Field demonstration of foam injection to confine a chlorinated solvent source zone

Surfactant-enhanced in-situ oxidation of DNAPL source zone: Experiments and numerical modeling

In this study we investigate the synergetic effects of combining surfactant-enhanced dissolution with in-situ oxidation of a pool-dominated PCE DNAPL source zone entrapped in porous media. Flow cell flushing experiments packed with silica sand and natural calcareous soil were conducted with a surfactant (Tween 80) and permanganate (MnO4-) used as dissolution and oxidation agents, respectively. The resultant breakthrough curves exhibited a multiple step behavior with mass removal controlled in the latter stages by the less-accessible DNAPL mass. DNAPL spatial architecture, flow-field heterogeneity, and flushing solution all influenced the remediation effort. When taking into account both the surfactant-enhanced dissolution and permanganate oxidation processes, mass-flux reduction/mass-removal behavior relationships indicated that the inclusion of oxidation in the remediation scheme delayed the drop in mass flux from the source zone, leading to improved DNAPL removal efficiency. Numerical modeling was also performed to further evaluate the efficacy of the surfactant-enhanced chemical oxidation of DNAPL PCE with permanganate. The system of reaction equations available in the multiphase flow simulator UTCHEM were adapted to simulate the chemical oxidation process in the presence of a surfactant. The model results yield lower oxidation reaction rate constants in the presence of Tween 80, indicating that Tween 80 can interfere with the reaction rate. However, the increase in the solubility of PCE in the presence of Tween 80 more than compensates for the decrease in reaction rate constant. Overall, for Tween 80/MnO4- applied at sufficient dosages, more efficient DNAPL zone remediation was achieved compared to surfactant flushing or permanganate oxidation alone.

Localized Delivery of Liquid Fertilizer in Coarse-Textured Soils Using Foam as Carrier

Agrochemicals and fertilizers are central to modern agriculture and are credited with the large increase of crop yield as a part of the Green Revolution of the 1960’s. Timely and targeted fertilizer application to crop root zones enhances effectiveness and reduces unintended release to the environment. This is particularly important for highly mobile liquid fertilizers (e.g., nitrate) that can be mobilized with infiltrating water to bypass root-bearing soil volumes. We report a novel liquid fertilizer delivery method using foam as carrier. The high degree of control and mechanical stability of liquid fertilizer foam (defined dispersed gas bubbles in a continuous liquid phase) injection into coarse soils (most susceptible to preferential flows) is proposed a novel delivery method to targeted root zone volumes at concentrations and geometry that promote uptake and reduces losses. This note and preliminary communication meant to serve a proof of concept report comparing foam and conventional liquid fertilizer applications. The results indicate that foam-delivery reduced fertilizer leaching thus improving its retention in soil for similar flow conditions of liquid delivery. Theoretical estimates suggest that the effects of fertilizer retention could be enhanced in more localized (3-D) injection of foam fertilizers and other agrochemicals thus enhancing agronomic efficiency and reducing environmental risk of contamination.

Assessment of shear-thinning fluids and strategies for enhanced in situ removal of heavy chlorinated compounds-DNAPLs in an anisotropic aquifer

The removal of chlorinated organic hydrocarbons (COHs) -DNAPLs was studied in permeability-contrasted sandboxes with an egg-box shaped substratum. Aqueous solutions were compared to viscous shear-thinning fluids (xanthan solution and foam). Interfacial and viscous effects were compared by increasing the capillary number of injected fluids. Non-spatially targeted DNAPL recovery (NSTR) where the driving force was the injection pressure, was compared to spatially targeted DNAPL recovery (STR) where a pumping system allowed the controlled flow. A historical contamination made of a complex mixture of COHs and hexachlorobutadiene (HCBD) as a model were used. NSTR results showed that DNAPL recovery with non-viscous liquids did not exceed 40%. The best results were obtained for xanthan solutions with surfactant ~ 1.3 ×CMC for which pure phase recovery amounted to 88% and 93% for HCBD and for the historical DNAPL, respectively. The STR strategy showed similar recovery yields, whereas xanthan concentrations were 10-times lower. Mass balances on DNAPL showed that at most, 0.15% of COHs was dissolved in the aqueous effluents. NZVI (1 g.l^-1) were delivered in xanthan in view of the chemical degradation of residual COHs and showed a 65% transmission through the low permeability soil.

