Structures of ubiquitin insertion mutants support site-specific reflex response to insertions hypothesis

Generation of ubiquitin-based binder with an inserted active peptide

The grafting of active peptides onto structurally stable scaffold proteins is effective for the generation of functional proteins. In this study, we aimed to develop a grafting method using ubiquitin as a scaffold protein. Ubiquitin is a small protein consisting of 76 amino acid residues that is highly stable against heat and pH stress, which are desirable characteristics for a scaffold protein. Moreover, its structure is maintained even if it is split or additional residues are inserted. Therefore, we assumed that grafting of an active peptide into ubiquitin would result in a functional protein. As a proof of concept, we developed the ubiquitin-based binder (UbB), into which the p53 (17-28) peptide was inserted between Ile36 and Pro37. The p53 (17-28) peptide, utilized as a model active peptide in this work, is known to bind to mouse double minute 2 homolog (Mdm2). Size exclusion chromatography and circular dichroism indicated that UbB maintained a similar structure to that of ubiquitin. The affinity for Mdm2 measured by surface plasmon resonance was 292 times greater than that of the p53 (17-28) peptide. These observations indicate that ubiquitin is a robust scaffold for peptide grafting. We hope that this study will aid further development of ubiquitin-based protein engineering.

Enhancing ubiquitin crystallization through surface-entropy reduction

Ubiquitin has many attributes suitable for a crystallization chaperone, including high stability and ease of expression. However, ubiquitin contains a high surface density of lysine residues and the doctrine of surface-entropy reduction suggests that these lysines will resist participating in packing interactions and thereby impede crystallization. To assess the contributions of these residues to crystallization behavior, each of the seven lysines of ubiquitin was mutated to serine and the corresponding single-site mutant proteins were expressed and purified. The behavior of these seven mutants was then compared with that of the wild-type protein in a 384-condition crystallization screen. The likelihood of obtaining crystals varied by two orders of magnitude within this set of eight proteins. Some mutants crystallized much more readily than the wild type, while others crystallized less readily. X-ray crystal structures were determined for three readily crystallized variants: K11S, K33S and the K11S/K63S double mutant. These structures revealed that the mutant serine residues can directly promote crystallization by participating in favorable packing interactions; the mutations can also exert permissive effects, wherein crystallization appears to be driven by removal of the lysine rather than by addition of a serine. Presumably, such permissive effects reflect the elimination of steric and electrostatic barriers to crystallization.

Unequivocal single-molecule force spectroscopy of proteins by AFM using pFS vectors

Nanomechanical analysis of proteins by single-molecule force spectroscopy based on atomic force microscopy is increasingly being used to investigate the inner workings of mechanical proteins and substrate proteins of unfoldase machines as well as to gain new insight into the process of protein folding. However, such studies are hindered by a number of technical problems, including the noise of the proximal region, ambiguous single-molecule identification, as well as difficulties in protein expression/folding and full-length purification. To overcome these major drawbacks in protein nanomechanics, we designed a family of cloning/expression vectors, termed pFS (plasmid for force spectroscopy), that essentially has an unstructured region to surmount the noisy proximal region, a homomeric polyprotein marker, a carrier to mechanically protect the protein of interest (only the pFS-2 version) that also acts as a reporter, and two purification tags. pFS-2 enables the unambiguous analysis of proteins with low mechanical stability or/and complex force spectra, such as the increasingly abundant class of intrinsically disordered proteins, which are hard to characterize by traditional bulk techniques and have important biological and clinical implications. The advantages, applications, and potential of this ready-to-go system are illustrated through the analysis of representative proteins.

Predicting the magnitude of the reflex response to insertions in ubiquitin

The ability to predict the structural response of a protein to an insertion would be a significant advance for the fields of homology modeling and protein design. However, the effects of insertions on protein conformation are not well understood. Previous work has demonstrated that for two loops in ubiquitin, the primary determinant of the structural adaptation to insertions is the insertion site rather than the sequence of the insertion; this phenomenon was termed the reflex response of loops to insertions. We report herein the analysis of ubiquitin mutants with insertions in two other loops. This study demonstrates that the insertion site is the primary determinant of the response to insertions for these two new loops as well, which further supports the reflex response hypothesis. We also attempted to predict the relative magnitudes of the responses at each site but were unsuccessful. Using the additional data collected in this work, we have refined our predictive hypothesis.

Thermodynamic analysis of an antagonistic folding-unfolding equilibrium between two protein domains

A simple model is formulated for analyzing the coupled folding-unfolding equilibrium present in a unique class of molecular switch proteins. We previously fused two single-domain proteins, barnase and ubiquitin, such that the free energy stored in the folded structure of one subunit is used to drive unfolding of the other. Here, we present a thermodynamic test of that mechanism. The antagonistic interaction is represented by a coupling free energy term DeltaGX. DeltaGX is the penalty imposed on folding of one domain by the native structure of the other. If DeltaGX=0, then neither domain senses the other and they fold and unfold independently. If DeltaGX>0, then destabilizing one domain will stabilize the other, and vice versa. In the limit where DeltaGX is greater than the intrinsic stability of either protein, then only one domain can be folded at any given time. We estimate DeltaGX by measuring stability parameters for a series of mutants that destabilize either the barnase or ubiquitin domains. Fitting the data to the model leads to a DeltaGX value of approximately 4 kcal mol(-1). DeltaGX is proposed to depend on both the length of the linker peptides used to join the two proteins, and on the inherent structural plasticity of each domain. We predict that shortening the linkers from their current lengths of two and three amino acid residues will increase structural and thermodynamic coupling.

Sequence-structure and structure-function analysis in cysteine-rich domains forming the ultrastable nematocyst wall

The nematocyst wall of cnidarians is a unique biomaterial that withstands extreme osmotic pressures, allowing an ultrafast discharge of the nematocyst capsules. Assembly of the highly robust nematocyst wall is achieved by covalent linkage of cysteine-rich domains (CRDs) from two main protein components, minicollagens and nematocyst outer wall antigen (NOWA). The bipolar minicollagens have different disulfide patterns and topologies in their N and C-terminal CRDs. The functional significance of this polarity has been elusive. Here, we show by NMR structural analysis that all representative cysteine-rich domains of NOWA are structurally related to N-terminal minicollagen domains. Natural sequence insertions in NOWA CRDs have very little effect on the tightly knit domain structures, nor do they preclude the efficient folding to a single native conformation. The different folds in NOWA CRDs and the atypical C-terminal minicollagen domain on the other hand can be directly related to different conformational preferences in the reduced states. Ultrastructural analysis in conjunction with aggregation studies argues for an association between the similar NOWA and N-terminal minicollagen domains in early stages of the nematocyst wall assembly, which is followed by the controlled association between the unusual structures of C-terminal minicollagen domains.