Sensitivity and specificity of the flexion and extension relaxation ratios to identify altered paraspinal muscles' flexion relaxation phenomenon in nonspecific chronic low back pain patients

Regional flexion relaxation phenomenon in lumbar extensor muscles under delayed-onset muscle soreness: high-density surface electromyography insights

PURPOSE

This study aimed to investigate whether lumbar delayed-onset muscle soreness (DOMS) impacts the magnitude of the flexion relaxation phenomenon regionally.

METHODS

Eighteen adult participants (9 men and 9 women) performed flexion extension movement under two conditions (with and without DOMS). Lumbar muscle activation strategies were recorded using high-density surface electromyography (HDsEMG) on both sides of the trunk. To determine the spatial distribution of flexion relaxation phenomenon, flexion relaxation ratio of muscle activity was computed for all electrodes of the HDsEMG grid and the coordinates of the centroid (average position of flexion relaxation ratio across the HDsEMG grid) in the mediolateral and craniocaudal axis were calculated.

RESULTS

The results revealed a cranial shift (~ 6 mm) of flexion relaxation phenomenon within the lumbar extensor muscles when DOMS was present (both sides: p < 0.05), possibly attributed to the increased recruitment of lumbar stabilizing muscles located caudally, which may serve as a guarding mechanism to pain.

CONCLUSION

These results highlight the importance of evaluating the entire lumbar region when assessing the flexion relaxation phenomenon.

Intra-day, short- and long-term reliability of surface electromyographic measurements during a standardized measurement protocol for lower back pain patients

BackgroundThe identification of back muscle dysfunction is a prerequisite for successful rehabilitation. Therefore, surface electromyography can be used for diagnostic and evaluative purposes. However, data quality highly depends on a) variance and inaccuracies in methodological procedures and b) on time-dependent changes, particularly in complex conditions such as chronic low back pain.ObjectiveTo assess intra-day, short-term and long-term reliability of a protocol designed for electromyographic measurements of the paraspinal muscles.MethodsThree everyday tasks were selected for measurement in two healthy populations (mean age (years): 26.25/30.49 (SD: 7.05/11.03), sex-balanced). The procedure follows a detailed protocol (e.g., including ultrasound, electrode placement, movement commands). Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), standard error of measurement (SEM) and minimum detectable change (MDC) were calculated.ResultsProne extension task demonstrated excellent test-retest agreement in all timespans (ICC = 0.92-0.96, SEM = 6.08-8.11, MDC = 16.85-22.49). Forward bending reliability ranged from moderate in long-term (ICC = 0.68-0.71, SEM = 1.98-2.52, MDC = 5.48-6.99) to good in intra-day (ICC = 0.76-0.89, SEM = 1.73-2.15, MDC = 4.79-5.95) to excellent in short-term assessment (ICC = 0.97, SEM = 1.07-1.21, MDC = 2.96-3.34). Sitting task showed the lowest test-retest agreement ranging between good to moderate in intra-day (ICC = 0.60-0.77, SEM = 1.22-1.26, MDC = 1.61-3.48)) and short-term reliability (ICC = 0.50-0.75, SEM = 1.24-2.06, MDC = 0.62-4.04) and moderate in long-term reliability (ICC = 0.65-0.71, SEM = 1.43-1.85, MDC = 3.95-5.12).ConclusionUsing standardized procedures, surface electromyography can provide reliable data for practitioners in low back pain rehabilitation. Timespan had a limited influence on reliability compared to the type of task performed.

