Christensen vs Biomet Microfixation alloplastic TMJ implant: Are there improvements? A numerical study

Effect of condylar rotation on the stress environment of the temporomandibular joint in patients with mandibular protrusion

PURPOSE

The study aims to analyse the effects of condylar rotation on the biomechanical environment of the TMJ after bilateral sagittal split ramus osteotomy (BSSRO) through the finite element method (FEM).

METHODS

Thirteen patients with mandibular prognathism and twenty-three normal subjects were recruited. The three-dimensional (3D) models were reconstructed. 13 representative morphological parameters were measured for comparison. A patient was selected to perform virtual BSSRO surgery by rotating the condyles in MIMICS. The preoperative and postoperative 3D models of the patient were subsequently imported into ABAQUS for finite element analysis. The preoperative and postoperative stresses and joint spaces in the TMJs were investigated.

RESULTS

The maxillofacial morphologies of the patients with mandibular protrusion was significantly different from those of the asymptomatic subjects (P<.05). Stresses in the postoperative group were lower than those in the preoperative group. The rotation of the condyle could cause the variations in stress levels and joint spaces within the TMJs. Inward and upward rotation of the condyle was associated with higher stress in the TMJ, whereas the lowest stress was observed when the condyle remained stationary following surgical intervention.

SIGNIFICANCE

Lateral, medial and superior joint spaces were more related to the stresses in the TMJs. The condyle should be kept in place as much as possible to avoid disrupting the balance of the TMJ in patients with mandibular protrusion.

Development and validation of a digital twin of the human lower jaw under impact loading by using non-linear finite element analyses

Mandibular fractures are one of the most frequently observed injuries within craniofacial region mostly due to tumor-related problems and traumatic events, often related to non-linear effects like impact loading. Therefore, a validated digital twin of the mandible is required to develop the best possible patient-specific treatment. However, there is a need to obtain a fully compatible numerical model that can reflect the patients' characteristics, be available and accessible quickly, require an acceptable level of modeling efforts and knowledge to provide accurate, robust and fast results at the same time under highly non-linear effects. In this study, a validated simulation methodology is suggested to develop a digital twin of mandible, capable of predicting the non-linear response of the biomechanical system under impact loading, which then can be utilized to design treatment strategies even for multiple fractures of the mandibular system. Using Computed Tomography data containing cranial (skull) images of a patient, a 3-dimensional mandibular model, which consists cortical and cancellous bones, disks and fossa is obtained with high accuracy that is compatible with anatomical boundaries. A Finite Element Model (FEM) of the biomechanical system is then developed for a three-level validation procedure including (A) modal analysis, (B) dynamic loading and (C) impact loading. For the modal analysis stage: Free-free vibration modes and frequencies of the system are validated against cadaver test results. For the dynamic loading stage: Two different regions of the mandible are loaded, and maximum stress levels of the system are validated against finite element analyses (FEA) results, where the first loading condition (i) transfers a 2000 N force acting on the symphysis region and, the second loading condition (ii) transfers a 2000 N force acting on the left body region. In both cases, equivalent muscle forces dependent on time are applied. For the impact loading stage: Thirteen different human mandibular models with various tooth deficiencies are used under the effects of traumatic impact forces that are generated by using an impact hammer with different initial velocities to transfer the impulse and momentum, where contact forces and fracture patterns are validated against cadaver tests. Five different anatomical regions are selected as the impact site. The results of the analyzes (modal, dynamic and impact) performed to validate the digital twin model are compared with the similar FEA and cadaver test results published in the literature and the results are found to be compatible. It has been evaluated that the digital twin model and numerical models are quite realistic and perform well in terms of predicting the biomechanical behavior of the mandible. The three-level validation methodology that is suggested in this research by utilizing non-linear FEA has provided a reliable road map to develop a digital twin of a biomechanical system with enough confidence that it can be utilized for similar structures to offer patient-specific treatments and can help develop custom or tailor-made implants or prosthesis for best compliance with the patient even considering the most catastrophic effects of impact related trauma.

Computational modelling of the fossa component fixation associated with alloplastic total temporomandibular joint replacements

The alloplastic total temporomandibular joint (TMJ) replacement is a complex surgical approach to end-stage TMJ disorders. The fixation of TMJ prostheses remains a critical issue for implant design and performance. For the fossa component, it is generally considered to use fixation screws to achieve tripod stability. However, the fossa may still come loose, and the mechanism remains unknown. A computational framework, consisting of a musculoskeletal model for calculating muscle and TMJ forces, and a finite element model for the fossa fixation simulation, was developed. A polyethylene (PE) fossa with stock prosthesis design was analyzed to predict contact pressures at the fixation interfaces, and stresses/strains in the fossa implant and bone during the static loading of normal chewing bite and maximum-force bite. The predicted maximum von Mises stresses were 33 MPa and 44 MPa for the bone, 13 MPa and 28 MPa for the PE fossa, and 131 MPa and 244 MPa for the screws, for the normal and maximum bites, respectively; the peak minimum principal strain was in the range of -2514 ∼ -3545 με for the bone. The results show that the sufficient initial mechanical strength of the fossa component fixation can be established using the screws in combination with bone support. The functional loads applied through the prosthetic TMJ bearing can be largely transferred to supporting bone without causing high level stresses. Tightening fixation screws with a pretension of 100 N can reduce transverse load to the screws and help prevent screw loosening. Further research is recommended to accurately quantify the transverse load and its influence on screw loosening during dynamic loading, and the frictional properties at the bone-implant interface.

