Assessment of chlorinated ethenes degradation after field scale injection of activated carbon and bioamendments: Application of isotopic and microbial analyses

Low-temperature Aquifer Thermal Energy Storage combined with in situ bioremediation of chlorinated ethenes: Pilot-scale observations and model-based interpretation

Microbial reductive dechlorination is a key process in aquifers contaminated with chlorinated ethenes and results in a net mass reduction of organic pollutants. Biodegradation rates in the subsurface are temperature-dependent and may be enhanced by increased groundwater temperatures. This study explores the potential of combining the temperature increase from low-temperature Aquifer Thermal Energy Storage with In Situ Bioremediation (ATES-ISB). The effects of highly dynamic groundwater flow and heat transport on microbial degradation rates were examined in a contaminated aquifer based on a pilot-scale experiment and a comprehensive process-based modeling analysis. The low-temperature ATES-ISB pilot test was carried out in Birkerød (Denmark), in an aquifer contaminated with trichloroethene by implementing a groundwater flow dipole, injecting heated groundwater, biostimulating the system with lactate and bioaugmenting it with a Dehalococcoides containing culture. Solute concentrations were monitored in four observation wells over the course of the test and a non-isothermal reactive transport model, solved in a two-dimensional heterogeneous domain, was developed to quantitatively interpret the experimental observations. The process-based numerical model also allowed evaluating the evolution of chlorinated ethenes concentrations considering different hydraulic, thermal, and operational scenarios. The results demonstrate the beneficial combination of ATES with in situ contaminant bioremediation, showing enhancement of contaminant mass reduction and more complete reductive dechlorination. The developed process-based model can be instrumental for the design and parameterization of pilot and full scale low-temperature ATES-ISB remediation in shallow aquifer systems.

Pilot tests for the optimization of the bioremediation strategy of a multi-layered aquifer at a multi-focus site impacted with chlorinated ethenes

A multi-layered aquifer in an industrial area in the north of the Iberian Peninsula is severely contaminated with the chlorinated ethenes (CEs) tetrachloroethylene, trichloroethylene, cis-1,2-dichloroethylene, and vinyl chloride. Both shallow and deep aquifers are polluted, with two differentiated north and south CEs plumes. Hydrogeochemical and isotopic data (δ13C of CEs) evidenced natural attenuation of CEs. To select the optimal remediation strategy to clean-up the contamination plumes, laboratory treatability studies were performed, which confirmed the intrinsic biodegradation potential of the north and south shallow aquifers to fully dechlorinate CEs to ethene after injection of lactate, but also the combination of lactate and sulfidized mZVI as an alternative treatment for the north deep aquifer. In the lactate-amended microcosms, full dechlorination of CEs was accompanied by an increase in 16S rRNA gene copies of Dehalococcoides and Dehalogenimonas, and the tceA, vcrA and bvcA reductive dehalogenases. Three in situ pilot tests were implemented, which consisted in injections of lactate in the north and south shallow aquifers, and injections of lactate and sulfidized mZVI in the north deep aquifer. The hydrogeochemical, isotopic and molecular analyses used to monitor the pilot tests evidenced that results obtained mimicked the laboratory observations, albeit at different dechlorination rates. It is likely that the efficiency of the injections was affected by the amendment distribution. In addition, monitoring of the pilot tests in the shallow aquifers showed the release of CEs due to back diffusion from secondary sources, which limited the use of isotopic data for assessing treatment efficiency. In the pilot test that combined the injection of lactate and sulfidized mZVI, both biotic and abiotic pathways contributed to the production of ethene. This study demonstrates the usefulness of integrating different chemical, isotopic and biomolecular approaches for a more robust selection and implementation of optimal remediation strategies in CEs polluted sites.

An approach for estimating microbial growth and chlorinated ethenes biotransformation in groundwater based on discrete observations

The bioremediation of chlorinated ethenes (CEs) contaminated groundwater is attracting increasingly attention in practical remediation projects. However, modelling of microbial metabolic processes under the constraints of substrate and environmental factors is inadequate. This study developed a new kinetic model, which incorporated the logistic model and Dual-Monod kinetic to represent the interaction between the controlled microbial growth and the bioavailable substrates in CE-contaminated groundwater. The proposed model was based on discrete observations to simulate microbial growth under the constraints of substrate and environmental conditions, reducing the amount of observational data required for the model. Meanwhile, the proposed model introduced two new kinetic parameters, the effective specific growth rate μeff and the real self-limiting coefficient of microbial growth keff,sl, to simplified the number of independent parameters. A parameter estimation method based on the quasi-Newton's algorithm for the proposed model was also developed. The model was validated based on the hypothetical data, experimental results, and a published dataset, demonstrated the successful simulation of microbial growth and the sequential biodegradation of PCE in groundwater systems (*E < 0.3). The monitoring duration and the sampling schedule have significant impacts on estimating the biological parameters, and large errors would be induced when the data from the periods of extremely low substrate concentration or microbial growth decline were involved in parameter estimation. The research suggested that the proposed kinetic model provided a new insight to express the limitation of microbial population growth due to the available substrates and environmental factors, and is hoping to be applied in actual CE-contaminated sites.

