Nitrogen removal in vermifiltration: Mechanisms, influencing factors, and future research needs

Influence of earthworm population density on the performance of vermifiltration for treating liquid dairy manure

The dairy industry has seen notable changes in the last couple of decades, including increased size of farms and regional concentrations of dairies. This has resulted in substantial manure production in small geographical areas, raising environmental concerns. Vermifiltration, an emerging low cost and eco-friendly technology for treating wastewater, was evaluated to assess the influence of earthworm population density on the performance of a laboratory-scale vermifilter treating liquid dairy manure. We monitored the reduction efficiencies of various components, including total nitrogen (TN), ammonium-nitrogen (NH4 +-N), nitrate-nitrogen (NO3 --N), total phosphorus (TP), orthophosphate (ortho-P), chemical oxygen demand (COD), total solids (TS), and total suspended solids (TSS), in treated dairy wastewater. This evaluation was conducted at 0; 5000; 10,000; and 15,000 earthworm densities per cubic meter (m-3) of bedding. Reduction efficiencies of 41%-89% (TN), 46%-86% (NH4 +-N), 34%-74% (NO3 --N), 3%-17% (TP), 18%-38% (ortho-P), 35%-66% (COD), 24%-54% (TS), and 50%-87% (TSS) were observed with higher earthworm densities exhibiting greater reduction efficiencies. Notably, the densities of Eisenia fetida at 10,000 and 15,000 earthworms m-3 showed no significant difference in vermifilter performance. This suggests that increasing the Eisenia fetida density beyond 10,000 earthworms m-3 may not further improve the vermifilter's performance in treating dairy wastewater. This study's findings indicate that using vermifiltration with an earthworm population density of 10,000 earthworms m-3 could effectively mitigate the negative environmental impact of liquid dairy wastewater at a low cost and sustainably.

Effects of bed depths and the ratio of aerobic to anaerobic zone on the performance of horizontal subsurface flow macrophyte-assisted high-rate vermifilters treating synthetic brewery wastewater

Effects of total vermibed depth, as well as the ratio of aerobic (the unsubmerged) to anaerobic (the submerged) zone on the performance of the horizontal subsurface flow macrophyte-assisted vermifilters (HSSF-MAVFs) treating synthetic brewery wastewater at a higher hydraulic loading rate (HLR), were investigated for the first time. Results showed that the HSSF-MAVF with a 50 cm total and 18 cm submerged vermibed depth yielded the optimum removal of the pollutants, ensuring a (91.2 ± 1.7)%, (81.8 ± 1.9)%, (67.4 ± 3.9)%, and (63.1 ± 2.3)% removal of chemical oxygen demand (COD), ammonium N (NH4 + -N), total N (TN), and organic N, respectively, whereas there was an increase of (142 ± 6.3)% in the effluent nitrate-N (NO3 - -N) than that in the influent. At the optimum condition, the effluent concentrations of all the pollutants including COD, NH4 + -N, NO3 - -N, TN, and organic N were well below the surface water discharge standards specified by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), and thus, the effluent of the HSSF-MAVF could be safely discharged into the surface water bodies. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Total vermibed depth of HSSF-MAVFs was optimized for organic and nitrogen removal. HSSF-MAVFs were subjected to the higher HLR of synthetic brewery wastewater. Removal of COD and NH4 + -N was decreased with the increase in submerged bed depth. Removal of organic N and TN was increased with the increase in submerged bed depth. Total/unsubmerged bed depth had a positive impact on the organic and N removal.

