Position of ST-deviation measurements relative to the J-point: Impact for ischemia detection

Improving reliability for measuring ST deviation in suspected acute coronary syndrome

BACKGROUND

Standard 12‑lead ECG is used for diagnosis and risk stratification in suspected acute coronary syndrome (ACS) patients. Artifacts have significant impact on the measuring quality, which consequently affect the diagnostic decision. We used a signal quality indicator (SQI) to identify the ECG segments with lower artifact levels which we hypothesized would improve ST measurements.

METHODS

The Staff III 12‑lead ECG database was used with the ECG segments before balloon inflation (n = 185). SQI scores per second were calculated and a 10-s ECG segment with least noise and artifacts (Clean10) was identified for each minute of recording. The first 10 s of ECG recordings (First10) for each minute were selected as a reference. The Philips DXL™ algorithm was used to measure the ST levels at J-point, +20 ms, +40 ms, +60 ms, and + 80 ms after the J-point. Standard deviations (SDs) for the ST measurements for each of the 185 ECG records were calculated for the Clean10 and for the First10 across records. The resulting SDs for the Clean10 were compared with the SDs for the First10 using the Wilcoxon signed rank test.

RESULTS

The results indicated that 1) The SDs for the Clean10 are lower than that of the First10; 2) The SDs for J+20 ms and J+40 ms are lowest among the 5 different measuring points although similar improvement for the Clean10 over the First10 is observed for J+60 ms and J+80 ms as well; 3) The improvement at the J-point was not as high as other ST measurements.

CONCLUSIONS

The SQI is demonstrated as an efficient tool to identify the ECG segments with lower artifacts that produce more consistent and reliable ST measurement. The measurements at J+20 ms demonstrated the highest consistency among the five studied measuring points.

Optimal measuring point for ST deviation in chest pain patients with possible acute coronary syndrome

INTRODUCTION

In the ECG, significant ST elevation or depression according to specific amplitude criteria can be indicative of acute coronary syndrome (ACS). Guidelines state that the ST amplitude should be measured at the J point, but data to support that this is the optimal measuring point for ACS detection is lacking. We evaluated the impact of different measuring points for ST deviation on the diagnostic accuracy for ACS in unselected emergency department (ED) chest pain patients.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We included 14,148 adult patients with acute chest pain and an ECG recorded at a Swedish ED between 2010 and 2014. ST deviation was measured at the J point (STJ) and at 20, 40, 60 and 80 ms after the J point. A discharge diagnosis of ACS or not at the index visit was noted in all patients.

RESULTS

In total, 1489 (10.5%) patients had ACS. ST amplitude criteria at STJ had a sensitivity of 28% and a specificity of 92% for ACS. With these criteria, the highest positive and negative predictive values for ACS were obtained near the J point, but the optimal point varied with ST deviation, age group and sex. The overall best measuring points were STJ and ST20.

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates that the diagnostic accuracy of the ECG criteria for ACS is very low in ED chest pain patients, and that the optimal measuring point for the ST amplitude in the detection of ACS differs between ST elevation and depression, and between patient subgroups.