Comparison of peracetic acid and sodium hypochlorite enhanced Fe(Ⅱ) coagulation on algae-laden water treatment

Management of cyanobacteria and cyanotoxins in drinking water: A comprehensive review on occurrence, toxicity, challenges and treatment approaches

The synergistic effects of increased anthropogenic activities and climate change have intensified the frequency of cyanobacterial blooms in surface water bodies. These blooms pose significant health risks to humans and animals due to the release of cyanotoxins into the water. Conventional drinking water treatment plants (DWTPs) are often ineffective in removing cyanobacterial cells due to challenges such as electrostatic repulsion, hydrophilicity, and buoyancy. While excessive pre-oxidation can remove cyanobacteria, it may cause cell lysis, increase cyanotoxin concentration, and surpass various regulatory guidelines, posing additional risks of forming disinfection by-products (DBPs). Moderate pre-oxidation presents a viable alternative by effectively removing intact cyanobacterial cells. This review comprehensively analyses the occurrence, toxicity, associated challenges faced by DWTPs, and treatment approaches for cyanobacteria. Various moderate pre-oxidation processes for enhancing coagulation efficiency while preserving cell integrity are systematically summarized and critically discussed. The review also highlights the importance of holistic multi-barrier approaches, including prevention, corrections measures and water intake management for managing cyanobacterial contamination in drinking water treatment. It underscores the need for intensive research to develop affordable and effective solutions to ensure sustainable and safe drinking water provision.

Evaluation of the actinia-shaped composite coagulant for removal of algae in water: Role of charge density

A series of novel cationic modified actinia-shaped composite coagulant (AMS-C), with similar tentacle length and distribution but different charge density (CD), was successfully designed and fabricated by combination of a cationic graft starch and attapulgite (ATP). AMS-C shows a high efficiency in coagulative removal of Microcystis aeruginosa from water over a wide pH range. The algae-harvesting efficiency of optimized AMS-C can reach to 92.27 % only within 1.0 min after settlement and its maximal harvesting efficiency is as high as 99.25 % at the optimum dosage of 1.5 mg/L. This can be attributed to its special composited structure with abundant cationic long tentacle chains. CD of AMS-C is a key structural factor. AMS-C with a relatively high CD obviously enhanced the coagulation efficiency and settling performance through the improved charge neutralization, besides, the distinct long tentacle chains of AMS-C allowed its easy accessibility and tightly contacted with the algal cells, and thus facilitated the formation of large, dense and fast regrowing algal flocs by the enhanced bridging and sweeping effects. The aforementioned effects were together contributed to the effective removal of algae. The effective interactions between microalga cells and the composite coagulants were also verified using extended Deryaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek theory. Moreover, AMS-C was able to remove Microcystins-LR without destroying the cells, and still maintained a high algae-harvesting efficiency in real water bodies. Therefore, AMS-C, with the advantages of high-performance, environmentally-friendliness and low-cost, has notably promising application prospects in effective treatment of harmful algal blooms.

Odorant production surges induced by exogenous oxidative stress: An overlooked risk in PAA-based moderate preoxidation for algal-laden water

Moderate preoxidation is feasible for odor-producing algae treatments, usually requiring trade-offs in algal removal and integrity maintenance. However, dosing oxidants may cause internal oxidative homeostasis imbalances and secondary odorous metabolite responses, adding new trade-offs for moderate treatments. Peracetic acid (PAA)/Fe processes are promising strategies in moderate treatments and thus were applied to examine how to achieve the following three trade-offs: good algal removal, no odorant increases and no releases. For algal removal, the highest removal efficiency was 71.1 %, 87.0 % and 98.1 %, respectively, in PAA/Fe(Ⅲ) separate, PAA/Fe(Ⅱ) separate and PAA/Fe(Ⅱ) simultaneous process. Odorant responses always followed a pattern of "promotion-low dosages, inhibition-high dosages", with the highest production reaching 3.91-fold of the control without PAA addition, well above odorant threshold concentrations (500 ng/L). Instant releases did not occur, yet with delayed releases observed during sludge retention in sedimentation tanks (5, 16 h). It was verified that exogenous oxidative stress stimulated odorant generation with multiple reactive species. Among them, PAA oxidant was crucial in algal removal and odorant promotion; R-O· and ·OH caused odorant generation and degradation, respectively. Overall, PAA/Fe(Ⅱ) processes were more suitable for moderate treatments, simultaneously avoiding odorant increases and allowing sludge retention. This work provides a novel perspective for moderate preoxidation, highlighting instant odorant generation and delayed releases triggered by exogenous PAA stressors.