A Critical Review on the Vermicomposting of Organic Wastes as a Strategy in Circular Bioeconomy: Mechanism, Performance, and Future Perspectives

AbstractTo meet the current need for sustainable development, vermicomposting (VC), a natural, eco-friendly, and cost-effective technology, can be a wise selection for the bioconversion of organic wastes into value-added by-products. However, no one has tried to establish the VC technology as an economically sustainable technology by exploring its linkage to circular bioeconomy. Even, no researcher has made any effort to explore the usability of the earthworms (EWs) as a protein supplement while assessing the economic perspectives of VC technology. Very few studies are available on the greenhouse gas (GHG) emission potential of VC technology. Still, the contribution of VC technology towards the non-carbon waste management policy is not yet explored. In the current review, a genuine effort has been made to inspect the contribution of VC technology towards the circular bioeconomy, along with evaluating its capability to bioremediate the organic wastes generated from domestic, industrial, and agricultural premises. The potential of the EWs as a protein source has also been explored to strengthen the contribution of VC technology towards the circular bioeconomy. Moreover, the linkage of the VC technology to the non-carbon waste management policy has been comprehensively demonstrated by highlighting its carbon sequestration and GHG emission potentials during the treatment of organic wastes. It has been observed that the cost of food production was reduced by 60--70% by replacing chemical fertilizers with vermicompost. The implication of the vermicompost significantly lessened the harvesting period of the crops, thereby helping the farmers attain higher profits by cultivating more crops in a single calendar year on the same plot. Furthermore, the vermicompost could hold the soil moisture for a long time, lessening the water demand up to 30-40%, which, in turn, reduced the frequency of irrigation. Also, the replacement of the chemical fertilizers with vermicompost resulted in a 23% increment in the grapes' yield, engendering an extra profit of up to 110000 rupees/ha. In Nepal, vermicompost has been produced at a cost of 15.68 rupees/kg, whereas it has been sold to the local market at a rate of 25 rupees/kg as organic manure, ensuring a net profit of 9.32 rupees/kg of vermicompost. EWs embraced 63% crude protein, 5-21% carbohydrates, 6-11% fat, 1476 kJ/100 g of metabolizable energy, and a wide range of minerals and vitamins. EWs also contained 4.11, 2.04, 4.43, 2.83, 1.47, and 6.26  g/kg (on protein basis) of leucine, isoleucine, tryptophan, arginine, histidine, and phenylalanine, respectively, enhancing the acceptability of the EW meal (EWM) as the protein supplement. The inclusion of 3 and 5% EWM in the diet of broiler pullets resulted in a 12.6 and 22.5% increase in their feed conversion ratio (FCR), respectively after one month. Similarly, when a 100% fish meal was substituted by 50% EWM and 50% fish meal, the FCR and growth rate of Parachanna obscura were increased substantially. The VC of maize crop residues mixed with pig manure, cow dung, and biochar, in the presence of Eisenia fetida EWs, yielded only 0.003-0.081, 0-0.17, and 130.40-189.10 g CO₂-eq.kg^-1 emissions of CO₂, CH₄, and N₂O, respectively. Similarly, the VC of tomato stems and cow dung ensured 2.28 and 5.76 g CO₂-eq.kg^-1 CO₂ emissions of CH₄ and N₂O, respectively. Additionally, the application of vermicompost at a rate of 5 t/ha improved the soil organic carbon proportion and aggravated carbon sequestration. The land application of vermicompost improved micro-aggregation and cut down the tillage, reducing GHG emissions and triggering carbon sequestration. The significant findings of the current review suggest that VC technology potentially contributes to the concept of circular bioeconomy, substantially negotiates potential GHG emissions, and complies with the non-carbon waste management policy, reinforcing its acceptability as an economically sound and environmentally benevolent organic waste bioremediation alternative.

A review on integrated vermifiltration as a sustainable treatment method for wastewater

To overcome the scarcity of fresh water, concerned authorities worldwide are bound to think about remediation and reuse of domestic and industrial effluents. The present review study on integrated vermifiltrationwith hydroponic system explains mechanism followed in system and presently the reutilization and remediation of domestic and industrial effluents. It explains the result of integrated vermifiltration and recognizes factors such as clogging, hydraulic loading rate or rain on bed, salinity, and sunlight affect the efficiency of system. The study also focuses on limitations associated with vermifiltration and also suggestions have been made for enhancing the sustainability and performance of existing practices. After literature review, integrated vermifiltration with hydroponic system considered as a natural and eco-friendly method for treating polluted water. Active zone of vermifilter remove organics, nitrate from nitrogen, total and dissolved phosphorus from wastewater. The vermifiltration and integrated vermifiltration with macrophyte able remove chemical oxygen demand (COD) in the range (53.7%-64.4%) and (75.5%-82.8%) respectively. The integrated system reduces land consumption and wastewater can be reutilized in cultivation.