Multidisciplinary monitoring of an in-situ remediation test of chlorinated solvents

Pollutions on and within the underground poses risks for groundwater contamination and is a widespread global problem. Common remediation methods based on digging and removal can be expensive and have limitations, while in-situ remediation is an attractive alternative. However, there is a need to develop tools to monitor the effectiveness both in terms of the successful injection of remediation fluids but also the effectiveness of the treatment, i.e., degree of degradation/removal of the pollutants and possible metabolites. This paper presents a methodology for monitoring the changes following an in-situ remediation treatment of a site contaminated with chlorinated solvents. The methodology consists of two different methods, where Direct Current resistivity and time-domain Induced Polarization (DCIP) was used to acquire daily data and geochemical analyses on water samples were collected approximately every three months. The geophysical results provide insights on how the injected fluids are spreading and assist in acquiring a better understanding of the geological and hydrogeological system. On the other hand, the geochemical sampling enhances our knowledge about the hydrochemistry of the system and the concentration of the pollutants. Our research highlights the challenges of monitoring in-situ bioremediation experiments in complex environments and in cases where pollutants are situated in low hydraulic conductivity formations. The joint interpretation of the data shows the importance of an interdisciplinary approach to understand complex systems.

Managing the remediation strategy of contaminated megasites using field-scale calibration of geo-electrical imaging with chemical monitoring

Groundwater contamination is a threat to drinking water resources and ecosystems. Remediation by injection of chemical reagents into the aquifer may be preferred to excavation to reduce cost and environmental footprint. Yet, successful remediation requires complete contact between contamination and reagents. Subsurface heterogeneities are often responsible for diffusion into low-permeable zones, which may inhibit this contact. Monitoring the spatial distribution of injected reagents over time is crucial to achieve complete interaction. Source zone contamination at megasites is particularly challenging to remediate and monitor due to the massive scale and mixture of contaminants. Source zone remediation at Kærgård Plantation megasite (Denmark) is monitored here, with a new methodology, using high-resolution cross-borehole electrical resistivity tomography (XB-ERT) imaging calibrated by chemical analyses on groundwater samples. At this site, high levels of toxic non-aqueous phase liquids (NAPL) are targeted by in-situ chemical oxidation using activated persulfate. It may take numerous injection points with extensive injection campaigns to distribute reagents, which requires an understanding of how reagent may transport within the aquifer. A geophysical (XB-ERT) monitoring network of unprecedented size was installed to identify untreated zones and help manage the remediation strategy. The combination of spatially continuous geophysical information with discrete but precise chemical information, allowed detailed monitoring of sulfate distribution, produced during persulfate activation. Untreated zones identified in the first remediation campaign were resolved in the second campaign. The monitoring allowed adjusting the number of injection screens and the injection strategy from one campaign to the next, which resulted in better persulfate distribution and contaminant degradation in the second campaign. Furthermore, geophysical transects repeated over the timespan of a remediation campaign allowed high-resolution time-lapse imaging of reagent transport, which could in the future improve the predictability of transport models, compared to only using on a-priori assumptions of the hydraulic conductivity field.

Groundwater chlorinated solvent plumes remediation from the past to the future: a scientometric and visualization analysis

Contamination of groundwater with chlorinated hydrocarbons has serious adverse effects on human health. As research efforts in this area have expanded, a large body of literature has accumulated. However, traditional review writing suffers from limitations regarding efficiency, quantity, and timeliness, making it difficult to achieve a comprehensive and up-to-date understanding of developments in the field. There is a critical need for new tools to address emerging research challenges. This study evaluated 1619 publications related to this field using VOSviewer and CiteSpace visual tools. An extensive quantitative analysis and global overview of current research hotspots, as well as potential future research directions, were performed by reviewing publications from 2000 to 2022. Over the last 22 years, the USA has produced the most articles, making it the central country in the international collaboration network, with active cooperation with the other 7 most productive countries. Additionally, institutions have played a positive role in promoting the publication of science and technology research. In analyzing the distribution of institutions, it was found that the University of Waterloo conducted the majority of research in this field. This paper also identified the most productive journals, Environmental Science & Technology and Applied and Environmental Microbiology, which published 11,988 and 3253 scientific articles over the past 22 years, respectively. The main technologies are bioremediation and chemical reduction, which have garnered growing attention in academic publishing. Our findings offer a useful resource and a worldwide perspective for scientists engaged in this field, highlighting both the challenges and the possibilities associated with addressing groundwater chlorinated solvent plumes remediation.