Estimation of Local Equilibrium Foam Model Parameters as Functions of the Foam Quality and the Total Superficial Velocity

In this paper, the behavior of foam in a porous medium is studied in order to understand the effect of the fluid velocity on foam properties. This aspect is crucial during foam injection, as due to radial effects the foam velocity largely decreases around the injection well. The foam properties are detailed through the use of a new local equilibrium foam model parameter estimation approach using an improved new shear function and based on the most widely used STARS model developed by the Computer Modeling Group (CMG). A new mode of calculation of the STARS model parameters is then presented in order to allow both a semiautomated fitting of several quality scan pressure curves and a consideration of the role of the total velocity. The approach is tested through column experiments done at various velocities and gas fractions. Furthermore, the proposed model is also tested on literature results in order to validate it for very different experimental conditions. This study and the fitted results are then used to understand, on both our column experiments and the literature data, the existence of two shear effects and their origins.

Experimental study of foam propagation and stability in highly permeable porous media under lateral water flow: Diverting groundwater for application to soil remediation

Foam propagation and stability in highly permeable porous media, encountered in soil pollution applications, are still challenging. Here, we investigated the application of foam for blocking the aquifer to divert the flow from a contaminated zone and, therefore, ease the remediation treatments. The main aim was to better understand the critical parameters when the foam is injected into a highly permeable aquifer with high groundwater flow velocity (up to 10 m/day). A decimetric-scale 2D tank experimental setup filled with 1 mm glass beads was used. The front part of the 2D tank was made of transparent glass to photograph the foam flow using the light-reflected method. The water flow was generated horizontally through injection and pumping points on the sides of the tank. The pre-generated foam was injected at the bottom center of the tank. Water streamlines (using dye tracing) and water saturation were investigated using image interpretation. Results show that 100% of the water flow was diverted during the injection of the foam. Foam stability in porous media depends significantly on the horizontal water flow rate. Recirculating water containing the surfactant increases foam stability. The main mechanism of destruction was identified as the dilution of the surfactant in water. However, the head-loss measurements showed that despite foam destruction, the relative permeability of the water phase in the media remained quite low. Injection of foam increases the radius of gas propagation, thanks to foam's high viscosity, compared to a pure gas injection case. These results are new highlights on the efficiency of foam as a blocking agent, showing that it can also serve as a means for gas transport more efficiently in porous media, especially for soil remediation applications.

Effects of Gas Trapping on Foam Mobility in a Model Fracture

Abstract

In enhanced oil recovery, foam can effectively mitigate conformance problems and maintain a stable displacement front, by trapping gas and reducing its relative permeability in situ. In this study, to understand gas trapping in fractures and how it affects foam behavior, we report foam experiments in a 1-m-long glass model fracture with a hydraulic aperture of 80 $$\upmu $$ μ m. One wall of the fracture is rough, and the other is smooth. Between the two is a 2D porous medium representing the aperture in a fracture. The fracture model allows direct visualization of foam inside the fracture using a high-speed camera. This study is part of a continuing program to determine how foam behaves as a function of the geometry of the fracture pore space (AlQuaimi and Rossen in Energy & Fuels 33: 68-80, 2018a). We find that local equilibrium of foam (where the rate of bubble generation equals that of bubble destruction) has been achieved within the 1-m model fracture. Foam texture becomes finer, and less gas is trapped as interstitial velocity, and pressure gradient increase. Shear-thinning rheology of foam has also been observed. The fraction of trapped gas is significantly lower in our model (less than 7%) than in 3D geological pore networks. At the extreme, when velocity increases to 7 mm/s, there is no gas trapped inside the fracture. Our experimental results of trapped-gas fraction correlate well with the correlation of AlQuaimi and Rossen (SPE J 23: 788-802, 2018b) for fracture-like porous media. This suggests that the correlation can also be applied to gas trapping in fractures with other geometries.

