Predicted versus executed surgical orthognathic treatment

Accuracy of virtual surgical planning in bimaxillary orthognathic surgery with mandible first sequence: A retrospective study

The aim of this study was to verify treatment accuracy using virtual surgical planning (VSP) with a mandible-first sequence and strict surgical protocol to determine what surgical and methodological factors might influence outcomes. VSP transfer accuracy was evaluated retrospectively through a modified method involving voxel-based superimposition in patients who had undergone bimaxillary surgery with a mandible-first sequence to correct dentoskeletal deformities. Data analysis showed that the movements planned and those executed were substantially equivalent (p < 0.01), with the exception of mandibular and maxillary sagittal movements that were 0.72 ± 0.90 mm and 1.41 ± 1.04 mm smaller, respectively, than planned. This study showed that a mandible-first sequence is accurate for transferring virtual surgical planning intraoperatively. There are several factors involved in the proper transfer of virtual planning beyond the software, such as surgical technique and sequencing. Inaccurate sagittal movements and maxillary repositioning seem to depend mainly on surgical factors.

Operator Performance of the Digital Setup Fabrication for Orthodontic–Orthognathic Treatment: An Explorative Study

The purpose of this study was to explore the operator performance of the fabrication of digital orthodontic setups integrated into cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) scans. Fifteen patients who underwent a combined orthodontic–orthognathic surgical treatment were included. The pre-treatment digital dental models and CBCT scans were fused, and four operators made virtual setups twice for all patients. Differences between the virtual setups were calculated by recording tooth crown movement from the pre-treatment model to the virtual setup. To examine performance, Pearson’s correlation coefficients, duplicate measurement errors, and inter-operator differences were calculated. For intra-operator performance, correlation values varied among tooth types, with mean correlation values from 0.66 to 0.83 for the maxilla and 0.70 to 0.83 for the mandible. For inter-operator performance, mean correlation values varied from 0.40 to 0.87 for the maxilla and from 0.44 to 0.80 for the mandible. Rotational mean differences exceeded the range of clinical acceptance (>2 degrees) at 18% for the maxilla and 20.8% for the mandible, and translational mean differences exceeded the range of clinical acceptance (0.6 mm) at 9.7% and 26% for the maxilla and mandible, respectively. The intra- and inter-operator performance of digital orthodontic setup construction for virtual three-dimensional orthognathic planning shows significant errors.

Complications Following One-Stage Versus Two-Stage Surgical Treatment of Transverse Maxillary Hypoplasia

PURPOSE

Contemporary literature suggests a similar transverse stability of a surgical-assisted rapid palatal expansion and a segmented Le Fort I osteotomy. The aim of this study was to compare postoperative complications of 1-stage (segmental maxillary osteotomy) and 2-stage (surgical-assisted rapid palatal expansion followed by Le Fort I osteotomy) treated patients to determine the preferred treatment strategy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This retrospective study included 74 consecutive patients (age range: 14 - 57 years; 36 males, 38 females) with a moderate transverse maxillary hypoplasia: 32 patients were treated in a 1-stage protocol and 42 in a 2-stage protocol with a postoperative follow-up of at least 1 year. Dental complications such as loss of teeth, gingival dehiscence, periodontal bone loss, apical root resorption, and surgical complications such as pain, hemorrhage, altered neurosensitivity, wound infection, aseptic necrosis were analyzed. Univariate analysis consisted of a generalized linear model with logit link or Fisher exact test.

RESULTS

No significant difference was found for group characteristics except for longer orthodontic treatment time in the 2-stage group. Incidence and severity of complications were comparable for the 1-stage and 2-stage patients. Only overall pain was significantly greater in the 2-stage patient group (P = .038).

CONCLUSIONS

Considering a similar complication rate and transversal stability, the choice between 1-stage and 2-stage approach for patients with a moderate transverse maxillary hypoplasia should be patient specific.

Simplified orthognathic surgical treatment using non-surgical asymmetric maxillary expansion: A case report

BACKGROUND

Transverse problems can be exacerbated by highly compensated occlusion in patients with skeletal asymmetry, which makes pre-surgical decompensation harder to achieve.

OBJECTIVE

This case report describes a case of combined orthognathic surgery with facial asymmetry. We used pre-orthodontic surgical simulation to visualize the goal for presurgical orthodontics, planning for a one-jaw surgical treatment option.

METHODS

The planned asymmetric expansion was performed using a maxillary skeletal expander (MSE II) with surgical corticopuncture over only the left side before MSE activation. Surgery was performed to achieve mandibular left outward yaw rotation to correct the patient's facial asymmetry after the planned amount of expansion was reached.

