Features of the social and built environment that contribute to the well-being of people with dementia who live at home: A scoping review

How to age right and care(fully) at home? A protocol for a multistage comparative study of ageing in place and hospital at home care across three countries

INTRODUCTION

Ageing right care(fully) is a transnational research study which explores and maps an understanding of the care pathways between ageing in place and hospital at home policy and practices for older adults in Israel, the Netherlands and Sweden. The countries are suited to be compared where they have growing, ageing populations, a focus on healthcare reform and several policies to reduce the cost of care for older populations. Ageing in place is a government-led policy that is often associated with choice; however, there is a recent debate about whether ageing in place is a universal desire for all older adults. Research shows that the care pathway between the hospital and the home, associated with ageing in place, can impact well-being, especially if the built, social and technological environments do not meet the healthcare needs and preferences of older adults. This is significant as new programmes for digital hospital at home innovations are being developed as part of a global transformation in healthcare systems. The aim of the study is to compare different approaches to ageing in place and hospital at home care in different regions. The multiapproach study explores the demographics, policy structure, decision-making process and the crucial role of the built, social and technological environments along the hospital to home care pathways of older adults.

METHODS AND ANALYSIS

The mixed-method, comparative study includes a new multienvironment theoretical contribution explored across a three-phase research method to understand the care pathways of older adults ageing in place receiving hospital at home care. The first phase compares each country's population and policy structures relating to ageing in place, hospital discharge, home hospitalisation and at-home care for older adults. The second phase maps patient journeys of older adults living in each country through the perspective of the older adult, caregivers and care professionals. The third phase explores the synergies between the knowledge gained through phases 1 and 2-from a policy and a personal level-and mobilises the knowledge into policy recommendations and implementation guidelines.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

The comparative study has been approved by the Sheba Medical Centre in Israel (SMC-1330-24), the Ethics Committee of Tel Aviv University (0009216-2), the Humanities and Social Science Ethics Committee at the University of Twente in the Netherlands (240040) and the Swedish Ethical Review Authority (Dnr 2024-07569-01). The results will be shared with end-users, including citizens, carers, healthcare policymakers, planners, architects and designers, through social media, publications, workshops and international conferences. This future-focused research approach will allow stakeholders to rethink and imagine ways that health and care systems can be personalised and responsive to the future needs of older adult populations.

Social interactions in dementia: perceptions of current situation and opportunities

BACKGROUND

Social interactions can have a beneficial effect on people with dementia (PWD). However, little is known about the details of social interactions in dementia, information that is useful for planning social interventions. The aim of our study was to gain a deeper insight, provided by people in dementia care, into (i) the characteristics of social interactions of PWD, (ii) which social interactions are considered as particularly important, (iii) how important social interactions are perceived, and (iv) what is perceived to increase social interactions among PWD.

METHODS

Responses of 501 people in dementia care (mostly family and professional caregivers; more than three-quarters female; average age 53.5 years) provided in a structured, quantitative survey were included in this analysis. Descriptive analyses were conducted.

RESULTS

The majority of PWDs' social interactions take place in their home or day care and arise from support services as well as organized activities. More than half of the participants perceived singing, telling life stories, or moving together (e.g., walking, dancing) as valuable social interactions that PWD benefit from in many ways. Positive effects (e.g., aggression, depression, positive emotions, activation) are mainly perceived for social interactions such as laughing together, touch, hugging, simply being together, or being involved in daily activities. Overall, participants rated social interactions as rather important for the course of the symptoms. A fixed social contact besides the primary caregiver and offers from the community, associations, and religious institutions are considered rather important in increasing the social interactions of PWD.

CONCLUSIONS

Simple social interactions of PWD such as laughing, eating or singing together that can be realized in the home environment and in the context of organized caregiving activities are perceived most valuable. Enhancing social interactions, especially beyond the primary caregiving context, may be valuable for those living with dementia.

Individual and Neighborhood Characteristics of Walking Activity in People Living With Dementia: A Proof of Concept for Quantitative Spatial Analysis

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

Creating dementia-friendly neighborhoods is crucial for enhancing outdoor walking activity and maintaining social participation among people living with dementia (PLWD). This study utilizes GPS and geographic information system technologies to conduct a quantitative spatial analysis, revealing how individual and neighborhood characteristics are associated with PLWD's walking activity characteristics.