Article Highlights

Graphic Abstract

Use of saponin foam reinforced with colloidal particles as an application to soil remediation: Experiments in a 2D tank

Foam can be used to achieve environmental remediation in case of contamination caused by light non aqueous phase spills. However, when it comes in contact with oily pollutants, foam becomes weaker and its life time is greatly reduced. Such weakening can be dampened by using silica particles -together with saponin surfactant- which were shown to reinforce foam in bulk and 1D sandpack experiments. Here is addressed both foam propagation in a 2D porous media when buoyancy and gravity interfere, and foam behaviour when in contact with floating oil. Therefore, macroscopic foam displacement, and specific liquid and gas phases behaviours were studied in a 2D-tank. A piston-like displacement was observed during foam propagation in the absence of oil, while foam liquid phase was influenced by gravity and did not propagate homogeneously on entire tank height. In the presence of oil, foam was partly destroyed, which increased the local permeability of gas and created new preferential paths for gas flow. This effect was partially avoided via a surfactant concentration increase, but solid colloidal particles turned out to be a more efficient stabilizing agent, by significantly increasing foam strength and its oil-tolerance.

A new foam-based method for the (bio)degradation of hydrocarbons in contaminated vadose zone

An innovative foam-based method for Fenton reagents (FR) and bacteria delivery was assessed for the in situ remediation of a petroleum hydrocarbon-contaminated unsaturated zone. The surfactant foam was first injected, then reagent solutions were delivered and propagated through the network of foam lamellae with a piston-like effect. Bench-scale experiments demonstrated the feasibility of the various treatments with hydrocarbon (HC) removal efficiencies as high as 96 %. Compared to the direct injection of FR solutions, the foam-based method led to larger radii of influence and more isotropic reagents delivery, whereas it did not show any detrimental effect regarding HC oxidation. Despite 25 % of HCs were expelled from the treated zone because of high foam viscosity, average degradation rates were increased by 20 %. At field-scale, foam and reagent solutions injections in soil were tracked both using visual observation and differential electric resistivity tomography. The latter demonstrated the controlled delivery of the reactive solutions using the foam-based method. Even if the foam-based method duration is about 5-times longer than the direct injection of amendment solutions, it provides important benefits, such as the confinement of harmful volatile hydrocarbons during Fenton treatments, the enhanced reagents delivery and the 30 % lower consumption of the latter.

Saponin foam for soil remediation: On the use of polymer or solid particles to enhance foam resistance against oil

Foams can be used to remediate aquifer pollution due to industrial leaks. However, when in contact with oily pollutants, foams may collapse and thus have a very limited life-time. A suitable formulation of biodegradable foam that resists oil contact is therefore needed. Hence, the ability of xanthan polymer and silica colloidal particles to stabilise foam against oil was investigated. Their performance in terms of stabilisation was evaluated via foam generation experiments in columns of porous medium, conducted with and without oil. The results show that the addition of xanthan polymer led to an increase in the viscosity of the solution, which thwarted the formation of foam. It did not improve the resistance of foam to oil, but increased altogether the resistance factor up to more than twice the original value. Concerning silica particles, it was demonstrated that they both noticeably increased resistance factor and moderately stabilised foam against oil by 20% at optimum concentration. As such, this study presents a new way to reinforce foam against oil for soil remediation issues.

