High risk of misinterpreting hair analysis results for children tested for methadone

Infant exposure to drugs of abuse investigated by hair analysis

Infant exposure to drugs of abuse represents a worldwide problem whose extent is difficult to estimate. Despite the potentially serious health consequences, few data concerning exposure in children under 1 year of age are available. Since in clinical and forensic settings, neonatal and infant hair testing represents a useful method for investigating suspected drug exposures, an observational retrospective study was performed on hair analysis of children under 1 year of age evaluated at the University Hospital of Padova between 2018 and 2022 with the aim of estimate the extent and define the characteristics of this phenomenon in the reference setting. The sample included 102 infants. Chemical-toxicological analyses were requested in 38 cases (37.3%) because of clinically suspicious symptoms of the child (e.g., neuropsychiatric symptoms and suspected neonatal abstinence syndrome) and in 64 cases (62.7%) because of other reasons (e.g., maternal drug history, at-risk environment, and suspected maltreatment). Based on the presence or absence of symptoms in the request, the sample was subdivided into two groups. Hair analysis in these two showed the presence of drug of abuse, respectively, in 44.7% and 67.2% of the cases (p = 0.026). Cocaine was the most frequently detected substance, followed by opiates, and it was detected less frequently in cases investigated for suspicious clinical symptoms (p < 0.05). The results confirm the difficulties in interpreting the clinical picture and in defining the extent of exposure to drugs of abuse. An integrated assessment is fundamental to interpret the case and achieve adequate care of the child.

Accidental Detection of Cocaine in Urine in Pediatric Patients: Case Series and Literature Review

Infantile occult exposure to cocaine in domestic environments represents a complex clinical and medico-legal problem, which can be associated with abuse and neglect and with potential short- and long-term health risks for children. The authors present a retrospective study on 764 children under 14 years old who accessed the Emergency Department of IRCCS Meyer from 2016 to 2023 and were included in the GAIA (Child and Adolescent Abuse Group) protocol for suspected maltreatment and abuse, and for which a urine toxicology analysis was performed. The aim is to discuss the medico-legal implications and highlight the need for a thorough evaluation and management of such situations. Urine screening tests for substances of abuse (e.g., cocaine, opiates, etc.) were performed with an EMIT® Siemens VIVA-E drug testing system (Siemens, Newark DE) in 124 cases for which the child's clinical condition raised suspicion of intoxication, or the family context indicated distress or substance abuse dependency. The screening results revealed the presence of cocaine and its main metabolite, benzoylecgonine, in the urine of 11 children. In one case, a single girl was brought to the Emergency Department by staff from the facility where she and her mother were staying. In most of the cases, children were brought to the Emergency Department by their parents who accessed the Emergency Department due to various clinical manifestations (drowsiness, agitation, seizures, hypotonia, diarrhea, vomiting, etc.), except for one case of eye trauma suspected to be caused by abuse or neglect by one of the parents. Three of the children did not have signs or symptoms attributable to substance exposure, whilst eight of the cases presented some of the symptoms associated with occult infant exposure to cocaine, such as neurological manifestations, seizures, gastrointestinal symptoms, and respiratory depression. The probable mode of intake was mostly through breastfeeding and continuous environmental exposure due to domestic contamination or inhalation of "crack". In the case of a 12-hour-old infant, there was probable prenatal in utero exposure. All the children were hospitalized, some for medical reasons and others solely as a precautionary measure for proper care. In all cases, a report was made to the Prosecutors as required by the Italian Penal Code, as well as to the Court of Minor. The study highlighted the importance of a multidisciplinary approach involving pediatricians, social workers, and forensics, as well as close collaboration with the relevant authorities, as the Gaia service at IRCCS Meyer offers. The occasional detection of cocaine in cases that showed no suspicion of intoxication led to a modification of the procedure and the development of a standardized protocol at IRCCS Meyer both in terms of prevention and in the detection and interception of hidden cases, in order to intervene early and initiate the necessary care pathways (secondary prevention). This protocol includes routine toxicological urine testing in all suspected or confirmed cases of child abuse, not just in those where symptoms might suggest a suspicion of intoxication.