Enhancing understanding: Back muscle strength and individual flexibility impact on the flexion-relaxation phenomenon in the lumbar erector spinae

The flexion-relaxation phenomenon (FRP) refers to the deactivation of back muscles during deep forward trunk bending. This study examined the effects of back muscle strength, individual flexibility, and trunk angle on FRP in the back muscles. Forty male participants were classified into four groups according to toe-touch flexibility and back muscle strength. Lumbar erector spinae (LES) activity and the lumbosacral angle (LSA) were measured at incremental trunk flexion angles (0°-90°, with increments of 15°) to analyze FRP. Results indicated significant effects of back muscle strength, flexibility, and trunk angle on LES activity (all p < 0.001). Flexibility (p < 0.05) and trunk angle (p < 0.001) also influenced LSA. Additionally, an interaction between flexibility and trunk angle impacted LES activation (p < 0.001). Flexibility mainly determined FRP onset, while back muscle strength influenced efforts during moderate trunk flexion (30°-60°). These findings indicate that differences in lower back load among individuals with varying back muscle strengths become apparent even at relatively small trunk flexion angles (approximately 30°). When prolonged static trunk flexion in workplace settings places considerable strain on the lower back, we recommend utilizing toe-touch flexibility and back muscle strength assessments as practical screening tools for identifying early and subtle indicators of the FRP in workers.

The clinical utility and reliability of surface electromyography in individuals with chronic low back pain: A systematic review

Chronic low back pain (CLBP) is a common disorder worldwide, affecting young and old adults alike. Kinematic studies of lumbar-pelvic mobility allied with surface electromyogram (sEMG) can assist in the assessment and management of CLBP. This systematic review aimed to synthesise the evidence relating to the diagnostic accuracy and reliability of the surface electromyogram in chronic low back pain patients during flexion-extension-relaxation tasks. Five databases (PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Embase and CINAHL) were searched for eligible studies from inception to March 2024. The risk of bias assessment for the included studies was conducted using the QUADAS-2 tool. Studies included adults (≥18 years) with CLBP > 3 months, reported diagnostic accuracy or reliability measures for sEMG during flexion-extension-relaxation tasks. Eleven studies were included in our systematic review. The risk of bias was found to be high for patient selection, reference standard and flow and timing domains with low risk of bias for the index test domain in most of the included studies. For diagnostic accuracy, six studies reported values ranging between 56-99 % indicating poor to excellent accuracy levels. Four studies reported values between 76-100 % for sensitivity and 65-100 % for specificity indicating sufficient to excellent accuracy levels. Seven studies reported moderate to excellent reliability levels, ranging between 0.66-0.99. This systematic review found the diagnostic accuracy and reliability of sEMG in CLBP patients to range from poor to excellent levels. This systematic review adds knowledge for practitioners and clinicians regarding the use of sEMG during forward, flexion and relaxation tasks/movements.

Relationship between the flexion relaxation phenomenon and kinematics of the multi-segmental spine in nonspecific chronic low back pain patients

The flexion relaxation phenomenon (FRP) is characterized by the reduction of paraspinal muscle activity at maximum trunk flexion. FRP is reported to be altered (persistence of spinal muscle activity) in more than half of nonspecific chronic low back pain (NSCLBP) patients. Little is known about how the multi-segmental spine affects FRP. The aim of this observational study was to investigate the relationship between FRP and kinematic parameters of the multi-segmental spine in NSCLBP patients. Forty NSCLBP patients and thirty-five asymptomatic participants performed a standing maximal trunk flexion task. Surface electromyography was recorded along the erector spinae longissimus. The kinematics of the spine were assessed using a 3D motion analysis system. The investigated spinal segments were upper thoracic, lower thoracic, thoracolumbar, upper lumbar, lower lumbar, and lumbopelvic. Upper lumbar ROM, anterior sagittal inclination of the upper lumbar relative to the lower lumbar in the upright position, and ROM of the upper lumbar relative to the lower lumbar during full trunk flexion were significantly correlated with the flexion relaxation ratio (Rho 0.42 to 0.58, p < 0.006). The relative position and movement of the upper lumbar segment seem to play an important role in the presence or absence of FRP in NSCLBP patients.

