Development of sandwich and competitive ELISA formats to determine β-conglycinin: Evaluation of their performance to detect soy in processed food

Development of an indirect competitive ELISA based on the common epitope of fish parvalbumin for its detection

A common epitope (AGSFDHKKFFKACGLSGKST) of parvalbumin from 16 fish species was excavated using bioinformatics tools combined with the characterization of fish parvalbumin binding profile of anti-single epitope antibody in this study. A competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) based on the common epitope was established with a limit of detection of 10.15 ng/mL and a limit of quantification of 49.29 ng/mL. The developed ELISA exhibited a narrow range (71% to 107%) of related cross-reactivity of 15 fish parvalbumin. Besides, the recovery, the coefficient of variations for the intra-assay and the inter-assay were 84.3% to 108.2%, 7.4% to 13.9% and 8.5% to 15.6%. Our findings provide a novel idea for the development of a broad detection method for fish allergens and a practical tool for the detection of parvalbumin of economic fish species in food samples.

Comparison of competitive and sandwich immunochromatographic analysis in the authentication of chicken in meat products

Cheap chicken meat is often used as an undeclared substitute in meat products. In this study, two formats of the immunochromatographic assay (ICA) of immunoglobulins of class Y (IgY) as a biomarker for chicken authentication were developed. In both competitive ICA (cICA) and sandwich ICA (sICA), gold nanoparticles (GNP) were conjugated with anti-species antibodies. A simple procedure of sample preparation, which took only 30 min, was proposed. Test systems demonstrated high sensitivity and rapidity: visual limits of detection of IgY and assay durations were 12/14 ng/mL and 10/15 min for cICA and sICA, respectively. The absence of cross-reactivity with the mammalian species confirmed the high specificity of the test systems. Good applicability of the assays was confirmed for the detection of chicken in raw meat mixtures: as low as 3% and 0.2% (w/w) of chicken could be revealed in beef and pork by cICA and sICA, respectively. The influence of heat processing of meat-based products on immune recognition and, consequently, the analytical performance of the test systems was revealed. It was shown that sICA is preferable for the detection of IgY even in thermally processed meat. The proposed ICAs can be recommended for rapid on-site control of meat products' composition.

Influence of linoleic acid on the immunodetection of shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) tropomyosin and the mechanism investigation via multi-spectroscopic and molecular modeling techniques

The effect of linoleic acid (LA) on the IgG/IgE recognition, in vitro digestibility and immunodetection of shrimp tropomyosin (TM) was investigated. Subsequently, the simultaneous binding of LA-TM was explored using multi-spectroscopic and molecular modeling techniques. Our findings reveled that the addition of LA significantly reduced TM's IgG/IgE immunoreactivity, digestibility, and immunodetection. Further analysis using multi-spectroscopic and molecular modeling techniques indicated that while TM's secondary structure remained largely unchanged, its 3-D structure showed significant alterations such as increased particle size and hydrophobic surface area, and a higher number of buried hydrophobic residues exposed due to the binding of LA to TM. These structural changes rendered it difficult for target antibodies and digestive enzymes to interact with related epitopes and cleavage sites buried inside the molecule. The results obtained in this study provide valuable insights into the molecular mechanism of poor immunodetection caused by food matrix interference.

Assessment of the Efficiency of Technological Processes to Modify Whey Protein Antigenicity

Whey is a by-product that represents a cheap source of protein with a high nutritional value, often used to improve food quality. When used as a raw material to produce hypoallergenic infant formulas (HIF), a processing step able to decrease the allergenic potential is required to guarantee their safe use for this purpose. In the present paper, thermal treatments, high hydrostatic pressure (HHP), and enzymatic hydrolysis (EH) were assessed to decrease the antigenicity of whey protein solutions (WPC). For monitoring purposes, a competitive ELISA method, able to detect the major and most allergenic whey protein β-lactoglobulin (BLG), was developed as a first step to evaluate the efficiency of the processes. Results showed that EH together with HHP was the most effective combination to reduce WPC antigenicity. The evaluation method proved useful to monitor the processes and to be employed in the quality control of the final product, to guarantee the efficiency, and in protein antigenicity reduction.