Hair toxicological analysis of infants and their mothers: a 5-year retrospective study focusing on cocaine

Prenatal and infant exposure to drugs of abuse is an emerging social and public health problem affecting children health and which may relate to child abuse and neglect. Exposure to drugs of abuse may occur through different routes, including intrauterine, breastfeeding, accidental intake, passive inhalation, and intentional administration. Currently, cases of suspected exposure can be investigated by hair toxicological analysis, the interpretation of which is, however, often difficult, leading to consequent difficulties in the management of such cases. In order to provide a contribution in terms of interpretation of the analytical results, this study aimed to search for the possible existence of elements, from a toxicological point of view, indicative towards the route of exposure. A retrospective study was performed on cases of suspected exposure to drugs of abuse in children aged 0-1 year, evaluated at a University Hospital between 2018 and 2022. Data of children hair toxicological analysis were analyzed and then compared with those of their mothers, when available; 41.6% children tested positive for cocaine. The study found a significant correlation between cocaine and benzoylecgonine concentrations, and a benzoylecgonine/cocaine ratio that tends to decrease as the age of children increases. From the comparison with mothers, a child/mother cocaine concentration ratio lower than 1 was found in all cases of hair sampled within the first week of life, and a ratio greater than or equal to 1 in all cases in which the sampling was performed later. These results, if confirmed in a larger cohort, could represent a contribution in the interpretation of cases of infant exposure to drugs of abuse and be integrated in the context of their multidisciplinary evaluation.

Testing for 2,4-dinitrophenol in human hair by LC-MS/MS and interpretation issues

2,4-dinitrophenol, initially developed for industrial purposes, is used in the synthesis of dyes and various drugs, including herbicides, fungicides and insecticides. Incidentally, it was discovered that 2,4-dinitrophenol increases human basal metabolic rate. As a consequence, people who want to loose weight can abuse 2,4-dinitrophenol. It is a compound of choice for bodybuilders who abuse it in combination with anabolic steroids and clenbuterol. Numerous deaths have been attributed to 2,4-dinitrophenol. Up to now, 2,4-dinitrophenol was never reported in hair. The authors present an original method to test for 2,4-dinitrophenol in hair after methanolic extraction using LC-MS/MS. The limit of detection of the procedure is 0.01 ng/mg and the method was fully validated in the range 0.1-50 ng/mg. 2,4-dinitrophenol tested positive in the brown hair of a subject deceased from acute poisoning at 5.15, 13.06 and 25.48 ng/mg in the 3 × 3 cm segments. As excessive sweating is associated to 2,4-dinitrophenol abuse, major contribution of this matrix must be taken into consideration when interpreting the data. In this case, there was a regular increase of 2,4-dinitrophenol concentration from root to tip. This specific pattern can be the consequence of sweat contamination, i.e., the older hair being for a longer time in contact with sweat.

Interpretation of hair and nails findings in an infant death case related to maternal addiction to tramadol

An 11-month-old boy was found dead. Autopsy findings (cyanosis and polyvisceral congestion) and blood tramadol (TR) concentration of 6240 μg/L were consistent with an acute TR intoxication. In this poisoning situation, owing to the mother's statements (TR addiction leading to daily TR-orange juice mixture preparation accidentally used for the baby bottle preparation by the mother's partner), and the question of possible previous TR administrations to the infant, hair and/or nails (infant, mother, partner, 6-year-old sister) analysis was performed. Hair (2-cm-long hair segments from proximal [S1] to distal [S3]) and nails concentrations (pg/mg; nd: not detected) were as follows: Infant (hair: TR 1420 [S1], 1622 [S2], 2736 [S3]; O-DMT 16-38; N-DMT 34-100 [TR in significant quantities in the hair decontamination bath]-toenails: TR 584; O-DMT 8; N-DMT 15), mother (hair: TR 2340 [S1], 2150 [S2], 2500 [S3]; O-DMT 704-1170; N-DMT 827-1360), mother's partner (fingernails: TR 72; O-DMT nd; N-DMT nd) and sister (hair: TR 261 [S1], 524 [S2]; O-DMT 15 [S1], 16 [S2]; N-DMT 20 [S1], 38 [S2]). Metabolite ratio (infant and sister hair) was comparable to those observed in hair of pharmaceutical industry employees manufacturing tramadol. TR in washing baths, low observed nail concentrations (infant and partner) confirm (i) TR-related mother's addiction and (ii) external contamination issues (TR in sweat of the child at the time of death and in living environment) to explain the infant's keratinized samples results. This case report illustrates the interest of analyzing keratinized matrices of the whole family in such a situation.