Control ultrafiltration membrane fouling in Chlorella-laden water treatment by integrated heat-activated peroxydisulfate pre-oxidation and coagulation treatment

The membrane fouling induced by algal extracellular organic matter (EOM) remain a bottleneck in restricting ultrafiltration (UF) application during harmful algal-water treatment. In current study, the application of heat-activated peroxydisulfate (PMS) and coagulation (Aluminum chlorohydrate, PACI) on membrane fouling behavior during Chlorella-laden water treatment was investigated. The membrane fouling mechanism was analyzed using the extended Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Over-beek (XDLVO) theory. The results revealed that separated heat-activated PMS could enhance the filtration flux of EOM at high PMS does >0.2 mM, whereas the membrane fouling was further alleviated by combined heat-activated PMS (0.2-1.0 mM) and PACI (20 mg/L) treatment, especially at low PMS dose. Combined heat-activated PMS and PACI pretreatment could effectively increase the adhesive repulsion between membrane and foulants and reduce the cohesion free energies between organic foulants than those by separated heat-activated PMS treatment, making the initial filtration flux reduced and the cake layer looser. Moreover, the organic foulants of proteins, polysaccharides, and humic-like organics were removed. Cake formation was the major fouling mechanism when EOM was treated with/without separated heat-activated PMS treatment, whereas the membrane fouling mechanism was changed from cake layer formation to pore blocking after combined heat-activated PMS and PACI treatment. Overall, this research provided a feasible method in membrane fouling control during Chlorella -laden water treatment.

Reliable assessment and prediction of moderate preoxidation of sodium hypochlorite for algae-laden water treatment

Chemical moderate preoxidation for algae-laden water is an economical and prospective strategy for controlling algae and exogenous pollutants, whereas it is constrained by a lack of effective on-line evaluation and quick-response feedback method. Herein, excitation-emission matrix parallel factor analysis (EEM-PARAFAC) was used to identify cyanobacteria fluorophores after preoxidation of sodium hypochlorite (NaClO) at Excitation/Emission wavelength of 260(360)/450 nm, based on which the algal cell integrity and intracellular organic matter (IOM) release were quantitatively assessed. Machine learning modeling of fluorescence spectral data for prediction of moderate preoxidation using NaClO was established. The optimal NaClO dosage for moderate preoxidation depended on algal density, growth phases, and organic matter concentrations in source water matrices. Low doses of NaClO (<0.5 mg/L) led to short-term desorption of surface-adsorbed organic matter (S-AOM) without compromising algal cell integrity, whereas high doses of NaClO (≥0.5 mg/L) quickly caused cell damage. The optimal NaClO dosage increased from 0.2-0.3 mg/L to 0.9-1.2 mg/L, corresponding to the source water with algal densities from 0.1 × 10⁶ to 2.0 × 10⁶ cells/mL. Different growth stages required varying NaClO doses: stationary phase cells needed 0.3-0.5 mg/L, log phase cells 0.6-0.8 mg/L, and decaying cells 2.0-2.5 mg/L. The presence of natural organic matter and S-AOM increased the NaClO dosage limit with higher dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentrations (1.00 mg/L DOC required 0.8-1.0 mg/L NaClO, while 2.20 mg/L DOC required 1.5-2.0 mg/L). Compared to other predictive models, the machine learning model (Gaussian process regression-Matern (0.5)) performed best, achieving R2 values of 1.000 and 0.976 in training and testing sets. Optimal preoxidation followed by coagulation effectively removed algal contaminants, achieving 91%, 92%, and 92% removal for algal cells, turbidity, and chlorophyll-a, respectively, thereby demonstrating the effectiveness of moderate preoxidation. This study introduces a novel approach to dynamically adjust NaClO dosage by monitoring source water qualities and tracking post-preoxidation fluorophores, enhancing moderate preoxidation technology application in algae-laden water treatment.

Efficient disinfection of combined sewer overflows by ultraviolet/peracetic acid through intracellular oxidation with preserving cell integrity

Combined sewer overflows (CSOs) introduce microbial contaminants into the receiving water bodies, thereby posing risks to public health. This study systematically investigated the disinfection performance and mechanisms of the combined process of ultraviolet and peracetic acid (UV/PAA) in CSOs with selecting Escherichia coli (E. coli) as a target microbial contaminant. The UV/PAA process exhibited superior performance in inactivating E. coli in simulated CSOs compared with UV, PAA, and UV/H2O2 processes. Increasing the PAA dosage greatly enhanced the disinfection efficiency, while turbidity and organic matter hindered the inactivation performance. Singlet oxygen (1O2), hydroxyl (•OH) and organic radicals (RO•) contributed to the inactivation of E. coli, with •OH and RO• playing the prominent role. Variations of intracellular reactive oxygen species, malondialdehyde, enzymes activities, DNA contents and biochemical compositions of E. coli cells suggested that UV/PAA primarily caused oxidative damage to intracellular molecules rather than the damage to the lipids of the cell membrane, therefore effectively limited the regrowth of E. coli. Additionally, the UV/PAA process displayed an outstanding performance in disinfecting actual raw CSOs, achieving a 2.90-log inactivation of total bacteria after reaction for 4 min. These results highlighted the practical applicability and effectiveness of the UV/PAA process in the disinfection of CSOs.