Understanding the Mechanism of Increased IgG/IgE Reactivity but Decreased Immunodetection Recovery in Thermally Induced Shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) Tropomyosin via Multispectroscopic and Molecular Dynamics Simulation Techniques

Despite the fact that tropomyosin (TM) has highly stable structural characteristics, thermal processing can adversely influence its immunodetection, and the mechanism involved has not been elucidated. Purified TM was heated at various temperatures, and then the IgG/IgE-binding capacity and immunodetection recovery were determined; meanwhile, the structural alterations were analyzed via spectroscopic and molecular dynamics simulation techniques. The obtained results demonstrated that heat-treated TM showed significantly increased IgG/IgE reactivity, confirmed by indirect ELISA and immunoblotting analysis, which might be attributed to the increased structural flexibility, and thus allowed TM to be recognized IgG/IgE easily. However, these structural alterations during thermal processing would contribute to the masking of some epitopes located in TM's surface due to the presence of curled or folded conformation with a considerable reduction of the solvent-accessible surface and radius of gyration, which primarily caused immunodetection recovery reduction in the sandwich ELISA (sELISA) test. The number of antigen binding sites might play a crucial role in a sandwich immunodetection system for sensitive and precise analysis in processed foods.

Effect of thermal and ultrasound treatments on denaturation and allergenic potential of Pru p 3 protein from peach

The effect of thermal and ultrasound treatments on denaturation and allergenicity of Pru p 3, the major peach allergenic protein, was determined. The degree of denaturation of Pru p 3 was estimated by sandwich ELISA using specific rabbit IgG, that was previously developed. Validation of ELISA test showed high sensitivity and specificity, and acceptable results of precision and robustness. Allergenicity of Pru p 3 was determined by immunofluorescent assay using three pools of sera from peach allergic individuals. Denaturation of Pru p 3 was dependent on the intensity of the thermal treatment applied and the treatment medium. Thus, the degree of denaturation of Pru p 3 treated at 95 °C for 40 min was about 60% and 95%, for the protein heated in peach extract and in buffer, respectively. Ultrasound treatments denatured Pru p 3 up to 60%, being dependent on amplitude and pressure. However, both heat and ultrasound treatments at the most severe conditions applied inhibited less than 10% the IgE-binding of Pru p 3. These results indicate that although heat and ultrasound treatments induce a considerable denaturation of Pru p 3, they are not effective in reducing its allergenicity.

Graphical abstract

Establishment of DAS-ELISA for the detection of antigenic changes in glycinin after heat processing

In this study, a double antibody sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (DAS-ELISA) method was established to detect the antigenic changes of thermally processed products containing glycinin. The proposed DAS-ELISA method used heat-treated antigen-absorbing antiserum as the coating antibody, and horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-labeled rabbit anti-glycinin polyclonal antibody as the detection antibody. The specificity test results which were obtained using the proposed method indicated that good specificity had been achieved. The cut-off value was 0.388, and the LOD was determined to be 19.53 ng/mL. The coefficient of variation was less than 5.25% (intra-day) and 9.50% (inter-day). In this study's milk powder addition test, the recovery rate of the glycinin ranged between 83.65% and 90.13%. The established DAS-ELISA method was also used to detect soybean thermal processing products, such as soy sauce, steamed fish and soy sauce, soybean paste, beef sauce, soy milk powder, and tofu. The results showed that the OD450 values of the aforementioned products were lower than the OD450 values of the glycinin in defatted soybean flour. Therefore, it was indicated that the above products has undergone different degrees of thermal processing. In other words, the majority of the epitopes of glycinin in the products had been destroyed by the thermal processing and could not be combined with heat-treated antigen-absorbing antiserum.

Development of sandwich ELISA and lateral flow immunoassay to detect almond in processed food

Almond (Prunus dulcis) represents a potential allergenic hazard that should be included in Allergen Control Plans. In this study, sandwich ELISA and lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA), using amandin (Pru du 6) as the target protein, were developed to detect almond in processed food and validated according to international guides. ELISA could detect 2 ng/mL and LFIA 30 ng/mL of pure amandin. No cross-reactivity was found on a panel of 50 food commodities with the exception of Pecan nut, Brazil nut and chestnut for which the cross-reactivity was lower than 0.02%. Furthermore, ELISA and LFIA were able to detect 0.12 and 0.70 ppm of almond protein in foods spiked with almond extract whereas 0.20 and 2.0 ppm could be detected in baked cookies incurred with almond, respectively. Both techniques could be applied for food manufacturers and control agencies for monitoring the presence of almond traces in food and working surfaces.