METHODS

Twenty-five participants from Metro Vancouver had their regular walking routes (RWR) from home to neighborhood destinations recorded using GPS technology. Spatial analysis tools and existing survey data were utilized to construct the research geodatabase. Nonparametric tests (Spearman's rank correlation, Kendall's tau, and Mann-Whitney) and parametric tests (Pearson correlation and point biserial) assessed associations between independent variables, including sociodemographic characteristics of participants (e.g., age and health) and their neighborhoods (e.g., age structure and language barriers), and built environment features (e.g., land use diversity), with two dependent variables: length of RWR and walking time to regular destination within the 20-min walkshed.

RESULTS

Longer RWR and increased walking time to regular destination within the 20-min walkshed are associated with fewer physical health limitations, gentler terrain, proximity to green spaces, and bus stops. In addition, higher land use diversity, proximity to secondary streets, integrated sidewalks, higher number of benches and intersections, and a slight street network curvature showed positive associations with RWR length and walking time to regular destination within the 20-min walkshed.

CONCLUSION

GPS and geographic information system technologies provide a unique quantitative method for understanding mobility patterns among PLWD. While limited by participant numbers, this exploratory study provides directions for future investigations. Significance/Implications: This study offers insights into designing dementia-friendly neighborhoods that support social engagement and physical activity among PLWD.

How to Encourage the Public to Help People With Dementia in the Community: A Scoping Review

BACKGROUND

In a response to the lack of public awareness of dementia, 'ageing in place' and 'dementia-friendly community' policies have been proposed, and a number of relevant studies have been carried out.

AIM

To map the evidence of public help for people with dementia in the community.

DESIGN

A scoping review.

METHODS

A comprehensive search of nine databases was conducted to find studies from the inception of the databases to January 2024. We developed our inclusion criteria to identify studies about public help for people with dementia in the community. Data from included studies were charted (purposively designed template) and narrated synthesis in relation to the study's research questions.

RESULTS

Of 34 studies included, we found that difficult situations were encountered by people with dementia after developing cognitive, behavioural and psychological symptoms. We identified three types of helping behaviour, namely, formal planned, informal planned and spontaneous helping behaviour, which were influenced by general demographic characteristics, knowledge, attitudes, responsibilities and understanding. Fourteen studies proposed interventions to promote public help for people with dementia in the community, covering three categories of teaching, practical and web-based methods.

CONCLUSIONS

It is necessary to develop a systematic intervention to promote public helping behaviour according to the characteristics of people with dementia and the modifiable influencing factors of helping behaviour.

PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION

No patient or public contribution. This is a Scoping Review.

The dementia-nature-inclusivity nexus and the needs of people living with dementia

Understanding how to improve the physical and cognitive accessibility of visitor economy businesses and organisations wanting to offer nature-based outdoor pursuits for people with dementia is key to supporting their inclusion and agency. The aim of this qualitative study was to understand the experiences, needs and preferences of people with dementia participating in nature-based outdoor pursuits in their leisure time. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 15 people with dementia and 15 family members and subjected to thematic analysis. Four themes related to inclusion for people with dementia and their family members reflected diversity in individual needs and preferences for engaging with nature-based outdoor pursuits, their own adaptations to maintain access including accommodating risk, how cognitive and physical accessibility can be supported by businesses, and which practical and psychosocial barriers prevent inclusion. Learning from people with dementia and their family members has helped bridge the gap to their inclusion in nature-based outdoor pursuits. Their insights will inform the development of such pursuits by businesses and organisations as well as future work into risk decision-making.

Re-municipalising sociospatial infrastructure: A journeying ethnography of Greater Manchester's dementia (un)friendly buses

Transport can pose substantial challenges for people with dementia. Dementia-friendly approaches seek to encourage public transport use by enhancing people and places through educational initiatives and architectural augmentation respectively. The Greater Manchester Combined Authority is implementing dementia-friendliness within a major re-municipalisation of public transport. Reporting findings from a journeying ethnography of bus travel with passengers with dementia, this paper critiques contemporary friendly transport. It argues that buses are vital sociospatial infrastructures, the friendliness of which is constituted by entangled socio-material and political economic forces. The re-municipalisation of friendly transport requires a radical civic offer of social de-segregation and equitable development.