Quantification of contaminant mass discharge from point sources in aquitard/aquifer systems based on vertical concentration profiles and 3D modeling

Point sources with contaminants, such as chlorinated solvents, per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), or pesticides, are often located in low-permeability aquitards, where they can act as long-term sources and threaten underlying groundwater resources. We demonstrate the use of a 3D numerical model integrating comprehensive hydrogeological and contamination data to determine the contaminant mass discharge (CMD) from an aquitard into the underlying aquifer. A mature point source with a dissolved chlorinated solvent in a clayey till is used as an example. The quantitative determination is facilitated by model calibration to high-resolution vertical concentration profiles obtained by direct-push sampling techniques in the aquifer downgradient of the contaminant source zone. The concentration profiles showed a plume sinking with distance from the source characteristic for such aquitard/aquifer settings. The sinking is caused by the interplay between infiltrating water and horizontal groundwater flow. The application of 3D solute transport modeling on high-resolution profiles allowed for determining the infiltration rate, the hydraulic conductivity in the aquitard, and, ultimately, the CMD. Different source zone conceptualizations demonstrate the potential effects of fractures and sorption in source zones in aquitards on CMD development. Fractures in the aquitard had a minor influence on the current CMD determined with the presented approach. Still, fractures with hydraulic apertures larger than 10 μm were crucial for the temporal development of the CMD and plume. A thorough characterization of the source zone conditions combined with high-resolution concentration profiles and detailed modeling is valuable for shedding light on the probable future development of groundwater contamination arising from sources in aquitard/aquifer settings and evaluating remedial actions.

Exploring the role of microbes for the management of persistent organic pollutants

Persistent organic pollutants (POPs) are chemicals which have been persisting in the environment for many years due to their longer half-lives. POPs have gained attention over the last few decades due to the unsustainable management of chemicals which led to their widespread and massive contamination of biota from different strata and environments. Due to the widespread distribution, bio-accumulation and toxic behavior, POPs have become a risk for organisms and environment. Therefore, a focus is required to eliminate these chemicals from the environment or transform into non-toxic forms. Among the available techniques for the removal of POPs, most of them are inefficient or incur high operational costs. As an alternative to this, microbial bioremediation of POPs such as pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, polychlorinated biphenyls, pharmaceuticals and personal care products is much more efficient and cost-effective. Additionally, bacteria play a vital role in the biotransformation and solubilization of POPs, which reduces their toxicity. This review specifies the Stockholm Convention that evaluates the risk profile for the management of existing as well as emerging POPs. The sources, types and persistence of POPs along with the comparison of conventional elimination and bioremediation methods of POPs are discussed comprehensively. This study demonstrates the existing bioremediation techniques of POPs and summaries the potential of microbes which serve as enhanced, cost-effective, and eco-friendly approach for POPs elimination.

Field application of glycerol to enhance reductive dechlorination of chlorinated ethenes and its impact on microbial community

Chlorinated ethenes (CEs) are common and persistent contaminants of soil and groundwater. Their degradation is mostly driven by a process of bacterial reductive dechlorination (also called organohalide respiration) in anaerobic conditions. This study summarizes the outcomes of the long-term in-situ application of glycerol for the enhanced reductive dechlorination of CEs on a highly contaminated site. Glycerol injection resulted in an almost immediate increase in the abundance of fermentative Firmicutes, which produce essential sources of carbon (acetate) and electrons (H₂) for organohalide-respiring bacteria (OHRB) and change groundwater conditions to be suitable for OHRB growth. The decreased redox potential of groundwater promoted also the proliferation of sulfate-reducing bacteria, which compete for electron donors with OHRB but at the same time support their growth by producing essential corrinoids and acetate. A considerable increase in the abundance of OHRB Dehalococcoides, concurrently with vinyl chloride (VC) reductase gene levels, was revealed by real time polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) method. Consistent with the shifts in bacterial populations, the concentrations of pollutants tetrachloroethylene and trichloroethylene decreased during the monitoring period, with rising levels of cis-1,2-dichloroethylene, VC, and most importantly, the final CE degradation products: ethene and ethane. Our study implies the importance of syntrophic bacterial interactions for successful and complete CE degradation and evaluates glycerol as convenient substrate to enhance reductive dechlorination and as an effective source of electrons for OHRB.

