Pupillary light reflex as a diagnostic aid from computational viewpoint: A systematic literature review

Basics, benefits, and pitfalls of pupillometers assessing visual function

Numerous commercially and non-commercially available pupillometers are nowadays able to assess various biological functions in humans, by evaluating pupils' dynamics in response to specific stimuli. However, the use of pupillometers for ophthalmic afferent evaluations (i.e., photoreceptoral responses) in real-world settings is relatively limited. Recent scientific and technological advances, coupled with artificial intelligence methods have improved the performance of such devices to objectively detect, quantify, and classify functional disturbances of the retina and the optic nerve. This review aims to summarize the scientific principles, indications, outcomes, and current limitations of pupillometry used for evaluation of afferent pathways in ophthalmic clinical settings.

Evaluating the utility of quantitative pupillometry in a neuro-critical care setting for the monitoring of intracranial pressure: A prospective cohort study

INTRODUCTION

Assessment of the pupillary light reflex (PLR) is key in intensive care monitoring of neurosurgical patients, particularly for monitoring intracranial pressure (ICP). Quantitative pupillometry using a handheld pupillometer is a reliable method for PLR assessment. However, many variables are derived from such devices. We therefore aimed to assess the performance of these variables at monitoring ICP.

METHODS

Sedated patients admitted to neurocritical care in a tertiary neurosurgical centre with invasive ICP monitoring were included. Hourly measurement of ICP, subjective pupillometry (SP) using a pen torch device, and quantitative pupillometry (QP) using a handheld pupillometer were performed.

RESULTS

561 paired ICP, SP and QP pupillary observations from nine patients were obtained (1122 total pupillary observations). SP and QP had a moderate concordance for pupillary size (κ=0.62). SP performed poorly at detecting pupillary size changes (sensitivity=24%). In 40 (3.6%) observations, SP failed to detect a pupillary response whereas QP did. Moderate correlations with ICP were detected for maximum constriction velocity (MCV), dilation velocity (DV), and percentage change in pupillary diameter (%C). Discriminatory ability at an ICP threshold of >22 mmHg was moderate for MCV (AUC=0.631), DV (AUC=0.616), %C (AUC=0.602), and pupillary maximum size (AUC=0.625).

CONCLUSION

QP is superior to SP at monitoring pupillary reactivity and changes to pupillary size. Although effect sizes were moderate to weak across assessed variables, our data indicates MCV and %C as the most sensitive variables for monitoring ICP. Further study is required to validate these findings and to establish normal range cut-offs for clinical use.

Effect of Light Intensity on the Relative Afferent Pupillary Defect in Unilateral Neuro-ophthalmic Pathology

SIGNIFICANCE

Objective pupillometry with standardized light intensities allows a comprehensive assessment of the relative afferent pupillary defect in patients with unilateral neuro-ophthalmic pathology.

PURPOSE

This study aimed to determine the impact of varying light intensities on the grade of relative afferent pupillary defect in unilateral neuro-ophthalmic pathology vis-à-vis healthy controls.

METHODS

Monocular pupillary light reflexes of 20 controls (14 to 50 years) and 31 cases (12 to 72 years) with clinically diagnosed relative afferent pupillary defect were measured thrice using 1-second-long light pulses, followed by 3 seconds of darkness, at eight light intensities (6.4 to 1200 lux) using objective pupillometry. The relative afferent pupillary defect was quantified as the ratio of the percentage change in the direct light reflexes of the left and right eyes. Its change with light intensity was described using standard exponential fits.

RESULTS

The median (25th to 75th interquartile range) defect score of 54.8% cases decreased from baseline values of 1.58 (1.25 to 1.87) for right eye pathology and 0.45 (0.39 to 0.55) for left eye pathology to saturation values of 1.18 (1.05 to 1.31) and 0.98 (0.95 to 1.06), respectively, at light intensities between 56.9 and 300.5 lux. Like controls (1.01 [1.00 to 1.06]), the defect scores of the remaining 45.2% cases were constant with light intensity at 1.23 (1.18 to 1.46) and 0.87 (0.86 to 0.89) for right and left eye pathologies, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Relative afferent pupillary defects may decrease with test light intensity in a significant proportion of patients with unilateral neuro-ophthalmic pathology. This highlights the importance of objective pupillometry with standardization light intensities for clinical assessment of afferent pupillary defects.

Visual Quality, Motility Behavior, and Retinal Changes Associated with Reading Tasks Performed on Electronic Devices

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to objectively evaluate visual discomfort using an eye tracker and aberrometer after a 21-min reading session on an iPad and an Ebook. Additionally, retinal changes were analyzed using optical coherence tomography (OCT).