Remediation of trapped DNAPL enhanced by SDS surfactant and silica nanoparticles in heterogeneous porous media: experimental data and empirical models

The remediation of nonaqueous phase liquids (NAPLs) enhanced by surfactant and nanoparticles (NP) has been investigated in numerous studies. However, the role of NP-assisted surfactants in the dissolution process is still not well discussed. Besides, there is a lack of empirical dissolution models considering the effects of initial residual saturation S_trap, NAPL distribution, and surfactant concentration in NAPL-aqueous phase systems. In this work, micromodel experiments are conducted to quantify mass transfer coefficients for different injected aqueous phases including deionized water, SDS surfactant solutions, and NP-assisted solutions with different levels of concentrations and flow rates. Observations reveal that silica nanoparticles (SNP) can significantly enhance interphase mass transfer, while SDS surfactant reduces the mass transfer coefficient. In addition, S_trap and intrinsic interfacial area a_i, as an indicator of dense nonaqueous phase liquids (DNAPL) distribution, influence the interphase mass transfer. The a_i is also independent of DNAPL saturation S_NAPL except for S_NAPL < 7% when ganglia breakup occurs. Based on these observations, new empirical dissolution models are proposed in the presence and the absence of SDS surfactant and SNP in which a_i, S_trap, and surfactant concentrations are introduced as new parameters. The evaluated mass transfer rate coefficients using the proposed models show a significant improvement compared to available empirical models. The finding of this study might be attractive for application in field-scale simulations of surfactant-enhanced aquifer remediation (SEAR) and NP-assisted methods.

Fractional-Flow Theory for Non-Newtonian Surfactant-Alternating-Gas Foam Processes

Foam can improve sweep efficiency in gas-injection-enhanced oil recovery. Surfactant-alternating-gas (SAG) is a favored method of foam injection. Laboratory data indicate that foam can be non-Newtonian at low water fractional flow fw, and therefore during gas injection in a SAG process. We investigate the implications of this finding for mobility control and injectivity, by extending fractional-flow theory to gas injection in a non-Newtonian SAG process in radial flow. We make most of the standard assumptions of fractional-flow theory (incompressible phases, one-dimensional displacement through a homogeneous reservoir, instantaneous attainment of local equilibrium), excluding Newtonian mobilities. For this initial study, we ignore the effect of changing or non-uniform oil saturation on foam. Non-Newtonian behavior at low fw implies that the limiting water saturation for foam stability varies as superficial velocity decreases with radial distance from the well. We discretize the domain radially and perform Buckley–Leverett analysis on each narrow increment in radius. Solution characteristics move outward with fixed fw. We base the foam model parameters and non-Newtonian behavior on laboratory data in the absence of oil. We compare results to mobility and injectivity determined by conventional simulation, where grid resolution is usually limited. For shear-thinning foam, mobility control improves as the foam front propagates from the well, but injectivity declines somewhat with time. This change in mobility ratio is not that at steady state at fixed water fractional flow in the laboratory, however, because the shock front in a non-Newtonian SAG process does not propagate at fixed fractional flow (though individual characteristics do). Moreover, the shock front is not governed by the conventional condition of tangency to the fractional-flow curve, though it continually approaches this condition. Injectivity benefits from the increased mobility of shear-thinning foam near the well. The foam front, which maintains a constant dimensionless velocity for Newtonian foam, decelerates somewhat with time for shear-thinning foam. For shear-thickening foam, mobility control deteriorates as the foam front advances, though injectivity improves somewhat with time. Overall, however, injectivity suffers from reduced foam mobility at high superficial velocity near the well. The foam front accelerates somewhat with time. Conventional simulators cannot adequately represent these effects, or estimate injectivity accurately, in the absence of extraordinarily fine grid resolution near the injection well.