Dementia-Sensitive Environmental Design of Living Units in German Nursing Homes: First Results of the German Environmental Audit Tool (G-EAT)

BACKGROUND

The built environment is a key component of dementia-specific care. Little is known about the characteristics of dementia-sensitive environmental elements in living units of nursing homes in Germany. The German Environmental Audit Tool (G-EAT) is a systematic assessment tool for describing these elements in detail.

AIM OF THE STUDY

To describe the extent of dementia-sensitive design principles and environmental elements in a regionally limited sample of living units in Germany.

METHODS

The built environment was assessed using G-EAT and analysed quantitatively and descriptively. Definitions of living units were developed based on site visits and analysed using qualitative content analysis.

RESULTS

The 42 participating living units were heterogeneous in terms of space and composition. Dementia-sensitive design principles varied greatly in their implementation in the built environment; on average, 87.7% of the environmental elements were oriented towards a familiar environment. In contrast, visual accessibility was much less frequently enabled by the built environment (mean 37.3%).

CONCLUSIONS

The characteristics of various dementia-sensitive environmental elements need to be further investigated against the background of the nursing home care concept and the homogeneity of the resident group to enable the initiation of tailored environmental adaptation that can be implemented by interdisciplinary teams in nursing homes. This also requires a follow-up study with a larger sample of living units to identify the factors that promote and inhibit the development of a dementia-sensitive environment.

A Systematic Review of Research Gaps in the Built Environment of Inpatient Healthcare Settings

OBJECTIVE

This study utilized the evidence-gap map method and critically examined the scope, methodologies, and focus of the studies that investigated the influence of the built environment on inpatient healthcare settings over a decade (2010-2021).

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review per the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses guidelines and surveyed 406 articles, primarily from North America and Europe.

RESULTS

Our findings revealed a dominant focus on architectural features (73%), such as room design and ward layout. Comparatively, there was less emphasis on interior-, ambient-, social-, and nature-related features. Most previous studies explored multiple environmental features, which indicated the intricacy of this field. Research outcomes were diverse, with person-centered care (PCC) being the most frequently investigated, followed by safe care, emotional well-being, activity, and behavior. Furthermore, research methods varied considerably based on the study's outcomes and features. Clinical outcomes and safe care favored quantitative methods, activity and behavior favored mixed methods, and PCC favored qualitative research.

CONCLUSION

This review provides an in-depth overview of the existing studies on healthcare design research and sheds light on the current trends and methodological choices. The insights garnered can guide future research, policy-making, and the development of healthcare facilities.

The Moral and Gender Implications of Measures Used to Modulate the Mobility of People With Dementia Living in Residential Care Environments: A Scoping Review

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Policies and measures often restrict the mobility of people with dementia living in residential care environments to protect them from harm. However, such measures can violate human rights and affect the quality of life. This review aims to summarize the literature on what is known about measures used to modulate the life-space mobility of residents with dementia living in a residential care environment. Furthermore, moral and sex and gender considerations were explored.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

A scoping review framework was referenced to summarize the literature. A total of 5 databases were searched: PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, SCOPUS, and Web of Science. The studies for eligibility using the Rayyan screening tool.

RESULTS

A total of 30 articles met the inclusion criteria. A narrative description of the findings of the articles is presented across 3 themes: (1) measures and strategies used to modulate the life-space mobility; (2) moral aspects; and (3) sex and gender considerations.

DISCUSSION AND IMPLICATIONS

Various measures are used to modulate the life-space mobility of people with dementia living in residential care facilities. Research exploring the sex and gender differences of people with dementia is lacking. With a focus on human rights and quality of life, measures used to restrict or support mobility must support the diverse needs, capacity, and dignity of people with dementia. Noting the capacity and diversity of people with dementia will require society and public space to adopt strategies that promote safety and mobility to support the quality of life of people with dementia.

Dementia care and prevention in community settings: a built environment framework for cognitive health promotion

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Most people with dementia live in the community. As lifespan increases, one in three persons aged 85+ are expected to live with dementia. We conduct a systematic search to identify frameworks for dementia care and prevention in community settings. This is important to ensure quality of life for people living with cognitive decline (PLCD).

