH (from 14.5 mIU/mL to 8.7 mIU/mL) and AFC (from 10-12 to 16-18 total). After 3 more cycles with clomid, her FSH level increased to 16.8 mIU/mL and her AFC level was <10.

CONCLUSIONS

After three failed clomid cycles, a patient with DOR had improved FSH and AFC levels when she received TCM treatment. However, this patient was still unable to conceive although three more clomid cycles were attempted. More research is needed to discern demographically which patients benefit best from multiple, serial clomid interventions. In addition, it is important to investigate more-integrative treatments for patients with DOR, including assisted reproductive techniques, acupuncture, and Chinese herbs.

Comparison of different starting gonadotropin doses (50, 75 and 100 IU daily) for ovulation induction combined with intrauterine insemination

Purpose

To prevent multiple pregnancies the goal of ovulation induction by gonadotropins is to achieve only mono-follicular development. The most important issue is therefore to determine the starting dose. The aim of this study is to compare three different starting doses of follitropin beta to assess the lowest effective dose.

Methods

We evaluated 92 cycles with ovarian stimulation for patients with unexplained infertility, anovulatory disorder or mild male factor. We prospectively divided patients into 50, 75 and 100 IU groups based on patients’ response to clomiphene citrate treatment.

Results

We performed 87 intrauterine inseminations (95 % of cycles with ovulation induction). Five cycles were cancelled. We achieved 15 pregnancies; total pregnancy rate was 18 %. Pregnancy rate was 22, 10 and 28 % in 50, 75 and 100 IU follitropin beta groups. The average number of follicles was 2.0 ± 0.8, 2.2 ± 1.1 and 2.5 ± 1.8 (ns), total dose of gonadotropins (IU) 483 ± 192, 600 ± 151 and 830 ± 268 (p < 0.001), respectively. We observed one case of twins in 75 and 100 IU treatment group, as well (25 % risk).

Conclusions

This study suggests that based on the dose which was chosen according to clomiphene citrate response, all treatment regimes were effective for ovulation induction. 50 IU of follitropin beta daily is the appropriate starting dose to support ovulation for clomiphene citrate-sensitive women. The disadvantage may be an increased risk of cycle cancellation due to low ovarian response. Daily doses 75 or 100 IU of rFSH increase total consumption of gonadotropins.

Strategies to reduce multiple pregnancies due to ovulation stimulation

OBJECTIVE

To review factors associated with high-order multiple births (HOMB) due to ovulation induction (OI) and the efficacy of strategies to reduce their occurrence.

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of published studies of OI with intrauterine insemination (IUI) where patient and cycle characteristics were fully documented.

RESULT(S)

High-order multiple pregnancies (HOMP) were positively related to use of high doses of gonadotropin, number of 7-10 mm preovulatory follicles, and E(2), and inversely related to age and number of treatment cycles. Strategies successful in reducing HOMP include: use of clomiphene (CC) before gonadotropins, minimal gonadotropin doses, cancellation for more than three follicles >10-15 mm, and aspiration of excess follicles. Depending on the strategy used, 5%-20% of cycles may be canceled but HOMP rates can be less than 2% and pregnancy rates can average 10%-20% per cycle. Pregnancy rates per patient need not be reduced if low doses are continued for 4-6 cycles.

CONCLUSION(S)

High-order multiple pregnancies due to OI can be reduced to 2% or less by less aggressive stimulation without reducing overall chances of pregnancy for most patients.

Risk factors for high-order multiple pregnancy and multiple birth after controlled ovarian hyperstimulation: Results of 4,062 intrauterine insemination cycles

OBJECTIVE

To determine factors responsible for high-order multiple pregnancy (HOMP) and high-order multiple births when multiple cycles of controlled ovarian hyperstimulation-IUI (COH-IUI) are performed.

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis.

SETTING

Private infertility clinic.

PATIENT(S)

Women (n = 2,272) who underwent 4,067 consecutive COH-IUI cycles.

INTERVENTION(S)

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

High-order multiple pregnancy rate, pregnancy rate (PR), and birth rate (PR) per cycle.

RESULT(S)

High-order multiple pregnancy was related to number of follicles of diameter > or = 10 mm, age, and treatment cycle. For age <32 years, HOMP was 6% for three to six follicles and 20% for seven or more follicles. For ages 32 to 37 years, HOMP was 5% for three to six follicles and 12% for seven or more follicles. In the first COH-IUI cycle, HOMP was 8% for three to six follicles and 15% for seven or more follicles. In the second cycle, HOMP did not occur unless there were more than six follicles. No HOMP occurred after the second cycle. Pregnancy rate did not increase significantly when there were more than four follicles. Continuing COH-IUI past the third cycle resulted in additional pregnancies in patients with one to eight follicles.

CONCLUSION(S)

High-order multiple pregnancy can be predicted by age and number of follicles of diameter > or = 10 mm. Controlled ovarian hyperstimulation is not necessary to achieve satisfactory overall pregnancy rates if ovulation induction is continued past the third cycle in low responders.

Insémination intra-utérine : état des lieux chez l’humain

Despite its being used for a long time, intrauterine insemination (i.u.i.) remains debated as to its precise place and efficacy among assisted reproductive technologies. Data issued from the French Health Ministry inquiries are strictly limited to the number of cycles and the pregnancies and births including the multiple ones. Concerning 2000, more than 44,000 cycles were registered with 8% deliveries per cycle and 12% multiple pregnancies. Apart from the cervical female infertility which is considered to have the best prognosis with i.u.i., literature data remain controversial with male and unexplained infertility. Prospective randomized studies are rather scarce, particularly when considering the inclusion of untreated control population. Meta-analyses have been published for ten years, which allowed to better define the place of i.u.i. in patient management. However one may notice that the sperm cut-off parameters for male infertility and the respective contribution of i.u.i. and ovulation treatment do not allow develop some evidence-based guidelines for i.u.i. good practice. Quite all meta-analyses modulated their conclusions by addressing the need for large randomized controlled studies. Such a need seems now quite reinforced since results were until now expressed as pregnancy rate per cycle or pregnancy rate per couple, whereas single live birth rate and drop out rate are claimed to be taken into account nowadays. Moreover the level of controlled hyperstimulation is highly questionable with both hyperstimulation ovary syndrome and multiple pregnancy risks. Patients facing with failed i.u.i. cycles may turn to i.v.f. or i.c.s.i.. Interestingly data coming from the French national register (FIVNAT) did not show major differences between couples turning to i.v.f. (i.c.s.i.) after previously failed i.u.i. cycles or using directly i.v.f. (i.c.s.i.). Moreover the prognostic as evaluated on pregnancy rate per cycle was unchanged between such patients, which does not support some selection of patients by i.u.i. failure. Thus, although i.u.i. seems likely a cost-effective treatment in infertile couples, the precise conditions of its management (spontaneous or stimulated cycle, mono-, pauci- or multi-follicular induction) remain to be assessed. Indeed large controlled randomized studies including untreated group are required even if such design might have a non negligible cost. However these rather common treatments do have a high cost and any effort to rationalise them will have some economical impact. Another practical approach, although less ambitious, might consist in developing a per cycle registry which should allow to precise the French practice at a large national level.