Gas cooking and respiratory outcomes in children: A systematic review

Effects of indoor environments and outdoor air pollutants in residential areas on acute exacerbation in patients with severe asthma

This study aimed to determine the effects of indoor environment (IE) and outdoor air pollutants (OAPs) in residential areas on acute exacerbation (AE) in patients with severe asthma. A total of 115 participants were recruited. To characterize IE, we used structured questionnaires and estimated OAP concentrations using a land-use regression model. Participants who were exposed to passive smoking and lived in houses where the kitchen and living room were not separated showed a significantly higher rate of AE (p = 0.014 and 0.0016, respectively). The mean concentration of PM2.5 in residential areas during the last 3 years was significantly higher in participants with AE than that in those without AE (19.8 ± 3.1 vs. 21.0 ± 2.5 µg/m3, p = 0.033). Moreover, the serum level of 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine significantly increased in participants with AE compared to those without AE (56.9 ± 30.0 vs. 94.7 ± 44.5 ng/mL, p = 0.0047) suggesting enhanced oxidative stress in those with AE.

Challenging unverified assumptions in causal claims: Do gas stoves increase risk of pediatric asthma?

The use of unverified models for risk estimates and policy recommendations can be highly misleading, as their predictions may not reflect real-world health impacts. For example, a recent article states that NO2 from gas stoves "likely causes ∼50,000 cases of current pediatric asthma from long-term NO2 exposure alone" annually in the United States. This explicitly causal claim, which is contrary to several methodology and review articles published in this journal, among others, reflects both (a) An unverified modeling assumption that pediatric asthma burden is approximately proportional to NO2; and (b) An unverified causal assumption that the assumed proportionality between exposure and response is causal. The article is devoid of any causal analysis showing that these assumptions are likely to be true. It does not show that reducing NO2 exposure from gas stoves would reduce pediatric asthma risk. Its key references report no significant associations - let alone causation - between NO2 and pediatric asthma. Thus, the underlying data suggests that the number of pediatric asthma cases caused by gas stoves in the United States is indistinguishable from zero. This highlights the need to rigorously validate modeling assumptions and causal claims in public health risk assessments to ensure scientifically sound foundations for policy decisions.