RESULTS

The results showed substantial improvement of facial aesthetics as well as skeletal symmetry. Cooperation and communication between surgeon and orthodontist ensured that the final results were satisfactory.

Virtual setup in orthodontics: planning and evaluation

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical accuracy of virtual orthodontic setups by using a new CBCT-based approach.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ten patients who underwent pre-surgical orthodontics were included in this study. Pre-treatment and pre-surgical cone-beam CT (CBCT) scans and digital dental models were available. The pre-treatment digital dental model was used to create an orthodontic virtual setup. The digital dental models were fused with the corresponding CBCT scans, and the two CBCT scans were aligned using voxel-based matching. Moving each individual tooth from the virtual setup to the final outcome allows the calculation of the accuracy of the virtual setup by using an iterative closest point algorithm. Differences between virtual setup and final outcome were recorded as well as the ICC between two observers.

RESULTS

The inter-observer variability showed a high level of agreement between the observers. The largest mean difference between observers was found in the cranial/caudal direction (0.36 ± 0.30 mm) and the roll rotation (1.54 ± 0.98°). Differences between the virtual setup and final outcome were small in the translational direction (0.45 ± 0.48 mm). Rotational mean differences were larger with the pitch of the incisors (0.00 ± 7.97°) and molars (0.01 ± 10.26°) as largest difference. Excessive extrusion of all upper teeth and more anterior movement than planned were seen for both upper and lower arch. Lower molars showed less extrusion.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The data of this study can be used to obtain more insight in the accuracy and achievability of orthodontic virtual setup. Tooth movement can now be studied in more details which can lead to new insights.

Bone-borne surgically assisted rapid maxillary expansion: A retrospective three-dimensional evaluation of the asymmetry in expansion

PURPOSE

Asymmetrical expansion occurs in patients treated with Surgically Assisted Rapid Maxillary Expansion (SARME). In the clinical setting, this asymmetrical expansion is seen in multiple directions. However, the frequency, actual directions and amount of asymmetry are unclear. Hence, the aim of this study was to analyze the directions and amount of asymmetrical lateral expansion in non-syndromic patients with transversal maxillary hypoplasia on employing bone-borne transpalatal distraction by means of SARME. Treatment involved corticotomies of all four bony supports, including pterygomaxillary disjunction.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective case series was formed from patients treated with SARME. Pre- and postdistraction Cone Beam Computed Tomography scans were superimposed. A reference frame was created to analyze lateral expansion asymmetries in five directions.

RESULTS

Clinical relevant asymmetries (>3.0 mm) in at least one of the investigated directions occurred in 55% of the patients. Lateral expansion asymmetries occurred mostly in the inferior-anterior part between the left and right segment and asymmetry in total expansion was noted between the anterior and posterior part of the maxilla.

CONCLUSION

This study confirms the clinical suspicion that using SARME with a bone-borne distractor and pterygomaxillary disjunction to treat non-syndromic patients with transversal maxillary hypoplasia, results in regular asymmetrical lateral expansion.

Accuracy of 3-Dimensional Virtual Surgical Simulation Combined With Digital Teeth Alignment: A Pilot Study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the accuracy of virtual surgical simulation combined with digital teeth alignment and the applicability of this technique to the diagnosis and establishment of a 3-dimensional (3D) visualized treatment objective for orthognathic surgery by comparing virtual simulation images with actual post-treatment images.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This retrospective study included patients who underwent computed tomography (CT) before and after treatment. The 3D digital images were constructed from the initial CT images and dental cast scan data, and virtual surgical simulation combined with digital teeth alignment was performed. Accuracy of the virtual simulation was analyzed by comparing the distances of skeletal and dental landmarks in the horizontal, sagittal, and coronal reference planes with those on post-treatment images using the Wilcoxon signed rank test. Intraclass correlation coefficients were calculated to evaluate the degree of concordance between the 2 images.

RESULTS

The study sample included 11 patients (mean age, 18.8 yr). Most landmarks had differences smaller than 2 mm in the 3 reference planes between virtual simulation and post-treatment images; these differences were not statistically significant (P > .05). Most skeletal landmarks, except the A point, B point, and gonion, showed normal to high concordance between the virtual simulation and post-treatment images in the 3 reference planes (P < .05); dental landmarks exhibited a broad range of concordance.

CONCLUSION

The 3D virtual surgical simulation combined with digital teeth alignment using pretreatment CT images yielded results sufficiently accurate to be used for the diagnosis and establishment of visualized treatment objectives for orthognathic surgery.