Moderate oxidation of algae-laden water: Principals and challenges

The occurrence of seasonal algae blooms represents a huge dilemma for water resource management and has garnered widespread attention. Therefore, finding methods to control algae pollution and improve water quality is urgently needed. Moderate oxidation has emerged as a feasible way of algae-laden water treatment and is an economical and prospective strategy for controlling algae and endogenous and exogenous pollutants. Despite this, a comprehensive understanding of algae-laden water treatment by moderate oxidation, particularly principles and summary of advanced strategies, as well as challenges in moderate oxidation application, is still lacking. This review outlines the properties and characterization of algae-laden water, which serve as a prerequisite for assessing the treatment efficiency of moderate oxidation. Biomass, cell viability, and organic matter are key components to assessing moderate oxidation performance. More importantly, the recent advancements in employing moderate oxidation as a treatment or pretreatment procedure were examined, and the suitability of different techniques was evaluated. Generally, moderate oxidation is more promising for improving the solid-liquid separation process by the reduction of cell surface charge (stability) and removal/degradation of the soluble algae secretions. Furthermore, this review presents an outlook on future research directions aimed at overcoming the challenges encountered by existing moderate oxidation technologies. This comprehensive examination aims to provide new and valuable insights into the moderate oxidation process.

Is monochloramine pre-oxidation a viable strategy for enhancing the treatment efficiency of algae-laden water with conventional drinking water treatment process?

Algal blooms worldwide pose many challenges to drinking water production. Pre-oxidation with NaClO, KMnO4, or ozone is commonly used to enhance algal removal in conventional drinking water treatment processes. However, these currently utilized oxidation methods often result in significant algal cell lysis or impede the operation of the subsequent units. Higher algal removal with pre-chlorination in algal solutions prepared with natural water, compared to those prepared with ultrapure water, has been observed. In the present studies, preliminary findings indicate that ammonium in natural water alters chlorine species to NH2Cl, leading to improved treatment efficiency. NH2Cl with 1.5-3.0 mg∙L-1 as Cl2 with an oxidation time of 3-7 h significantly enhancing algal removal by coagulation. The selective oxidation of surface-absorbed organic matter (S-AOM) by NH2Cl, followed by the subsequent peeling off of this material from the algal surface, leading to an increase in zeta potential from -20.2 mV to -3.8 mV, constitutes the primary mechanism of enhanced algal removal through coagulation. These peeled S-AOM retained their large molecular weight and acted as polymer aids. Compared with NaClO and KMnO4, NH2Cl displays the best performance in improving algal removal, avoiding cell lysis, and decreasing the potential for nitrogenous disinfection byproducts formation under the reaction conditions used in this study. Notably, in major Chinese cities, water purification plants commonly rely on suburban lakes or reservoirs as water sources, necessitating the transportation of raw water over long distances for times up to several hours. These conditions favor the implementation of NH2Cl pre-oxidation. The collective results indicate the potential of NH2Cl oxidation as a viable pretreatment strategy for algal contamination during water treatment processes.

Reinvestigation on the Mechanism for Algae Inactivation by the Ultraviolet/Peracetic Acid Process: Role of Reactive Species and Performance in Natural Water

This study provided an in-depth understanding of enhanced algae inactivation by combining ultraviolet and peracetic acid (UV/PAA) and selecting Microcystis aeruginosa as the target algae species. The electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) tests and scavenging experiments provided direct evidence on the formed reactive species (RSs) and indicated the dominant role of RSs including singlet oxygen (1O2) and hydroxyl (HO•) and organic (RO•) radicals in algae inactivation. Based on the algae inactivation kinetic model and the determined steady-state concentration of RSs, the contribution of RSs was quantitatively assessed with the second-order rate constants for the inactivation of algae by HO•, RO•, and 1O2 of 2.67 × 109, 3.44 × 1010, and 1.72 × 109 M-1 s-1, respectively. Afterward, the coexisting bi/carbonate, acting as a shuttle, that promotes the transformation from HO• to RO• was evidenced to account for the better performance of the UV/PAA system in algae inactivation under the natural water background. Subsequently, along with the evaluation of the UV/PAA preoxidation to modify coagulation-sedimentation, the possible application of the UV/PAA process for algae removal was advanced.

