Amyloid-like Fibril Formation of Co-chaperonin GroES: Nucleation and Extension Prefer Different Degrees of Molecular Compactness

Type I Hsp40s/DnaJs aggregates exhibit features reminiscent of amyloidogenic structures

A rise in temperature triggers a structural change in the human Type I 40 kDa heat shock protein (Hsp40/DnaJ), known as DNAJA1. This change leads to a less compact structure, characterized by an increased presence of solvent-exposed hydrophobic patches and β-sheet-rich regions. This transformation is validated by circular dichroism, thioflavin T binding, and Bis-ANS assays. The formation of this β-sheet-rich conformation, which is amplified in the absence of zinc, leads to protein aggregation. This aggregation is induced not only by high temperatures but also by low ionic strength and high protein concentration. The aggregated conformation exhibits characteristics of an amyloidogenic structure, including a distinctive X-ray diffraction pattern, seeding competence (which stimulates the formation of amyloid-like aggregates), cytotoxicity, resistance to SDS, and fibril formation. Interestingly, the yeast Type I Ydj1 also tends to adopt a similar β-sheet-rich structure under comparable conditions, whereas Type II Hsp40s, whether human or from yeast, do not. Moreover, Ydj1 aggregates were found to be cytotoxic. Studies using DNAJA1- and Ydj1-deleted mutants suggest that the zinc-finger region plays a crucial role in amyloid formation. Our discovery of amyloid aggregation in a C-terminal deletion mutant of DNAJA1, which resembles a spliced homolog expressed in the testis, implies that Type I Hsp40 co-chaperones may generate amyloidogenic species in vivo.

Amyloid and Amyloid-Like Aggregates: Diversity and the Term Crisis

Active accumulation of the data on new amyloids continuing nowadays dissolves boundaries of the term "amyloid". Currently, it is most often used to designate aggregates with cross-β structure. At the same time, amyloids also exhibit a number of other unusual properties, such as: detergent and protease resistance, interaction with specific dyes, and ability to induce transition of some proteins from a soluble form to an aggregated one. The same features have been also demonstrated for the aggregates lacking cross-β structure, which are commonly called "amyloid-like" and combined into one group, although they are very diverse. We have collected and systematized information on the properties of more than two hundred known amyloids and amyloid-like proteins with emphasis on conflicting examples. In particular, a number of proteins in membraneless organelles form aggregates with cross-β structure that are morphologically indistinguishable from the other amyloids, but they can be dissolved in the presence of detergents, which is not typical for amyloids. Such paradoxes signify the need to clarify the existing definition of the term amyloid. On the other hand, the demonstrated structural diversity of the amyloid-like aggregates shows the necessity of their classification.

Bacillus subtilis HelD, an RNA Polymerase Interacting Helicase, Forms Amyloid-Like Fibrils

HelD, an RNA polymerase binding protein from Bacillus subtilis, stimulates transcription and helps in timely adaptation of cells under diverse environmental conditions. At present, no structural information is available for HelD. In the current study, we performed size exclusion chromatography coupled to small angle X-ray scattering (SEC-SAXS) which suggests that HelD is predominantly monomeric and globular in solution. Using combination of size exclusion chromatography and analytical ultracentrifugation, we also show that HelD has a tendency to form higher order oligomers in solution. CD experiments suggest that HelD has both α-helical (∼35%) and β sheet (∼26%) secondary structural elements. Thermal melting experiments suggest that even at 90°C, there is only about 30% loss in secondary structural contents with T_m of 44°C. However, with the increase in temperature, there was a gain in the β-sheet content and significant irreversible loss of α-helical content. Using a combination of X-ray fiber diffraction analysis, and dye based assays including Thioflavin-T based fluorescence and Congo red binding assays, we discovered that HelD forms amyloid-like fibrils at physiologically relevant conditions in vitro. Using confocal imaging, we further show that HelD forms amyloid inclusions in Escherichia coli. Bioinformatics-based sequence analysis performed using three independent web-based servers suggests that HelD has more than 20 hot-spots spread across the sequence that may aid the formation of amyloid-like fibrils. This discovery adds one more member to the growing list of amyloid or amyloid-like fibril forming cytosolic proteins in bacteria. Future studies aimed at resolving the function of amyloid-like fibrils or amyloid inclusions may help better understand their role, if any, in the bacterial physiology.