RECENT FINDINGS

61 frameworks are synthesized into the dementia care and prevention in community (DCPC) framework. It highlights three levels of provision: built environment and policy supports, access and innovation, and inclusion across stages of decline. Domains of intervention include: basic needs; built environment health and accessibility; service access and use; community health infrastructure; community engagement; mental health and wellbeing; technology; end-of-life care; cultural considerations; policy, education, and resources. Personhood is not adequately represented in current built environment frameworks. This is supplemented with 14 articles on lived experiences at home and social practices that contribute to PLCD's social identity and psychological safety.

SUMMARY

Policy makers, health and built environment professionals must work together to promote "personhood in community" with PLCD. Clinicians and community staff may focus on inclusion, social identity and a sense of at-homeness as attainable outcomes despite diagnosis.

Person-Environment Exchange Processes in Transition into Dementia: A Scoping Review

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The important role that the environment plays in the lives of older people is widely acknowledged. To date, little is known about person-environment processes during the early stages of dementia. This scoping review aims to provide an overview of the processes involved during early dementia and the relationship to different dimensions of their life space.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

A scoping review was conducted according to the Johanna Briggs Institute Manual, which involved searching for research on early dementia and the environment across 3 databases.

RESULTS

A total of 1,358 records were screened, with 284 sources included in the first categorization of the diverse relationships that exist between the environment and the person living with early dementia. Finally, 102 sources were selected that describe person-environment exchange processes of agency, belonging, or stress. People living with dementia actively shape, use, seek out, and avoid their environment as a reaction to both declining abilities and environmental barriers. Specifically, feelings of connectedness and familiarity are important.

DISCUSSION AND IMPLICATIONS

Taking both an environmental gerontology perspective and a processual, that is, transition perspective broadens the understanding of the experience and behavior of people living with early dementia. They constantly interact with and shape their environment and desire a sense of belonging. This sense of belonging might be threatened by dementia but can be actively reinforced by people living with dementia. These person-environment processes and their dynamics over time should be further investigated. Especially, quantitative data and data on socioeconomic environments are lacking.

Monitoring and Evaluation of Dementia-Friendly Neighborhoods Using a Walkshed Approach: Protocol for a Scoping Review

BACKGROUND

The number of people in society living with dementia is growing. In Canada, most people who live with dementia live at home, often in a neighborhood setting. Neighborhood environments can be a source of independence, social engagement, and well-being. They can also contain barriers that limit physical activity, social engagement, and well-being. A dementia-friendly neighborhood includes assets that support persons living with dementia and their caregivers in multiple life domains, including those that support walking within the neighborhood environment.

OBJECTIVE

The objectives for this scoping review are twofold. First, focusing on walkshed analysis, we aim to extend scholarly understandings of methodological practices used in the monitoring and evaluation of dementia-friendly neighborhoods. Second, we aim to provide clear and practical guidance for those working in planning, design, and public health fields to assess the neighborhood context in support of evidence-based action to improve the lives of persons living with dementia.

METHODS

The study design follows Arksey and O'Malley's scoping review framework and PRISMA-P (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Protocols) guidelines. We will conduct a search of peer-reviewed studies in 6 electronic databases to identify the use of Geographic Information System analysis to measure the walkshed of persons living with dementia in a community setting. As age is a primary risk factor associated with dementia, we will also include studies that focus more broadly on community-dwelling older adults aged 65 years and older. Data will be extracted, analyzed, and represented according to 3 domains. This includes study details, walkshed analysis methods, and criteria and indicators used to measure dementia-friendly neighborhoods.

RESULTS

The results of the study and the submission of a manuscript for peer review are expected in June 2024. The results of the review are expected to contribute to an understanding of methods for monitoring and evaluating dementia-friendly neighborhoods. Expected findings will include a detailed breakdown of current parameters and routines used to conduct walkshed analysis. Findings will also convey criteria that can be operationalized in a Geographic Information System as indicators to assess barriers and facilitators to walking in a neighborhood setting.