Measurement of 7-dehydrocholesterol and cholesterol in hair can be used in the diagnosis of Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome

7-dehydrocholesterol (7-DHC) and cholesterol (CHOL) are biomarkers of Smith-Lemli-Opitz Syndrome (SLOS), a congenital autosomal recessive disorder characterized by elevated 7-DHC level in patients. Hair samples have been shown to have great diagnostic and research value, which has long been neglected in the SLOS field. In this study, we sought to investigate the feasibility of using hair for SLOS diagnosis. In the presence of antioxidants (2,6-ditert-butyl-4-methylphenol and triphenylphosphine), hair samples were completely pulverized and extracted by micro-pulverized extraction in alkaline solution or in n-hexane. After microwave-assisted derivatization with N,O-Bis(trimethylsilyl)trifluoroacetamide, the analytes were measured by GC-MS. We found that the limits of determination for 7-DHC and CHOL were 10 ng/mg and 8 ng/mg, respectively. In addition, good linearity was obtained in the range of 50-4000 ng/mg and 30-6000 ng/mg for 7-DHC and CHOL, respectively, which fully meets the requirement for SLOS diagnosis and related research. Finally, by applying the proposed method to real hair samples collected from 14 healthy infants and two suspected SLOS patients, we confirmed the feasibility of hair analysis as a diagnostic tool for SLOS. In conclusion, we present an optimized and validated analytical method for the simultaneous determination of two SLOS biomarkers using human hair.

A Systematic Review of Metabolite-to-Drug Ratios of Pharmaceuticals in Hair for Forensic Investigations

After ingestion, consumed drugs and their metabolites are incorporated into hair, which has a long detection window, ranging up to months. Therefore, in addition to conventional blood and urine analyses, hair analysis can provide useful information on long-term drug exposure. Meta-bolite-to-drug (MD) ratios are helpful in interpreting hair results, as they provide useful information on drug metabolism and can be used to distinguish drug use from external contamination, which is otherwise a limitation in hair analysis. Despite this, the MD ratios of a wide range of pharmaceuticals have scarcely been explored. This review aims to provide an overview of MD ratios in hair in a range of pharmaceuticals of interest to forensic toxicology, such as antipsychotic drugs, antidepressant drugs, benzodiazepines, common opiates/opioids, etc. The factors influencing the ratio were evaluated. MD ratios of 41 pharmaceuticals were reported from almost 100 studies. MD ratios below 1 were frequently reported, indicating higher concentrations of the parent pharmaceutical than of its metabolite in hair, but wide-ranging MD ratios of the majority of pharmaceuticals were found. Intra- and interindividual differences and compound properties were variables possibly contributing to this. This overview presents guidance for future comparison and evaluation of MD ratios of pharmaceuticals.

Exhumation of a Methamphetamine Body-Packer: Pitfalls of Hair Result Interpretation

Carrying out toxicological investigations in biological samples (e.g. hair) collected from extensively decomposed bodies and even more interpretation of subsequently obtained results is challenging, even more in some particular circumstances of death. In order to illustrate these pitfalls, we report the case of the exhumation of a methamphetamine body-packer. Autopsy examination of a 41-year-old man, one year after his burial, revealed the presence of 44 green pellets (7 out of 44 were torn) along all the gastrointestinal tract. A 6-cm long dark hair strand and pellets were sampled for toxicological analyses. Large toxicological screenings were applied to hair and pellets using both LC-MS/MS and LC-HRMS. Intact pellets contained around 10 g of methamphetamine (MA) with a purity ranging from 29 to 35 %. Positive hair results were amiodarone (4.12 ng/mg), desethylamiodarone (5.29 ng/mg) and methamphetamine (7.63 ng/mg). Methamphetamine pellets in gastrointestinal tract were consistent with the autopsy conclusion, i.e. fatal intoxication due to in corpore pellet rupture in a body-packer (the victim was initially deemed to have died from heart failure). In the absence of available data in the literature, amiodarone and metabolite presence in hair could putatively be the consequence of a chronic treatment. Methamphetamine hair concentration was similar to those observed in regular consumers. However, interpreting this hair result is challenging due to (i) the possibility of contamination by sweat at the time of death, and (ii) the probable contamination by putrefaction fluids. This latter hypothesis (artifactual contamination during the post-mortem period) is highly supported by high concentration of methamphetamine in decontamination bath, and even more by the absence of the major methamphetamine metabolite (amphetamine) in hair. As a conclusion, in this particular situation, the hair analysis result (presence of MA and concomitant absence of amphetamine) is in agreement with the previously-established cause of death.