Comparative assessment of a foam-based oxidative treatment of hydrocarbon-contaminated unsaturated and anisotropic soils

In situ delivery of liquid reagents in vadose zone is limited by soil anisotropy and gravity. The enhanced delivery of persulfate (PS) as oxidant, using a new foam-based method (F-PS) was compared at bench-scale to traditional water-based (W-PS) and surfactant solution-based (S-PS) deliveries. The goal was to distribute PS uniformly in coal tar-contaminated unsaturated and anisotropic soils, both in terms of permeability and contamination. Water was the less efficiently delivered fluid because of the hydrophobicity of the contaminated soils. Surfactant enhanced PS-distribution into contaminated zones by reducing interfacial tension and inverting soil wettability. Regardless of coal tar contamination contrasts (0 vs. 5 and 1 vs. 10 g kg _soil^-1) or strong permeability contrasts, PS-solution injection after foam injection led to the most uniform reagents delivery. While PS-concentration varied more than 5-times between zones using W-PS and S-PS methods, it varied less than 1.6-times when the F-PS one was used. Finally, despite unfavorable conditions, the foam-based method did not show any detrimental effect regarding the oxidation of hydrocarbons compared to the W-PS and S-PS methods carried out in ideal conditions. Moreover, hydrocarbon degradation rates were slightly higher when using F-PS than S-PS due to a lower surfactant content in the targeted zone.

Targeted delivery of hydrogen for the bioremediation of aquifers contaminated by dissolved chlorinated compounds

Dihydrogen (H₂) gas injection is a promising option to enhance the reductive biodehalogenation of contaminants in groundwater. However, it is challenging to ensure its targeted delivery at the right places in plumes, and for the long times required for bioremediation. In this paper, the ability of surfactant foam to retain H₂ in the saturated zone and to enhance its release in the dissolved form was compared to traditional biosparging. H₂ gas was injected, either alone, or as foam, in a 2D saturated cell packed with glass beads. This cell was continuously flushed with deoxygenated water to mimic aquifer circulation, and H₂ was studied both in terms of gas distribution in the cell and dissolved concentrations downstream the injection zone. Experimental results are discussed in conjunction with simulations obtained using modeling. Both show that the viscous behavior of foam allows to efficiently retain greater volumes of H₂ gas, 3.5 times higher than biosparging. Moreover, it is retained in a dense manner around the injection point, making possible the targeted delivery of this reagent. Besides, the gas dissolution in groundwater showed to be steadier and more persistent when gas was injected as foam, with dissolution rate constants observed to be 1.12 à 1.58 times lower. Finally, the retained foamed-gas persistently reduced water's relative permeability 1.7 to 5 times, diverting the groundwater flow from the treated zone despite the fast elution of the surfactant. Hence, when H₂-foam injection is targeted to plume's contaminant concentration hotspots, on top of enhancing bioremediation, it can reduce contaminant diffusion to groundwater.

Effects of carrier on the transport and DDT removal performance of nano-zerovalent iron in packed sands

The delivery of nano-zerovalent iron (nZVI) as a remediation agent to targeted areas in soil was studied using different carriers. Among water, surfactant solution, and surfactant foam, the nZVI transport and carrying abilities followed the order of surfactant foam > surfactant solution > water. The nZVI migration was also facilitated by increased soil particle size and high surfactant concentration. Batch experiments probed the remediation of dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT)-contaminated sand under different conditions. Compared to surfactant solution, the use of foam as a carrier achieved much higher DDT removal efficiencies for both coarse (foam/solution: 99/69%) and fine (foam/solution: 60/26%) sands. Additionally, the DDT removal efficiency was strongly influenced by surfactant concentration: foams generated using 1 and 5 g L^-1 sodium lauryl ether sulfate (SLES) solutions reached the respective efficiencies of 44% and 75% under identical experimental conditions. However, the nature of the surfactant did not significantly affect the total removal efficiency of DDT. Solubilization, increased sweep efficiency, and reduction by nZVI were identified as factors affecting the DDT removal efficiency, and all three of them were involved when foam-nZVI was used as the flushing fluid.