CONCLUSIONS

As far as we are aware, the proposed scoping review will be the first to provide comprehensive methodological or technical guidance for conducting walkshed analysis specific to persons living with dementia. Both the scalability and objective nature of walkshed analysis are likely to be of direct interest to public health practitioners, planners, and allied professionals. Clearly documenting methods used in walkshed analysis can spur increased collaboration across these disciplines to enable an evidence-informed approach to improving neighborhood environments for persons living with dementia.

INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID)

PRR1-10.2196/50548.

Understanding the home environment of older adults living with dementia: A scoping review of assessment tools

Rigorous assessments to better understand the person-environment interaction are essential to comprehend how neurocognitive disorders influence in-home functioning of older people living with dementia. No recent synthesis identifies validated instruments targeting the human (e.g. caregivers) and nonhuman (e.g. objects) elements of the home environment interacting with this population and used with the perspective of aging in place. Consequently, following Arksey and O'Malley's (2005) scoping review method, 2,182 articles were identified in six databases and in gray literature. Two reviewers independently selected 23 relevant articles describing 19 validated assessment tools targeting elements of the home interacting with older people with dementia, namely: nonhuman environment (n = 13), human environment (n = 3), and person-environment interaction (n = 3). This overview highlights the scarcity of tools addressing the human environment and the person-environment interaction to foster sustainable at-home living for older people with neurocognitive disorders, demonstrating the need to incorporate new evidence-based, holistic methods into dementia home care.

Monitoring and evaluation of dementia-friendly neighbourhoods using a walkshed approach: A scoping review protocol (Preprint).. [DOI: 10.2196/preprints.50548] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

UNSTRUCTURED

The number of people in society living with Dementia is growing. In Canada, most people who live with dementia live at home, often in a neighbourhood setting. Neighbourhood environments can be source of independence, social engagement, and well-being, but can also contain barriers that limit physical activity, social engagement, and well-being. A dementia-friendly neighbourhood includes assets that support persons living with dementia and their caregivers in multiple life domains, including those that support walking within the neighbourhood environment. The study design follow’s Arksey and O’Malley’s scoping review framework and PRISMA-P guidelines. A search of peer-reviewed studies in six electronic databases will be conducted to identify the use of GIS analysis to measure the walkshed of persons living with dementia in a community setting. Data will be extracted, analyzed and represented according to three domains, including study details, walkshed analysis methods, and criteria and indicators used to measure dementia-friendly neighbourhoods. Results of the review are expected to contribute understanding of methods for monitoring and evaluation of dementia friendly neighbourhoods. Both the scalability and objective nature of walkshed analysis are likely to be of direct interest to public health practitioners and planning and allied professionals.

Inequality in housing transitions during cognitive decline

Independent living can become challenging for people experiencing cognitive decline. With reduced functioning and greater care needs, many people with dementia (PWD) may need to move to another home with better safety features, move to live closer to or with relatives who can provide care, or enter a nursing home. Housing plays a key role in supporting quality of life for both PWD and their caregivers, so the ability to move when needed is crucial for their well-being. Yet the substantial costs of moving, housing, and care mean that PWD with limited financial resources may be unable to afford moving, exacerbating inequalities between more and less advantaged PWD. Emerging qualitative research considers the housing choices of PWD and their caregivers, yet little is known on a broader scale about the housing transitions PWD actually make over the course of cognitive decline. Prior quantitative research focuses specifically on nursing home admissions; questions remain about how often PWD move to another home or move in with relatives. This study investigates socioeconomic and racial/ethnic disparities in the timing and type of housing transitions among PWD in the United States, using Health and Retirement study data from 2002 through 2016. We find that over half of PWD move in the years around dementia onset (28% move once, and 28% move twice or more) while 44% remain in place. Examining various types of moves, 35% move to another home, 32% move into nursing homes, and 11% move in with relatives. We find disparities by educational attainment and race/ethnicity: more advantaged PWD are more likely to move to another home and more likely to enter a nursing home than less advantaged groups. This highlights the importance of providing support for PWD and their families to transition into different living arrangements as their housing needs change.

Putting "the broken bits together": A qualitative exploration of the impact of communication changes in dementia

INTRODUCTION

Communication is an area of health and functioning that is profoundly affected by dementia. While it is known that people living with dementia and their care partners experience disruptions to daily activities and social engagement, detailed knowledge about the lived impact of dementia-related communication changes is lacking. This study sought an in-depth understanding of the lived experience of dementia-related communication changes and the associated impact, needs, and strategies.