Common structural features of toxic intermediates from α-synuclein and GroES fibrillogenesis detected using cryogenic coherent X-ray diffraction imaging

The aggregation and deposition of α-synuclein (αSyn) in neuronal cells is correlated to pathogenesis of Parkinson's disease. Although the mechanism of αSyn aggregation and fibril formation has been studied extensively, the structural hallmarks that are directly responsible for toxicity toward cells are still under debate. Here, we have compared the structural characteristics of the toxic intermediate molecular species of αSyn and similar toxic species of another protein, GroES, using coherent X-ray diffraction analysis. Using coherent X-ray free electron laser pulses of SACLA, we analysed αSyn and GroES fibril intermediate species and characterized various aggregate structures. Unlike previous studies where an annular oligomeric form of αSyn was identified, particle reconstruction from scattering traces suggested that the specific forms of the toxic particles were varied, with the sizes of the particles falling within a specific range. We did however discover a common structural feature in both αSyn and GroES samples; the edges of the detected particles were nearly parallel and produced a characteristic diffraction pattern in the diffraction experiments. The presence of parallel-edged particles in toxic intermediates of αSyn and GroES fibrillogenesis pointed towards a plausible common molecular interface that leads to the formation of mature fibrils.

Suppression of amyloid fibrils using the GroEL apical domain

In E. coli cells, rescue of non-native proteins and promotion of native state structure is assisted by the chaperonin GroEL. An important key to this activity lies in the structure of the apical domain of GroEL (GroEL-AD) (residue 191–376), which recognizes and binds non-native protein molecules through hydrophobic interactions. In this study, we investigated the effects of GroEL-AD on the aggregation of various client proteins (α-Synuclein, Aβ42, and GroES) that lead to the formation of distinct protein fibrils in vitro. We found that GroEL-AD effectively inhibited the fibril formation of these three proteins when added at concentrations above a critical threshold; the specific ratio differed for each client protein, reflecting the relative affinities. The effect of GroEL-AD in all three cases was to decrease the concentration of aggregate-forming unfolded client protein or its early intermediates in solution, thereby preventing aggregation and fibrillation. Binding affinity assays revealed some differences in the binding mechanisms of GroEL-AD toward each client. Our findings suggest a possible applicability of this minimal functioning derivative of the chaperonins (the “minichaperones”) as protein fibrillation modulators and detectors.

Mechanism of Amyloidogenesis of a Bacterial AAA+ Chaperone

Amyloids are fibrillar protein superstructures that are commonly associated with diseases in humans and with physiological functions in various organisms. The precise mechanisms of amyloid formation remain to be elucidated. Surprisingly, we discovered that a bacterial Escherichia coli chaperone-like ATPase, regulatory ATPase variant A (RavA), and specifically the LARA domain in RavA, forms amyloids under acidic conditions at elevated temperatures. RavA is involved in modulating the proper assembly of membrane respiratory complexes. LARA contains an N-terminal loop region followed by a β-sandwich-like folded core. Several approaches, including nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations, were used to determine the mechanism by which LARA switches to an amyloid state. These studies revealed that the folded core of LARA is amyloidogenic and is protected by its N-terminal loop. At low pH and high temperatures, the interaction of the N-terminal loop with the folded core is disrupted, leading to amyloid formation.

Structural basis of Cu, Zn-superoxide dismutase amyloid fibril formation involves interaction of multiple peptide core regions

Cu, Zn-superoxide dismutase (SOD1), an enzyme implicated in the progression of familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (fALS), forms amyloid fibrils under certain experimental conditions. As part of our efforts to understand ALS pathogenesis, in this study we found that reduction of the intramolecular disulfide bond destabilized the tertiary structure of metal free wild-type SOD1 and greatly enhanced fibril formation in vitro. We also identified fibril core peptides that are resistant to protease digestion by using mass spectroscopy and Edman degradation analyses. Three regions dispersed throughout the sequence were detected as fibril core sequences of SOD1. Interestingly, by using three synthetic peptides that correspond to these identified regions, we determined that each region was capable of fibril formation, either alone or in a mixture containing multiple peptides. It was also revealed that by reducing the disulfide bond and causing a decrease in the structural stability, the amyloid fibril formation of a familial mutant SOD1 G93A was accelerated even under physiological conditions. These results demonstrate that by destabilizing the structure of SOD1 by removing metal ions and breaking the intramolecular disulfide bridge, multiple fibril-forming core regions are exposed, which then interact with each another and form amyloid fibrils under physiological conditions.