Evidence for the transfer of methadone and EDDP by sweat to children's hair

In cases where there is a question as to whether children have come into contact with drugs, examinations of their scalp hair are frequently carried out. Positive test results are often discussed in the forensic community due to the various possible modes via which drugs and their metabolites can be incorporated into the hair. These include drug uptake by the child (e.g. oral ingestion or inhalation), but also contamination of hair via contact with the sweat from drug users. In this study, the possibility of methadone and its metabolite EDDP being incorporated into children’s hair by contact with sweat from persons undergoing opiate maintenance therapy (methadone) was examined. The transfer of methadone and EDDP via sweat from methadone patients (n = 15) to children’s hair was simulated by close skin contact of drug-free children’s hair, encased in mesh-pouches, for 5 days. Sweat-collecting patches (hereafter referred to as ‘sweat patches’) were applied to the test persons’ skin. One strand of hair and one sweat patch were collected daily from each patient. Analyses were performed using GC–MS/MS (hair) and LC–MS/MS (serum, sweat patches). After 4 days of skin contact, methadone was detectable in the formerly drug-free hair strands in all 15 study participants. EDDP was detectable in 34 of 75 hair strands, with the maximum number of positive results (11 EDDP-positive hair strands) being detected after 5 days. These results show that transfer of methadone and EDDP to drug-free hair is possible through close skin contact with individuals taking part in methadone substitution programmes. A correlation between serum concentration, sweat concentration and substance concentration in hair strands could not be demonstrated, but a tendency towards higher concentrations due to longer contact time is clearly evident.

Evidence of repeated mirtazapine poisoning in children by hair analysis

Mirtazapine is an antidepressant drug, used to treat depression, but also, in some specific conditions, to treat obsessive-compulsive disorder and anxiety. Although mirtazapine is not a hypnotic, it can make the subject feel drowsy. Children under the age of 18 should not take mirtazapine, but for some very special diseases, a physician can prescribe it for a limited period of time. The authors report a case involving 2 children (7- and 9-year-old) who were administered mirtazapine without consent by the mother, who was under daily therapy with this antidepressant. Hair specimens, collected from the children were tested by liquid chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry for mirtazapine and its metabolite, N-desmethylmirtazapine, on 3 × 1 cm segments. The hair test results (3 × 1 cm segments) have demonstrated that both children have been repetitively exposed to mirtazapine for approximately the last 3 months before hair collection, with concentrations in the range 1.32-3.79 and 0.64-2.54 ng/mg for mirtazapine and N-desmethylmirtazapine, respectively. Environmental contamination was ruled out as the measured concentrations are highly variable according to the pattern of drug distribution and the washes were negative. Hair testing for drugs appears as an excellent diagnostic tool for child protection toward drug exposure.

Specific interpretation of hair concentrations in 2 fatal metformin intoxication cases

Hair analysis is very useful for toxicological investigations since, by providing a wider detection window, it gives the possibility to perform a retrospective study on the historical consumption of a substance. Unfortunately, there are no data available for hair concentrations in metformin-related deaths. In this study, the authors present 2 cases of fatal metformin intoxication in which, for the first time, hair analysis was performed using a specific GC-MS/MS method. Metformin was tested positive in femoral blood (112.3 mg/L and 64.7 mg/L respectively) and cardiac blood (226.9 and 203.2 mg/L) of the two subjects. For case 1, other samples were also tested positive, including vitreous humor (31.1 mg/L) and gastric contents (773.5 mg/L). In case 2, metformin was measured at 844.9 mg/L in urine. Metformin hair concentrations were 28.3-44.8 and 22.5 ng/mg for both cases, respectively. The concentrations found in the 2 fatal cases are clearly higher than those obtained in a previous study with subjects under treatment (0.3-3.8 ng/mg) or those found in 3 post-mortem cases where metformin death was excluded (0.6-1.4 ng/mg). Excessive sweating during the agonal phase due to fatal hypoglycemia could explain these elevated concentrations as sweat can have contaminated the hair.

Environmental Methamphetamine Exposures and Health Effects in 25 Case Studies

The clandestine manufacture and use of methamphetamine can result in contamination of residential properties. It is understood that this contamination remains in homes for a significant period, however there are a lack of data available to understand the health effects of exposure to environmental methamphetamine contamination (third-hand exposure). Our study collected information from 63 individuals in 25 separate case studies where the subjects had unwittingly suffered third-hand exposure to methamphetamine from former manufacture, use, or both. Data included environmental contamination data, information on subjects' health effects, and evidence of exposure using hair analysis. This study identified a range of health effects that occur from residing in these properties, including behavioural effects or issues, sleep issues, respiratory effects, skin and eye effects, and headaches. Methamphetamine was detected in hair samples from some individuals, including children. The exposures and concomitant reported health effects covered a wide range of environmental methamphetamine levels in the properties, including low levels close to the current Australian guideline of 0.5 µg methamphetamine/100 cm². There were no discernible differences between health effects from living in properties contaminated from former manufacture or use. This study demonstrates that residing in these properties can represent a serious public health risk.