METHODS

A total of 31 young subjects (24 ± 4 years) participated in this study. They read for 21 min on an Ebook and for another 21 min on an iPad under controlled lighting conditions while their eye movements were monitored using an eye tracker. Aberrometry and retinal OCT measurements were taken before and after each reading session. Parameters such as pupil diameter, fixations, saccades, blinks, total aberration, high-order aberration, low-order aberration, and central and peripheral retinal thickness in the nine early treatment diabetic retinopathy study (ETDRS) areas were measured for each reading situation. Statistical analysis was performed on the collected data.

RESULTS

No statistically significant differences (p > 0.05) between the two devices were observed in terms of the different types of eye movements or the changes in retinal thickness. However, the aberrometric analysis showed variations in post-reading situations depending on the device used.

CONCLUSION

Reading speed and visual discomfort resulting from electronic device usage can be objectively assessed using an eye tracker and aberrometer. Additionally, changes found in central and peripheral retinal thickness between the two devices and the baseline measurements were not significant and remained relatively stable.

Combat Sports as a Model for Measuring the Effects of Repeated Head Impacts on Autonomic Brain Function: A Brief Report of Pilot Data

Automated pupil light reflex (PLR) is a valid indicator of dysfunctional autonomic brain function following traumatic brain injury. PLR's use in identifying disturbed autonomic brain function following repeated head impacts without outwardly visible symptoms has not yet been examined. As a combat sport featuring repeated 'sub-concussive' head impacts, mixed martial arts (MMA) sparring may provide a model to understand such changes. The aim of this pilot study was to explore which, if any, PLR variables are affected by MMA sparring. A cohort of n = 7 MMA athletes (age = 24 ± 3 years; mass = 76.5 ± 9 kg; stature = 176.4 ± 8.5 cm) took part in their regular sparring sessions (eight rounds × 3 min: 1 min recovery). PLR of both eyes was measured immediately pre- and post-sparring using a Neuroptic NPi-200. Bayesian paired samples t-tests (BF₁₀ ≥ 3) revealed decreased maximum pupil size (BF₁₀ = 3), decreased minimum pupil size (BF₁₀ = 4) and reduced PLR latency (BF₁₀ = 3) post-sparring. Anisocoria was present prior to sparring and increased post-sparring, with both eyes having different minimum and maximum pupil sizes (BF₁₀ = 3-4) and constriction velocities post-sparring (BF₁₀ = 3). These pilot data suggest repeated head impacts may cause disturbances to autonomic brain function in the absence of outwardly visible symptoms. These results provide direction for cohort-controlled studies to formally investigate the potential changes observed.

Alterations of color vision and pupillary light responses in age-related macular degeneration

Introduction

Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is the leading cause of irreversible central vision loss in developed countries and one of the leading causes of blindness. In this work, we evaluated color vision and the pupil light reflex (PLR) to assess visual function in patients with early and neovascular AMD (NVAMD) compared with the control group.

Methods

We recruited 34 early patients with dry AMD and classified them into two groups following AREDS: 13 patients with NVAMD and 24 healthy controls. Controls and patients with early dry AMD had visual acuity (VA) best or equal to 20/25 (0.098 logMAR). Color vision was assessed in controls and patients with early dry AMD using the Cambridge Color Test (CCT) 2.0 through the Trivector protocol. The PLR was evaluated using a Ganzfeld, controlled by the RETI-port system. The stimuli consisted of 1s blue (470 nm) and red (631 nm) light flashes presented alternately at 2-min intervals. To assess the cone contribution, we used a red flash at 2.4 log cd.m^-2, with a blue background at 0.78 log cd.m^-2. For rods, we used 470-nm flashes at -3 log cd.m^-2, and for the melanopsin function of ipRGCs, we used 470 nm at 2.4 log cd.m^-2.

Results

Patients with early dry AMD had reduced color discrimination in all three axes: protan (p = 0.0087), deutan (p = 0.0180), and tritan (p = 0.0095) when compared with the control group. The PLR has also been affected in patients with early dry AMD and patients with NVAMD. The amplitude for the melanopsin-driven response was smaller in patients with early dry AMD (p = 0.0485) and NVAMD (p = 0.0035) than in the control group. The melanopsin function was lower in patients with NVAMD (p = 0.0290) than the control group. For the rod-driven response, the latency was lower in the NVAMD group (p = 0.0041) than in the control group. No changes were found in cone-driven responses between the control and AMD groups.

Conclusion

Patients with early dry AMD present diffusely acquired color vision alteration detected by CCT. Rods and melanopsin contributions for PLR are affected in NVAMD. The CCT and the PLR may be considered sensitive tests to evaluate and monitor functional changes in patients with AMD.