Biomechanical Evaluation of a Standard Temporomandibular Joint Prosthesis and Screw Arrangement Optimization: A Finite Element Analysis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Artificial total joint replacement is an important method of temporomandibular joint (TMJ) reconstruction, which has been advocated for TMJ osteoarthrosis, ankylosis, tumors, and other diseases. We designed one type of standard TMJ prosthesis fit for Chinese patients. This study aimed to explore the biomechanical behavior of the standard TMJ prosthesis using finite element analysis and selects an optimal screw arrangement scheme for clinical application.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A female volunteer was recruited for a maxillofacial computed tomography scan, then the Hypermesh software was used to establish a finite element model of a mandibular condyle defect repaired with an artificial TMJ prosthesis. An advanced universal finite element program software was used to calculate the stress and deformation under a simulated maximum bite force loading. Also, the forces of screws under different numbers and arrangements were analyzed. Meanwhile, we designed an experiment to verify the calculation model.

RESULTS

The average maximum stress of the fossa component of the standard prosthesis model was 19.25 MPa. The average maximum stress of the condyle component was 82.58 MPa, mainly concentrated near the top row hole. The fossa component should be fixed with at least 3 screws, and the optimal number of screws was 4. The condyle component should be fixed with at least 4 screws, and its optimal number was 6. The best scheme of screw arrangement was determined. The results of the verification experiment showed that the analysis was reliable.

CONCLUSIONS

The stress distribution of the standard TMJ prosthesis is uniform, meanwhile, the number and arrangement of the screws significantly affect the contact force of the screws.

Customised Implant for Temporomandibular Joint: New Technique to Design and Stress Analysis to Balance the Loading at Both Ends

The temporomandibular joint (TMJ) is a critical joint for the opening and closing of the mouth. The generation of customised TMJs according to individuals' dental anatomy is needed. Currently, the implants available on the market lack consideration of the patient's dental anatomy. This leads to the creation of an imbalance in the reaction forces on both ends of the TMJ. This requires a slight structural change in the design parameters to give a solution. The purpose of this study is to propose a new design that includes the geometry and materials for a TMJ implant. Stress analysis was carried out on the TMJ to balance the reaction forces at both TMJ ends. A static analysis was performed using ANSYS Workbench, to compare the results of two customised designs of TMJ implants, in order to better balance the reaction forces at both ends. The model in the study showed that the reaction forces for both the patient-specific TMJ implants were nearly balanced. The reaction forces were better balanced, and almost equivalent to the intact conditions. The stresses in the mandible were more uniformly distributed in the customised design of the TMJ implant. The two types of design showed that the custom design took up less space in the patient's region of surgery, making it a better option compared to a stock TMJ implant. The custom implant would allow faster patient rehabilitation, as the reaction forces would be close to those in intact conditions.

Biomechanical Analysis of Patient-Specific Temporomandibular Joint Implant and Comparison with Natural Intact Jaw Bone Using Finite Element Method

The purpose of this study is to design a patient-specific TMJ implant and study its behaviour under different loading conditions compared with natural intact TMJ. There are several diseases, which affect the proper growth and function of TMJ, and in some cases, TMJ injury results from accidents. To repair the TMJ, temporomandibular joint replacement or TJR surgery is performed. In this work, CT-scan data of the skull and mandible region with broken condylar head were used to study the biomechanical behaviour of the intact mandible and customized TMJ prostheses in order to design a patient-specific total TMJ implant. The customized TMJ implant was virtually studied under simulated loading conditions using finite element method (FEM) in ANSYS Workbench and then compared to the intact jaw-mandible for the combinations of two different biocompatible material models. It is observed that the natural TMJ has a higher deformation value as compared to the patient-specific TMJ implant due to the lower mechanical strength of bone relative to the Ti-6Al-4V and Co-Cr alloy. Hence, we can conclude that the designed custom TMJ implant is safe for the patient from the point of design perspective.

3D-printed porous condylar prosthesis for temporomandibular joint replacement: Design and biomechanical analysis

BACKGROUND

Customized prosthetic joint replacements have crucial applications in severe temporomandibular joint problems, and the combined use of porous titanium scaffold is a potential method to rehabilitate the patients.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to develop a design method to obtain a titanium alloy porous condylar prosthesis with good function and esthetic outcomes for mandibular reconstruction.

METHODS

A 3D virtual mandibular model was created from CBCT data. A condylar defect model was subsequently created by virtual condylectomy on the initial mandibular model. The segmented condylar defect model was reconstructed by either solid or porous condyle with a fixation plate. The porous condyle was created by a density-driven modeling scheme with an inhomogeneous tetrahedral lattice structure. The porous condyle, supporting fixation plate, and screw locations were topologically optimized. Biomechanical behaviors of porous and solid condylar prostheses made of Ti-6Al-4V alloy were compared. Finite element analysis (FEA) was used to evaluate maximum stress distribution on both prostheses and the remaining mandibular ramus.

