Osteomark: a surgical navigation system for oral and maxillofacial surgery

Computer-assisted navigation in oral and maxillofacial surgery: A systematic review

Background

The term "navigation" describes a device that can pinpoint critical anatomical features, the most direct path to the target, and the optimal surgical orientation. This study aimed to conduct a comprehensive literature search on computer-assisted navigation for use in oral and maxillofacial surgery.

Methods

Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement, relevant studies were retrieved from five electronic databases: Medline, Web of Science, PubMed, Google Scholar, and Saudi Digital Library (SDL). The central question was, "Does the computer-assisted navigation system improve the outcome of surgical procedures in the oral and maxillofacial region?" The Cochrane Risk of Bias 2 was used to determine the various types of bias.

Results

Post-traumatic midfacial reconstruction is one of the many fields that have benefited from the use of computer-assisted navigation because of its reliability. It can also be used to extricate difficult foreign entities from the operative zone. Locating critical anatomical components, communicating the surgical plan to the patient, and verifying surgical success can improve the function and appearance of patients with dentofacial abnormalities. In addition, it decreases the surgical error margin and duration.

Conclusion

Computer-assisted navigation is promising in surgical practice. The accuracy of surgery can be significantly enhanced by first planning the process in a virtual environment and then performing it under close supervision in real time. In addition, the time required for preoperative planning and surgery can be reduced by creating and improving software programs.

Training of novice surgeons using dynamic computer assisted dental implant surgery: An exploratory randomized trial

BACKGROUND

Dynamic Computer Assisted Implant Surgery (CAIS) systems have been shown to improve accuracy of implant placement, thus training in the use of such systems is becoming increasingly important. There is a scarcity of research on how to implement dynamic CAIS training in the settings of postgraduate university education.

PURPOSE

To determine the effectiveness of two modes of CAIS training programs on motor skill acquisition of novice surgeons.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty-six postgraduate students without experience in dynamic CAIS systems were randomly assigned to a distributed training program (3 training sessions over 3 days) or a massed training (3 training sessions over the same day). A post-test involving the placement of one implant was conducted for both groups, 7 days after completion of the training. Surgical time and implant accuracy were recorded and analyzed, using independent t-tests, with 0.05 significant level.

RESULTS

Both groups reached the accuracy benchmarks expected by current standards in the use of CAIS. No significant differences with regards to accuracy were found between the groups, but a trend was documented favoring performance of distributed (mean difference-0.4, 95% confidence interval-0.7-0.1) in the accuracy at platform level. Distributed training students performed faster than massed for the third trial (mean difference-95.0, 95% confidence interval-178.8 to -11.2).

CONCLUSIONS

Novice students reached the accuracy benchmarks with the use of CAIS through both a massed and a distributed training program, while there was a strong but marginally not significant trend for higher accuracy in the distributed group. Students who received the training in the distributed format over the process of different days, performed faster. Trial registered in Thai Clinical Trials Registry: https://www.thaiclinicaltrials.org/show/TCTR20230109002. This clinical trial was not registered prior to participant recruitment and randomization.

The accuracy and learning curves of active and passive dynamic navigation-guided dental implant surgery: An in vitro study

OBJECTIVES

Infrared dynamic navigation principles can be categorized into active and passive navigation systems based on whether the surgical instruments can emit or only reflect light, respectively. This in vitro study aimed to compare the accuracy of implant placement and the learning curves of both active and passive dynamic navigation systems using different registration methods.

METHODS

Implants (n=704) were placed in 64 sets of models and divided into active (Yizhime, DCARER, Suzhou, China) and passive (Iris-Clinic, EPED, Kaohsiung, China) dynamic navigation groups. Both marker point-based registration (M-PBR) and feature point-based registration (F-PBR) were employed by two groups mentioned above. Based on preoperative and postoperative cone-beam computed tomography imaging, the coronal, midpoint, apical, and angular deviations were analyzed from 2D and 3D views. The operation time was recorded for each group.