Labeled Peptide-Free UHPLC-MS/MS Method Used for Simultaneous Determination of Shrimp and Soybean in Sauce Products

Unintentional missing of shrimp and soybean allergen information on precautionary food allergen labeling often occurs in sauce products. To avoid food allergies, sensitive and time-saving analytical methods are urgently needed. However, the currently reported methods usually employed labeled peptides for isotope internal standard quantitation, and the matrix effect caused by protein extraction or digestion can not be corrected. In this study, a labeled peptide-free standard addition method was developed for simultaneous determination of shrimp and soybean in sauce products using ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS/MS). Through the rational selection of stable peptides, satisfying mean recoveries and relative standard deviations of the chosen peptides are achieved. The limit of quantifications of each peptide ranged from 0.25 to 5 μg tropomyosin/g sauce and from 1 to 10 μg Gly m 6/g sauce, respectively. Using the labeled peptide-free UHPLC-MS/MS method, not only ideal experimental results were obtained surpassing those obtained with labeled peptides, but also the reagents were economized and shortening of the sample preparation time was achieved.

Advances on the rapid and multiplex detection methods of food allergens

With the gradually increasing prevalence of food allergy in recent years, food allergy has become a major public health problem worldwide. The clinical symptoms caused by food allergy seriously affect people's quality of life; there are unknown allergen components in novel food and hidden allergens caused by cross contamination in food processing, which pose a serious risk to allergy sufferers. Thus, rapid and multiplex detection methods are required to achieve on-site detection or examination of allergic components, so as to identify the risk of allergy in time. This paper reviews the progress of high-efficiency detection of food allergens, including enhanced traditional detection techniques and emerging detection techniques with the ability high-throughput detection or screening potential food allergen, such as xMAP, biosensors, biochips, etc. focusing on their sensitivity, applicability of each method in food, along with their pretreatment, advantages, limitation in the application of food analysis. This paper also introduces the challenges faced by these high-efficiency detection technologies, as well as the potential of customized allergen screening methods and rapid on-site detection technology as future research directions.

Novel monoclonal antibody-sandwich immunochromatographic assay based on Fe3O4/Au nanoparticles for rapid detection of fish allergen parvalbumin

In this study, a rapid sandwich immunochromatographic assay (ICA) was developed to detect parvalbumin (PV). Firstly, two optimum primary monoclonal antibody (mAb) against PV had been screened out: mAb1 was used as the capture antibody, and mAb2 conjugated to Fe₃O₄/Au nanoparticles (Fe₃O₄/AuNPs) that served as a detection reagent. Using this pair of mAbs, a sandwich ICA strip based on Fe₃O₄/AuNPs was developed. The results showed that the color intensity of test line positively correlated with the PV concentration in the standard or spiked sample. The limit of detection for qualitative (LOD) and quantitative detection (LOQ) were 2 ng/mL and 0.691 ng/mL, respectively. Besides, the detection time of this ICA strip was within 15 min. The recovery rates ranged from 104.0% to 117.4%, within an acceptable level (80-120%). Moreover, the developed assay also showed high cross reaction in different fish species. These results demonstrated that the established test strip has the potential to be used as a rapid screening tool for large scale determination of PV in foodstuffs.

Influence of different extraction conditions on the detection of glycinin and β-conglycinin in model processed foods by ELISA

The presence of undeclared soy proteins in food can cause severe reactions in soy allergic individuals. The extraction of target proteins from processed foods is a crucial step in allergen detection by immunoassays, as only successfully extracted target proteins can be detected by the specific antibodies. The effectiveness was studied of different conditions (type of buffer, temperature and time of incubation) on the extraction of total protein, and concentration of glycinin and β-conglycinin from different food matrices. The yields were determined using a soy protein isolate and three processed foods (sausage, bread and pâté) incurred with soy proteins. The yields were affected by the processing of analysed products and the composition and pH of the extraction buffers. Neutral and alkaline buffers (pH from 7.4 to 10.6) exhibited good protein extraction capacity and detectability of the specific target proteins. Denaturing additives and highly alkaline buffer (pH 12) extracted more crude protein but they were incompatible with the ELISA assay. Overall, the best results were obtained using phosphate (pH 7.4) and Tris/HCl (pH 8.5) buffers in the presence of 0.5 M NaCl. Crude protein yield of food extracts did not correlate with that of glycinin and β-conglycinin, whereas a good relationship was found between the yields of the two proteins.