METHODS

As part of an overarching participatory design study, a qualitative (interpretive description) exploration was undertaken with people living with dementia and their care partners. Data from semi-structured interviews were analysed using thematic analysis.

RESULTS

We interviewed 13 people living with dementia and 21 care partners and drew three themes and 10 subthemes from the interviews. The first theme illustrates how dementia changes communication which in turn changes life; the second captures the impact of changes on people living with dementia and care partners emotionally and in the context of relationships; and the third describes some positive and constructive ways of moving forward with dementia-related communication changes.

CONCLUSIONS

Interventions to enhance function, participation, and wellbeing for people living with dementia and their care partners need to encompass support for communication changes. There is a need to ensure that people living with dementia feel dignified and respected during communication, and that care partners and inclusive communities are educated, trained, and supported to facilitate communication.

Friendly Residential Environments and Subjective Well-Being in Older People with and without Help Needs

Previous studies have shown that friendly environments are associated with well-being and higher quality of life in older people. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between friendly environments and subjective well-being by segmenting the population according to the need for help in performing activities of daily living (ADLs) in a representative sample of people over 55 years of age in the Basque Country (Spain) (n = 2760). To determine the predictive power of friendliness on subjective well-being, two separate linear regression models were obtained according to the need for help in ADLs. The results obtained show a greater explanatory power of the model in the case of people who required help. However, in the case of people who do not need help, subjective health had a greater weight in the predictions. This paper's findings support the greater importance of the characteristics of the physical and social environment, as people's functional status worsens, with friendliness being an explanatory factor for people's well-being as they age and their dependency increases.

Older adults' adaptations to life events: a mobility perspective

Mobility research tends to focus on physical movement and experiences in later life; however, changes in older adult mobility over time remains underexplored. Furthermore, older adults typically experience many life events, some of which result from cognitive and physical decline, and many of which impact mobility. This article aims to explore how life events affect the mobility of older adults over time. We conducted in-depth interviews with 22 older adults aged 55 years and over from Lancashire, United Kingdom. Of these participants, eight lived with memory problems. The findings show that both anticipated and unexpected life events play a profound role in the participants' mobility over time. Retirement, long-term illness and age-related illness were examples of anticipated life events, while the death of a loved one and developing memory problems were examples of unexpected life events. In both cases, participants' made external adaptations, such as moving home, or internal adaptations, such as self-awareness. The findings also emphasise the layered nature of life events and adaptations playing a role in the participants' mobility. Additionally, life events such as developing memory problems showed a domino effect, triggering further life events and adaptations which impacted the participants' mobility. This article emphasises how transition periods can occur before or after a life event, showing that adaptations can be pre-emptive to a life event. Our article contributes to calls for internal adaptations to be fully incorporated into age-related policy and also for age-related policy to be more inclusive for older adults who experience memory problems and dementia.

Taking time: The temporal politics of dementia, care and support in the neighbourhood

Dementia is a global health challenge and currently the focus of a coordinated international response articulated through the notion of 'dementia-friendly communities and initiatives' (DFCIs). Yet, while increasing research attention has been paid to the social and spatial dimensions to life with dementia in a neighbourhood setting, the temporalities of dementia have been largely overlooked. This article sets out different aspects of the lived experience of time for people with dementia and unpaid carers, before exploring the temporal politics of formal dementia care and support. The authors show that time is a site for material struggle and a marker of unequal relations of power. People with dementia and unpaid carers are disempowered through access to formal care, and this is illustrated in their loss of (temporal) autonomy and limited options for changing the conditions of the care received. The authors advocate for a time-space configured understanding of the relationship with neighbourhood and foreground a tempo-material understanding of dementia. Set against the backdrop of austerity policy in the UK, the findings reveal that ongoing budgetary restrictions have diminished the capacity for social care to mediate in questions of social justice and inequality, at times even compounding inequity.