Pupil assessment with a new handheld pupillometer in healthy subjects

OBJECTIVE

To assess the pupil response with a new handheld pupillometer in healthy subjects.

METHODS

Sixty-four eyes of 32 healthy subjects (mean age 21.2 years) were tested. After dark adaptation for 10 min, pupil responses to 1 s red and blue light stimuli at 100 cd/m² were measured in the order from right to left eyes with a 1 min interval. The initial pupil size (D1, mm), minimum pupil size (D2, mm), and constriction rate (CR, %) were obtained. Intra-examiner reproducibility was examined using the coefficient of variation (CV, %) and the Bland-Altman plot. Inter-examiner consistency was examined using the interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and the agreements with a conventional device, by Pearson's correlation coefficient (r).

RESULTS

The CV of all parameters have high reproducibility in the red (11.0-20.7%) and blue (5.5-12.1%) light stimuli. Bland-Altman plot analysis showed no bias with both light stimuli. "Almost perfect" and "substantial" correlations between the examiners were obtained in the red (ICC = 0.78-0.94) and blue (ICC = 0.71-0.89) light stimuli. "Excellent" and "good" correlations between the devices were obtained, except for the CR parameter in the red (D1: r = 0.90; p < 0.001, D2: 0.72; p < 0.001, and CR: 0.08; p = 0.631, respectively) and blue (D1: r = 0.87; p < 0.001, D2: 0.70; p < 0.001, and CR: 0.19; p = 0.274, respectively) light stimuli.

CONCLUSION

The novel pupillometer is useful for assessing pupil response. However, because of their different constructions, the CR values cannot be compared directly between the devices.

Tracking Eye Movements for Diagnosis in Myasthenia Gravis: A Comprehensive Review

BACKGROUND

Around 60%--75% of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients initially present with nonspecific ocular symptoms. Failed recognition of these symptoms may delay the diagnosis of MG up to 5 years or more, leading to a reduced likelihood of remission and increased morbidity. Current diagnostic tests are either poorly sensitive for patients presenting with ocular symptoms alone or are time consuming, invasive, require a high level of technical expertise, and generally are universally difficult to obtain. This review will explore quantitative eye and pupil tracking as a potential noninvasive, time-effective, and less technically demanding alternative to current diagnostic tests of MG.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

Comprehensive literature review.

RESULTS

Thirty-two publications using oculography for the diagnosis of MG and 6 studies using pupillometry were evaluated. In MG patients, extra ocular muscle fatigue was evident in reports of intersaccadic, intrasaccadic and postsaccadic abnormalities, changes in optokinetic nystagmus, slow eye movements, disconjugate saccades, and pupillary constrictor muscle weakness.

CONCLUSIONS

Our review identified several potentially useful variables that derive from oculography and pupillometry studies that could assist with a timely diagnosis of MG. Limitations of this review include heterogeneity in design, sample size, and quality of the studies evaluated. There is a need for larger, well-designed studies evaluating eye-tracking measures in the diagnosis of MG, especially for patients presenting with purely ocular symptoms.

PupilEXT: Flexible Open-Source Platform for High-Resolution Pupillometry in Vision Research

The human pupil behavior has gained increased attention due to the discovery of the intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells and the afferent pupil control path's role as a biomarker for cognitive processes. Diameter changes in the range of 10-2 mm are of interest, requiring reliable and characterized measurement equipment to accurately detect neurocognitive effects on the pupil. Mostly commercial solutions are used as measurement devices in pupillometry which is associated with high investments. Moreover, commercial systems rely on closed software, restricting conclusions about the used pupil-tracking algorithms. Here, we developed an open-source pupillometry platform consisting of hardware and software competitive with high-end commercial stereo eye-tracking systems. Our goal was to make a professional remote pupil measurement pipeline for laboratory conditions accessible for everyone. This work's core outcome is an integrated cross-platform (macOS, Windows and Linux) pupillometry software called PupilEXT, featuring a user-friendly graphical interface covering the relevant requirements of professional pupil response research. We offer a selection of six state-of-the-art open-source pupil detection algorithms (Starburst, Swirski, ExCuSe, ElSe, PuRe and PuReST) to perform the pupil measurement. A developed 120-fps pupillometry demo system was able to achieve a calibration accuracy of 0.003 mm and an averaged temporal pupil measurement detection accuracy of 0.0059 mm in stereo mode. The PupilEXT software has extended features in pupil detection, measurement validation, image acquisition, data acquisition, offline pupil measurement, camera calibration, stereo vision, data visualization and system independence, all combined in a single open-source interface, available at https://github.com/openPupil/Open-PupilEXT.