Contrasting regulatory effects of organic acids on aerobic vinyl chloride biodegradation in etheneotrophs

Vinyl chloride (VC) is a common groundwater pollutant generated during anaerobic biodegradation of chlorinated solvents (e.g., trichloroethene (TCE) or tetrachloroethene (PCE)). Aerobic VC biodegradation by etheneotrophs can support anaerobic PCE and TCE bioremediation to achieve complete removal in situ. However, anaerobic bioremediation strategies necessitate biostimulation with electron donors that are fermented in situ, generating organic acids that could influence aerobic VC biodegradation processes. We examined the effect of organic acids (lactate, acetate, propionate, and butyrate) on aerobic VC biodegradation by VC-assimilating etheneotrophs Mycobacterium strain JS60 and Nocardioides strain JS614. Strain JS60 grew on all organic acids tested, while strain JS614 did not respond to lactate. VC-grown strain JS60 fed VC and one or more organic acids showed carbon catabolite repression (CCR) behavior where VC biodegradation occurred only after organic acids were depleted. In contrast, CCR was not evident in VC-grown strain JS614, which degraded VC and organic acids simultaneously. Acetate-grown JS60 showed similar CCR behavior when fed VC and a single organic acid, except that extended lag periods (5-12 days) occurred before VC oxidation ensued. Acetate-grown JS614 fed VC and either acetate or butyrate displayed 5-8 day lag periods before simultaneous VC and organic acid biodegradation. In contrast, acetate-grown JS614 degraded VC and propionate without a significant lag, suggesting a regulatory link between propionate and VC oxidation in JS614. Different global regulatory mechanisms controlling VC biodegradation in the presence of organic acids in etheneotrophs have implications for developing combined anaerobic-aerobic bioremediation strategies at chlorinated ethene-contaminated sites. KEY POINTS: • With organic acids present, VC utilization was repressed in JS60, but not in JS614 • Strain JS60 grew readily on lactate, while strain JS614 did not • Propionate alleviated lag periods for VC utilization in acetate-grown JS614.

Pore network and Darcy scale modelling of DNAPL remediation using ethanol flushing: Study of physical properties in DNAPL remediation

Co-solvent flushing into contaminated soils is one of the most effective techniques for Dense Non-Aqueous Phase Liquid (DNAPL) remediation. In addition to the increase of DNAPL solubility, co-solvents (e.g. ethanol) can alter the viscosity and density of aqueous phase and diffusion coefficient of solute. Any changes in these parameters can change the flow behaviour and alter the upscaled DNAPL mass transfer coefficient which is a key parameter controlling soil and groundwater remediation at Darcy-scale. While numerous studies have investigated DNAPL remediation using co-solvents at the Darcy scale, pore-scale modelling of co-solvent enhanced DNAPL remediation has not been well investigated. In this work, a three-dimensional pore-network model was developed to simulate the 1,2-dichlorobenzene (DCB) remediation experiments using ethanol-water flushing solution. The model simulates the effect of changes in solubility, viscosity, density, and diffusion coefficient during co-solvent flushing of the DNAPL. The results of pore network modelling for ethanol-water flushing for the DCB remediation were also validated using the experimental data. In addition to pore-scale modelling, a continuum scale modelling (Darcy-scale) was used for the DCB remediation using ethanol-water flushing. The results of both pore network and continuum scale modelling demonstrated that the ethanol content and flushing velocity influence the interphase mass transfer and DNAPL dissolution process. The results indicated while the mass transfer coefficient decreased in the presence of ethanol, the process of NAPL remediation was improved due to the substantial increase of solubility in the presence of co-solvent. The large scale modelling showed that NAPL bank can be formed in the front of ethanol-water mixture flushing.

Dataset for laboratory treatability experiment with activated carbon and bioamendments to enhance biodegradation of chlorinated ethenes

This dataset describes the outcome of a laboratory trichloroethene (TCE) treatability experiment with liquid activated carbon and bioamendments. The treatability experiment included unamended microcosms, bioamended microcosms with a Dehalococcoides containing culture and electron donor, and bioamended microcosms including liquid activated carbon (PlumeStop®). Data were collected frequently over an 85-day experimental period. Data were collected for the following parameters: redox sensitive species, chlorinated ethenes, non-chlorinated end-products, electron donors, compound specific isotopes, specific bacteria and functional genes. The reductive dechlorination of TCE could be described by a carbon isotope enrichment factor (ε_C) of -7.1 ‰. In the amended systems, the degradation rates for the TCE degradation were 0.08–0.13 d⁻¹ and 0.05–0.09 d⁻¹ determined by concentrations and isotope fractionation, respectively. Dechlorination of cis-DCE was limited. This dataset assisted in identifying the impact of different bioamendments and activated carbon on biodegradation of chlorinated ethenes. The dataset is useful in optimising design and setup for future laboratory and field investigations. This study provides novel information on the effect of low dose liquid activated carbon on chlorinated ethenes degradation by applying isotopic and microbial techniques, and by linking the outcome to a field case study. The data presented in this article are related to the research article “Assessment of chlorinated ethenes degradation after field scale injection of activated carbon and bioamendments: Application of isotopic and microbial analyses” (Ottosen et al., 2021).