Measurement of clavicular length and shortening after a midshaft clavicular fracture: Spatial digitization versus planar roentgen photogrammetry

Assessment of the measurement methods in midshaft clavicle fracture

Background

Clavicle fractures account for approximately 5% of all fractures in adults and 75% of clavicle fractures occur in the midshaft. Shortening greater than two centimeters is an indicative of surgical treatment. Radiographic exams are often used to diagnose and evaluate clavicle fractures but computed tomography (CT) scan is currently considered the best method to assess these deformities and shortening.

Goal

1- To investigate whether different methods of performing the radiographic exam interfere on the measurement of the fractured clavicle length.

2- Compare the clavicle length measurements obtained by the different radiographic exam methods with the CT scan measurements, used as a reference.

Materials and methods

Twenty-five patients with acute (< 3 weeks) midshaft clavicle fracture were evaluated. Patients underwent six radiographic images: PA Thorax (standing and lying), AP Thorax (standing and lying) and at 10° cephalic tilt (standing and lying), and the computed tomography was used as reference.

Results

The mean length (cm) obtained were: 14,930 on CT scan, 14,860 on PA Thorax Standing, 14,955 on PA Thorax Lying, 14,896 on AP Thorax Standing, 14,960 AP Thorax Lying, 15,098 on 10° cephalic tilt Standing and 15,001 on 10° cephalic tilt Lying, (p > 0,05).

Conclusion

1- There is no significant statistical difference in the clavicle fracture length measurement among the variety of radiographic exam performances.

2- The method that comes closest to computed tomography results is the PA thorax incidence, with the patient in the lying position.

Reliability of the radiographic views in supine position for evaluation of displaced midshaft clavicle fracture length

PURPOSE

To analyze the agreement of the displaced midshaft clavicle fracture length measurement between each of the supine radiographic position (chest anteroposterior (AP), both clavicle AP, and 20° cephalic tilt clavicle AP view) and computed tomography (CT) scan of the clavicle. Furthermore, the inter- and intraobserver reliability of each radiographic position was analyzed.

METHODS

Prospective cross-sectional study was performed with patients diagnosed with displaced midshaft clavicle fracture treated conservatively. Three views of radiographs and CT scan of clavicle were obtained in supine position after informed consent. The measurement of fractured clavicle length was done by three observers at the time and after 4 weeks interval.

RESULTS

Thirty-three patients (25 males and 8 females), with a mean age of 45, were recruited. The agreement between each of the radiographic measurement and CT scan was good. The interobserver reliability was moderate to good for radiographic measurement. The highest intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of 0.80-0.81 was shown between the 20° cephalic tilt and the CT scan, followed by the both clavicle AP (0.75-0.77) and the chest AP (0.69-0.75), respectively. There was an excellent intraobserver reliability for all of the radiographic measurement with the ICC 0.92-0.99.

CONCLUSION

The supine radiographs could be a useful option to measure the displaced midshaft clavicle fracture length. The recommended view was the 20° cephalic tilt clavicle AP view in supine position to best evaluate the fractured clavicle length.

S-shaped titanium endomedullary nail reduces telescoping of comminuted midshaft clavicular fractures

BACKGROUND

The surgical treatment of displaced midshaft clavicular fractures (DMCF) is clinically relevant and a much discussed topic. The axial stability of DMCF after intramedullary nailing (IMN) is still a matter of debate.

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to present a modification of IMN of DMCF with S-shaped titanium endomedullary nail (TEN) and determine fracture telescoping from day one after surgery to the time of fracture healing.

METHOD

In a prospective analytic cohort study over a 6-year period (2012-2017) at a Level II trauma care centre, a total of 128 patients with DMCF were included and classified according to the AO/OTA classification system. Group I was AO/OTA type 15.2A/15.2B (N = 68) and group II was AO/OTA type 15.2C (N = 60). After a modified open stabilization technique of each DMCF with IMN (S-shaped TEN), the dynamics of radiological assessed telescoping until union and rate of surgical adverse events were measured. Significance was assumed for p < 0.05.

RESULTS

One day after surgery, fractured clavicles were lengthened slightly in both groups compared to the unfractured clavicules (group I: 1.2%; group II: 0.9%). After osseus consolidation, the fractured clavicules were significantly shortened in both groups (group I: - 2.9%; group II: - 3.6%). Measurement of the clavicular shortening at one day postsurgically and at consolidation revealed a mean telescoping of - 3.99% in group I and of - 4.6% in group II. The difference between the two groups was not significant (P = 0.522). The overall rate of major surgical adverse events was 2.3%.

CONCLUSION

The proposed operative technique of IMN (stabilization of the DMCF with a long, S-shaped, tight-fitting TEN) provides enough axial stability to prevent significant telescoping of the comminuted fractures. The rate of nonunion is low and the overall rate of major adverse events is similar to the reported events after plate fixation in the literature.

Three-dimensional clavicle displacement analysis and its effect on scapular position in acute clavicle midshaft fracture

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to measure the distance of the clavicle in 3 dimensions (3D) and each direction (anterior to posterior, medial to lateral, and superior to inferior) and to analyze the correlation of the angular orientation of the scapula according to each directional distance of the clavicle.

METHODS

Sixty-seven patients with Robinson 2B1 and 2B2 clavicle midshaft fracture (46.0 ± 17.4 years, men = 50, women = 17) were selected as final subjects. Patients' computed tomography was reconstructed using an image processing program (3D Slicer 4.3 software). Anteroposterior (AP) distance, medial-to-lateral distance, superior-to-inferior distance, and 3D distance of both clavicles were measured. The plane connecting the 3 points (superior pole, inferior pole, and center of glenoid) of the scapula was used to calculate differences in the angular orientation between both scapulae.

RESULTS

Among each directional distance of the clavicle, only the AP distance showed negative correlation with scapular angular orientation with anterior tilting, internal rotation, and upward rotation of the scapula (Pearson's correlation coefficient: -0.68, -0.24, and -0.28; P < .001, P = .048, and P = .021).

CONCLUSION

The shortening of the AP distance of the clavicle was related to the angular orientation of the scapula in acute clavicle fracture. AP shortening should be considered when determining the treatment of clavicle fracture.

Reliability of measurements of the fractured clavicle: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

The objective of this systematic review was to evaluate the reliability and reproducibility of measurements of shortening in midshaft clavicle fractures (MSCF) using any available imaging technique.

METHODS

Electronic databases (PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane) were searched. The 4-point-scale COSMIN checklist was used to evaluate the methodological quality of studies.

RESULTS

Four studies on reliability of measurement of MSCF were identified. These studies were of fair and poor quality. The reported intrarater reliability varied between none to fair, and intrarater reliability was minimal.

CONCLUSION

No definite conclusions could be drawn. In order to optimize future studies and the realization of comparable results, more research is necessary to identify a standardized method of imaging and measuring. Level of Evidence III.