RESULTS

The active dynamic navigation group exhibited significantly greater accuracy than the passive dynamic navigation group for outcome variables (angular deviation, 4.13 ± 2.39° and 4.62 ± 3.32°; coronal global deviation, 1.48 ± 0.60 and 1.86 ± 1.12 mm; apical global deviation, 1.75 ± 0.81 and 2.20 ± 1.68 mm, respectively). Significant interaction effects were observed for both registration methods and four quadrants with different dynamic navigation systems. Learning curves for the two dynamic navigation groups approached each other after 12 procedures, and finally converged after 27 procedures.

CONCLUSIONS

The accuracy of active dynamic navigation system was superior to that of passive dynamic navigation system. Different combinations of dynamic navigation systems, registration methods, and implanted quadrants displayed various interactions.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

Our findings could provide guidance for surgeons in choosing an appropriate navigation system use in various implant surgeries. Furthermore, the time required by surgeons to master the technique was calculated for reference. Nevertheless, there are certain limitations to this in vitro study, and therefore further research is required.

Augmented reality navigation with real-time tracking for facial repair surgery

PURPOSE

Facial repair surgeries (FRS) require accuracy for navigating the critical anatomy safely and quickly. The purpose of this paper is to develop a method to directly track the position of the patient using video data acquired from the single camera, which can achieve noninvasive, real time, and high positioning accuracy in FRS.

METHODS

Our method first performs camera calibration and registers the surface segmented from computed tomography to the patient. Then, a two-step constraint algorithm, which includes the feature local constraint and the distance standard deviation constraint, is used to find the optimal feature matching pair quickly. Finally, the movements of the camera and the patient decomposed from the image motion matrix are used to track the camera and the patient, respectively.

RESULTS

The proposed method achieved fusion error RMS of 1.44 ± 0.35, 1.50 ± 0.15, 1.63 ± 0.03 mm in skull phantom, cadaver mandible, and human experiments, respectively. The above errors of the proposed method were lower than those of the optical tracking system-based method. Additionally, the proposed method could process video streams up to 24 frames per second, which can meet the real-time requirements of FRS.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed method does not rely on tracking markers attached to the patient; it could be executed automatically to maintain the correct augmented reality scene and overcome the decrease in positioning accuracy caused by patient movement during surgery.

Electromagnetic surgical navigation in patients undergoing mandibular surgery

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of electromagnetic (EM) navigation for guidance on osteotomies in patients undergoing oncologic mandibular surgery. Preoperatively, a 3D rendered model of the mandible was constructed from diagnostic computed tomography (CT) images. Cutting guides and patient specific reconstruction plates were designed and printed for intraoperative use. Intraoperative patient registration was performed using a cone beam CT scan (CBCT). The location of the mandible was tracked with an EM sensor fixated to the mandible. The real-time location of both the mandible and a pointer were displayed on the navigation system. Accuracy measurements were performed by pinpointing four anatomical landmarks and four landmarks on the cutting guide using the pointer on the patient and comparing these locations to the corresponding locations on the CBCT. Differences between actual and virtual locations were expressed as target registration error (TRE). The procedure was performed in eleven patients. TREs were 3.2 ± 1.1 mm and 2.6 ± 1.5 mm using anatomical landmarks and landmarks on the cutting guide, respectively. The navigation procedure added on average half an hour to the duration of the surgery. This is the first study that reports on the accuracy of EM navigation in patients undergoing mandibular surgery.

[Application of mixed reality technique for the surgery of oral and maxillofacial tumors]

OBJECTIVE

To explore the application of mixed reality technique for the surgery of oral and maxillofacial tumors.

METHODS

In this study, patients with a diagnosis of an oral and maxillofacial tumor who were referred to Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology from December 2018 to January 2020 were selected. The preoperative contrast-enhanced computed tomography data of the patients were imported into StarAtlas Holographic Medical Imaging System (Visual 3D Corp., Beijing, China). Three-dimensional (3D) model of tumor and key structures, such as skeleton and vessels were reconstructed to three-dimensionally present the spatial relationship between them, followed with the key structures delineation and preoperative virtual surgical planning. By using mixed reality technique, the real-time 3D model was displayed stereotactically in the surgical site. While keeping sterile during operation, the surgeon could use simple gestures to adjust the 3D model, and observed the location, range, and size of tumor and the key structures adjacent to the tumor. Mixed reality technique was used to assist the operation: 3D model registration was performed for guidance before tumor excision; intraoperative real-time verification was performed during tumor exposure and after excision of the tumor. The Likert scale was used to evaluate the application of mixed reality technique after the operation.