Protonation favors aggregation of lysozyme with SDS

Different proteins have different amino acid sequences as well as conformations, and therefore different propensities to aggregate. Electrostatic interactions have an important role in the aggregation of proteins as revealed by our previous report (J. M. Khan et al., PLoS One, 2012, 7, e29694). In this study, we designed and executed experiments to gain knowledge of the role of charge variations on proteins during the events of protein aggregation with lysozyme as a model protein. To impart positive and negative charges to proteins, we incubated lysozyme at different pH values of below and above the pI (∼11). Negatively charged SDS was used to 'antagonize' positive charges on lysozyme. We examined the effects of pH variations on SDS-induced amyloid fibril formation by lysozyme using methods such as far-UV circular dichroism, Rayleigh scattering, turbidity measurements, dye binding assays and dynamic light scattering. We found that sub-micellar concentrations of SDS (0.1 to 0.6 mM) induced amyloid fibril formation by lysozyme in the pH range of 10.0-1.0 and maximum aggregation was observed at pH 1.0. The morphology of aggregates was fibrillar in structure, as visualized by transmission electron microscopy. Isothermal titration calorimetry studies demonstrated that fibril formation is exothermic. To the best of our current understanding of the mechanism of aggregation, this study demonstrates the crucial role of electrostatic interactions during amyloid fibril formation. The model proposed here will help in designing molecules that can prevent or reverse the amyloid fibril formation or the aggregation.

Role of C-terminal negative charges and tyrosine residues in fibril formation of α-synuclein

α-Synuclein (140 amino acids), one of the causative proteins of Parkinson's disease, forms amyloid fibrils in brain neuronal cells. In order to further explore the contributions of the C-terminal region of α-synuclein in fibril formation and also to understand the overall mechanism of fibril formation, we reduced the number of negatively charged residues in the C-terminal region using mutagenesis. Mutants with negative charges deleted displayed accelerated fibril formation compared with wild-type α-synuclein, demonstrating that negative charges located in the C-terminal region of α-synuclein modulate fibril formation. Additionally, when tyrosine residues located at position 125, 133, and 136 in the C-terminal region were changed to alanine residue(s), we found that all mutants containing the Tyr136Ala mutation showed delays in fibril formation compared with wild type. Mutation of Tyr136 to various amino acids revealed that aromatic residues located at this position act favorably toward fibril formation. In mutants where charge neutralization and tyrosine substitution were combined, we found that these two factors influence fibril formation in complex fashion. These findings highlight the importance of negative charges and aromatic side chains in the C-terminal region of α-synuclein in fibril formation.

Fibrillogenic propensity of the GroEL apical domain: a Janus-faced minichaperone

The chaperonin GroEL plays an essential role in promoting protein folding and in protecting against misfolding and aggregation in the cellular environment. In this study, we report that both GroEL and its isolated apical domain form amyloid-like fibrils under physiological conditions, and that the fibrillation of the apical domain is accelerated under acidic conditions. We also found, however, that despite its fibrillation propensity, the apical domain exhibits a pronounced inhibitory effect on the fibril growth of β(2)-microglobulin. Thus, the analysis of the behaviour of the apical domain reveals how aggregation and chaperone-mediated anti-aggregation processes can be closely related.