Differential Back Muscle Flexion-Relaxation Phenomenon in Constrained versus Unconstrained Leg Postures

Previous studies examining the flexion-relaxation phenomenon (FRP) in back muscles through trunk forward flexion tests have yielded inconsistent findings, primarily due to variations in leg posture control. This study aimed to explore the influence of leg posture control and individual flexibility on FRP in back and low limb muscles. Thirty-two male participants, evenly distributed into high- and low-flexibility groups, were recruited. Activities of the erector spinae, biceps femoris, and gastrocnemius muscles, alongside the lumbosacral angle (LSA), were recorded as participants executed trunk flexion from 0° to 90° in 15° increments, enabling an analysis of FRP and its correlation with the investigated variables. The findings highlighted significant effects of all examined factors on the measured responses. At a trunk flexion angle of 60°, the influence of leg posture and flexibility on erector spinae activities was particularly pronounced. Participants with limited flexibility exhibited the most prominent FRP under constrained leg posture, while those with greater flexibility and unconstrained leg posture displayed the least FRP, indicated by their relatively larger LSAs. Under constrained leg posture conditions, participants experienced an approximate 1/3 to 1/2 increase in gastrocnemius activity throughout trunk flexion from 30° to 90°, while biceps femoris activity remained relatively constant. Using an inappropriate leg posture during back muscle FRP assessments can overestimate FRP. These findings offer guidance for designing future FRP research protocols.

Understanding the flexion-relaxation phenomenon in non-specific chronic low back pain patients throught immersive virtual reality feedback approach

The flexion-relaxation phenomenon (FRP) is frequently absent among non-specific chronic low back pain (NSCLBP) patients. However, it is unknown whether this absence is intrinsic to their pathology or merely a consequence of reduced trunk flexion. Immersive virtual reality (IVR) can create a patient avatar whose range of motion can be modulated to differ from the real movement. The present study enrolled 15 NSCLBP patients and 15 asymptomatic participants with similar characteristics to disentangle the relationship between range of motion and the FRP in NSCLBP using IVR. Trunk kinematics and lumbar muscle electromyography were assessed. The IVR environment was combined with a motion capture system to create avatars that moved like each participant. The IVR display showed a closed room and a mirror reflecting the subject's avatar with a target line to be reached by trunk flexion. The avatar's trunk movements were modulated from reality, leading the participants to flex their trunk more than their voluntary maximum trunk flexion. Under IVR conditions, NSCLBP patients significantly increased their trunk flexion angle, which was coupled with a significant improvement in the FRP. The absence of the FRP among the NSCLBP population appeared to be primarily related to reduced trunk flexion.

The Application of Surface Electromyography Technology in Evaluating Paraspinal Muscle Function

Surface electromyography (sEMG) has emerged as a valuable tool for assessing muscle activity in various clinical and research settings. This review focuses on the application of sEMG specifically in the context of paraspinal muscles. The paraspinal muscles play a critical role in providing stability and facilitating movement of the spine. Dysfunctions or alterations in paraspinal muscle activity can lead to various musculoskeletal disorders and spinal pathologies. Therefore, understanding and quantifying paraspinal muscle activity is crucial for accurate diagnosis, treatment planning, and monitoring therapeutic interventions. This review discusses the clinical applications of sEMG in paraspinal muscles, including the assessment of low back pain, spinal disorders, and rehabilitation interventions. It explores how sEMG can aid in diagnosing the potential causes of low back pain and monitoring the effectiveness of physical therapy, spinal manipulative therapy, and exercise protocols. It also discusses emerging technologies and advancements in sEMG techniques that aim to enhance the accuracy and reliability of paraspinal muscle assessment. In summary, the application of sEMG in paraspinal muscles provides valuable insights into muscle function, dysfunction, and therapeutic interventions. By examining the literature on sEMG in paraspinal muscles, this review offers a comprehensive understanding of the current state of research, identifies knowledge gaps, and suggests future directions for optimizing the use of sEMG in assessing paraspinal muscle activity.