RESULTS

Eight patients underwent mixed reality assisted tumor resection, and all of them successfully completed the operation. The average time of the 3D model registration was 12.0 minutes. In all the cases, the surgeon could intuitively and three-dimensionally observe the 3D model of the tumor and the surrounding anatomical structures, and could adjust the model during the operation. The results of the Likert scale showed that mixed reality technique got high scores in terms of perceptual accuracy, helping to locate the anatomical parts, the role of model guidance during surgery, and the potential for improving surgical safety (4.22, 4.19, 4.16, and 4.28 points respectively). Eight patients healed well without perioperative complications.

CONCLUSION

By providing real-time stereotactic visualization of anatomy of surgical site and guiding the operation process through 3D model, mixed reality technique could improve the accuracy and safety of the excision of oral and maxillofacial tumors.

Comparing Accuracy of Implant Installation with a Navigation System (NS), a Laboratory Guide (LG), NS with LG, and Freehand Drilling

The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy of implant placement by using the conventional freehand method, the surgical guide alone, the dental navigation system alone, and the dental navigation system with a surgical guide. The participants were aged 20 years or older and were requiring dental implant surgery according to an assessment made by a dentist between July 2014 and December 2017. A total of 128 dental implants were inserted, 32 dental implants in each group, and participants with similar or identical age (i.e., 20–50 years or 50 years or above) and missing tooth locations were paired for comparison. Accuracy was measured by overlaying the real position in the postoperative Cone Beam Computerized Tomography (CBCT) on the virtual presurgical placement of the implant in a CBCT image. Using the dental navigation system with a surgical guide could help dentists to position implants more accurately. Total, longitudinal, and angular error deviation were significantly different (p < 0.0001). The same level of accuracy could be obtained for the different jaws and tooth positions. The one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) showed that the total, longitudinal, and angular errors differed significantly (p < 0.0001). A comparison of the four dental implant surgical methods indicated that the combination of a dental implant navigation system and a surgical guide kit achieved the highest accuracy in terms of the different tooth positions and jaws.

A practical marker-less image registration method for augmented reality oral and maxillofacial surgery

BACKGROUND

Image registration lies in the core of augmented reality (AR), which aligns the virtual scene with the reality. In AR surgical navigation, the performance of image registration is vital to the surgical outcome.

METHODS

This paper presents a practical marker-less image registration method for AR-guided oral and maxillofacial surgery where a virtual scene is generated and mixed with reality to guide surgical operation or provide surgical outcome visualization in the manner of video see-through overlay. An intraoral 3D scanner is employed to acquire the patient's teeth shape model intraoperatively. The shape model is then registered with a custom-made stereo camera system using a novel 3D stereo matching algorithm and with the patient's CT-derived 3D model using an iterative closest point scheme, respectively. By leveraging the intraoral 3D scanner, the CT space and the stereo camera space are associated so that surrounding anatomical models and virtual implants could be overlaid on the camera's view to achieve AR surgical navigation.

RESULTS

Jaw phantom experiments were performed to evaluate the target registration error of the overlay, which yielded an average error of less than 0.50 mm with the time cost less than 0.5 s. Volunteer trial was also conducted to show the clinical feasibility.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed registration method does not rely on any external fiducial markers attached to the patient. It performs automatically so as to maintain a correct AR scene, overcoming the misalignment difficulty caused by patient's movement. Therefore, it is noninvasive and practical in oral and maxillofacial surgery.

Application of a newly designed mandibular distraction device for navigation surgery in goats

PURPOSE

This animal study is to investigate the accuracy of navigation-guided mandibular distraction osteogenesis with a special designed distraction device by TBNavis-CMFS navigation system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Four goats were included in this study. The 3D simulation unilateral mandibular distraction osteogenesis was simulated for 14 mm lengthening in TBNavis-CMFS navigation system. A new designed mandibular distraction device with the detachable adapter for navigation surgery in combination with the specific mandibular dynamic reference frame was applied. Navigation guided distraction osteogenesis was performed on goats and mandible was gradually distracted according to the simulation. Postsurgical 3-D skeletal measurements of presurgical simulations and postsurgical outcomes were compared statistically.