RESULTS

The FEA results showed levels of maximum stresses were 6.6%, 36.4% and 47.8% less for the porous model compared to the solid model for LCI, LRM, and LBM loading conditions. Compared to the solid prosthesis, the porous prosthesis had a weight reduction of 57.7% and the volume of porosity of the porous condyle was 65% after the topological optimization process.

CONCLUSIONS

A custom-made porous condylar prosthesis with fixation plate was designed in this study. The 3D printed Ti-6Al-4V porous condylar prosthesis had reduced weight and effective modulus of elasticity close to that of cortical bone. The.

Biological Treatments for Temporomandibular Joint Disc Disorders: Strategies in Tissue Engineering

The temporomandibular joint (TMJ) is an important structure for the masticatory system and the pathologies associated with it affect a large part of the population and impair people's lifestyle. It comprises an articular disc, that presents low regeneration capacities and the existing clinical options for repairing it are not effective. This way, it is imperative to achieve a permanent solution to guarantee a good quality of life for people who suffer from these pathologies. Complete knowledge of the unique characteristics of the disc will make it easier to achieve a successful tissue engineering (TE) construct. Thus, the search for an effective, safe and lasting solution has already started, including materials that replace the disc, is currently growing. The search for a solution based on TE approaches, which involve regenerating the disc. The present work revises the TMJ disc characteristics and its associated diseases. The different materials used for a total disc replacement are presented, highlighting the TE area. A special focus on future trends in the field and part of the solution for the TMJ problems described in this review will involve the development of a promising engineered disc approach through the use of decellularized extracellular matrices.

Temporomandibular Disorders: Current Concepts and Controversies in Diagnosis and Management

Temporomandibular disorders (TMD) are a group of orofacial pain conditions which are the most common non-dental pain complaint in the maxillofacial region. Due to the complexity of the etiology, the diagnosis and management of TMD remain a challenge where consensus is still lacking in many aspects. While clinical examination is considered the most important process in the diagnosis of TMD, imaging may serve as a valuable adjunct in selected cases. Depending on the type of TMD, many treatment modalities have been proposed, ranging from conservative options to open surgical procedures. In this review, the authors discuss the present thinking in the etiology and classification of TMD, followed by the diagnostic approach and the current trend and controversies in management.

Prospective study of five-year outcomes and postoperative complications after total temporomandibular joint replacement with two stock prosthetic systems

To evaluate and compare outcomes and complications associated with reconstruction of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ), we prospectively analysed the data of 70 patients who had their joints replaced with stock prostheses during the period 2004-14 and who had been followed up for five years. We used two types of stock prostheses: the metal-on-metal Christensen system (CS), and the ultra-high-molecular-weight-polyethylene-on-metal Biomet® system (BS). Data were collected at 3, 6, 12, 24, 36, 48, and 60 months postoperatively and compared with preoperative measurements. Five years after the replacement there was an increase in mean (SD) mouth opening from 2.0 (0.6) to 4.0 (0.5cm) (p=0.012) in the CS, and from 2.5 (1.0) cm to 4.1 (0.6) cm (p=0.018) in the BS. The mean (SD) reductions in visual analogue pain scores were from 6.9 (1.6) to 2.0 (1.4) (p=0.001) in the CS, and 6.5 (1.4) to 1.5 (1.1) (p=0.001) in the BS. There were no significant differences in improvements in mouth opening or reduction in pain between the two groups. However, there were differences in the number of implants that failed, which led to removal and replacement of 2/14 prostheses in the CS group and 3/77 in the BS group (p=0.06). The results supported the placement of stock prostheses, as evidenced by a low incidence of complications and adverse events, and a long-term improvement in function and reduction in pain in the TMJ. The BS group had significantly fewer prosthetic failures than the CS group.

Biomechanical simulation of temporomandibular joint replacement (TMJR) devices: a scoping review of the finite element method

The aim of this study was to perform a literature review on the use of finite element modeling (FEM) for the evaluation of the biomechanical behavior of temporomandibular joint replacement (TMJR) devices. An electronic search of online medical and scientific literature database was conducted using selected search terms. The search identified 307 studies, of which 19 were considered relevant to this study. Of the 19 selected studies, 10 (52.6%) investigated the influence of geometry and fixation methods, while two (10.5%) evaluated the behavior of artificial condyle-fossa structures. The TMJR devices assessed in these studies included TMJ Inc. (aka Christensen; 63.2%), Zimmer Biomet (15.7%), Stryker (10.5%), and a theoretical intramedullary condylar component (5.3%); 26.3% of the studies evaluated custom TMJR devices. Such studies provided important data on the distribution of strain and stress through TMJR structural components and surrounding bone by using different software systems and methods. The mean stress values were lower on a custom TMJR condyle-ramus component and the supporting bone than on the stock device. FEM proved to be an accurate and valuable biomechanical simulation tool for studying the current TMJR devices and should be considered a useful tool for the improvement and development of future joint replacement devices.