Evaluation of the treatment performance and reuse potential in agriculture of organized industrial zone (OIZ) wastewater through an innovative vermifiltration approach

Vermifiltration (VF) is a natural and sustainable biofilter that has many advantages, including being energy-free, cost-effective, and allowing ease of application and maintenance. In this study, the effectiveness of a lab-scale VF system was assessed by the removal efficiency of total suspended solids, electrical conductivity, chemical oxygen demand, total nitrogen, total phosphorus, fecal coliform, and heavy metals in organized industrial zones (OIZ) and domestic wastewater (DW) for the first time. Additionally, the reuse suitability of the treated wastewater was determined by comparing different countries' and global irrigational criteria. The lab systems were built with four layers: one worm-bed and three varying filtering materials, and operated at an optimum hydraulic loading rate of 1.8-2 m³/m²/day for 45 days with Eisenia fetida as the earthworm species. The results demonstrated that removal efficiencies of total suspended solids and chemical oxygen demand were found to be 95% and 80% in OIZ wastewater and 90% and 88% in DW, respectively. Total nitrogen and total phosphorus were removed at rates of 69% and 67% in OIZ wastewater, respectively, and 84% and 74% in DW. Besides, the VF system has shown satisfactory removal performance for heavy metals ranging from 51% to 77% in OIZ wastewater that has met Turkish national wastewater discharge limits. Although the final characterization of treated wastewater was suitable, heavy metal and fecal coliform levels have not met many countries' irrigation water quality criteria. To meet global irrigation standards and to enhance the VF performance, further experimental studies should be carried out, including parameters such as bed material type in the reactor, worm type, and different operating conditions.

Vermifiltration: Strategies and techniques to enhance the organic and nutrient removal performance from wastewater

The vermifiltration (VF) technology has gained significant attention as a green alternative for remediating domestic and industrial wastewater over the last few decades. Of late, the implementation of various modifications to the orthodox VF technology, including tweaks in the design and operation of the vermifilters, has been portrayed in the available literature. However, owing to the scatteredness of the available information, the knowledge regarding the execution of the modified vermifilters is still inadequate. Hence, an effort has been made to comprehensively overview the innovative strategies and techniques adopted to improve the organic and nutrient removal potential of the VFs from wastewater. In addition, future perspectives have been recognized to design more efficient and sustainable VFs. This review explores more of such novel tactics to improve the performance of the VF technology regarding organic and nutrient removal from wastewater. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Innovative strategies and techniques implemented to VF technology were comprehensively overviewed. Design modification and advantages of each innovation were highlighted. The pollutant removal performance of every modification was emphasized. Modified vermifilters were better than the conventional vermifilters in terms of organic and nutrient removal from the wastewater.

Advances in Studies on Microbiota Involved in Nitrogen Removal Processes and Their Applications in Wastewater Treatment

The discharge of excess nitrogenous pollutants in rivers or other water bodies often leads to serious ecological problems and results in the collapse of aquatic ecosystems. Nitrogenous pollutants are often derived from the inefficient treatment of industrial wastewater. The biological treatment of industrial wastewater for the removal of nitrogen pollution is a green and efficient strategy. In the initial stage of the nitrogen removal process, the nitrogenous pollutants are converted to ammonia. Traditionally, nitrification and denitrification processes have been used for nitrogen removal in industrial wastewater; while currently, more efficient processes, such as simultaneous nitrification-denitrification, partial nitrification-anammox, and partial denitrification-anammox processes, are used. The microorganisms participating in nitrogen pollutant removal processes are diverse, but information about them is limited. In this review, we summarize the microbiota participating in nitrogen removal processes, their pathways, and associated functional genes. We have also discussed the design of efficient industrial wastewater treatment processes for the removal of nitrogenous pollutants and the application of microbiome engineering technology and synthetic biology strategies in the modulation of the nitrogen removal process. This review thus provides insights that would help in improving the efficiency of nitrogen pollutant removal from industrial wastewater.