RESULTS

Navigation assisted distraction osteogenesis was successfully performed and the new designed distraction devices worked uneventful. The accuracy of intra-operative registration was within 1 mm. The mandible was lengthened for 14.25 mm in average (13.87-14.36 mm). There were no significant differences between simulation distraction and post-operative 3-D measurements (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

A new designed distraction device could be used in navigation guided mandibular distraction osteogenesis on goats with high accuracy by using the TBNavis-CMFS navigation system.

Video see-through augmented reality for oral and maxillofacial surgery

BACKGROUND

Oral and maxillofacial surgery has not been benefitting from image guidance techniques owing to the limitations in image registration.

METHODS

A real-time markerless image registration method is proposed by integrating a shape matching method into a 2D tracking framework. The image registration is performed by matching the patient's teeth model with intraoperative video to obtain its pose. The resulting pose is used to overlay relevant models from the same CT space on the camera video for augmented reality.

RESULTS

The proposed system was evaluated on mandible/maxilla phantoms, a volunteer and clinical data. Experimental results show that the target overlay error is about 1 mm, and the frame rate of registration update yields 3-5 frames per second with a 4 K camera.

CONCLUSIONS

The significance of this work lies in its simplicity in clinical setting and the seamless integration into the current medical procedure with satisfactory response time and overlay accuracy. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Mandibular Tissue Engineering: Past, Present, Future

Almost 2 decades ago, the senior author's (M.T.J.) first article was with our mentor, Dr Leonard B. Kaban, a review article titled "Distraction Osteogenesis: Past, Present, Future." In 1998, many thought it would be impossible to have a remotely activated, small, curvilinear distractor that could be placed using endoscopic techniques. Currently, a U.S. patent for a curvilinear automated device and endoscopic techniques for minimally invasive access for jaw reconstruction exist. With minimally invasive access for jaw reconstruction, the burden to decrease donor site morbidity has increased. Distraction osteogenesis (DO) is an in vivo form of tissue engineering. The DO technique eliminates a donor site, is less invasive, requires a shorter operative time than usual procedures, and can be used for multiple reconstruction applications. Tissue engineering could further reduce morbidity and cost and increase treatment availability. The purpose of the present report was to review our experience with tissue engineering of bone: the past, present, and our vision for the future. The present report serves as a tribute to our mentor and acknowledges Dr Kaban for his incessant tutelage, guidance, wisdom, and boundless vision.

Vision-based markerless registration using stereo vision and an augmented reality surgical navigation system: a pilot study

Background

This study evaluated the use of an augmented reality navigation system that provides a markerless registration system using stereo vision in oral and maxillofacial surgery.

Method

A feasibility study was performed on a subject, wherein a stereo camera was used for tracking and markerless registration. The computed tomography data obtained from the volunteer was used to create an integral videography image and a 3-dimensional rapid prototype model of the jaw. The overlay of the subject’s anatomic site and its 3D-IV image were displayed in real space using a 3D-AR display. Extraction of characteristic points and teeth matching were done using parallax images from two stereo cameras for patient-image registration.

Results

Accurate registration of the volunteer’s anatomy with IV stereoscopic images via image matching was done using the fully automated markerless system, which recognized the incisal edges of the teeth and captured information pertaining to their position with an average target registration error of < 1 mm. These 3D-CT images were then displayed in real space with high accuracy using AR. Even when the viewing position was changed, the 3D images could be observed as if they were floating in real space without using special glasses.

Conclusion

Teeth were successfully used for registration via 3D image (contour) matching. This system, without using references or fiducial markers, displayed 3D-CT images in real space with high accuracy. The system provided real-time markerless registration and 3D image matching via stereo vision, which, combined with AR, could have significant clinical applications.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12880-015-0089-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Static or Dynamic Navigation for Implant Placement-Choosing the Method of Guidance

The purpose of the present report is to contrast and compare 2 methods of dental implant placement. One method uses computed tomography data for computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing to generate static guides for implant placement. The second method is a dynamic navigation system that uses a stereo vision computer triangulation setup to guide implant placement. A review of the published data was performed to provide evidence-based material to compare each method. Finally, the indications for each type of method are discussed.