Covalent structural changes in unfolded GroES that lead to amyloid fibril formation detected by NMR: insight into intrinsically disordered proteins

Co-chaperonin GroES from Escherichia coli works with chaperonin GroEL to mediate the folding reactions of various proteins. However, under specific conditions, i.e. the completely disordered state in guanidine hydrochloride, this molecular chaperone forms amyloid fibrils similar to those observed in various neurodegenerative diseases. Thus, this is a good model system to understand the amyloid fibril formation mechanism of intrinsically disordered proteins. Here, we identified a critical intermediate of GroES in the early stages of this fibril formation using NMR and mass spectroscopy measurements. A covalent rearrangement of the polypeptide bond at Asn(45)-Gly(46) and/or Asn(51)-Gly(52) that eventually yield β-aspartic acids via deamidation of asparagine was observed to precede fibril formation. Mutation of these asparagines to alanines resulted in delayed nucleus formation. Our results indicate that peptide bond rearrangement at Asn-Gly enhances the formation of GroES amyloid fibrils. The finding provides a novel insight into the structural process of amyloid fibril formation from a disordered state, which may be applicable to intrinsically disordered proteins in general.

Isolation of short peptide fragments from alpha-synuclein fibril core identifies a residue important for fibril nucleation: a possible implication for diagnostic applications

alpha-Synuclein is one of the causative proteins of the neurodegenerative disorder, Parkinson's disease. Deposits of alpha-synuclein called Lewy bodies are a hallmark of this disorder, which is implicated in its progression. In order to understand the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation of alpha-synuclein in more detail, in this study we have isolated a specific, ~20 residue peptide region of the alpha-synuclein fibril core, using a combination of Edman degradation and mass-spectroscopy analyses of protease-resistant samples. Starting from this core peptide sequence, we then synthesized a series of peptides that undergo aggregation and fibril formation under similar conditions. Interestingly, in a derivative peptide where a crucial phenylalanine residue was changed to a glycine, the ability to initiate spontaneous fibril formation was abolished, while the ability to extend from preexisting fibril seeds was conserved. This fibril extension occurred irrespective of the source of the initial fibril seed, as demonstrated in experiments using fibril seeds of insulin, lysozyme, and GroES. This interesting ability suggests that this peptide might form the basis for a possible diagnostic tool useful in detecting the presence of various fibrillogenic factors.

Amyloid formation by the pro-inflammatory S100A8/A9 proteins in the ageing prostate

Background

The conversion of soluble peptides and proteins into polymeric amyloid structures is a hallmark of many age-related degenerative disorders, including Alzheimer's disease, type II diabetes and a variety of systemic amyloidoses. We report here that amyloid formation is linked to another major age-related phenomenon − prostate tissue remodelling in middle-aged and elderly men.

Methodology/Principal Findings

By using multidisciplinary analysis of corpora amylacea inclusions in prostate glands of patients diagnosed with prostate cancer we have revealed that their major components are the amyloid forms of S100A8 and S100A9 proteins associated with numerous inflammatory conditions and types of cancer. In prostate protease rich environment the amyloids are stabilized by dystrophic calcification and lateral thickening. We have demonstrated that material closely resembling CA can be produced from S100A8/A9 in vitro under native and acidic conditions and shows the characters of amyloids. This process is facilitated by calcium or zinc, both of which are abundant in ex vivo inclusions. These observations were supported by computational analysis of the S100A8/A9 calcium-dependent aggregation propensity profiles. We found DNA and proteins from Escherichia coli in CA bodies, suggesting that their formation is likely to be associated with bacterial infection. CA inclusions were also accompanied by the activation of macrophages and by an increase in the concentration of S100A8/A9 in the surrounding tissues, indicating inflammatory reactions.

Conclusions/Significance

These findings, taken together, suggest a link between bacterial infection, inflammation and amyloid deposition of pro-inflammatory proteins S100A8/A9 in the prostate gland, such that a self-perpetuating cycle can be triggered and may increase the risk of malignancy in the ageing prostate. The results provide strong support for the prediction that the generic ability of polypeptide chains to convert into amyloids could lead to their involvement in an increasing number of otherwise apparently unrelated diseases, particularly those associated with ageing.