Interpol review of toxicology 2016-2019

This review paper covers the forensic-relevant literature in toxicology from 2016 to 2019 as a part of the 19th Interpol International Forensic Science Managers Symposium. The review papers are also available at the Interpol website at: https://www.interpol.int/content/download/14458/file/Interpol%20Review%20.Papers%202019.pdf.

The Difficult Interpretation of a Hair Test Result from a 32-Month-Old Child: Administration of Propranolol and Quetiapine or Contamination?

A 23-month-old boy was brought to a medical center by his mother, as she noticed that the father has gripped him around the neck and this had left marks. As a result of this, a child protection medical examination was requested. However, there was a significant chronology of mental health issues in the mother. Among the mother’s medications, quetiapine and propranolol were the more active. Given a consultant pediatrician was concerned that the boy was vulnerable and potentially has experienced neglect and physical harm, the local authority instructed a hair test to document possible poisoning. However, this occurred several months later, due to court delays (postponed hearings and decisions) when the child was 32-month old. The laboratory received a strand of hair of the child (12 cm in length, light brown in color) and a strand of hair of the mother (&gt;20 cm in length, dark in color) with the request to test both specimens by segmentation (12 x 1 cm) for quetiapine, an anti-psychotic drug and propranolol, a β-blocker agent. After decontamination and segmentation, the specimens were incubated in borate buffer pH 9.5 and extracted by a mixture of ether/dichloromethane/hexane/isoamyl alcohol to test for the drugs, including norquetiapine by a specific LC–MS-MS method. The first 3 cm segments of the child’s hair were free of drug, roughly corresponding to the period he was no more in contact with the mother. Propranolol tested positive in the other segments at 15–72 pg/mg, with a linear increase from the proximal to the distal end. This was also observed for quetiapine, with concentrations in the range 10–18 pg/mg. Norquetiapine was never identified in the child’s hair. The following concentrations were observed in the mother’s hair: 6028–10,284, 910–4576 and 1116–6956 pg/mg for propranolol, quetiapine and norquetiapine, respectively. This confirmed that the donor was a long-term repetitive user of propranolol and quetiapine. The hair test results have indicated that the child was in contact with propranolol and quetiapine for a long period. It is not possible to put a temporal period for each segment, as the hair growth at the age of 32 months is not the same as for an adult (difference in the duration of the anagen period), nor to put any quantitative dosage or frequency of exposure(s) when interpreting the data. An increase of concentrations from root to tip was observed which is considered highly indicative of external contamination, with the older hair segments (those which are the more concentrated) being in contact for a longer time with contaminated items (hands of the mother, home items such as furniture, dishes, beddings, etc.). Overinterpreting drug findings in hair can have very serious legal implications in child protection cases, particularly when no other toxicological test and no clinical report exist to support voluntary administration of drugs. Whatever the findings, a proper interpretation of hair test results is critical and should be done ideally with other information available, such as medical history, witness statements and the available circumstances of the matter. A single hair test should not be used to determine long-term exposure to a drug.

Variability associated with interpreting drugs within forensic hair analysis: A three-stage interpretation

Hair analysis is capable of determining both an individual's long-term drug history and a single exposure to a drug, which can be particularly important for corroborating incidents of drug-facilitated crimes. As a source of forensic evidence that may be used in a court of law, it must be credible, impartial and reliable, yet the pathways of drug and metabolite entry into hair are still uncertain. Many variables may influence drug analysis results, most of which are outside of the control of an analyst. An individual's pharmacokinetic and metabolic responses, hair growth rates, drug incorporation routes, axial migration, ethnicity, age and gender, for example, all display interpersonal variability. At present there is little standardization of the analytical processes involved with hair analysis. Both false positives and negative results for drugs are frequently encountered, regardless of whether a person has consumed a drug or not. In this regard, we have categorized these variables and proposed a three-stage analytical approach to facilitate forensic toxicologists, hair analysis experts, judiciaries and service users in the analytical and interpretation process.