Nitrogen removal from domestic wastewater using core-shell anthracite/Mg-layered double hydroxides (LDHs) in constructed wetlands

To investigate the mechanism of nitrogen removal by anthracites and enhance the nitrogen removal efficiency in constructed wetland, three kinds of layered double hydroxides (MgFe-LDHs, MgCo-LDHs, MgAl-LDHs) were prepared by co-precipitation under alkaline conditions and coated in situ on the surface of anthracites to synthesize core-shell anthracites/Mg-LDHs composites. Experiments with different treatments (columns loaded with original anthracites and anthracite/Mg-LDH composites) were conducted to study the nitrogen removal efficiency of domestic wastewater in constructed wetlands. The results of nitrogen removal experiments showed that the anthracite/MgAl-LDH composite had the best performance with average removal rates of 53.69%, 72.91%, and 47.43% for TN, NH₄⁺-N, and organic nitrogen, respectively. Modification changed the denitrification mode of the anthracites. The data of adsorption isothermal experiments were fitted better with the Freundlich model. The amount of ammonifier, nitrosobacteria, nitrobacter, and denitrifier on the surface of the Mg-LDH-modified anthracite was higher than that of the original anthracite. The performance of the anthracite in removing nitrogen was attributed to physical interception, chemical adsorption, and biological degradation. Moreover, the modified anthracites were superior to the original anthracite in the chemical adsorption and biodegradation, which indicated that coating the Mg-LDHs on the surface of common anthracite was a potential method to improve the nitrogen removal efficiency of domestic wastewater and to restore the eutrophic water body.

Simultaneous Carbon and Nitrogen Removal from Domestic Wastewater using High Rate Vermifilter

Being a cost-effective and environmentally benign technology, vermifiltration has significantly replaced the available conventional wastewater remediation methods in many cases over the last few decades. The present work emphasizes on the investigation of the nitrogen transformation dynamics, in addition to the organic carbon abatement in the designed high rate hybrid vermifilter. Moreover, the economical sustainability of the vermifiltration technology has also been enlightened by creating a bridge with the concept of circular bio-economy. The designed high rate macrophyte-assisted vermifilter (MAVF) ascertained significant high nitrogen and organic carbon removal efficiencies from the real domestic sewage, considering the chemical oxygen demand (COD) of the influent and hydraulic loading rate (HLR) as the input variables. The designed MAVF facilitated the maximum ammonium nitrogen (NH4 +-N), organic nitrogen, and total kjeldahl nitrogen removal efficiencies up to 98.2 ± 0.70%, 100%, and 99 ± 0.47%, respectively when COD of the influent and HLR were 200 ± 25 mg/L and 3 ± 0.1 m3/m2-d, respectively. On the other hand, substantial enhancement in the nitrate nitrogen (NO3 --N) in the effluent (73 ± 10.55 times its influent concentration) was observed with influent COD of 200 ± 25 mg/L and HLR of 7 ± 0.2 m3/m2-d. When the influent COD and HLR were maintained at 700 ± 45 mg/L and 3 ± 0.1 m3/m2-d, respectively, the highest total nitrogen removal of 87 ± 2.25% was obtained. Alternatively, the influent COD of 200 ± 25 mg/L and HLR of 3 ± 0.1 m3/m2-d yielded the highest COD removal efficiency of 77 ± 1.59%. Hence, the outcome of the present research work strengthens the suitability of the vermifiltration technology as an economically and ecologically sound natural wastewater bio-remediation technology for the treatment of domestic wastewater.