Fibril formation of hsp10 homologue proteins and determination of fibril core regions: differences in fibril core regions dependent on subtle differences in amino acid sequence

Heat shock protein 10 (hsp10) is a member of the molecular chaperones and works with hsp60 in mediating various protein folding reactions. GroES is a representative protein of hsp10 from Escherichia coli. Recently, we found that GroES formed a typical amyloid fibril from a guanidine hydrochloride (Gdn-HCl) unfolded state at neutral pH. Here, we report that other hsp10 homologues, such as human hsp10 (Hhsp10), rat mitochondrial hsp10 (Rhsp10), Gp31 from T4 phage, and hsp10 from the hyperthermophilic bacteria Thermotoga maritima, also form amyloid fibrils from an unfolded state. Interestingly, whereas GroES formed fibrils from either the Gdn-HCl unfolded state (at neutral pH) or the acidic unfolded state (at pH 2.0-3.0), Hhsp10, Rhsp10, and Gp31 formed fibrils from only the acidic unfolded state. Core peptide regions of these protein fibrils were determined by proteolysis treatment followed by a combination of Edman degradation and mass spectroscopy analyses of the protease-resistant peptides. The core peptides of GroES fibrils were identical for fibrils formed from the Gdn-HCl unfolded state and those formed from the acidic unfolded state. However, a peptide with a different sequence was isolated from fibrils of Hhsp10 and Rhsp10. With the use of synthesized peptides of the determined core regions, it was also confirmed that the identified regions were capable of fibril formation. These findings suggested that GroES homologues formed typical amyloid fibrils under acidic unfolding conditions but that the fibril core structures were different, perhaps owing to differences in local amino acid sequences.

Differential Effects of Alcohols on Conformational Switchovers in α-Helical and β-Sheet Protein Models

Organic solvents may induce non-native structures of proteins that mimic folding intermediates and/or conformations that occur in proximity to biological membranes. Here we systematically investigate the effects of simple (i.e., MeOH and EtOH) and fluorinated (i.e., trifluoroethanol, TFE) alcohols on the secondary structure and thermodynamic stability of two complementary model proteins using a combination of circular dichroism, fluorescence, and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) detection methods. The selected proteins are alpha-helical Borrelia burgdorferi VlsE and beta-sheet human mitochondrial co-chaperonin protein 10 (cpn10). We find that switches between VlsE's native and non-native superhelical and beta-sheet structures readily occur (pH 7, 20 degrees C). The pathway depends on the alcohol: addition of MeOH induces a transition to a superhelical structure that is followed by conversion to beta-structure, whereas EtOH only unfolds the protein. TFE unfolds VlsE at low percentages but promotes the formation of a superhelical state upon further additions. For cpn10, both MeOH and TFE additions govern initial unfolding; however, further additions of MeOH result in the formation of a non-native beta-structure, whereas subsequent additions of TFE induce a superhelical structure. EtOH additions promptly unfold and precipitate cpn10. Both VlsE's and cpn10's non-native structures exhibit high stability toward chemical and thermal perturbations. This study demonstrates that in response to different alcohols, polypeptides can readily adopt both alpha- and beta-enriched conformations. The biological significance of these findings is discussed.

Amyloid Fibril Formation of α-Synuclein Is Accelerated by Preformed Amyloid Seeds of Other Proteins

Alpha-synuclein is one of the causative proteins of familial Parkinson disease, which is characterized by neuronal inclusions named Lewy bodies. Lewy bodies include not only alpha-synuclein but also aggregates of other proteins. This fact raises a question as to whether the formation of alpha-synuclein amyloid fibrils in Lewy bodies may occur via interaction with fibrils derived from different proteins. To probe this hypothesis, we investigated in vitro fibril formation of human alpha-synuclein in the presence of preformed fibril seeds of various different proteins. We used three proteins, Escherichia coli chaperonin GroES, hen lysozyme, and bovine insulin, all of which have been shown to form amyloid fibrils. Very surprisingly, the formation of alpha-synuclein amyloid fibril was accelerated markedly in the presence of preformed seeds of GroES, lysozyme, and insulin fibrils. The structural characteristics of the natively unfolded state of alpha-synuclein may allow binding to various protein particles, which in turn triggers the formation (extension) of alpha-synuclein amyloid fibrils. This finding is very important for understanding the molecular mechanism of Parkinson disease and also provides interesting implications into the mechanism of transmissible conformational diseases.