Assessment tools for measurement of dementia-friendliness of a community: A scoping review

BACKGROUND

A quantitative assessment of the dementia-friendliness of a community can support planning and evaluation of dementia-friendly community (DFC) initiatives, internal review, and national/international comparisons, encouraging a more systematic and strategic approach to the advancement of DFCs. However, assessment of the dementia-friendliness of a community is not always conducted and continuous improvement and evaluation of the impact of dementia-friendly initiatives are not always undertaken. A dearth of applicable evaluation tools is one reason why there is a lack of quantitative assessments of the dementia-friendliness of communities working on DFC initiatives.

PURPOSE

A scoping review was conducted to identify and examine assessment tools that can be used to conduct quantitative assessments of the dementia-friendliness of a community.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Peer-reviewed studies related to DFCs were identified through a search of seven electronic databases (MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Embase, EMCare, HealthSTAR, and AgeLine). Grey literature on DFCs was identified through a search of the World Wide Web and personal communication with community leads in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Characteristics of identified assessment tools were tabulated, and a narrative summary of findings was developed along with a discussion of strengths and weaknesses of identified tools.

RESULTS

Forty tools that assess DFC features (built environment, dementia awareness and attitudes, and community needs) were identified. None of the identified tools were deemed comprehensive enough for the assessment of community needs of people with dementia.

Social Citizenship Through Out-of-Home Participation Among Older Adults With and Without Dementia

There is limited empirical knowledge about how older adults living with dementia enact their social citizenship through out-of-home participation. This study aimed: (a) to investigate out-of-home participation among older adults with and without dementia in four countries and (b) to compare aspects of stability or change in out-of-home participation. Using a cross-sectional design, older adults with mild-to-moderate dementia and without dementia, aged 55 years and over, were interviewed using the Participation in ACTivities and Places OUTside the Home questionnaire in Canada (n = 58), Sweden (n = 69), Switzerland (n = 70), and the United Kingdom (n = 128). Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and a two-way analysis of variance. After adjustment for age, diagnosis of dementia and country of residence had significant effects on total out-of-home participation (p < .01). The results contribute to policies and development of programs to facilitate social citizenship by targeting specific activities and places.

Living with the aftermaths of a stroke in the era of the COVID-19 pandemic; the significance of home and close surroundings

Stay-at-home recommendations to reduce the spread of the COVID-19 virus have had a major impact on people's everyday lives. However, while the evidence indicates that such recommendations have caused distress, anxiety, and fear among the public, little is known about how persons living with complex health conditions, e.g., disability after stroke, have experienced and handled the situation. We interviewed fourteen participants (7 women, 7 men) aged 61–91 years living in ordinary housing during summer 2020 to explore how people who recovered after a stroke experienced their everyday lives in their homes and close surroundings during the COVID-19 pandemic recommendations. Three intertwined themes were constructed from the narrative data and the iterative thematic analysis: (1) Places within and out of reach, (2) Upholding activities–strategies and structures, and (3) Adapting to new circumstances. The findings suggest that places within reach were important to maintain activities and provide structure in daily life. The participants seemed to make use of their previous experiences of adjusting to new circumstances after stroke when adapting to living under the stay-at-home recommendations. In addition, feeling that they now shared the restrictions with all other people in society seemed to ease their situations. Access to nature and spaces in the close surroundings was essential for staying socially connected and receiving support in daily life. The significance of the home and the neighbourhood for health experiences among people who recently have had a stroke should inform rehabilitation interventions both during and after pandemics and environmental planning.

Feasibility, Interrater Reliability and Internal Consistency of the German Environmental Audit Tool (G-EAT)

Dementia-specific environmental design has the potential to positively influence capabilities for daily living and quality of life in people with dementia living in nursing homes. To date, no reliable instrument exists for systematically assessing the adequacy of these built environments in Germany. This study aimed to test the adapted version of the Environmental Audit Tool-High Care (EAT-HC)-the German Environmental Audit Tool (G-EAT)-with regard to its feasibility, interrater reliability and internal consistency. The G-EAT was applied as a paper-pencil version in the German setting; intraclass correlation coefficients at the subscale level ranged from 0.662 (III) to 0.869 (IV), and 42% of the items showed at least substantial agreement (Cohen's kappa ≥ 0.60). The results indicate the need to develop supplementary material in a manual that illustrates the meaning of the items and practical implications regarding dementia-specific environmental design. Furthermore, the intersectionality of built and physical environments must be considered when interpreting G-EAT results in future research and applications to residential long-term care practice.