The Flexion Relaxation Phenomenon in Patients with Radiculopathy and Low Back Pain: A Cross-Sectional Study

Although the measurements of the lumbar spine and pelvic flexion have shown that subjects with radiculopathy exhibited greater decreases of motion when compared with subjects with low back pain, there is still a lack of evidence regarding the changes in flexion relaxation ratio in patients with radiculopathy. The aims of this study were to investigate the flexion relaxation ratio and flexion of the lumbar spine and pelvis in subjects with low back pain (LBP) and LBP with radiculopathy (LBPR) in comparison with healthy subjects (CG-control group). A total of 146 participants were divided in three groups: LBP patients (54 males; 21 females); LBPR patients (26 males; 11 females); and CG subjects (16 males; 18 females). The lumbar spine and pelvis flexion was recorded using optoelectronic motion capture system. The electrical activity of the erector spinae muscles was assessed by surface electromyography during flexion-extension movements. Comparisons between groups were made using one-way ANOVA tests and Mann-Whithney U test with the level of statistical significance at 0.05. The lumbar and pelvic flexion and electromyography of the erector spinae muscle showed significant differences between LBP and LBPR patients compared to CG. Patients LBPR showed significantly smaller angles of lumbar and pelvic flexion compared to LBP patients and CG. An increase in the erector spinae muscle activity during flexion was also observed in patients with radiculopathy. The increased muscular activity of the erector spinae is related to the reduced flexion of the lumbar spine in order to protect the lumbar spine structure. Measurements of trunk, lumbar spine and pelvic flexion, and the flexion relaxation ratio may allow us to predict better outcomes or responsiveness to treatment of LBPR patients in the future.

A systematic review and meta analysis of measurement properties for the flexion relaxation ratio in people with and without non specific spine pain

This review sought to identify, critically appraise, compare, and summarize the literature on the reliability, discriminative validity and responsiveness of the flexion relaxation ratio (FRR) in adults (≥ 18 years old) with or without spine pain (any duration), in either a clinical or research context. The review protocol was registered on Open Science Framework ( https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/27EDF ) and follows COSMIN, PRISMA, and PRESS guidelines. Six databases were searched from inception to June 1, 2022. The search string was developed by content experts and a health services librarian. Two pairs of reviewers independently completed titles/abstracts and full text screening for inclusion, data extraction, and risk of bias assessment (COSMIN RoB Toolkit). At all stages, discrepancies were resolved through consensus meetings. Data were pooled where possible with a three-level random effects meta-analyses and a modified GRADE assessment was used for the summary of findings. Following duplicate removal, 728 titles/abstracts and 219 full texts were screened with 23 included in this review. We found, with moderate certainty of evidence, that the cervical FRR has high test-retest reliability and lumbar FRR has moderate to high test-retest reliability, and with high certainty of evidence that the cervical and lumbar FRR can discriminate between healthy and clinical groups (standardized mean difference - 1.16 [95% CI - 2.00, - 0.32] and - 1.21 [- 1.84, - 0.58] respectively). There was not enough evidence to summarize findings for thoracic FRR discriminative validity or the standard error of measurement for the FRR. Several studies used FRR assuming responsiveness, but no studies were designed in a way that could confirm responsiveness. The evidence supports adequate reliability of FRR for the cervical and lumbar spine, and discriminative validity for the cervical and lumbar spine only. Improvements in study design and reporting are needed to strengthen the evidence base to determine the remaining measurement properties of this outcome.

The association between different physical activity levels and flexion-relaxation phenomenon in women: a cross-sectional study

BACKGROUND

To investigate whether the flexion-relaxation phenomenon differs in women with different physical activity levels.

METHODS

Seventy-two subjects were recruited for this study. The electromyographic activity of the erector spinae and multifidus muscles was recorded during a flexion task using a surface electromyographic device. The flexion-relaxation and extension-relaxation ratios were calculated. Participants were classified into different physical activity level groups based on their responses to the International Physical Activity Questionnaire. A Welch analysis of variance was conducted to compare the flexion-relaxation ratio and extension-relaxation ratio between groups.

RESULTS

A significant difference in the flexion-relaxation and extension-relaxation ratio was observed in both the erector spinae and multifidus muscles between different levels of physical activity.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, we observed that female participants with high levels of physical activity showed a more pronounced flexion-relaxation phenomenon compared to those with moderate and low levels of physical activity. No significant difference was found between moderate and low physical activity levels. The findings of our study highlight the association between physical activity and the mechanics of the spinal stabilising muscles.