Peracetic acid-based electrochemical treatment of sulfamethoxazole and real antibiotic wastewater: Different role of anode and cathode

Although has high oxidation capacity and low toxic by-product formation potential, the feasibility, mechanism, and antibiotic treatment performance of peracetic acid (PAA)-based electrochemical system remains unknown. This work systematically studied the electro-activation process of PAA, and distinguished the different mechanisms of anode and cathode. In the PAA-based electrochemical system, the anode mainly produces BDD(•OH), and the cathode is mainly the R-O• (especially CH3CO3•). These differences lead to different degradation pathway and toxicity evolution of sulfamethoxazole (SMX). The anode transformation products (TPs) show negative toxicity and are difficult to be further removed, while TPs from PAA-dominated cathode posed electron-donating effect and a tapering ecological risk. The BDD(•OH) can well mineralize the TPs produced from cathode. Moreover, the active chlorine produced by the anode can effectively avoid the accumulation of NH4+- N released by antibiotic degradation. In an undivided cell, PAA-based treatment for real antibiotic wastewater achieved 73.9%, 59.4%, 76.9%, and 31.7% of COD, TOC, NH4+- N, and TN removal, respectively. More importantly, when PAA existed in this system, the active chlorine and AOCl accumulation are inhibited (inhibition ratio 83.5% and 82.7%, respectively). This study provides theoretical and technical support for the practical application of PAA-based electrochemical system.

Using Fe(II)/Fe(VI) activated peracetic acid as pretreatment of ultrafiltration for secondary effluent treatment: Water quality improvement and membrane fouling mitigation

Ultrafiltration (UF) is a technology commonly used to treat secondary effluents in wastewater reuse; however, it faces two main challenges: 1) membrane fouling and 2) inadequate nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and organic micropollutants (OMPs) removal. To address these two issues, in this study, we applied peracetic acid (PAA), Fe(VI)/PAA, and Fe(II)/PAA as UF pretreatments. The results showed that the most effective pretreatment was Fe(II)/200 μM PAA, which reduced the total fouling resistance by 90.2%. In comparison, the reduction was only 29.7% with 200 μM PAA alone and 64.3% with Fe(VI)/200 μM PAA. Fe(II)/200 μM PAA could effectively remove fluorescent components and hydrophobic organics in effluent organic matter (EfOM), and enhance the repulsive force between foulants and membrane (according to XDLVO analysis), and consequently, mitigate pore blocking and delay cake layer formation. Regarding pollutant removal, Fe(II)/200 μM PAA effectively degraded OMPs (>85%) and improved P removal by 58.2% via in-situ Fe(Ⅲ) co-precipitation. The quencher and probe experiments indicated that FeIVO2+, •OH, and CH3C(O)OO•/CH3C(O)O• all played important roles in micropollutant degradation with Fe(II)/PAA. Interestingly, PAA oxidation produced highly biodegradable products such as acetic acid, which significantly elevated the BOD5 level and increased the BOD5/total nitrogen (BOD5/TN) ratio from 0.8 to 8.6, benefiting N removal with subsequent denitrification. Overall, the Fe(II)/PAA process exhibits great potential as a UF pretreatment to control membrane fouling and improve water quality during secondary effluent treatment.

Vitamin C promoted refractory organic contaminant elimination in the zero-valent iron/peracetic acid system: Efficiency, mechanism and effects of various parameters

The conventional zero-valent iron/peracetic acid (ZVI/PAA) system is severely limited owing to the passivation of ZVI and the low recovery of Fe²⁺. In this study, a reducing agent, vitamin C (H₂A), was used for the first time to enhance the ZVI/PAA system as a way to improve its degradation performance. Under optimal conditions, the removal efficiency of the H₂A/ZVI/PAA system was 82.9%, while that of the H₂A/PAA and ZVI/PAA systems were only 19.0% and 25.6%. Free radical quenching and electron paramagnetic experiments (EPR) confirmed that CH₃C(O)O•, •OH and CH₃C(O)OO• were the major active species for acid orange 7 (AO7) degradation with contributions of 9.7%, 75% and 14.4%, respectively. The degradation mechanism was proposed through UV-vis full-wavelength scanning and chemical oxygen demand (COD) experiments. The removal of AO7 was not affected in the presence of Cl^-, SO₄^2- and HCO₃^-, while inhibition occurred with humic acid. ZVI exhibited excellent catalytic properties and stability, and the removal efficiency of AO7 exceeded 70% after three cycles. Additionally, the H₂A/ZVI/PAA system showed good ability to remove AO7 in well water, lake water, river water and reservoir water, and the elimination efficiency of MO, DCF and ACE also exceeded 70%. Overall, this study contributes new cognition for enhancing the ZVI/PAA system to degrade contaminants, which is expected to achieve a cleaner water environment.