Approach to intraoperative electromagnetic navigation in orthognathic surgery: A phantom skull based trial

INTRODUCTION

Intraoperative guidance using electromagnetic navigation is an upcoming method in maxillofacial surgery. However, due to their unwieldy structures, especially the line-of-sight problem, optical navigation devices are not used for daily orthognathic surgery. Therefore, orthognathic surgery was simulated on study phantom skulls, evaluating the accuracy and handling of a new electromagnetic tracking system.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Le-Fort I osteotomies were performed on 10 plastic skulls. Orthognathic surgical planning was done in the conventional way using plaster models. Accuracy of the gold standard, splint-based model surgery versus an electromagnetic tracking system was evaluated by measuring the actual maxillary deviation using bimaxillary splints and preoperative and postoperative cone beam computer tomography imaging. The distance of five anatomical marker points were compared pre- and postoperatively.

RESULTS

The electromagnetic tracking system was significantly more accurate in all measured parameters compared with the gold standard using bimaxillary splints (p < 0.01). The data shows a discrepancy between the model surgical plans and the actual correction of the upper jaw of 0.8 mm. Using the electromagnetic tracking, we could reduce the discrepancy of the maxillary transposition between the planned and actual orthognathic surgery to 0.3 mm on average.

DISCUSSION

The data of this preliminary study shows a high level of accuracy in surgical orthognathic performance using electromagnetic navigation, and may offer greater precision than the conventional plaster model surgery with bimaxillary splints.

CONCLUSION

This preliminary work shows great potential for the establishment of an intraoperative electromagnetic navigation system for maxillofacial surgery.

Assessment of the OsteoMark-Navigation System for Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery

PURPOSE

To assess the accuracy of a novel navigation system for maxillofacial surgery using human cadavers and a live minipig model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We tested an electromagnetic tracking system (OsteoMark-Navigation) that uses simple sensors to determine the position and orientation of a hand-held pencil-like marking device. The device can translate 3-dimensional computed tomographic data intraoperatively to allow the surgeon to localize and draw a proposed osteotomy or the resection margins of a tumor on bone. The accuracy of the OsteoMark-Navigation system in locating and marking osteotomies and screw positions in human cadaver heads was assessed. In group 1 (n = 3, 6 sides), OsteoMark-Navigation marked osteotomies and screw positions were compared to virtual treatment plans. In group 2 (n = 3, 6 sides), marked osteotomies and screw positions for distraction osteogenesis devices were compared with those performed using fabricated guide stents. Three metrics were used to document the precision and accuracy. In group 3 (n = 1), the system was tested in a standard operating room environment.

RESULTS

For group 1, the mean error between the points was 0.7 mm (horizontal) and 1.7 mm (vertical). Compared with the posterior and inferior mandibular border, the mean error was 1.2 and 1.7 mm, respectively. For group 2, the mean discrepancy between the points marked using the OsteoMark-Navigation system and the surgical guides was 1.9 mm (range 0 to 4.1). The system maintained accuracy on a live minipig in a standard operating room environment.

CONCLUSION

Based on this research OsteoMark-Navigation is a potentially powerful tool for clinical use in maxillofacial surgery. It has accuracy and precision comparable to that of existing clinical applications.

Optimization of the interface between radiology, surgery, radiotherapy, and pathology in head and neck tumor surgery: a navigation-assisted multidisciplinary network

A navigation-assisted multidisciplinary network to improve the interface between radiology, surgery, radiotherapy, and pathology in the field of head and neck cancer is described. All implicated fields are integrated by a common server platform and have remote data access in a ready-to-use format. The margins of resection and exact locations of biopsies are mapped intraoperatively. The pathologist uses the numerical coordinates of these samples to precisely trace each specimen in the anatomical field. Subsequently, map-guided radiotherapy is planned. In addition to the benefits of image-guided resection, this model enables radiotherapy planning according to the specific coordinates of the resection defect plus any residually affected sites identified by the pathologist. Irradiation of adjacent healthy structures is thereby minimized. In summary, the navigation-assisted network described grants timely multidisciplinary feedback between all fields involved, attains meticulous pathological definition, and permits optimized coordinate-directed radiotherapy.